“Charles Todd hasn’t made a misstep yet in his elegant series featuring Scotland Yard detective Ian Rutledge, and
A Matter of Justice
keeps the streak going.”—
Cleveland Plain Dealer
The
Washington Post
calls the Ian Rutledge novels by Charles Todd, “one of the best historical series being written today.”
A Matter of Justice
—the eleventh in the
New York Times
Notable, Edgar® Award-nominated, and Barry Award-winning series—brings back the haunted British police inspector and still shell-shocked World War One veteran in a tale of unspeakable murder in a small English village filled to bursting with dark secrets and worthy suspects. A
New York Times
bestseller as spellbinding and evocative as the best of Ruth Rendell, Anne Perry, Martha Grimes, and P.D. James,
A Matter of Justice
represents a new high for this exceptional storyteller.
Customer Reviews
Rating Breakdown
★★★★★
60%
(992)
★★★★
25%
(414)
★★★
15%
(248)
★★
7%
(116)
★
-7%
(-116)
Most Helpful Reviews
★★★★★
4.0
AHWYSJIMUEIUBSBWKASE...
✓ Verified Purchase
Impressive Psychological Mystery
First thing, the author here - Charles Todd - is actually a mother and son writing team. It is very impressive to me that two people can join together as one to produce such a highly intelligent, literary and intelligent piece of work. Kudos of the highest order are deserved.
The main story here evolves around the death of a not very well liked London businessman Harold Quarles. His body is discovered in the most unusual of circumstances in Somerset, where he has a summer estate. Called in is Scotland Yard Investigator Ian Rutledge. He certainly has his hands full for all the townspeople in both Somerset and London are not very fond of Mr. Quarles. Almost everyone is a suspect, openly verbalizing their dislike of the man and gratitude that someone finally did away with him.
The story mainly takes place in 1920 England but does take trips back to some major events in South Africa during the Boer War. There are a lot of characters here and they are all three dimensional and very well developed. They are all very believable. Most believable though is the main character, our Inspector, Ian Rutledge. His character does not merely go through the motions. We understand and are told why he thinks what he does and why he takes the actions he chooses. He is a troubled soul and has some mental problems due to some issues that fill him with great guilt from his own actions in WWI. He feels responsible for the death of a particular soldier and this spector haunts him. This man is very real to Ian Rutledge and he hears him talking to him all the time. Inspector Rutledge is a very complex man who is excellent at his job while being so disturbed that he continuously talks out loud to this dead man whose voice he hears. This makes for a very intriguing main character.
This is the 11th novel in the INSPECTOR RUTLEDGE series and my first time venturing into it. I had some questions about certain background material but I'm sure all these issues would have been addressed had I read the other books. I read it as a stand alone and still found it first rate. I give it 4 stars and not 5 for even though it is so well written and provides great psychological characterization it does remain a whodunit. At times I got a little bored and wished there was a little more suspense, a little more happening, to make the ride a little more pleasurable.
But I do highly recommend this book. If you are a reader of the series I am sure you will be thrilled. And if you are looking to explore a new writer, this one can't be beat.
31 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AGAM7XSVSBJ4IG5TMY5S...
✓ Verified Purchase
Another Case for Rutledge and Hamish
The post World War I cases of Scotland Yard Inspector Rutledge and his otherworldly sidekick Hamish are always interesting, well written and nicely paced and this 11th in the series is no exception. But the suspension-of-disbelief requirements in this one are causing me to dock it one star.
How the man who sets the plot in motion happens to come upon and learn of his brother's brutal murder from its only witness many years later stretches credibility considerably. The way the brother then chooses to go into business with the murderers and lose a pile of money as a prelude to exacting vengeance is convenient for the plot but doesn't quite make sense. How the wife of the deceased-to-be happens to learn he's a murderer is also a little too convenient. And the wrap up, in which the revenge motive comes full circle, has plausibility problems in that the perpetrator had given little evidence of being mentally equipped to organize and pull off such a plan.
If you can manage to shrug all that off and just enjoy another investigative outing with Inspector Rutledge and Hamish and a townfull of red herrings, interesting suspects and other well drawn characters, then good for you, as I think you'll find it a riveting read.
8 people found this helpful
★★★★★
4.0
AH6VFZ4XI47J5G3BSGDV...
✓ Verified Purchase
"It was time his ways caught up with him"
Readers of Charles Todd's series know Ian Rutledge as a former army man haunted by his experiences in WWI, now an inspector at Scotland Yard. [[ASIN:0061233595 A Matter of Justice: An Inspector Ian Rutledge Mystery (Inspector Ian Rutledge Mysteries)]] is the first I've read in the series and I am eager to go back and read some of the earlier stories.
The book begins with a tried and true technique: first we meet Ronald Evering contemplating revenge in the book's "real time" of 1920, and then we flash back to the wartime crime in which two soldiers caused the death of Evering's brother. From there the book returns to 1920 and moves in a linear fashion. Rutledge is pulled in to investigate the death of one of the former soldiers, and there's a twist to the crime that speaks of real passion.
The crime scene is in Cambury, "a village that's outgrown itself." The victim, Quarles, was a London financial advisor with a country home in Cambury where he'd appointed himself squire, indulged in some bad behavior, and lined up an impressive array of enemies. The butcher, the baker, the candlestick maker (figuratively speaking) and Quarles's estranged wife all had issues with him. Rutledge follows up leads, makes a couple of quick trips back to London to question people, and progresses from theory to theory; there are many potential suspects in Cambury, London, and beyond. It's all well plotted and in the end all the loose ends are tied up in a satisfactory fashion. There may not be many "aha! moments" until the end but then that's probably the case in real police work too.
A MATTER OF JUSTICE could have been a five star read for me if there had been more of the back-story revealed. In particular, I was distracted by young Hamish MacLeod who was killed in the war while under Rutledge's command. He talks to Rutledge like an imaginary friend, and Rutledge talks back to him. This manifestation of Rutledge's shell shock might have been more effective for me if I'd read some of the earlier books; it kept me from getting inside the main character's head, which was already occupied by Hamish.
Overall I found this a satisfactory four-star read and I will definitely explore what the authors have done with this series in the earlier books. Charles Todd is the pen name for a mother-son duo.
This review was written from an uncorrected advance copy, for which I thank the publisher and Amazon Vine.
Linda Bulger, 2008
7 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AEBMTWVMX6B6IH6MXHHM...
✓ Verified Purchase
Just Okay
When you write a murder mystery in which both the murderer and the motive are known from the very beginning of the story, you need a very compelling plot and complex characters to keep the reader's interest.
This book had neither. By the end of Chapter 4, you will know both "who" and "why." You'll spend the rest of the book just waiting for Inspector Ian Rutledge to catch up with you.
Meanwhile, you will meet a hefty cast of red herring characters -- except you already know they are red herrings, so it quickly becomes tedious. (At least, it did for me.)
Personally, I didn't find anything wrong with the author team's writing style, but the plot and characters left me cold. The spirit who "haunts" Inspector Rutledge didn't even provide much interest for me. At the beginning of the series the madness manifested by the personality of Hamish may have made Rutledge a more complex character ... but by book #11, it seems foolish and clunky. It was as though Rutledge had an invisible sidekick who lived in his head.
Fans of the series will probably read and possibly enjoy this. As for me, I can't see myself picking up any other books in the series if this is a typical example.
6 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AG7P7MU4DYKHAMUQWRIS...
✓ Verified Purchase
The Haunted Detective
Every great literary detective has a special quirk: Poirot has his little grey cells; Marple has her fleecy knitting; Rumpole has his claret and Wordsworth; and Morse has his pint and his opera. In the tradition of these notable exemplar's, Inspector Ian Rutledge of Scotland Yard, the creditable sleuth of Charles Todd's "A Matter of Justice," has his Hamish. Acting as a sort of Greek (or Scottish) chorus, Hamish, who was killed going over the top in the Great War, lives on in Rutledge's head, persistently offering advice, often unsought, on the case at hand. His existence certainly renders Ian Rutledge one of the most interesting detective protagonists that I have encountered of late.
"A Matter of Justice" is set in England of 1920. And although it contains a continuity error (e.g., Betty, described as "age forty" on page 90 becoming "an elderly woman" on page 294), the book held my interest throughout. The characters are believable and the mystery is intriguing. Mr. Todd takes the time to develop his characters and to describe his settings, which include Devonshire, a Somerset village, and one of the Scilly Isles, off the coast of Cornwall.
I suppose that this mystery is one that would be called a "cozy" in the trade. I enjoyed it thoroughly and would recommend it to anyone who likes an old-fashioned mystery which presents a complex puzzle to be solved with a nice cup of tea.
5 people found this helpful
★★★★★
2.0
AFDYCVHOVTFXTVSEZTND...
✓ Verified Purchase
historical mystery
I will be right up front and state that I probably did not get full value out of this book, as it is the twelfth book in a series, and I have not read the previous books in the series.
For example, I am not sure what to make of Hamish - a sort of sidekick to the main character. Is Hamish an alternate personality of Rutledge? Is he a symptom of madness coming out of the horrible experiences of the trenches of WW1? Is Hamish a ghost? A largely harmless invisible friend?
Not having any of the background of the characters, I found Hamish to be quite tedious quite quickly.
Another thing that lessoned my enjoyment of the story was that everything is set up in the first two chapters of the story. We know what happened two decades before to spark the murder - we know who set up the murder and how and who was the murderer and why. But the bulk of the book is Rutledge trying to figure out what the reader already knows, and it seemed kind of pointless after a while to see him investigating all of the red herrings, all while knowing that they are all red herrings.
It may well be that long time readers of Charles Todd and his sleuth Ian Rutledge might greatly enjoy this story. But as someone newly walking in the series, not so much.
5 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AHV4XRDXP76REMTGZR5L...
✓ Verified Purchase
Sadly, it feels as though the train has gone off the rails
I once LOVED(!) this series, mainly because of the character of Rutledge. Decent, kind, thoughtful, haunted, suffering. A quintessential romantic hero really. But perhaps success has been a double-edged sword for this author (these writing partners). What I found particularly off-putting, enraging really, in this book was the wonton, Grand Guignolesque burning alive ALIVE ALIVE ALIVE of Lieutenant Evering. What was the point of that?? This was over-the-top beastial and totally unnecessary to the plot because it didn't contribute to anything that then transpired. A bullet through the brain before the fire would have made no change to the substance of the plotting. There was more than ample evidence throughout the book that Quarles was a bastard. This was gratuitous savagery. Possibly the most inhuman, vicious, negating thing one person can do to another. But the naked horror, the enormity of this act was not explored in Rutledge's response to the event. I found this to be horror for its own sake and it was a total turn off for me. It remains an open question if I will read another book in this series.
4 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AE55UIFZEFQX7C5QHCD3...
✓ Verified Purchase
Intricate. Haunting.
In future stories, I would really like Ian Rutledge to start having some fun. Really. And maybe even some romance. With a spunky, intelligent, well-bred lady.
Is he getting there in "A Matter of Justice"? The book is Charles Todd's eleventh Inspector Ian Rutledge Mystery, and he's still got a ways to go. Every one of the novels is a month more back on his job as a homicide investigator at Scotland Yard.
Rutledge's four years as an officer in the deathly, stinking trenches in France in World War One left their mark. He still has demons. In his own mind, he still endures the haunting presence of the voice of one Hamish McLeod, a good and moral man who had to be executed for refusing to order the men to advance suicidally over the top into No Man's Land.
While hospitalized after the war, Rutledge's condition so frightened his fiancée that she fled and married someone else. Now at the Yard, can Rutledge still perform as confidently and successfully as he did before the war?
"A Matter of Justice" opens with a younger son, Ronald Evering, jealously remembering his mother's greater love for her favorite, the older son, Lieutenant Timothy Evering, who had been murdered by two of his own men in the Boer War in South Africa. "Kill them," the mother had commanded Ronald, "Send them to hell, and I'll love you then."
Traveling to South Africa ten years later to retrieve his elder brother's body, the young son had learned of the murder and the identity of the murderers, Privates Quarles and Penrith. The evidence came from a wounded Boer soldier who had witnessed the event from his place of hiding.
As the years passed, Ronald Evering found that the traitorous pair had gone on to success in the financial world in London. To be closer to them and bide his time, he had even invested with them and gotten cheated. This old military murder, introduced in the first few pages of the book, hangs hauntingly over the entire story.
Though Quarles was respected in the business circles of London, he was almost universally hated farther west in the village near his country house. There he was known for his arrogant treatment of the villagers and as a seducer of wives and daughters. Even Quarles's wife hated him.
One evening Quarles is found murdered and grotesquely strung up in a barn on his estate. There is no shortage of suspects. The local police call in Scotland Yard for help, which brings in Rutledge. The many characters and their relationships are well drawn. The plotting proceeds expertly, and the resolution is a complex matter of justice. An engaging and satisfying read (330 pages).
4 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AHGHVDXRT2YHKZPOLJVT...
✓ Verified Purchase
Gone but not forgotten
In this book set in post-World War I England, Investor Ian Rutledge of Scotland Yard is assigned to investigate a murder that has taken a small town not far from where he had just attended a wedding. It will turn out that the events leading to the murder go back to South Africa during the time of the Boer War, and that a number of people have played a part.
Rutledge seems to be a detective in the Sherlock Holmes mode, who gets results by a combination of dogged persistence and sheer brilliance. Along the way he converses frequently with a fallen comrade in the Great War, a literary device that palls at times, and with a local cop who seems to be doing his best to derail the investigation.
Slick, entertaining, but quite improbable - I would recommend the book for people who enjoy murder mysteries and are not looking for something deeper.
3 people found this helpful
★★★★★
4.0
AH4PHUQB5OQ4ALDY7RQV...
✓ Verified Purchase
Red herrings and avenging angels galore
Ronald Evering, the last surviving member of his family, sits alone in his home on the Scilly Isles, one of the most remote parts of western England, recalling his mother's reproaches for not seeking vengeance on the two men who had murdered his brother in the veldts of South Africa during the Boer War. "Surely," he muses to himself in the introductory chapter of this well-crafted mystery, "he could work out a revenge that would in no way make him vulnerable."
But does he? A few hundred miles away in Wiltshire, the corpse of one of the two men responsible for that death, Harold Quarles, is found bizarrely displayed in an ancient tithe barn, stretched into a harness contraption usually used by the Christmas angel during the local Nativity play. It now holds Quarles, who hangs "like an avenging angel among the beams." But who is the real avenging angel? Quarles seemed to have alienated everyone he knew, from his wife - who lived her life almost completely separately from his - to his former partner. "There were two problems with Harold Quarles. One was his pursuit of women, the other his belief that most people could be used."
A more recent war - the trench warfare of 1914 to 1918 - has left its mark on Scotland Yard Inspector Ian Rutledge, summoned to investigate Quarles's odd death. A victim of shell shock, his investigatory sidekick isn't the customary loyal police sergeant but rather the ghost of his fellow soldier, Hamish MacLeod, whom Rutledge had to execute for desertion for refusing to follow the order to lead their men to certain death in the trenches. Now Hamish -- himself an avenging angel of sorts -- literally dogs Rutledge's footsteps, riding in the back seat of his car and sitting on the side of his bed, challenging his investigative techniques and preliminary conclusions. Rutledge worries about being caught talking to someone who doesn't exist but it's even worse when Hamish is quiet because then Rutledge must remain "prepared for an attack from any quarter when he least expected it."
In this case, even before they understand the Boer War connection, Rutledge and Hamish have plenty of suspects to occupy their attention - indeed, far too many, as almost the entire village, it seems, cheerfully admits to having a motive for wanting Quarles dead. Is the culprit a local man - the baker, the organist, even the local policeman - who would have been familiar with the mechanics required to rig up Quarles as the Christmas angel? Or are the local suspects simply red herrings? Ultimately, Rutledge stumbles over the Boer War crime and begins to prod away at that, leading to a satisfying resolution - and an ultimate conclusion that is a great final twist.
Hinting at what may - or may not - be the motive for the murder in the introductory chapter made this, the latest in a long series of outings for Rutledge and Hamish, less satisfying than most of the previous books. (I'd urge any newcomers to the series to start at the beginning; the writing is just as strong, and it will give you a better sense of the characters; this book, in fact, stands out as the least well-crafted of the series.) It's irritating to the reader to have access to knowledge that Rutledge doesn't. Thankfully it's not a technique that these authors have used previously and one I hope they don't use again as it simply felt like a clumsy solution that reduced the amount of suspense in the narrative. I was left to wonder at what point Rutledge would finally be on the same page I was; only then did the real suspense begin.
Still, there are several great twists in the final chapters that mean you won't end up feeling short-changed, including one that may signal a new departure for Rutledge on the personal front. As ever, the book's characters are convincing and intriguing and the author(s) capture the feel of a country still recovering from the trauma of the `war to end all wars'. And as ever, I'll be looking forward to next January and the next installment of this compelling series.