American Tall Tales
American Tall Tales book cover

American Tall Tales

Hardcover – September 24, 1991

Price
$14.54
Format
Hardcover
Pages
115
Publisher
Knopf Books for Young Readers
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0679800897
Dimensions
8.38 x 0.62 x 11.13 inches
Weight
1.53 pounds

Description

From Publishers Weekly American folk heroes of the 19th century spring to life in these splendidly retold sagas. Osborne's reputation as a gifted raconteur ( Favorite Greek Myths ; Beauty and the Beast ) is reaffirmed in this compendium, which retells the legends of familiar figures (Davy Crockett, Paul Bunyan, Johnny Appleseed, Pecos Bill), as well as lesser known personalities, such as Crockett's fictional wife Sally Ann Thunder Ann Whirlwind, a composite character shaped by tales of various real-life women. Also chronicled are heroes hailing from places other than the backwoods, including Stormalong, a giant sailor who as a baby was washed onto a Cape Cod beach by a tidal wave, and Mose, a New York City fireman immortalized in an 1848 Broadway play. As tantalizing as Osborne's storytelling are McCurdy's ( The Owl-Scatterer ) elaborate, full-color wood engravings, which in their robust stylization dramatically render the grandeur of these engrossing yarns. Ages 6-up. Copyright 1991 Reed Business Information, Inc. From School Library Journal Grade 3-6-- This strikingly handsome, oversized volume presents nine all-American figures whose overblown exploits take them from coast to coast and through all manner of occupations and preoccupations. Osborne has chosen familiar fictitious characters--Pecos Bill, Paul Bunyan, Febold Feboldson--and actual people, such as Johnny Appleseed and Davy Crockett, and relates episodes that stress the individuals' human weaknesses as well as strengths. She has melded several legendary characters into a single heroine, Sally Ann Thunder Ann Whirlwind, who more than holds her own in such grand company. The rip-roaring action, broad humor, and colorful language of the convention are all here, but the violence is kept to a minimum and the laughs aren't at anyone's expense, except perhaps the subjects, who feel rather foolish on occasion. McCurdy's intricate wood engravings tinted with watercolor equal their tall task. He sets these larger-than-life folk on majestic landscapes brimming with energy, rich with wildlife and local color. The author's thoughtful introduction and notes round out this superlative offering. It's "the whole steamboat!" --Luann Toth, School Library JournalCopyright 1991 Reed Business Information, Inc. From Kirkus Reviews For the 90's, a handsome, well-documented collection of stories about nine uniquely American characters. In her intelligent introduction, Osborne explains their genesis ``from various combinations of historical fact, the storytelling of ordinary people, and the imagination of professional writers'' and notes that changing times put a new light on stories deriding various groups (including women and even animals). Thus her intention is to emphasize ``gargantuan physical courage and absurd humor'' and to ``bring out the vulnerable and compassionate side'' despite the stories' ``ineradicable taint of violence.'' Osborne succeeds pretty well in her intention, piecing together stories that make fine introductions to characters like Mose and Stormalong. Her approach suits Johnny Appleseed and John Henry better than it does Davy Crockett battling a panther, but she does manage to put a new slant on Pecos Bill and his bouncing bride without undermining the story (there's no question of a wife's disobedience here; Sue wants to ride Bill's horse as a test of skill). The telling is more polished than lively--Glen Rounds's irrepressible wit (Ol' Paul, the Mighty Logger, 1949) is more fun, but these versions are perfectly acceptable. McCurdy's vigorous wood engravings, tinted with lucid color, contribute a rugged frontier flavor; lively, though a bit formal in style, they suit the text admirably. Each story is introduced by source notes; a story-by-story bibliography provides a good roundup of this popular genre. (Folklore. 6-12) -- Copyright ©1991, Kirkus Associates, LP. All rights reserved. "McCurdy's intricate wood engravings set these larger-than-life folk on majestic landscapes brimming with energy, rich with wildlife and local color. The author's thoughtful introduction and notes round out this superlative offering."--(starred) School Library Journal. From the Inside Flap Illus. in full color. Upstarts like Davy Crockett, giants like Paul Bunyan, and gentle souls like Johnny Appleseed are among the nine "tall" heroes featured in this exuberant collection of traditional American folk tales. Celebrating the 15th anniversary of these collection of tales. There are among nine "tall" heroes featured in this exuberant collection of traditional American folk tales, including Paul Bunyan, JohnnyAppleseed, John Henry, and other American folk heroes. Mary Pope Osborne is the award-winning author of over sixty books for children. Her works include One World, Many Religions; New York’s Bravest; Tales from the Odyssey; Adaline Falling Star; and the Magic Tree House series, a New York Times number one bestselling children’s book series that has sold over 100 million copies worldwide. Ms. Osborne lives in northwestern Connecticut with her husband, Will. xa0 Michael McCurdy is a distinguished illustrator whose wood engravings and drawings have enhanced many books for both adults and children. From 1968 to 1985, he owned Penmaen Press Books, where he produced beautiful small-press first editions by leading American and European writers and poets. He wrote and illustrated An Algonquin Year: The Year According to the Full Moon and edited and illustrated Escape from Slavery: The Boyhood of Frederick Douglass in His Own Words. He lives with his wife, Deborah, in Massachusetts. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. ... Read more

Features & Highlights

  • The perfect addition to every family’s home library and just right for sharing aloud,
  • American Tall Tales
  • introduces readers to America’s first folk heroes in nine wildly exaggerated and downright funny stories.
  • Here are Paul Bunyan, that king-sized lumberjack who could fell “ten white pines with a single swing”; John Henry, with his mighty hammer; Mose, old New York’s biggest, bravest fireman; Sally Ann Thunder Ann Whirlwind, who could “outgrin, outsnort, outrun, outlift, outsneeze, outsleep, outlie any varmint”; and other uniquely American characters, together in one superb collection.   In the tradition of the original nineteenth-century storytellers, Mary Pope Osborne compiles, edits, and adds her own two cents’ worth—and also supplies fascinating historical headnotes. Michael McCurdy’s robust colored wood engravings recall an earlier time, perfectly capturing all the vitality of the men and women who carved a new country out of the North American wilderness.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
60%
(247)
★★★★
25%
(103)
★★★
15%
(62)
★★
7%
(29)
-7%
(-29)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Another case of pc censorship

I remember loving these stories when I was a kid. I decided to purchase a collection to re-read, and with my nephews coming for a visit, thought it would be perfect read-aloud material. I received the book a few days before their arrival, looked at the Introduction, and sent it back the next day. I was saddened, but not surprised to see political correctness creeping into even these classics. The author decided that there were items in these old stories that run contrary to our modern sensibilities, such as "conquering nature" and I suppose some issues involving minorities, so she decided to leave out certain things and emphasize the "compassionate side" (author's words) of these tall tale heroes. And of course she had to concoct a female tall tale character (sally windy whirlwind, or something like that) to complete the picture. Look, these stories were written and/or passed down from long ago. Yes, peoples' sensibilities were different. Yes, there are parts of these stories, and so many others, that are, how shall we say, not sensitive to the feelings of some individuals. But that's the way they were written, and that's the way they were told. Come to grips with it. I wonder how this author would react if someone censored her writings? I'll bet we can all guess.
138 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

So-so...

I would give this book 4 stars for the ease and convenience of having most of the major American folk tales and heroes in one volume, but I would have to give it 3 stars for readability and interest. These stories are actually much more interesting than this book makes them.

I think that perhaps the author, in trying to combine as many different original sources as possible for each story, ended up forsaking style for thoroughness.

Tall tales, when done well, have much more poetic flow than Osborne's do. I thought I was perhaps being too picky, but the fact that my two kids (both story lovers and avid readers) were COMPLETELY uninterested in the stories in this book validates what I had concluded - this volume is pretty much uninspired.
38 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Poorly written -- makes you hate them all

This book has nine tales, but Osborne has written every story in the exact same manner. Am I reading a tale about Davy Crocket or Pecos Bill? Hard to tell, because the style of every tale is mind-numbingly identical. Hard to believe that someone could make tales about Johnny Appleseed and John Henry boring.

And the fake American Tall Tale called "Sally Ann" that Osborne invented (apparently to have a female tale for the feminists) is junk -- basically identical to Davy Crocket with only the name changed.
27 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

cultural mythology

I bought this book for a grandchild. I grew up with the stories and want to share them and the characters with him. Who hasn't heard of at least one of the characters in the book: Paul Bunyan, Davy Crockett?

The writing style will be easily understood by children in early elementary. The really exceptional part of this book is the Foreward. It easily and clearly explains how the stories in the book have become part of our US cultural heritage without needing to be an educator to understand it.

I highly recommend it to anyone considering this type of book.
24 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Disappointed

I sent it back. If you’re looking for the traditional tales of some of our country’s greatest heroes, this isn’t it. The author fictionalize a lot of their stories. I wish she would have presented these folk heroes as they’ve traditionally been portrayed. But I guess she thought today’s audiences needed something more politically correct. Also, she makes up totally new characters. If you want to write fiction, do it. But don’t mess with American legends. They don’t need any modern day, woke author to deconstruct their stories!

We got a refund!!
14 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

“Reimagined” to as not offend. Not the original stories.

I didn’t realize these stories had been “revised” until I read the intro. They should be told in their original form, offensive or not, because that opens the door to discussions on history, and cultural norms of the day (right or wrong). I’m disappointed in this. Another worthless “non-offensive” re-telling of history. I’d planned to read to my 8 year old, but I’ll look instead for the originals, so that we discuss history, society, etc after reading, and things have changed. Beware- This is the author of The Magic Treehouse as well. I’ll not be purchasing more of her books.
12 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Good collection

Varying collection of tall tales. Used it for my 5th graders to access Common Core standards by boosting a curriculum-mandated tall tale to a compare/contrast assignments using these tales. The tall tales are a good length for the students to read and discuss on their own. I also recommend it for 4th grade teachers when they investigate the different American regions. Large (but not huge) text makes it good for copying to use w/ the students
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Classic

I love American tall tales. Unfortunately, they are not often passed down to the youngest generation. It is hard to tell who enjoys a "big fish" story more, the listener or the teller. I have used these stories as an introduction to hyperbole and oral tradition. I ask the question: what makes a story fun to listen to, or fun to tell? These tales are a fantastic way to engage students in both writing and speaking in front of a group. By the end of the unit, everyone has written a story they're dying to tell around our tissue paper campfire.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Really great stories and illustrations

Fabulous! Bought to go along with the Read Aloud Revival book club. Really great stories and illustrations. Nicely made.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

American Folk Tales

I bought this book for a Creative Writing Assignment I am doing with a class of 5th graders. I read them one of the stories and then asked them to write their own versions, using one of the characters from several of the other stories. These stories, re-imagined by Mary Pope Osborne are written in such a way that keeps any age of reader interested. Accompanied by wonderful wood-etched drawings care of Michael McCurdy, it allows a child, who has very little understanding of the way things worked before planes and cars, to get a feel for our early American times and the way these larger than life characters lived.
6 people found this helpful