Beautiful Malice: A Novel
Beautiful Malice: A Novel book cover

Beautiful Malice: A Novel

Hardcover – July 13, 2010

Price
$12.40
Format
Hardcover
Pages
272
Publisher
Bantam
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0553808056
Dimensions
6.35 x 0.95 x 9.55 inches
Weight
1.1 pounds

Description

From Publishers Weekly Starred Review. "I didn't go to Alice's funeral." So opens Australian author James's impressive debut, a searing coming-of-age novel that deftly intertwines two violent backstories. Studious Katherine Patterson, who's reading a book under a tree during lunchtime at her Sydney high school, is surprised when Alice Parrie, "beautiful, popular, impossible to miss," hands Katherine an invitation to her 18th birthday party. Alice draws Katherine, who has her reasons for remaining aloof from others, into an addictive relationship that fatally sours as one disturbing secret after another comes to light. James, gifted with unusual insight into teenage agonies, probes Katherine's raw-nerve guilt over her sister Rachel's murder, Alice's self-destructive narcissism, and the healing power of young love. This unflinching exploration of psychological manipulation and the tragedies it creates introduces a promising new talent in literary suspense. Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. From Booklist Australian author James' U.S. debut speaks directly to older teens and twentysomethings. Katherine, a self-imposed outsider who narrates her own story, may be wrapped in guilt following the tragic death of her sister, but she is still recognizably 17—longing for friendship and fun, searching for love, committment, and sex. When charismatic classmate Alice befriends her, emotional baggage and all, she is surprised and enormously grateful. But as her self-confidence returns and she finds other friends and a sweet, gentle boyfriend, she begins to see her best friend in fresh light—and starts wondering if Alice is really a friend at all. A nail-biting thriller this isn't, and wouldn't be if the title wasn't an unfortunate giveaway. But the novel will be an easy sell as a beach book, and it's not hard to picture readers sympathizing with Katherine's deep-rooted need to make sense of the past and find satisfaction in the person she has become. --Stephanie Zvirin “Utterly gripping! Rebecca James is an exciting new writer.”—Cecelia Ahern xa0“[An] impressive debut . . . This unflinching exploration of psychological manipulation and the tragedies it creates introduces a promising new talent in literary suspense.”— Publishers Weekly (starred review)xa0“As the truth unfolds towards a devastating climax, no one escapes untouched. As a debut novel, one can only imagine what else Rebecca James has up her sleeve.”— Daily Mail (London)xa0“A good, suspenseful, psychological thriller . . . worthy of passing on to friends.” —The Roanoke Times “Powerfully emotional . . .xa0 a mesmerizing story.”—Wichita Falls Times News Record “Recommended for all thriller collections.”— Library Journal From the Paperback edition. Rebecca James was born in Sydney and spent her twenties teaching English in Indonesia and Japan. She currently lives in Armidale, Australia, with her partner and their four sons. She is at work on her next novel, to be published by Bantam. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Chapter One “Do you want to come?”xa0Alice Parrie is looking down, smiling. It’s lunchtime and I’m sittingxa0beneath a tree, alone, absorbed in a book.xa0“Sorry.” I shade my eyes and look up. “Come where?”xa0Alice hands me a piece of paper.xa0I take it and read. It’s a brightly colored photocopy of an invitationxa0to Alice’s eighteenth birthday party. Come one and come all!!xa0Bring your friends!! it reads. Free champagne! Free food! Onlyxa0someone as popular and as self- assured as Alice would issue such anxa0invitation; anyone more ordinary would feel as if she was beggingxa0for guests. Why me? I wonder. I know of Alice, everyone knows ofxa0Alice, but I’ve never spoken to her before. She is one of those girls—xa0beautiful, popular, impossible to miss.xa0I fold the invitation in half and nod. “I’ll try. It sounds like fun,”xa0I lie.xa0Alice looks at me for a few seconds. Then she sighs and plonksxa0herself down next to me, so close that one of her knees rests heavilyxa0against mine.xa0“You will not.” She grins.xa0I feel my cheeks begin to color. Even though my entire life canxa0sometimes feel like a façade, a wall of secrets, I’m not good at lying.xa0I look down at my lap. “Probably not.”xa0“But I want you to come, Katherine,” she says. “It’d really meanxa0a lot to me.”xa0I’m surprised that Alice even knows my name, but it’s even morexa0surprising—in fact, quite unbelievable—that she wants me to comexa0to her party. I’m practically unknown at Drummond High and havexa0no close friends. I come and go quietly, alone, and get on with myxa0studies. I try to avoid bringing attention to myself. I do well enough,xa0but my grades aren’t exceptional. I play no sport, have joined noxa0clubs. And though I know I can’t do this forever—live my entire lifexa0as a shadow—for now it’s okay. I’m hiding, I know that, I’m beingxa0a coward, but right now I need to be invisible, to be the kind of personxa0who arouses no curiosity in others. That way they never need toxa0know who I really am, or what has happened.xa0I close my book and start to pack away my lunch things.xa0“Wait.” Alice puts her hand on my knee. I look at her as coldlyxa0as I can, and she withdraws it. “I’m serious. I really do want you toxa0come. And I think what you said to Dan last week was fantastic. Ixa0really wish I could think of things like that to say, but I never can.xa0I’m just not quick enough. You know, I never would have thoughtxa0about that woman’s feelings like that. Not until I heard you tell Danxa0off. I mean, you were great, what you said was just so right, and youxa0really showed him up to be the moron that he is.”xa0I know immediately what Alice is referring to—the one and onlyxa0time I’d let my guard down, momentarily forgotten myself. I don’txa0often confront people anymore. In fact, it’s something I try veryxa0hard to avoid. But the way Dan Johnson and his friends had behavedxa0two weeks ago had disgusted me so much that I couldn’t helpxa0myself. We had a guest speaker talking about career planning andxa0college admissions. Sure, the speech was boring, we’d heard it all axa0billion times before, and the speaker was nervous and stuttered andxa0hesitated and talked in confusing circles, only becoming worse asxa0the crowd became noisier, more restless. Dan Johnson and his groupxa0of creepy friends had spotted their opportunity. They were so cruelxa0and deliberately disruptive that the woman ended up leaving in humiliatedxa0tears. When it was all over, I stood behind Dan in the hallwayxa0and tapped him on the shoulder.xa0Dan turned around with a smug, self- satisfied look on his face,xa0clearly anticipating some kind of approbation for his behavior.xa0“Did it ever occur to you,” I started, my voice surprisinglyxa0strong, fueled by anger, “how much you’ve hurt that woman? Thisxa0is her life, Daniel, her career, her professional reputation. Your patheticxa0cry for attention means a whole lot of humiliation for her. Ixa0feel sorry for you, Daniel. You must be very sad and small inside toxa0need to hurt someone like that, someone you don’t even know.”xa0“You were amazing,” Alice continues. “And to be honest, I wasxa0totally surprised. I mean, I think everyone was. No one speaks toxa0Dan like that.” She shakes her head. “No one.” Well, I do, I think. At least the real me does. “It was admirable. Courageous.”xa0And it’s that word that does it: courageous. I so want to be courageous.xa0I so want the coward in me to be obliterated and smashedxa0and destroyed that I can no longer resist Alice.xa0I stand up and hook my bag over my shoulder. “Okay,” I say, surprisingxa0myself. “Okay, I’ll come.”xa0Chapter TwoAlice insists that we get ready for the party together. She picks mexa0up in her car, a battered old Volkswagen, shortly after lunch on thexa0day of the party and takes me to her place. She lives alone, she tellsxa0me as she speeds along, weaving in and out of lanes, in a onebedroomxa0apartment in the inner city. I’m surprised by this, astonishedxa0really. I’d imagined that someone like Alice would live in axa0comfortable house in the suburbs with her devoted parents. I’dxa0imagined her being spoiled, pampered, coddled (just as I used to be),xa0and the fact that she lives alone makes her suddenly seem more interesting,xa0more complicated than I’ve given her credit for. It’s clearxa0that Alice and I have more in common than I’d imagined.xa0I want to ask her a million questions: Where are her parents?xa0How does she afford her own apartment? Is she ever afraid? Is shexa0lonely? But I keep quiet. I have secrets of my own. I’ve learned thatxa0asking questions only puts me at risk of being interrogated myself. Itxa0is safer not to be too curious about others, safer not to ask.xa0Her apartment is in a square, very ordinary- looking brick building. The stairwell is dark and uninviting, but when we get to herxa0apartment, breathless after jogging up four flights of stairs, shexa0opens the door to a room full of color and warmth.xa0The walls are a deep burnt orange and are decorated with large,xa0bright abstract paintings. Two enormous, soft- looking couches arexa0draped with burgundy fabric and strewn with colorful African cushions.xa0Unlit candles cover every horizontal surface.xa0“Voilà! My humble abode.” Alice tugs me inside and watches myxa0face expectantly as I look around the room. “What do you think? Ixa0did it all myself, you know. You should have seen it when I movedxa0in, so boring and plain. It’s amazing what a bit of color can do to axa0room, isn’t it? A little creativity and some bright paint is all youxa0really need.”xa0“This is so cool,” I say. And I can’t help but feel a little envious.xa0Alice’s space is so funky, so much younger than the modern, minimalistxa0apartment I live in.xa0“Really? You really like it?”xa0“Yes.” I laugh. “I really do.”xa0“I’m so glad. I want you to like it as much as I do because I planxa0for us to spend a lot of time together. And I can see us spending a lotxa0of time right here, in this room, talking and talking and talking,xa0sharing our precious secrets deep into the night.”xa0I’ve heard that charming, powerful people have the knack ofxa0making you feel as though you’re the only person in the world, andxa0now I know exactly what that means. I’m not quite sure what shexa0does, or how she does it—another person would have come acrossxa0as overly eager; obsequious, even—but when Alice gives me her attentionxa0like that, I feel golden, warm with the certainty that I’m fullyxa0understood.xa0For a brief, insane moment, I imagine telling her my secret. I picturexa0it all clearly. Me and Alice in this room—both a little tipsy, bothxa0giggly and happy and ever so slightly self- conscious with the feelingxa0you have when you’ve made a new friend, a special friend—I put myxa0hand on her knee so that she is still and quiet, so that she knows I’mxa0about to say something important, and then I tell her. I tell herxa0quickly, without pausing, without meeting her eyes. And when I’vexa0finished, she is warm and forgiving and understanding, as I hopedxa0she’d be. She hugs me. Everything is all right and I am lighter forxa0having told. I am free.xa0But this is all just a dream. A crazy fantasy. I tell her nothing.xa0I’m wearing my usual jeans and boots and shirt, and I’ve broughtxa0some makeup with me to put on before we go to the party, but Alicexa0insists that I wear a dress. Her closet is bursting with them, in allxa0sorts of colors and lengths and styles. There must be at least a hundred,xa0and some still have tags. I wonder where she gets the money,xa0how she affords so many clothes, and I’m tempted, once again,xa0to ask.xa0“I have a bit of a clothing habit.” She grins.xa0“Really?” I joke. “I would never have ... Read more

Features & Highlights

  • An international sensation that
  • The Wall Street Journal
  • called a “publishing phenomenon,” this layered, poignant, and chilling novel of psychological suspense is the year’s most stunning American fiction debut. From its wrenching opening to its shocking climax,
  • Beautiful Malice
  • unfolds a haunting story in which people, motives, and circumstances are never what they seem.Who is Katherine Patterson? It is a question she hopes no one can answer. To erase her past, Katherine has moved to a new city, enrolled in a new school, and even changed her name. She’s done the next best thing to disappearing altogether. Now, wary and alone, she seeks nothing more than anonymity. What she finds instead is the last thing she expected: a friend.Even more unlikely, Katherine’s new friend is the most popular and magnetic girl in school. Extroverted, gorgeous, flirtatious, and unpredictable, she is everything that Katherine is not and doesn’t want to be: the center of attention. Yet Alice’s enthusiasm is infectious, her candor sometimes unsettling, and Katherine, in spite of her guarded caution, finds herself drawn into Alice’s private circle. But Alice has secrets, too—darker than anyone can begin to imagine. And when she lets her guard down at last, Katherine discovers the darkest of them all. For there will be no escaping the past for Katherine Patterson—only a descent into a trap far more sinister . . . and infinitely more seductive.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(68)
★★★★
25%
(57)
★★★
15%
(34)
★★
7%
(16)
23%
(52)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

UGH!

As originally posted on my blog Ticket to Anywhere

Where to start...

There were just so many things about Beautiful Malice that did not work for me. First lets start with the setting. For the most part the setting is unclear, ambiguous but then the main characters all go for this weekend holiday in a town located in New South Wales, Australia. I was like...yes...finally a clear setting and one that makes the language of the book make sense. Australians just have a slightly different way of speaking than Americans - the cadences of words are just different. But then when the gang meets up with Ben - the author makes a point to say that he was Australian and that one reason why Alice dated him was for his accent. That just baffled me as by this point I thought they were all Australian. Then a few pages later Ben is telling a story and mentions when he first came to the state....and I just went huh? It didn't make sense since the only place that was ever mentioned was a place location in Australia - and living stateside you don't exactly make a weekend trip to Australia....especially when you're trying to keep things on the cheap.

Note: in talking with another blogger who read the Australian version of the book the setting was very clearly stated as Sydney, Australia...so it seems that for whatever reason the American publisher decided to try and remove those references.

But moving on...lets talk about sequence and the flow of time. This book has three distinct time periods in them and there is no real rhyme or reason to the authors jumping from one to another. The changes just became this jumbled mess for me which would knock me out of the story. I believe it was done as a way to try to heighten the suspense and make the thrills more thrilling as random bits and pieces of the past, present and future were revealed. But my suspense wasn't heightened the odd changes just annoyed me more than anything else. Especially during those times with the perspective of the book would change. For the bulk of the book the story was told in first person but every so often the I's would change to you's and it never really worked for me.

Then there is the plot.

The very first line tells you exactly what happens to Alice there is no suspense there. No shock. The story is just so flat and bland and I figured out what all the big reveals where before they were made official. The characters also all came across as flat and one dimensional. Alice was narcissistic and crazy and she appeared so form the start...she then just spirals out of control and it just doesn't ring true. Katherine is a girl trying to escape her past by forgetting it and when things get hard or rough she just turns her back on the darkness and tries to pretend it doesn't exist. This is not healthy behavior and not something that you want to do when the person you are trying to forget is crazy.

This book didn't work for me on so many levels and its not one that I can recommend. Beautiful Malice is also a book that is often billed as Young Adult but I don't get the YA vibe from it when I read it. The phrasing and the way the characters speak (in their bad dialogue scenes) is way more adult than teen. What about you...have you read Beautiful Malice? What did you think of it? Let me know if the comments below.

As originally posted on my blog Ticket to Anywhere
13 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Sad attempt at a novel

I keep rereading the back of this novel and am still stunned that they actually call this book a "publishing phenomenon" - a complex, poignant chilling novel of psychological suspense. I am also shocked to keep reading that the author Rebecca James used to be an English teacher. I really do hope she was better at that job than she is as an author. I am a huge fan of the psychological thriller genre and was very excited to read this novel. The story description is very intriguing. And that is the one and only good thing the author did here. She came up with a good plot. Now if only she had turned it over to a capable author. I don't often write reviews this negative but I feel the truth should always be told so that other readers know what to expect. This book is honestly one of the worst I have ever read. I only finished it for I had to write a review for the Vine program.

The story described on the back is exactly true to the premise in the book. We have Katherine who has endured a truly tragic experience in her life and she moves to a new school and tries to quietly blend in and just get by. But a very popular girl Alice befriends her and pulls her out of her shell. And we will find out that Alice has secrets as well and that Katherine will fall into a terror worse than that she has already endured. First off, these characters are in high school and in no way come across that way. Alice is seen as popular only in a couple of early scenes. Then she is just over the top bizarre. No one like this would be popular. But the real problem starts with the quality of the writing. Take away the adult themes of part of this novel and I would think that it was written for juveniles. The writing style is infantile, the characters are all one dimensional stereotypes and all the actions these characters take are in no way believable.

Do not allow yourself to be pulled in by the intriguing premise of this novel and waste your money. The story as it moves along becomes truly ridiculous and the ending is totally over the top and a true letdown. It just suddenly ends. There is no satisfaction for the reader even in the ending. I love pyschological thrillers which means deep characterizations and suspenseful themes with intricate plots that grow and develop. None of that is here. There is no intelligence or skill here whatsoever. Pass on this one.
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Excellent

I highly doubt that a large proportion of the negative reviews that I have read for this book were actually written by the age group in which this book is aimed at. I, for one, am in the intended audience, and absolutely loved it. For those who call this book cliche, I do not understand. This type of teenage girl fiction in which I can loose myself, and imagine myself as the characters, is the genre I thrive off.

This book made me cry and laugh. It was amazing. I did not expect the climatic 'mystery' ending. It was easy to read. It was laid out sensibly, with the flashbacks easy to understand.

I highly recommend this book.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Definitely not a YA read!

A massive disappointment.

The good stuff first so that you guys don't think I'm nasty giving it a poor rating because I was in some kind of bad mood. But honestly I couldn't see what the fuss was all about.

I guess it was a compelling read. Although I'm not quite sure why -- I can't say that I cared very much about the plot and, although I love psychological thrillers I couldn't say that there was any massive driving questions that had me chewing my nails. I read it in a couple of hours and there were some points in the book that I felt the tension that readers should feel but the feeling didn't last long, which was a major disappointment. This really could have been much better.

The character who had the most appeal to me was Robbie, a young man who has lost his mother and who finds no support or comfort from his emotionally wrecked father. One who is willing to succumb to the poison that is Alice so as to feel even an iota of happiness that she able to give him despite the destruction she brings to his heart and mind.

However, this is where I have to bridge the gap between praise and criticism. I relished the Alice parts because James showed elements of Alice's character, and the depth of her narcissism, with fairly subtle stuff like Alice not wanting to travel because no-one would know her abroad. However, James isn't satisfied until she has beaten that horse to a bloody pulp. James, you are wrtiing for a YA adult, but YAs are not morons. They know a narcissist when they see it even if they don't know the psychological term. The reader doesn't need a psychology master's student (Philippa) running around telling us that Alice has "issues." We understand how badly Alice's mother abandoning her must have screwed her up and that it's probably the reason behind her actions -- we don't need that vomit-inducing, sanctimonious paragraph that Katherine delivered at the end. We get that Alice is not 100% monster. We don't need Katherine laying out all of Alice's problems and giving us a mini-justification.

Even worse, we didn't see nearly enough of Alice's charm. Katherine kept telling us that she had it, but being hot/pretty and having charm and charisma are two different things. When Alice's sanity starts to slip, she doesn't seem charming - she just seems loud and obnoxious. Maybe that is the point, but the only scene (yes, one scene in the 300+ page novel) that I felt any sense of Alice's charismatic presence was in the "morning after" scene where she sobs all over Katherine with her full of bologna apologies.

James doesn't seem to know how to both show and tell about things in her writing. There needs to be a balance of writing what is happening (telling) and writing descriptions of actions that readers can infer meaning to (showing). Sadly, James never showed us anything, she only told us. Case in point: "I don't want to leave Mick." "Alice could be so charming sometimes." "I was Rachel's number one fan." We never really see any of Mick or Alice's more endearing qualities; Katherine just sort of tells us that they have them, and we're supposed to believe it without any real evidence.

Another thing that annoyed me is that I had no idea of time frame or setting. It's true that Beautiful Malice is non-linear, with HORRIBLE flash forwards to an adult Katherine but it spoiled the best twist of the novel, Katherine has a child. The book opens with Katherine and Alice's first real meeting and blabs through that for a while, then skips forward to Katherine and Robbie's first meeting, then skips forward again, with no indication of how long, to when Katherine and Robbie and Alice are all BFFs. That was just very confusing to me. I also didn't know where this was all taking place. The writer is Australian but I am not sure if that is the setting. The only description we get is they live in a city and that Katherine moved from the suburbs...but of where?? I can't stand not knowing the setting of a story. Just a pet peeve of mine.

The climax was poorly written. It was vague, confusing, and uninteresting. Why is it that James could write about rape (admittedly in a vague way), pregnancy, sociopathy, abduction, guilt, sex and nudity, but she couldn't write a good scene of violence? I'm not an overly gory person, but I felt that the ending was just such a cop-out. My blood was not pounding. My heart was not racing. More than anything I was scanning the pages thinking WTH is going on?

One more major point...I don't like how Katherine was made to feel as if it was her fault. I don't even like the thought being put into young girls heads that because Katherine had to do something to save herself that she feels at fault. No young woman should ever feel guilt is she is attacked. This is where I feel like the novel should not be labeled YA. Even though James tries to make it clear that Katherine isn't at fault, just the mere mention of it makes me sick. So IMHO this book should not be read by young readers. Not only is there the vague suggestion of blame if someone is attacked but there is bad language, sex, and drug use by minors. I wouldn't want my young daughter to read this book. So let this be a warning to parents who are deciding on whether to let thier teen read this book. I would say it is 18+, NOT FOR TEENAGERS.

There is probably more, but on the whole, Beautiful Malice was just a half-baked, inconsistent disappointmnent. There are no relationships, no tension and no real mystery. Next time no more of even the suggestion that if a girl is attacked it is her fault! Generous 2 stars.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

cannot recommend this book to anyone, esp JA.

It is incredible that anyone can imagine Katherine putting up with all the insane actions of Alice. This is not friendship of any stripe, just masochistic and sick. Senseless, I hope this author sharpens her skills as I won't pick up another of her books.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A heart-felt, piece-of-life novel

I knew I wanted to read this book, but I guess I wasn't exactly sure what to expect from it-- it's obvious from the introduction that this girl Alice is going to cause a lot of trouble, but I honestly didn't think she could be so cruel.

The way the book is set up kinda reminded me of Gabriel Garcia Marquez's Chronicles of a Death Foretold: we know from the beginning that Katherine has changed her name and moved to a city because of her sister's death, but events unfold later on, and the more the story continues, the more we find out about what really happened. One thing we know from the beginning is that Alice is bad news.

As I was reading about the horrible things she does, I found myself going, "Come on; who does that?" only to realize a second later that I actually do know people who are capable of that kind of cruelty. And then there were times when I wanted to grab Katherine and Robbie (the guy who's in love with Alice no matter how bad she treats him) by the shoulders and shake them, going, "She's evil! Run while you can!" But, of course, it doesn't always work that way and we're constantly pulled in by people whom we know are not good for us. And I think everyone knows the feeling of loving and hating someone both at the same time.

I think the book very well portrays how one bad decision can change your life, and that you don't usually realize it was a bad decision until you fall apart, and no matter how careful you try to be, you get caught up in things.

The ending felt kinda abrupt, and I was left wanting more, but it was a happy ending that felt warm and genuine.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

could be OK for young adult audience, but weak in general

I think that this book would only be a good read for a young adult. It would be aimed at a high school or early college student. The characters are young (most are in high school or recent grads) and therefore they are hard to relate to as an adult reader. Further, the level of writing is very young adult-like. James did a good job setting up a seedy (though very predictable) plot and all of the characters have a level of interest to them...with the exception of the main character, Katherine (which is really what ruined it for me). She was written in as a bystander and in most instances, her reactions were so understated/wishy-washy that it became frustrating. She is the main character, yet she doesn't seem to have a presence at all.

All around, it is weak in creativity, character development, and depth.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Not your average suspense novel

I read a lot. I'm pretty tough on crime fiction -- it's so cliche and overdone usually. The same kind of plot with the same kind of characters. I really liked Beautiful Malice because it was fresh and different. It's one of the best fiction books I've read in a long time. I found it to be very suspenseful and hard to put down. I don't want to give anything away about the plot, but rest assured you won't be disappointed if you pick up a copy. I do have to say it's a little predictable at the end, but that didn't bother me at that point.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Beautifully Disturbing

Extremely disturbing but in a good way. I was grabbed from the very first line, wondering what had Alice done that was so bad that her friend refused to go to her funeral and hated her for destroying her life. As the story unfolds, in drips of horror and terror, I started looking around every corner, suspecting bad things to come for Katherine, the survivor, and wondering what other tragedies would happen to her.

Rebecca James weaves a hypnotizing tale, one that has you almost believing in a happy ending, tempted to ignore the warning signs, yet knowing all along that whatever happiness that can be retrieved blossomed out of depth-less grief.

Well done and masterful. I couldn't turn the pages fast enough and often peeked ahead, unable to sustain the tension.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

This Book is Horrible

I can't understand how people like this novel. The story is completely predictable and has been done too many times. Honestly, it reads like bad teen romance. The timeline isn't even in sync. There are all of these references of how the "tragedy" happened years ago, etc, yet Katherine is only 17. The main problem is that no one would put with with the antics of this girl Alice. I understand suspending belief, but this goes too far. And the ending is - predictable! If you want to read it, do not pay for it! Go to the library.
3 people found this helpful