How Much of These Hills Is Gold: A Novel
How Much of These Hills Is Gold: A Novel book cover

How Much of These Hills Is Gold: A Novel

Paperback – April 6, 2021

Price
$12.79
Format
Paperback
Pages
336
Publisher
Riverhead Books
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0525537212
Dimensions
5.14 x 0.87 x 7.98 inches
Weight
8.8 ounces

Description

Praise for How Much of These Hills Is Gold : “Arresting, beautiful.” — The New York Times “An aching book, full of myths of Zhang’s making (including tigers that roam the Western hills) as well as joys, as well as sorrows. It’s violent and surprising and musical. Like Lucy and Sam, the novel wanders down byways and takes detours and chances. By journey’s end, you’re enriched and enlightened by the lives you have witnessed.” — The New York Times “[A] glittering debut . . . This novel is at once a thrilling adventure, a tender coming-of-age story, an excavation of the corrosive mythmaking surrounding the American west, and the arrival of a major literary talent.” — Esquire “While the book presents a counter-narrative to conventional tales of America’s origins, it also interrogates the more intimate dimensions of belonging and memory, asking, over and over, ‘What makes a home a home?’” — The New Yorker “Sure to be the boldest debut of the year.” — The Guardian “A fully immersive epic drama packed with narrative riches and exquisitely crafted prose . . . Zhang captures not only the mesmeric beauty and storied history of America’s sacred landscape, but also the harsh sacrifices countless people were forced to make in hopes of laying claim to its bounty.” — San Francisco Chronicle “Outstanding . . . Zhang does more than just push against the cowboy narrative: She shoves it clear out of the way. . . . at once subversive and searching”— The Washington Post "C Pam Zhang’s stunning debut novel wends forward and backward in time, asking in stark terms what it takes to claim a piece of the American dream. " “Just as Zhang tinkers with Western tropes, she also plays with language, weaving Chinese phrases with cowboy drawl, merging myths of tigers with fables about where the buffalo roam. Her prose at its best can be heart-stoppingly lyrical.” —USA Today “ How Much of These Hills Is Gold is first and foremost a family story, a gorgeous novel that gives its characters room to learn, mourn, fight, and reinvent themselves. But it also reveals the flaws and false revisions in the American mythos, the ways we have never fully overcome the brutalities on which this country was built, and how much was lost, destroyed, and stolen in the pursuit of profit along the way.” — Chicago Review of Books “Imaginative, vital . . . Zhang’s searing words pierce the heart of America’s founding mythology, laying bare its lies, and offering up a new, much-needed vision of this country and its people.” — Refinery29 “As she depicts their journey, Zhang prompts the reader to think about whose stories are told from this period of American history—fictional or not—and adds her urgent voice to the genre.” — Time “A world wrought of breath and blood and imagination.” — Lit Hub “Stunning . . . a long-overdue treatment of the American West.” — Outside “Lyrical and mythic, How Much of These Hills Is Gold reconceives the immigrant narrative to tell an original story of racism and American greed.” — The A.V. Club “C Pam Zhang’s electrifying debut is a sweeping work of historical fiction—the sort of masterpiece that immediately establishes an author as a force to be reckoned with.” — Harper’s Bazaar “This moving tale of family, gold, and freedom rings with a truth that defies rosy preconceptions. The description of human and environmental degradation is balanced by shining characters who persevere greatly. Highly recommended.” — Library Journal (starred review) “[An] extraordinary debut . . . Gorgeously written and fearlessly imagined, Zhang’s awe-inspiring novel introduces two indelible characters whose odyssey is as good as the gold they seek.” —Publishers Weekly (starred review) “Aesthetically arresting and a vital contribution to America’s conversation about itself.” — Kirkus Reviews (starred review) “Daringly original . . . Zhang’s laser-sharp reexamination of America’s myth-laden past is likely to help bring clarity to many issues that continue to challenge us all.” — BookPage (starred review) “Smart, beautiful, and intimate.”xa0— The Millions “Ferocious, dark and gleaming, a book erupting out of the interstices between myth and dream, between longing and belonging. How Much of These Hills Is Gold tells us that stories—like people, like the rough and stunning landscape of California itself—are constantly in the process of being made, broken, and finally remade into something tender and new.”xa0—Lauren Groff, The New York Times –bestselling author of Fates and Furies “A haunting, riveting and truly remarkable debut. Zhang writes with the clear-eyed lucidity of ancient mythmakers whose eyes are attuned to the vicissitudes of nature and humanity.” —Chigozie Obioma, author of Booker Prize finalist An Orchestra of Minorities “This exhilarating novel unweaves the myths of the American West and offers in their place a gorgeous, broken, soulful, feral song of family and yearning, origin and earth. C Pam Zhang is a brilliant, fearless writer. This book is a wonder.”xa0—Garth Greenwell, author of What Belongs to You “A truly gifted writer.”xa0—Sebastian Barry, author of The Secret Scripture “A ravishingly written revisionist story of the making of the West, C Pam Zhang’s debut is pure gold.” — Emma Donoghue, author of Room “ How Much of These Hills is a miracle, as timely as it is timeless, propulsive but also wonderfully meditative, a ferocious, tender epic about a vulnerable immigrant family trying to survive the American Gold Rush. I read it in one night and know I’ll revisit it soon: I envy you your first read of this book.” — R.O. Kwon, author of The Incendiaries “The writing here is intuitive, chewy, wonderful; the plot is devastatingxa0and the talent is dazzling. Zhang is a blazing writer.” — Daisy Johnson, author of Everything Under Born in Beijing but mostly an artifact of the United States, C Pam Zhang has lived in thirteen cities across four countries and is still looking for home. She’s been awarded support from Tin House, Bread Loaf, Aspen Words, and elsewhere, and currently lives in San Francisco. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Gold Ba dies in the night, prompting them to seek two silver dollars. Sam's tapping an angry beat come morning, but Lucy, before they go, feels a need to speak. Silence weighs harder on her, pushes till she gives way. "Sorry," she says to Ba in his bed. The sheet that tucks him is the only clean stretch in this dim and dusty shack, every surface black with coal. Ba didn't heed the mess while living and in death his mean squint goes right past it. Past Lucy. Straight to Sam. Sam the favorite, round bundle of impatience circling the doorway in too-big boots. Sam clung to Ba's every word while living and now won't meet the man's gaze. That's when it hits Lucy: Ba really is gone. She digs a bare toe into dirt floor, rooting for words to make Sam listen. To spread benediction over years of hurt. Dust hangs ghostly in the light from the lone window. No wind to stir it. Something prods Lucy's spine. "Pow," Sam says. Eleven to Lucy's twelve, wood to her water as Ma liked to say, Sam is nonetheless shorter by a full foot. Looks young, deceptively soft. "Too slow. You're dead." Sam cocks fingers back on pudgy fists and blows on the muzzle of an imagined gun. The way Ba used to. Proper way to do things, Ba said, and when Lucy said Teacher Leigh said these new guns didn't clog and didn't need blowing, Ba judged the proper way was to slap her. Stars burst behind her eyes, a flint of pain sharp in her nose. Lucy's nose never did grow back straight. She thumbs it, thinking. Proper way, Ba said, was to let it heal itself. When he looked at Lucy's face after the bloom of bruise faded, he nodded right quick. Like he'd planned it all along. Proper that you should have something to rememory you for sassing. There's dirt on Sam's brown face, sure, and gunpowder rubbed on to look (Sam thinks) like Indian war paint, but beneath it all, Sam's face is unblemished. Just this once, because Ba's fists are helpless and stiff under the blanket-and maybe she is good, is smart, thinks in some small part that riling Ba might make him rise to swing at her-Lucy does what she never does. She cocks her hands, points her fingers. Prods Sam's chin where paint gives way to baby fat. The jaw another might call delicate, if not for Sam's way of jutting it. "Pow yourself," Lucy says. She pushes Sam like an outlaw to the door. Sun sucks them dry. Middle of the dry season, rain by now a distant memory. Their valley is bare dirt, halved by a wriggle of creek. On this side are the miners' flimsy shacks, on the other the moneyed buildings with proper walls, glass windows. And all around, circumscribing, the endless hills seared gold; and hidden within their tall, dry grasses, ragtag camps of prospectors and Indians, knots of vaqueros and travelers and outlaws, and the mine, and more mines, and beyond, and beyond. Sam squares small shoulders and sets out across the creek, red shirt a shout against the barrenness. When they first arrived there was still long yellow grass in this valley, and scrub oaks on the ridge, and poppies after rain. The flood three and a half years back rooted up those oaks, drowned or chased away half the people. Yet their family stayed, set alone at the valley's far edge. Ba like one of those lightning-split trees: dead down the center, roots still gripping on. And now that Ba's gone? Lucy fits her bare feet to Sam's prints and keeps quiet, saving spit. The water's long gone, the world after the flood left somehow thirstier. And long gone, Ma. Across the creek the main street stretches wide, shimmering and dusty as snakeskin. False fronts loom: saloon and blacksmith, trading post and bank and hotel. People lounge in the shadows like dragon lizards. Jim sits in the general store, scritching in his ledger. It's wide as him and half as heavy. They say he keeps accounts of what's owed from every man in the territory. "Excuse us," Lucy murmurs, weaving through the kids who loiter near the candy, eyes hungering for a solution to their boredom. "Sorry. Pardon me." She shrinks herself small. The kids part lazily, arms knocking her shoulders. At least today they don't reach out to pinch. Jim's still fixed on his ledger. Louder now: "Excuse me, sir?" A dozen eyes prick Lucy, but still Jim ignores her. Knowing already that the idea's a bad one, Lucy edges her hand onto the counter to flag his attention. Jim's eyes snap up. Red eyes, flesh raw at the rims. "Off," he says. His voice flicks, steel wire. His hands go on writing. "Washed that counter this morning." Jagged laughter from behind. That doesn't bother Lucy, who after years lived in towns like this has no more tender parts to tear. What scoops her stomach hollow, the way it was when Ma died, is the look in Sam's eyes. Sam squints mean as Ba. Ha! Lucy says because Sam won't. Ha! Ha! Her laughter shields them, makes them part of the pack. "Only whole chickens today," Jim says. "No feet for you. Come back tomorrow." "We don't need provisions," Lucy lies, already tasting the melt of chicken skin on her tongue. She forces herself taller, clenches hands at her sides. And she speaks her need. I'll tell you the only magic words that matter, Ba said when he threw Ma's books in the storm-born lake. He slapped Lucy to stop her crying, but his hand was slow. Almost gentle. He squatted to watch Lucy wipe snot across her face. Ting wo, Lucy girl: On credit. Ba's words work some sort of magic, sure enough. Jim pauses his pen. "Say that again, girl?" "Two silver dollars. On credit." Ba's voice booming at her back, in her ear. Lucy can smell his whiskey breath. Daren't turn. Should his shovel hands clap her shoulders, she doesn't know if she'll scream or laugh, run or hug him round the neck so hard she won't come loose no matter how he cusses. Ba's words tumble out the tunnel of her throat like a ghost clambering from the dark: "Payday's Monday. All we need's a little stretch. Honest." She spits on her hand and extends it. Jim's no doubt heard this refrain from miners, from their dry wives and hollow children. Poor like Lucy. Dirty like Lucy. Jim's been known to grunt, push the needed item over, and charge double interest come payday. Didn't he once give out bandages on credit after a mine accident? To people desperate like Lucy. But none of them quite like Lucy. Jim's gaze measures her. Bare feet. Sweat-stained dress in ill-fitting navy, made from scraps of Ba's shirt fabric. Gangly arms, hair rough as chicken wire. And her face. "Grain I'll give your pa on credit," Jim says. "And whatever animal parts you find fit to eat." His lip curls up, flashes a strip of wet gum. On someone else it might be called a smile. "For money, get him to the bank." The spit dries tight on Lucy's untouched palm. "Sir-" Louder than Lucy's fading voice, Sam's boot heel hits the floor. Sam marches, straight-shouldered, out of the store. Small, Sam is. But capable of a man's strides in those calfskin boots. Sam's shadow licks back at Lucy's toes; in Sam's mind the shadow is the true height, the body a temporary inconvenience. When I'm a cowboy, Sam says. When I'm an adventurer. More recently: When I'm a famous outlaw. When I'm grown. Young enough to think desire alone shapes the world. "Bank won't help the likes of us," Lucy says. She might as well have said nothing. Dust tickles her nose and she stops to cough. Her throat ripples. She retches last night's dinner into the street. Straightaway come the strays, licking at her leavings. For a moment Lucy hesitates, though Sam's boots beat an impatient tattoo. She imagines abandoning her lone relation to crouch among the dogs, fight them for every drop that's hers. Theirs is a life of belly and legs, run and feed. Simple life. She makes herself straighten and walk two-legged. "Ready, pardner?" Sam says. This one's a real question, not a chewed-out spit-up line. For the first time today Sam's dark eyes aren't squinted. Under protection of Lucy's shadow, they've opened wide, something there half-melting. Lucy moves to touch that short black hair where the red bandana's come askew. Remembering the smell of Sam's baby scalp: yeasty, honest with oil and sun. But by moving she lets sun hit. Sam's eyes squeeze shut. Sam steps away. Lucy can tell from the bulge of Sam's pockets that those hands are cocked again. "I'm ready," Lucy says. The floor of the bank is gleaming board. Blond as the hair on the lady teller's head. So smooth no splinters catch Lucy's feet. The tap of Sam's boots acquires a raw edge, like gunshot. Sam's neck reddens under the war paint. Ta-tap, they go across the bank. The teller staring. Ta-TAP. The teller leans back. A man appears from behind her. A chain swings from his vest. TA-TAP TA-TAP TA-TAP. Sam stretches up to the counter on tiptoe, creasing boot leather. Sam's always stepped so careful before. "Two silver dollars," Sam says. The teller's mouth twitches. "Do you have an-" "They don't have an account." It's the man who speaks, looking at Sam as one might a rat. Sam gone quiet. "On credit," Lucy says. "Please." "I've seen you two around. Did your father send you to beg?" In a way, he did. "Payday's Monday. We only need a little stretch." Lucy doesn't say, Honest. Doesn't think this man would hear it. "This isn't a charity. Run on home, you little-" The man's lips keep moving for a moment after his voice has stopped, like the woman Lucy once saw speaking in tongues, a force other than her own pushing between her lips. "-beggars. Run on before I call the sheriff." Terror walks cold fingers down Lucy's spine. Not fear of the banker. Fear of Sam. She recognizes the look in Sam's eyes. Thinks of Ba stiff in the bed, eyes slitted open. She was the first to wake this morning. She found the body and sat vigil those hours before Sam woke, and she closed the eyes as best she could. She figured Ba died angry. Now she knows different: his was the measuring squint of a hunter tracking prey. Already she sees the signs of possession. Ba's squint in Sam's eyes. Ba's anger in Sam's body. And that's besides the other holds Ba has on Sam: the boots, the place on Sam's shoulder where Ba rested his hand. Lucy sees how it'll go. Ba will rot day by day in that bed, his spirit spilling from his body and moving into Sam till Lucy wakes to see Ba looking out from behind Sam's eyes. Sam lost forever. They need to bury Ba once and for all, lock his eyes with the weight of silver. Lucy must make this banker understand. She readies herself to beg. Sam says,xa0"Pow." Lucy is about to tell Sam to quit fooling. She reaches for those chubby brown fingers, but they've gone curiously shiny. Black. Sam is holding Ba's pistol. The teller falls in a faint. "Two silver dollars," Sam says, voice pitched lower. A shadow of Ba's voice. "I'm so sorry, sir," Lucy says. Her lips go up. Ha! Ha! "You know how kids are with their games, please excuse my little-" "Run on before I have you lynched," the man says. Looking straight at Sam. "Run on, you filthy. Little. Chink." Sam squeezes the trigger. A roar. A bang. A rush. The sense of something enormous passing Lucy's ear. Stroking her with rough palms. When she opens her eyes the air is gray with smoke and Sam has staggered back, hand clapped to a cheek bruised by the pistol's recoil. The man lies on the ground. For once in her life Lucy resists the tears on Sam's face, puts Sam second. She crawls away from Sam. Ears ringing. Her fingers find the man's ankle. His thigh. His chest. His whole, unblemished, beating chest. There's a welt on his temple from where he leapt back and banged his head on a shelf. Apart from that the man is unharmed. The gun misfired. From the cloud of smoke and powder, Lucy hears Ba laughing. "Sam." She resists the urge to cry too. Needing to be stronger than herself, now. "Sam, you idiot, bao bei, you little shit." Mixing the sweet and the sour, the caress and the cuss. Like Ba. "We gotta go." What could almost make a girl laugh is how Ba came to these hills to be a prospector. Like thousands of others he thought the yellow grass of this land, its coin-bright gleam in the sun, promised even brighter rewards. But none of those who came to dig the West reckoned on the land's parched thirst, on how it drank their sweat and strength. None of them reckoned on its stinginess. Most came too late. The riches had been dug up, dried out. The streams bore no gold. The soil bore no crops. Instead they found a far duller prize locked within the hills: coal. A man couldn't grow rich on coal, or use it to feed his eyes and imagination. Though it could feed his family, in a way, weeviled meal and scraps of meat, until his wife, wearied out by dreaming, died delivering a son. Then the cost of her feed could be diverted into a man's drink. Months of hope and savings amounting to this: a bottle of whiskey, two graves dug where they wouldn't be found. What could almost make a girl laugh-ha! ha!-is that Ba brought them here to strike it rich and now they'd kill for two silver dollars. So they steal. Take what they need to flee town. Sam resists at first, stubborn as ever. "We didn't hurt nobody," Sam insists. Didn't you mean to, though? Lucy thinks. She says, "They'll make anything a crime for the likes of us. Make it law if they have to. Don't you remember?" Sam's chin lifts, but Lucy sees Sam hesitate. On this cloudless day they both feel the lash of rain. Remembering when storm howled inside and even Ba could do nothing. "We can't wait around," Lucy says. "Not even to bury." Finally, Sam nods. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • A
  • NEW YORK TIMES
  • NOTABLE BOOK OF THE YEAR A
  • WASHINGTON POST
  • NOTABLE BOOK OF THE YEAR
  • ONE OF BARACK OBAMA'S FAVORITE BOOKS OF THE YEAR
  • ONE OF NPR'S BEST BOOKS OF 2020
  • LONGLISTED FOR THE 2020 BOOKER PRIZEFINALIST FOR THE 2020 CENTER FOR FICTION FIRST NOVEL PRIZEWINNER OF THE ROSENTHAL FAMILY FOUNDATION AWARD, FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF ARTS AND LETTERS
  • A NATIONAL BOOK FOUNDATION "5 UNDER 35" HONOREE
  • NATIONAL BESTSELLER
  • “Belongs on a shelf all of its own.” —NPR “Outstanding.” —
  • The Washington Post
  • Revolutionary . . . A visionary addition to American literature.” —
  • Star Tribune
  • An electric debut novel set against the twilight of the American gold rush, two siblings are on the run in an unforgiving landscape—trying not just to survive but to find a home.
  • Ba dies in the night; Ma is already gone. Newly orphaned children of immigrants, Lucy and Sam are suddenly alone in a land that refutes their existence. Fleeing the threats of their western mining town, they set off to bury their father in the only way that will set them free from their past. Along the way, they encounter giant buffalo bones, tiger paw prints, and the specters of a ravaged landscape as well as family secrets, sibling rivalry, and glimpses of a different kind of future. Both epic and intimate, blending Chinese symbolism and reimagined history with fiercely original language and storytelling,
  • How Much of These Hills Is Gold
  • is a haunting adventure story, an unforgettable sibling story, and the announcement of a stunning new voice in literature. On a broad level, it explores race in an expanding country and the question of where immigrants are allowed to belong. But page by page, it’s about the memories that bind and divide families, and the yearning for home.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(839)
★★★★
25%
(699)
★★★
15%
(419)
★★
7%
(196)
23%
(643)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Glad for the book, just not wowed by it

Understanding that reviews are measures of reactions and not an estimation of quality, you should note that there is a lot I am glad to see about this book: new faces at the table, new perspectives, new stories being told. And there is great potential to this story: an orphaned brother and sister in Gold Rush days having to make it on their own, the baggage of their troubled immigrant parents and their own growth obstacles as well as say to day survival.

Except that this plot line is actually a minority of the novel, and that’s one of the main elements that spurs my rating. A major chunk of the book goes backwards, explanations I wasn’t compelled to leave the present narrative for. It isn’t a senseless intrusion, of course, and Zhang is skilled enough to justify it, but it was a method that worked only logically for me but not as a compelling story.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Just because you can write a novel doesn’t mean you should.

I powered through to the end but at great cost to whatever reserve of patience I have left for reading books like this. Should have stopped after 20 pages. On the bright side, my OCD completist tendencies viz-a-viz reading challenging novels I think are now resolved, the author of this book having done everything she can to bury them in the swirling sands of this dry word desert along with her protagonists’ Ba’s decaying penis. Life is too short, and I thank the author for this reminder.
With every tortured flip of the pages of this novel, each one feeling like three, I could almost taste her disciplined daily writing schedule. Did she enjoy writing this? She clearly has talent (and perseverance); would a short story or essay not have been enough? I hope she’s ok. For myself, never again will I let myself be reeled in by cool cover art, Booker prize candidacy, or the knowledge that Obama liked it (fwiw I sincerely believe that he actually did read and enjoy this novel).

I realize I’m projecting here. It’s nobody’s fault but my own. On a more fair and objective note, the novel has a lot about hills (walking through them, talking about them, making the reader feel like he’s climbing one) a tiger mythology, themes concerning what makes beauty, what makes home, what makes…queerness? I think? Oh and gold. Lots of gold. And fools gold. And decaying penises.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A Disappointment

Not liked by the bookclub
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Slow and Ambiguous

This book was read for my book club. Unlikable characters, obscure plot, and I was always unsure what was going on. This required looking back to previous chapters which were equally ambiguous.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Did not like it

I love reading but I find it hard sometimes. I have started books that have captured me after pressing myself to advance in the story. It was not the case with this book. I did finish it as it was the chosen book for the book club.
✓ Verified Purchase

Poorly written book.

The author shoots off with a totally implausible series of events; I discovered later that she did no research into the period or place for the first part of the book. Little about Chinese Culture, too. Not sure why this book was written..
✓ Verified Purchase

Uneven writing makes reading difficult

Sorry, cannot recommend bc of the writing style that dampened my enthusiasm for the story. I thought certainly that it must be a badly translated novel! It isn’t.
Very difficult to gain meaning from the fragmented sentences and incomplete descriptions in the plot progression and time periods. Almost seemed to have another author writing the middle of the novel bc it flowed better, but only temporarily.
Almost gave up and then decided to skim the reading of many pages. I don’t normally quit a book so I persevered.
Bravo to those who enjoyed the book and thought it was a masterpiece….not for me.
✓ Verified Purchase

Emotional and beautifully written!

I've actually been wanting to read this book since it came out last year, but hadn't gotten around to it until recently, when one of my book clubs chose it as a monthly read. Going into this one, I will admit that I was a bit wary, as I'm not a fan of westerns (which is what this was billed as), but I was attracted to the premise of a story about a Chinese immigrant family in the American West during the gold rush era, which, of course, is not often seen in mainstream fiction. Now after having finished this, I would say that it was definitely different from what I expected, both in its bold, lyrical writing as well as in the way the story technically defied categorization in terms of genre and theme — there were elements of a western, yes, but there were also historical elements as well as magical realism that drove aspects of the story.

Majority of the story is told from the perspective of Lucy, who is twelve when we first meet her. Her Pa has just passed away and with her Ma gone for 3 years already, she and her eleven year old sister Sam are now left to fend for themselves in the mountains of the West. As they set off to bury their Pa, Lucy and Sam encounter situations that test the strength of their bond as siblings, as well as their ability to overcome their family's past. The narrative later moves further back to the past and explains the backstory to this family, giving us insight into how a Chinese family such as theirs ended up in a community where few others looked like them. Initially lured to the "golden mountains" by the promise of gold and riches, the reality couldn't be more different — weighted down by a secret in their past as well as the instability of prospecting, they switch to a grueling living by coal mining, which unfortunately does little to improve the family's situation. A third narrative moves the story 5 years after Pa's death, with Lucy and Sam reuniting again after having gone their separate ways — both siblings have changed in some ways, but underneath, they are also still the same. They decide to set off again, together this time, in pursuit of a better life in a place they can truly call their own.

This was an emotional read and one that was so beautifully written — lyrical, poetic, and so full of imagery. With that said though, as much as I loved the style of writing, I felt like the beauty of it transcended the story a bit — I'm not sure how to explain it, but I felt like, at times, I got so caught up in the depiction of a scene that I actually forgot where I was in the story and had to go back and reread. There was also an abstract quality to the writing that sometimes overshadowed the plot itself. From a historical perspective, as a few other reviewers already pointed out, there were some inaccuracies that those familiar with the time period and the history of the Chinese workers in the U.S. during that time may not be able to overlook, though for me personally, it didn't bother me too much.

In terms of character development — Lucy and Sam were characters I couldn't help but love, regardless of whatever flaws they may have had. I connected deeply with both characters, to the point that I didn't want the journey with either one of them to end. Perhaps it is because of my affinity for both of them that I didn't take to the ending too well (and that's all I'm going to say about it so as not to give anything away).

Overall, this was a worthwhile read that I definitely recommend, one that I'm also glad I finally got around to reading, however belatedly. This was a strong debut from C. Pam Zhang and I definitely look forward to the next work from her.
✓ Verified Purchase

I couldn’t make it through he book ,let alone to the west

I found nothing worthwhile in this book. At one point I finally asked myself why am I reading this? And at that point I stopped.
✓ Verified Purchase

An immigrant story of historic relevance

WHAT I LOVED MOST: A nugget of history; Idiosyncratic voice; Exotic time and place; Literary quality; Emotive experiences; Memorable characters; Multi-layered themes.

WHAT I LIKED LESS: The starkness of place, people, and prose make it a challenging read.