Shakey: Neil Young's Biography
Shakey: Neil Young's Biography book cover

Shakey: Neil Young's Biography

Paperback – May 13, 2003

Price
$18.99
Format
Paperback
Pages
786
Publisher
Anchor
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0679750963
Dimensions
6.1 x 1.7 x 9.2 inches
Weight
1.89 pounds

Description

“Jimmy McDonough’s fat, teeming, obsessive, and revelatory biography of Young is a pure shot of all-access pleasure. . . . Hugely original.” — Los Angeles Times Book Review “Just as unmanageable, hard-headed, overzealous, and ultimately endearing as Young himself . . . A maddening, beguiling portrait of an elusive maverick . . . A glorious mess.” — San Francisco Chronicle Book Review “An exhilarating match-up of author and subject makes Shakey a great, gripping read. . . . A must-read for anyone who cares about Neil Young.” — Rolling Stone “Staggeringly thorough . . . McDonough gets it all: the chaos, the grandeur, the good times and dreary deaths, the alcohol- and drug-besotted recording sessions, the broken hearts, and the sheer unfettered joy of a seriously gifted artist.” — Salon “The definitive book on the subject.” — The Washington Post “Exhaustive, quarrelsome, and sometimes maddening . . . there are revelations in abundance.” — The New York Times Book Review “Where the average rock-star biography is a tepid, toothless thing, McDonough has approached his task like a literary Terminator, steaming ahead with lethal thoroughness. One of the most penetrative studies of a rock icon ever written.” — Times (London)“A mammoth portrait of the artist and lively exhumation of rock n roll history. . . . [McDonough] traces a rich turbulent career in vivid detail.” — The New York Times “Imaginatively written...not only is Shakey an extraordinary literary feat of research and affection and endurance, it's an insight into the art of biography itself.”— Fort Worth Star-Telegram “Delves further into the life and motives of one of music's most private individuals than anything previously released. . . surprisingly comprehensive and thoroughly enjoyable. . . .The most detailed portrait of this shrouded artist to date.” — San Jose Mercury News “Exhaustively researched, impressively detailed. . . The long passages in which McDonough steps aside to let Young talk are the most revealing. ‘One day I'm a jerk,’ Young says, ‘the next day I'm a genius.’ This book argues artfully for the latter.”— People “Like meeting Brando's Kurtz in a cave at the end of Apocalypse Now . . . . Young comes across as a Jekyll-and-Hyde loner whose life has unfolded like a reckless chemistry experiment -- a control freak on an endless quest for the uncontrolled moment.” — Macleans (Canada)“McDonough is an avid fan, music critic and impartial journalist all in one. . . . [He] deftly weaves Young's life, actions and art together. . . . What was known of Young's life before was akin to a series of rough demos. In Shakey , McDonough delivers a full double-album.” — Rocky Mountain News “Does what most rock bios don’t: It fails to fawn, it delivers the juice, it subjects the hero to the scrutiny and disappointment of a fan. . . A page-turning good read..”— Houston Chronicle “Fascinating reading. . . McDonough gives us as good a look at [Young’s] cards as we’re likely to get.” — The Tampa Tribune “[Shakey's] unprecedented access makes for an entertaining read: McDonough, more than any music journalist since Peter Guralnick in his authoritative Careless Love: The Unmaking of Elvis Presley , has succeeded in stripping a star of his iconography.”— The Observer (London)“Crammed with razor-sharp insights and mind-boggling detail, Shakey is a rock-solid literary triumph, as inspired and inspiring as the eccentric figure it evokes with such frustrated devotion.” — The Guardian (London) “McDonough . . . pores through Young’s life with vivid prose and blunt detail, and he is unashamed to insert some stinging opinions. In his probing conversations with Young, . . . he challenges the formidable artist in ways that few others would dare.” — Pittsburgh Post-Gazette “It’s hard to imagine anyone trying to better this book. . . It has what Young values above all else. . . passion.”— Evening Standard (London) From the Inside Flap Neil Young is one of rock and roll?s most important and enigmatic figures, a legend from the sixties who is still hugely influential today. He has never granted a writer access to his inner life ? until now. Based on six years of interviews with more than three hundred of Young?s associates, and on more than fifty hours of interviews with Young himself, Shakey is a fascinating, prodigious account of the singer?s life and career. Jimmy McDonough follows Young from his childhood in Canada to his cofounding of Buffalo Springfield to the huge success of Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young to his comeback in the nineties. Filled with never-before-published words directly from the artist himself, Shakey is an essential addition to the top shelf of rock biographies. Neil Young is one of rock and roll's most important and enigmatic figures, a legend from the sixties who is still hugely influential today. He has never granted a writer access to his inner life - until now. Based on six years of interviews with more than three hundred of Young's associates, and on more than fifty hours of interviews with Young himself, Shakey is a fascinating, prodigious account of the singer's life and career. Jimmy McDonough follows Young from his childhood in Canada to his cofounding of Buffalo Springfield to the huge success of Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young to his comeback in the nineties. Filled with never-before-published words directly from the artist himself, Shakey is an essential addition to the top shelf of rock biographies. Jimmy McDonough is a journalist who has contributed to such publications as Variety, Film Comment, Mojo, Spin, and Juggs. But he is perhaps best known for his intense, definitive Village Voice profiles of such artists as Jimmy Scott, Neil Young, and Hubert Selby, Jr. Jimmy is also the author of The Ghastly One: The Sex-Gore Netherworld of Filmmaker Andy Milligan . He lives in the Pacific Northwest. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Innaresting characters –Who gave you the Nixon mask?I can’t recall, as John Dean would say. I’ll always tell ya if I remember, Jimmy. You talk about things and it comes back.–Every question seems to stir up something in you.Not the answers you were looking for . . . but they’re answers, heh heh. Hard to remember things. It’s all there, though. Maybe we oughta go into hypnotherapy, fuckin’ go right back. Take like, six months to get zoned in on the Tonight’s the Night sessions–exactly what was happening? “Okay, we’re gonna go back a little further today, Neil. . . .”–I’m frustrated.Hey, well, you’ve been frustrated since the beginning, heh heh. You’re not frustrated because of this–we’re doing it. You’re asking questions and I’m answering them. What could be less frustrating than THAT?–Maybe I should tell people in the intro you don’t wanna do the book.You can tell ’em if you want. The bottom line is if it went against the grain so hard, I wouldn’t be doin’ it. The thing is, it’s not necessarily my first love. I think that’s a subtle way of puttin’ it. Heh heh.The first time Jon McKeig really encountered Shakey he was under a car. Shakey’s a nickname–from alter ego Bernard Shakey, sometime moviemaker. It’s just one of many aliases: Joe Yankee, overdubber; Shakey Deal, blues singer; Phil Perspective, producer. The world knows him as Neil Young.McKeig had been toiling away on Nanoo, a blue and white ’59 Cadillac Eldorado Biarritz convertible of Young’s, for months without actually seeing him. The car was a mess, but McKeig would soon realize that this was Shakey’s M.O., buying beyond-dead wrecks for peanuts, then sparing no expense to bring them back to life. “I can name five automobiles he has that the parts cars were in better shape than the cars that were restored.” McKeig shook his head. “That’s extreme. I don’t believe anybody anywhere goes to that length. If the car smells wrong, you’re screwed; if it squeaks, it’s not cool . . . he’s fanatical.”One day Neil happened in for a personal inspection. “Neil came right over to the car, looked at it and–I’ll be damned–all of a sudden he went down to the concrete and slid right underneath. All you could see was his tennis shoes.”McKeig asked Young how far he wanted to go with the thrashed Cadillac. “Neil looked me straight in the eye and said calmly, ‘As long as it’s museum quality.’ ” McKeig shuddered. “I never heard it said like that–‘museum quality.’ Then he left. That’s all that was said. I never saw him–for years after.” Decades later, Nanoo still isn’t finished.Cars are a major part of Shakey’s world. He’s written countless songs in them and they figure into more than a few of his lyrics: “Trans Am,” “Long May You Run,” “Motor City,” “Like an Inca (Hitchhiker),” “Drifter,” “Roll Another Number (For the Road),” “Sedan Delivery,” “Get Gone”; the list goes on.Young would even advise me on touch-up paint and carburetor problems–until I flipped my ’66 Falcon Futura twice off the side of a two-lane, nearly killing myself. Out on the road in his bus, Young called me a few days after. “See, Neil?” I said. “You tried to bump me off, but I’m still here. Now I gotta finish the book.’’ Unnerved, he immediately called back after we hung up. “Jimmy,” he said, his voice awash in cellular static, “just want ya to know I’m glad ya didn’t die in the wreck.” Shakey and I had a colorful relationship. But that was all in the future.Right now it was April 1991, and I was in Los Angeles, watching McKeig–now Young’s live-in auto restorer and maintenance man–pilot members of Neil’s family through the service areas of the L.A. Sports Arena in a sleek black ’54 Caddy that Young called Pearl: He nicknames everything. It was a stunning vehicle. He had paid $400 for the car in 1974 and spent years and a fortune restoring it. Legend has it that some rich Arab saw Young tooling Pearl through Hollywood and offered him a pile of loot on the spot.Out of the Caddy’s backseat emerged Neil’s wife, Pegi, a striking blonde and a powerful force in her own right. She and Neil have two children, Ben and Amber. Family is a priority to both of them. Ben, born spastic, nonoral and quadriplegic, went everywhere with his mom and pop. It wasn’t unusual to see him at the side of the stage in his wheelchair, watching his father work.“Spud,” Ben’s nickname, graced the door of Pocahontas, which was parked not far from Pearl. A huge, Belgian-made ’70 Silver Eagle, forty feet long and sporting a souped-up mill, the bus had been Young’s home on the road since 1976. Young had gone to outlandish lengths in customizing it. Down one side was an extravagant stained-glass comet circling the earth; the roof was domed with vintage Hudson Hornet/Studebaker Starlight Coupe cartops that acted as skylights. The interior of the bus–designed under Young’s supervision to resemble the skeletal structure of a giant bird–was lavish with hand-carved wood, down to the door handle of the microwave. Above the big front windows hung a large brass eagle’s eye. “This bus is so fucked up and over the top,” Young would tell me with a grin. “Which is just how I was back in the mid-seventies when I built it.”Bus driver Joe McKenna was making sure Pocahontas was shipshape for Neil’s arrival. An Irishman with a low-slung belly, a silver pompadour and a voice lower than a frog’s, Joe loved the golf course and let little faze him. He seemed to have a calming effect on Young, who once dubbed him “The Lucky Leprechaun.” McKenna would beat cancer after Young helped him get alternative medical help. “Neil Young saved my life,” he told me. “Put that in your book.”Next to the steering wheel hung a sign that read in bold block letters, don’t spill the soup. I wouldn’t have driven that bus for love, money or drugs. When it came to Pocahontas, Shakey was like a hawk. He knew every ding and dimple and wanted the ones he didn’t know explained immediately.An intense relationship with his bus drivers, I mused, but tour manager Bob Sterne set me straight. “In all honesty, I think the intense relationship is with the bus,” said Sterne, a big, bearded, no-nonsense monolith with a constantly peeling nose and sporting a Cruex jock itch ointment T-shirt. Sterne and Joe McKenna weren’t exactly the best of pals. Sterne was forever seeking info on Young’s elusive doings and one of McKenna’s jobs was to keep the world away.Bob was no stranger to that task–his makeshift office inside the sports arena was plastered with signs like if you want a backstage pass, get lost. Sterne was hard-core. It came with the territory. “Neil’s not gonna do what you think he’s gonna do or what he said last week–it’s not a good place for the average person to be. The people who are looking for a paycheck don’t last long.”Young likes to keep everyone on their toes. “Neil’s come to me and said, ‘Go get all the set lists and throw ’em in the trash can’–and he said this to me fifteen minutes before the show,” said Sterne. “He’s not just talking about the band’s set list, he’s talking about the lighting guys, the sound guys–every single set list in the building.”Sitting in the office not far from Sterne was Tim Foster, Young’s stage manager and primary roadie. Foster had worked for Young off and on–mostly on–since 1973. With a Dick Tracy chin, a mustache and a baseball cap pulled down to his eyes, Foster saw everything and said little. “Tim never gets flustered,” said Sterne. “He understands Neil has no schedule.”Making his way through the backstage maze out to the arena’s mixing station was Tim Mulligan, his long hair, mustache and shades making him look like the world’s most sullen Doobie Brother. Nothing impresses Mulligan. He’s been working on Young’s albums and mixing his live sound for decades. “Producers, engineers come and go,” said Sterne. “Mulligan hangs in there. He doesn’t have an opinion.” Tim lives alone on Young’s ranch, without a phone. “Mulligan has this incredible allegiance,” said longtime Young associate “Ranger Dave” Cline. “He lives and breathes Neil. It’s his whole life.”It took years for Mulligan to warm to me, and even then he wouldn’t give me an interview, just tersely answered a few questions. Getting any one of Young’s crew to talk was like breaking into the Mafia. They were fiercely devoted, and although they’d all been subject to the ferocious twists and turns of Neil’s psyche, most had been around for decades. And every one of them was an individual. “Innaresting characters,” as Young would put it. “They’re all Neil,” said Graham Nash. “They all represent a slice of Neil’s personality.”“Neil likes quirky people around him,” said Elliot Roberts, Young’s manager since the late sixties. “I think having quirky people around him lessens–in his mind–his own quirkiness. ‘Yes, I am standing on my head, but look at these two other guys nude standing on their head.’ ”His mane of gray hair flying, Roberts was on his ninety-sixth phone call of the day, either chewing out some record-company underling or closing a million-dollar deal. Not far away, a bearded, sunglassed David Briggs–Young’s producer–prowled the stage, palming a cigarette J.D.-style and looking like the devil himself. Briggs and Roberts were the twin engines that powered the Neil Young hot rod. Feared, at times hated, both men possessed killer instincts and had been with Neil almost from the beginning. Roberts was a genius at pushing Young’s career, Briggs at pushing his art. It’s an understatement to say the two didn’t always see eye to eye.Roberts and Briggs were two of the quirkiest characters around–difficult, complicated men–but then so was just about everybody and everything in Young’s world. “Let’s look at Neil’s whole trip–the ranch, the people he plays with,” said computer wizard Bryan Bell, who worked extensively with Young in the late eighties. “ ‘Easy’ isn’t in the vocabulary.”“Neil is wonderful to work for in many ways and very difficult to work with in many ways,” said Roger Katz, former captain of Young’s boat. “He’s able to control most everything.” As David Briggs put it, “It’s not fun at all working with Neil–fun’s not part of the deal–but it’s very fulfilling.”I asked Young’s guitar tech Larry Cragg what the hardest tour had been. “All of ’em,” he said. “They’ve all been rough–every one of ’em made workin’ for anybody else real easy. The tours are out of the ordinary, the music, the movies–everything’s out of the ordinary. We do things differently around here. That’s just the way it is.”Cragg was tinkering with Young’s guitar rig, which sat in a little area to the rear of the stage. A gaggle of amps–a Magnatone, a huge transistorized Baldwin Exterminator, a Fender Reverb unit and the heart of it all: a small, weather-beaten box covered in worn-out tweed, 1959 vintage. “The Deluxe,” muttered amp tech Sal Trentino with awe. “Neil’s got four hundred and fifty-six identical Deluxes. They sound nothing like this one.” Young runs the amp with oversized tubes, and Cragg has to keep portable fans trained on the back so it doesn’t melt down. “It really is ready to just go up in smoke, and it sounds that way–flat-out, overdriven, ready to self-destruct.”Young has a personal relationship with electricity. In Europe, where the electrical current is sixty cycles, not fifty, he can pinpoint the fluctuation–by degrees. It dumbfounded Cragg. “He’ll say, ‘Larry, there’s a hundred and seventeen volts coming out of the wall, isn’t there?’ I’ll go measure it, and yeah, sure–he can hear the difference.”Shakey’s innovations are everywhere. Intent on controlling amp volume from his guitar instead of the amp, Young had a remote device designed called the Whizzer. Guitarists marvel at the stomp box that lies onstage at Young’s feet: a byzantine gang of effects that can be utilized without any degradation to the original signal. Just constructing the box’s angular red wooden housing to Young’s extreme specifications had craftsmen pulling their hair out.Cradled in a stand in front of the amps is the fuse for the dynamite, Young’s trademark ax–Old Black, a ’53 Gold Top Les Paul some knothead daubed with black paint eons ago. Old Black’s features include a Bigsby wang bar, which pulls strings and bends notes, and a Firebird pickup so sensitive you can talk through it. It’s a demonic instrument. “Old Black doesn’t sound like any other guitar,” said Cragg, shaking his head.For Cragg, Old Black is a nightmare. Young won’t permit the ancient frets to be changed, likes his strings old and used, and the Bigsby causes the guitar to go out of tune constantly. “At sound check, everything will work great. Neil picks up the guitar, and for some reason that’s when things go wrong.” Read more

Features & Highlights

  • Neil Young is one of rock and roll’s most important and enigmatic figures, a legend from the sixties who is still hugely influential today. He has never granted a writer access to his inner life – until now. Based on six years of interviews with more than three hundred of Young’s associates, and on more than fifty hours of interviews with Young himself,
  • Shakey
  • is a fascinating, prodigious account of the singer’s life and career. Jimmy McDonough follows Young from his childhood in Canada to his cofounding of Buffalo Springfield to the huge success of Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young to his comeback in the nineties. Filled with never-before-published words directly from the artist himself,
  • Shakey
  • is an essential addition to the top shelf of rock biographies.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
60%
(323)
★★★★
25%
(135)
★★★
15%
(81)
★★
7%
(38)
-7%
(-38)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

The best Neil book

The detail and obsession that went into this is evident - this is no usual ham-fisted bio-cash-in. Even the fall out with Neil adds perspective to McDonough's writing. My problem is that while it is flawless in terms of care and detail, McDonough comes accross as rather dislikeable. Fair enough he is a critic a lot of the time, but does he have to sound so preachy and knowing? Dare you have any respect for any of the more 'pretty' Young albums, or CS&N he will shred you to pieces. Furthermore, he's incredibly egotistic. The book is just as much about McDonough as it is Neil and with this I have a problem. Generally an excellent labour of love, but can the guy get off his high horse?
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Biographer or Critic?

If you want the facts of Neil's life, they're here. But McDonough reaches a point in the latter part of the book where he seems to think that HE is Neil Young's ultimate creative foil, criticizing and challenging Neil in a no-punches-pulled kind of way that serves the reader and the songwriter equally. He becomes increasingly more of a critic and less of a storyteller of Young's life.
I disliked this approach. It still irritates me.
McDonough seems to think that much of Neil's work is either slight or pure crap, with few exceptions. So, while it was interesting to me to find out how truly disasterous the "Time Fades Away" tour was, the recorded document of that tour probably doesn't need McDonough's critique. And you know what? The record still stands up. Even if McDonough or even Neil himself doesn't like it. So does the bar band side of "American Stars and Bars." So does the recorded version of "Like an Inca." Or "Old Ways."
Readers like me have enjoyed following the musical journey, even when it has run into dead ends. McDonough wants to tell us why it should have been a different journey. Well, too bad, Jimmy. It's a human highway, and Neil is flawed just like the rest of us. So tell us his story, not how he should have done what you wanted him to.
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The Definitive Neil Young bio

To quote a phrase Neil apparently uses often, this book was "very innaresting." Seriously, I could not put this down.

Before getting this biography, I was a casual fan and I knew less than nothing about Neil Young. From just listening to his radio hits I had put together a vague image of a patriotic hippy who dresses like a scruffy Indian. After just the first few chapters though, this image was shattered. Yet after finishing the book completely, I don't know if I'm any closer to knowing him. He is infinitely more complicated than I had thought.

Jimmy McDonough does the best possible job telling Neil's life story. And if you know anything about Neil, you know this is no easy task. The man has got to be the most elusive personality in rock and roll. You can't pin him down on a subject for long, and he's apt to up and leave any project at any time for any reason and you won't know he left till he's halfway across the country. Of course, this all makes the book just that much more of a good read.

Shakey reveals much about his life that I've never known. His childhood is covered pretty extensively and I think that's instrumental in understanding his songs. Dealings with CSNY are of course covered in detail. Interviews with David Briggs, Jack Nietzche, and others close to Neil provide great insight into life on Neil's huge ranch and into his recording process, which I think is priceless. But the best part of the book, for me, is the extensive interview with Neil that runs throughout the entire book. For someone who doesn't like to talk much about himself to the press, this is like a goldmine to a Neil Young fan.

Some reviewers have already mentioned that towards the end of the book Jimmy falters a bit. Yeah he does, there's no denying it. He gets a little too subjective, goes on for a little too long about Neil's association with trains, and basically loses focus. But really, it's no big deal. I went through this book in a week, then went back over certain parts. After being so immersed in Neil's world, I found myself not wanting to leave. Make sure you have plenty of Neil's albums around, cause you'll be wanting to hear them as they're being discussed in the book. This is a really "innaresting" read and for any fan of Neil it's a solid buy.
10 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Not perfect but a daring unique biography!

I'm conflicted on this one!

Much of it is THE BEST biography ever! A wonderful format intertwined with "innaresting" conversations with Neil. At the same time it pauses way to frequently to paint portraits of each character. Four pages of comments from artist about Elliot!? That's a real who cares picture that could paint itself through time.

It also struck me JmcD was not much of a fan which works well on one level but ends up interjecting negative opinions on recordings. Key thing is NY's market much of the time was high school long hair, flannel wearing, Red Wing boot, stoner males. WE LOVED 4 Way Street! WE LOVED the extended loose jams! Heck at the time before I understood guitar I considered NY one of THE best guitarist EVER! Hendrix like! On one level this is true as he get right to it with very little extra. But of course he's an average picker who took mediocre guitar abilities to the top of the heap!

Has great in depth stories about each album especially the Ditch Trilogy and pulls no punches on sensitive topics like Witten and Berry with NY chiming in on each.

NY steps up each time and while he'd take long breaks and who know what's not included or refused by NY there are plenty of personal opinions and truths to really make for some unsettling real reading.

It's a long book and can be intense. I had to take a break after Tonights the Night to digest it all!

Not perfect but a daring unique biography!
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

me first

Here's what I came away with after reading 'Shakey':
1) the age-old lesson that wealth and fame corrupts applies to the idols of the counterculture as much as everyone else who came before them. To Young's credit, he has recognized and attempted to avoid their trappings. Unfortunately, Young apparently started life with an illusion of self-importance that, like many of the other figures in the book, was only magnified by wealth and fame. In fact, it seems to be a reality of life that wealth and fame only magnify whatever it is that you are, good and bad.
2) it is possible to believe you are superior to others because you don't overtly try to make yourself superior to others.
3) having musical talent doesn't make you in any way better than anyone else. It is what it is: musical talent. It's no different, really, than being talented on the baseball field, the battlefield, or even the kitchen.
4) Neil, Stephen Stills, David Crosby, the record producers and managers, virtually everyone in the book, has had a lot of pain dished out to them in their lives, and dished out a lot of pain on others. There's an abundance of bad parenting and selfish living that is brought to the fore here. It's interesting how fame and wealth puts a gloss over people's lives that makes the grass seem greener on the other side. I don't think many people would enjoy trading places with Neil given the hardships he's had to endure, including bouts with polio, epilepsy, introversion, and having a disabled child.
5) It's interesting how beautiful music somehow rises to the surface in the midst of such suffering and selfishness. That is the inspiring and compelling phenomenon running throughout this narrative. It is the portions of the book that detail this process, whether taking place in songwriting or performance, that truly held my interest.
6) I excuse the writer for falling into self-excess. Just proves he's no different than anyone else he's writing about. No surprise that in illuminating everyone elses run for the spotlight, some of the photons fell on himself.
7) If there's a Neil Young lyric you've always thought was deep and mystical, forget about it... even Neil can't tell you what it means.
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

This book has turned me into a NY fanatic; AGAIN!

I totally enjoyed this book. It gave me a whole new world of insight on Neil. I hadn't listened to any pop music since 1977, and prior to that I had been a huge fan. I bought one of my old albums on CD recently, and found I loved his music just as much now as I did back then; maybe even more. Wanted to try some newer albums, and didn't know which ones, so thought this book might help. It helped a bit TOO well! I have now bought 7 new(er) CDs, a couple more books, and some videos, and checked out Neil's website and clips on youtube.

If I enjoy a subject, I WANT the book to be long, and that was definitely the case with this book. I have such a total respect now for a rock icon that has lasted so long. Not to mention his new album Living With War, which came out after the book was published, and which Neil has downloadable on his website. I really admire the way he has made a stand for what he feels, no matter the cost, and the fact that he made a protest song on the Viet Nam war, and has now done one on our present war! I love the way when the author asked Neil if he cared about all the bootlegs people had made, he said no. That, to me, said a lot about his character!

I take issue with the reviewer who mentioned the boring section on Neil's trains. I don't think it's boring at all. Also, as it is a huge part of Neil's life, I think it belonged in the book; there wasn't that much on it anyway!

I now own 12 NY CD's, with 3 more ordered and on the way! The book turned me into a Neil Young addict! I plan on reading the book over again, as soon as I am more familiar with all the music, as the book really delves deeply into most of the albums, and I would have understood the book much better had I been more familiar with them. Also, in response to another review, I read somewhere that Neil had sued JD for publishing the book! He definitely ''changed his mind,'' which is a huge part of the theme of the book! I found this to be a fascinating study of one of the greatest rockers ever.
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Great Biography of a Brilliant Artist

"Shakey" is one of the finest biographies that I have read. Author Jimmy McDonough is a tireless researcher and an excellent writer, in tune with the times in which Neil Young, his subject, has lived through and, in some respects, helped to shape.

The book thankfully offers chronological balance between the various stages in Young's life, from his youth in Winnipeg and rural Ontario, to his adolescence in North Toronto (in, as it happens, the very neighbourhood in which I experienced my adolescence), to his emigration to California. McDonough deserves credit for going to all of the places, both large and small, that Young inhabited, interviewing family members, neighbours and friends.

Another great aspect of the book is the material one learns about many other artists in and around Young's life; not only are there great insights into the likely characters such as Crosby, Stills and Nash, but one also learns a good deal about Bob Dylan, Joni Mitchell, and the numerous musicians, managers, producers and assorted hangers-on that Neil has attracted.

Embedded throughout each chapter are excerpts of a conversation between McDonough and Young. The author does a skillful job of encouraging Young to look back on various events in his life, often getting Young to confess to mistakes and errors in judgment. The role of this conversation is two-fold: first, McDonough performs a precarious, intriguing balancing act of serving as Young's dispassionate biographer, and as a friend in whom Young can feel comfortable confiding; second, the conversation reveals the full human side of Neil Young, warts and all, as he sees things today.

I've seen Neil Young in concert three times - with the Shocking Pinks in the 1980's, and, so far in this decade, with Crazy Horse (Greendale) and as CSNY (Freedom of Speech). To me, Young and his work are as original and vital as ever, and this view is corroborated by many well-known artists quoted in "Shakey".

To be sure, Young has had a bumpy road to travel, what with his parents splitting up when he was still living at home, his bouts with polio and epilepsy, and his challenges raising his two sons, both of whom are quite disabled. While Young has been, in many respects, a victim of the circumstances just described, he has been, either despite this or perhaps because of this, far from an angel himself: he has been a very tough, demanding guy to work with, to live with, or to just be around. Young has been described as a loner, mercurial, driven by his work to the point of distraction, inaccessible. Yet, as one of his cohorts has indicated, "magic things happen when you're around Neil".

"Shakey" does justice to the story of Neil Young, a versatile, brilliant, principled artist. While it is unfortunate that many in his midst have been hurt by his at times uncaring and insensitive ways, presumably they chose to have a relationship with him and, as such, were in a position to take the good with the bad.

For a Neil Young music fan, "Shakey" is an excellent resource. In addition, this book is also a valuable exposition of the spirit, mechanics and orientation of Young as an artist, someone intent on achieving specific end results. In other words, this book can be entertaining, informative and instructive; I certainly found it to be that way.
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Is this the best Neil Young biography we can expect?

Neil Young deserves a better biography than this massive pile of offal. The obnoxious author insists on inserting himself and his less than insightful critical assessments into every step of Neil Young's life. The man possess not one ounce of objectivity. While I have a lot of respect for Neil Young and love many of his earlier songs (which constitute much of what I have heard of him), I have never been a fanatic. This lack of fanaticism has limited my degree of fascination with his musical journey and I must admit that the book would be more compelling if I were a devotee. However, I suspect that even if I were one of the major Neil Young fans on the planet, I would be disappointed in this book. It contains some interesting biographical information and it illuminated my lack of knowledge of most things Young. That, coupled with my stubborn insistence not to give up on any book once I get past the half-way point, is the primary reason I plowed through to the end. This author is entitled to his opinion (which includes a dismissal of virtually all of Crosby, Stills & Nash's work together and with Young, not to mention considering their own solo work inconsequential) but his arrogance not only regarding Young's contemporaries but also Young himself is truly repellent. The book possesses a journeyman prose style and a Gonzo-like "Aren't I hip?" self-consciousness that prompts one to seek someone with a more reasonable, even-handed assessment. I recommend the book only for those who really want to know the essential facts of Neil Young's life although, to be honest, one could save time and suffer negligible lack of insight into what makes Young tick, by consulting a Wikipedia article.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Too much of everything...

I don't know, it's often a bit lame to suggest that a book could have used some more editing, but that's how I felt with this one. Clearly Young is a fascinating/infuriating character, and it seems as though McDonough is also. So it's not as though there's a lack of material to write about - I just wish McDonough had done it with a little more focus.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Wish I had my life back

Just finished reading this book. Very disappointed. First part of book about Neil's early live was somewhat interesting but rest of it was boring. I have always been a Neil Young fan but probably not as much after I read this book. Neil treats people very shabby, walking out on any number of people without a word, including CSN a number of times.
5 people found this helpful