Song for a Whale
Song for a Whale book cover

Song for a Whale

Hardcover – February 5, 2019

Price
$10.64
Format
Hardcover
Pages
320
Publisher
Delacorte Press
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-1524770235
Dimensions
5.8 x 1.06 x 8.6 inches
Weight
15.2 ounces

Description

From School Library Journal Gr 4-6-Twelve-year-old Iris has a passion for electronics and repairing antique radios. She's a strong student, too, except when she is hampered by the frustrations of being the only Deaf student in her classes. One day, Iris's science class watches a video about a whale named Blue 55, a hybrid blue/fin whale with an extremely unique voice; the sounds he makes are around 55 hertz, unlike most other whales, which communicate at much lower frequencies. Moved by Blue 55's very familiar struggle to communicate, Iris becomes determined to compose a song for Blue 55 at his frequency, and to play it for him in person. This mission involves a journey from her Houston home to Appleton, AK, that, miraculously, her widowed Grandma agrees to secretly arrange. Readers will need to suspend some disbelief in order to buy Iris's adventure as realistic fiction, but the nuances of her personality make her a compelling protagonist. Iris's depth of empathy, the joy she feels working with radios, and the skillful way she navigates two different worlds of communication create an authenticity that will resonate with Deaf and hearing readers alike. The paralyzing effects of grief are also addressed through Grandma. Gradual healing is depicted in a natural, healthy way, as Grandma turns away from isolation and begins using her talents, doing things that make her happy, and spending time with a loved one (Iris). VERDICT An uplifting tale that's a solid addition to most collections; especially recommended for libraries needing stronger representation of Deaf protagonists, which will be most.-Sara White, Seminole County Public Library, Casselberry, FLα(c) Copyright 2011. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted. Schneider Family Book Award Winner A New York Public Library Best Book of the Year "At its luminous heart, Song for a Whale is a tale about longing for connection and finding it in the most magical and unexpected of places. Fascinating, brave and tender, this is a story like no other about a song like no other. A triumph ." —Katherine Applegate, Newbery Award-winning author of The One and Only Ivan “ Song for a Whale is beautifully written and is such an important story for kids with big struggles in their lives. I fell into Iris's world from the first chapter .xa0 Lynne Kelly does an amazing job telling the story from Iris's perspective.” —Millicent Simmonds, actress, Wonderstruck and A Quiet Place "A quick-moving, suspenseful plot takes her from junkyards to a cruise ship as she [Iris] gains the confidence to stand up for herself and take control of her life. Written by a sign-language interpreter, this story incorporates important elements of Deaf culture and the expansiveness and richness of ASL ...this remains a satisfying, energetic read. Iris' adventures will engross readers ." — Kirkus Reviews "The strength of the book is its strong portrayal of Iris as a deaf girl in a hearing world and an intelligent 12-year-old in headlong, single-minded pursuit of her goal." — Booklist "Subtly and poignantly drawing a parallel between the girl and whale, Kelly ( Chained ), who has worked as a sign language interpreter, relays Iris’s venture with credibility and urgency .xa0This finely crafted novel affectingly illuminates issues of loneliness, belonging, and the power of communication. " — Publishers Weekly "Iris’s depth of empathy, the joy she feels working with radios, and the skillful way she navigates two different worlds of communication create an authenticity that will resonate with Deaf and hearing readers alike ... An uplifting tale that’s a solid addition to most collections; especially recommended for libraries needing stronger representation of Deaf protagonists." — SLJ Lynne Kelly has always loved reading, but while working as a special education teacher, she fell in love with children's literature all over again. She lives in Houston, Texas, and works as a sign language interpreter while writing books for kids. Her first book, Chained, was a South Asia Book Award Honor and Crystal Kite Award winner. Song for a Whale is her second novel. Find her online at http://lynnekellybooks.com/wordpress and on Twitter at @LynneKelly. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Until last summer I thought the only thing I had in common with that whale on the beach was a name. I sat with Grandpa after collecting shells and driftwood scattered along the shore, and wildflowers from the dunes. The shells and driftwood were for Grandma, and the flowers were for the whale. Grandpa had asked how school was going, and I told him it was the same, which wasn’t good. I’d been at that school for two years and still felt like the new kid. Grandpa patted the sand next to him. “Did you know she was probably deaf too?” he signed. I didn’t have to ask who he meant. The whale had been buried there for eleven years, and my parents had told me enough times about what happened that day. I shook my head. I hadn’t known that, and I didn’t know why Grandpa was changing the subject. Maybe he didn’t know what to tell me anymore about school. The whale had beached herself the same day I was born. When she was spotted in the shallow waters of the Gulf, some people stood on the shore and watched her approach. My grandma ran into the cold February water and tried to push her away from land, as if she could make a forty-ton animal change her mind about where she wanted to go. That was really dangerous. Even though the whale was weak by then, one good whack with a tail or flipper could have knocked Grandma out. I don’t know what I would’ve done--jumped in like she did or just stood there. “She wasn’t born deaf like we were,” Grandpa continued. “The scientists who studied her said it had just happened. Maybe she’d been swimming near an explosion from an oil rig or a bomb test.” When Grandpa told a story, I saw it as clearly as if it were happening right there in front of me. His signing hands showed me the whale in an ocean that suddenly went quiet, swimming over there, over there, over there, trying to find the sounds again. Maybe that was why she’d been there on our Gulf of Mexico beach instead of in deep ocean waters where she belonged. Sei whales didn’t swim so close to shore. Only her, on that day. “A whale can’t find its way through a world without sound,” Grandpa added. “The ocean is dark, and it covers most of the earth, and whales live in all of it. The sounds guide them through that, and they talk to one another across oceans.” With the familiar sounds of the ocean gone, the whale was lost in her new silent world. A rescue group came to the beach and tried to save the whale, and they called her Iris. Grandma asked my parents to give the name to me, too, since I’d entered the world as the whale was leaving it. After the marine biologists learned all they could from her, she was buried right there on the beach, along with the unanswered questions about what had brought her to that shore. We lived on that coast until the summer after second grade, when my family moved to Houston for my dad’s new job. Since then, we went back just once or twice a summer. The good thing about our new home was that it was closer to my grandparents. I liked being able to spend more time with them, especially since they were both Deaf like me. But we all missed the beach, and I missed being around kids like me. My old school had just a few Deaf kids, but that was enough. We had our classes together, and we had one another. “But it’s different for us,” Grandpa signed. “Out here, there’s more light, and all we need is our own small space to feel at home. Sometimes it takes time to figure things out. But you’ll do it. You’ll find your way.” I wish I’d asked him then how long that would take. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • In the spirit of modern-day classics like
  • Fish in a Tree
  • and
  • Counting by 7s
  • comes the Schneider Family Book Award-winning story of a deaf girl's connection to a whale whose song can't be heard by his species, and the journey she takes to help him.
  • From fixing the class computer to repairing old radios, twelve-year-old Iris is a tech genius. But she's the only deaf person in her school, so people often treat her like she's not very smart. If you've ever felt like no one was listening to you, then you know how hard that can be.When she learns about Blue 55, a real whale who is unable to speak to other whales, Iris understands how he must feel. Then she has an idea: she should invent a way to "sing" to him! But he's three thousand miles away. How will she play her song for him?Full of heart and poignancy, this affecting story by sign language interpreter Lynne Kelly shows how a little determination can make big waves.
  • "Fascinating, brave, and tender...a triumph." --Katherine Applegate, Newbery Award-winning author of
  • The One and Only Ivan

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
60%
(1.1K)
★★★★
25%
(456)
★★★
15%
(273)
★★
7%
(128)
-7%
(-128)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

So far from perfect for me. But it had a few cute moments.

When I first heard about this one I knew I had to read it. Because that cover is all kinds of stunning. And the story seemed amazing too. I do not think I have ever read a book about a deaf girl, and I was so excited to finally get to do that. Parts of this book were all kinds of awesome. But sadly, almost all of the book was bad. Oh.

And because of that I'm giving this book two stars. Which makes me so sad, but it has to be done. I had so many issues with this one. Yet I also enjoyed some of it a whole lot. I have so much to share about it. First, a huge thank you to the publisher for letting me take part in the blog tour and for sending me the lovely book.

While my blog tour in late January was supposed to be a review and a giveaway, I do not feel okay with sharing a two star review for a blog tour. Will be posting my review today, and will hopefully be sharing a spotlight and giveaway of an ARC post in January. I truly wish I could say that I loved this book. As I really wanted to. It seemed incredible. And looks truly gorgeous. But it was sadly filled with issues. I will start by saying that I have no idea if any of the deaf part of the book had issues as well, as I do not know anyone that is deaf. I will say that I found all of it to be written really well. I loved that the main girl was deaf. I loved reading about how she lived every day as a deaf person. Was so very interesting. And she was all kinds of awesome because of that. Love.

But sadly that did not save this book. Because even though the deaf parts were incredible, the rest of the writing was so very much not. I could not connect to anything in this book. It also felt so rushed. And a bit awkward at times. Especially so because Iris is said to be twelve years old, but yet she felt years younger than that. Which was a bit depressing. I also did not like this girl. Because of her personality. She treated a girl in her class so very badly. And not once was that owned up to. It bothered me so much, at all times.

Sure, it is written in a way that makes it seem like the girl in her class was an idiot, and doing everything wrong. But she was not. She was a girl who could hear. And who tried so hard to learn sign language so that she could talk to Iris too. But Iris did nothing to help her with this. All she did was turn away from her and ignore her and get angry with her for not being able to sign anything right. I felt like Iris should have helped her. Should have tried to be her friend, like this girl was trying so so very hard to be hers. Hmph.

Which means that sadly I did not like Iris very much at all. I tried to love her, I truly did. But yeah. No. She treated this girl badly in the beginning of the book. And then near the end she reads something about her, and she laughs and laughs at her, and it made me dislike Iris more and more. Was not good. Sure, there were parts of Iris that I liked. Getting to know how she talked with sign language was awesome. So loved her friendship with this adorable boy that was deaf as well. It was pretty adorable. But was sadly too little.

This book is about Iris being unhappy in her school. Since she is the only one there that is deaf. And her grandparents are deaf too, but her grandpa is dead and her grandma lives at a home for old people. Her mom can sign language too, and her brother as well. Her father was not good at it. And that was written badly too, because it was all kinds of painful to read about, and it really shouldn't have been written that way, at least, I do not think it should have. Parts of Iris's life was hard to read, which was bad and good.

While at school, she learns about a whale. Blue 55. He has a different song than every other whale in the ocean, and so no one can understand him. He is all alone and has no one around him. This is somewhat a true story, and I did like that a whole lot. It was interesting to read about the whales and such. But also a little weird. There are even really small pages with the whale point of view. Yeah. That was odd. And the way Iris reacted to learning about the whale. Yeah. I cannot support that. Not at all. Which is depressing.

I did love that Iris felt strongly about this whale. That she wanted to help him connect with others. Liked that she decided to make a song for him that he could hear, that no other whale could sing for him. But what I did not like is that she got obsessed with this whale right away and decided that she had to go to Alaska to find him, to see him. Did not like how she treated her family because of this. And then she runs away. With her grandmother. On a cruise ship, for weeks, without telling her family first. Uhm. What even.

I cannot help but say that I found this book to be a bit problematic. If that is the right word. It might not be, but I'm not sure how else to describe it. This book makes it feel it was okay that twelve year old deaf Iris ran away with her old and deaf grandmother, who was grieving for her dead husband, and was in a home because they feared she could not take care of herself. Yeah. And they run away together. That was not safe. And it was not okay. Sure, Iris thinks about her family a couple of times while being away. Hahaha.

That was not okay either. She is on a cruise for Alaska, far away from her family, without talking to them or telling them where she is going or why. Her grandma is keeping them updated, but that was still not an okay thing to do. Yet this book tells it in a way that it felt okay, that it was the right thing for Iris to do. That it was the only thing she could have done, the thing she was supposed to do. I do not support that at all. It was reckless and dangerous. Gosh, my review is much longer than I had planned for it to be. Sorry, haha.

But can't stop writing about this book. I must share all my thoughts. Some spoilers. There is even a scene in the book where Iris jumps into cold water and swims toward a huge whale. Looking it in the eyes. And swimming around it. Not once is it mentioned that this is dangerous. And it was. Incredibly so. And I'm not sure why this book is making it seem like all of this was okay. Hmm. Can't help but feel that this book was not all that safe. Of course, it is highly possible that I am the only one to feel this way, that others will not.

Which is also okay. I'm sorry to say that Song for a Whale was not a book for me at all. I wanted to love it, so so badly, but I could not. I found parts of it to be very good, and I wanted to know more. But most parts where not good at all. And I may have shared way too much in my review. But I just could not stop writing and I do not regret it. So curious to know what others will think of this book. Do let me know if you read it. Huge thank you to Random House Kids for sending me a free ARC copy of this book to read and review.

---

This review was first posted on my blog, Carina's Books.
17 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

one of my favorite middle-grade main characters ever!

This is such a rich, beautiful book, and Iris is one of my favorite middle-grade main characters ever. She is a bit prickly, perhaps, but for reasons the reader can totally empathize with. Neither her parents nor her classmates nor her teachers really understand her deeply. And despite it all, she remains caring and open to new people.

Iris's electronics talents are handled beautifully. They aren't treated as some kind of "girl tech genius" mystical powers. Instead, Iris's narration shows the concrete process through which she has learned to repair old radios, and how her passion for it and attention to detail let her do things that seem like magic to the other people. The radio repair descriptions were a mini-highlight of the book that could be inspiring to a lot of kids.

When Iris embarks on an expedition that helicopter parents (and most other parents besides) might find a little horrifying, the move feels true to her character, and the reader understands why she *has* to go. In the best spirit of children's literature, SONG FOR A WHALE is about a quest. Instead of a magical wardrobe or the Shire, this quest starts in a classroom presentation about a whale who can't communicate. But it has the same urgency and epic character as those famous quests, and it will change everything for the main character in a similar way.

As someone without direct personal experience of deafness, I very much appreciated the depiction of Deaf culture and what it is like for deaf people to communicate with each other and with hearing people. Iris's narration gave me more insight into the day-to-day experience of a deaf person, making it seem close rather than distant, and illuminating its joys as well as its frustrations.

SONG FOR A WHALE is a lovely, unique book, and I couldn't recommend it more highly!
14 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

One of My Favorite Reads of the Year!!!!

Even though the cover of this book is so gorgeous it's hard to stop staring at it, once you begin reading you can't help but fall in love with this book. I adore stories where every thread in the book supports the character arc in a way that is smooth and feels just right--that is what you get with SONG FOR A WHALE. Everything has a purpose and it all unrolls at the perfect time to make your heart soar.

Iris is such a spunky yet vulnerable character, you can't help but root for her. Her Grandmother is a blast. And every other character in the story was well rounded, full of strengths and flaws to make them relatable. Each one captured my heart and attention as I swam through the pages. I loved them all. And learning more about the deaf community is fascinating.

And then there is that wonderful whale, Blue 55. Haven't we all had a time where we were wandering through the world and weren't sure that no one else was hearing us? This whale will touch your heart and you will be rooting for both him and Iris the whole way through.

After swimming through this book, it is not a stretch to believe that Kelly's latest book will be in the hands of young readers for a very long time. As a fan of her debut, CHAINS, I can't wait to see what she writes next.
10 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I THOUGHT THE ONLY THING I HAD IN COMMON WITH THE WHALE ON THE BEACH WAS THE NAME WE SHARED

SONG FOR A WHALE

I got this book for my soon to be twelve year old grand girl. She absolutely loved it.

Paige says --

Iris is deaf and the only deaf student in her school. This makes her feel annoyed at her mom since Iris would like to go to a school were there are other deaf kids and where her best friend attends. In her science class she saw a video about a whale called Blue55 . Blue55 is a hybrid between a fin whale and a blue whale, the cause of him being a hybrid makes it so no other whale can understand him .

Iris hears about Blue55 and wants to help him. Can she?

Iris takes an adventure with her grandma to Alaska to meet Blue55. She makes new friends and makes different types of gadgets on her way to meet this whale.

Overall this was one of the best and most touching book I've ever read. This book would be good from 4th grade and up.

I really loved this book and can't wait for Lynne Kelly (the author) to publish more books like this one. -Paige
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Writing was Good but didn't like the character or plot

I never really got close to the main character of this book. I kept finding her whiny and was a little unable to accept that a tween could run away from her family and lie about what she was doing. The writing was fine but the story seemed a little weak. I just could not get over how self centered the main character was. Not sure that this will go on my recommend list.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A good book for teaching children how to have empathy for others

This is one of those books that teach children to be empathetic towards others and other creatures. This centers around a deaf girl who has found out that there is a whale that is not able to be heard. She creates a way so the whale will be able to hear her sing to him. The whale is 3000 miles away so Iris and her grandmother take off to find the whale.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Belonging

MG (8-12), FICTION, STEM (science, technology), DEAF

Twelve-year-old Iris is deaf. Iris is not very interested in school as communications with teachers and other students is a chore, even though she has an assist person to interpret for her throughout the day. She feels like no one "hears" her. One of her science teachers gives a presentation about a whale called BLUE 55 who's song is at 55Hz , no match for any other whale traveling the Pacific Ocean. Iris immediately feels a connection to BLUE 55. Iris also has an interesting hobby of repairing old tube style radios. She can't hear the music, but feels the vibrations made by sound.Figuring that BLUE 55 must be very lonely she sets about to create a song for BLUE at his range of 55 Hz. Can she get other adults on-board to help BLUE?? The story is about the importance of finding others that you can communicate with and finding your "Pod" - belonging. SONG FOR A WHALE is a very clever story written by an expert in ASL (American Sign Language) and gives hope for those who feel alone in the world! BLUE 55 is based on a real whale communicating at 52 Hz. Very well researched!! A great read!!
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Showcases How Important And Amazing The Deaf Community and ASL Really Is

I have purchased this book five times now for different friends and family, and probably will buy more! As a Deaf Education teacher who was a Sign Language Interpreter in a mainstream school for seven years this is such an impactful book that shows some of the hardships that come without language access and a story that is a really wonderful look into the amazing world that is the Deaf community. I love that the main character uses ASL to communicate, I love that she isn’t trying to overcome her deafness, LOVE the ASL poetry, and I love the story. I would love to see more amazing Deaf characters in more books, and more from Deaf authors, but this is an incredible start. Highly recommend!!
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Spunky, honest, lovable Iris will take you on an adventure!

This is one of those beautiful stories where you walk in the shoes of the first person narrator and see a side of things you may not always understand on your own. For me as a teacher and someone who does not speak ASL, this was especially true. I loved Iris's strength. The relationship between Iris and her karaoke-loving Grandma was really special, and I was glad to go on their adventure to Alaska with them. Middle grade stories with animals can't stay on my classroom shelves, and I know that my students will love Iris's story as much as I did.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Lyrical story with whale-sized heart

Smart and expressive, Iris is a heroine that does not disappoint. Struggling for friendship in a school without other Deaf students, Iris becomes fascinated with the plight of Hertz 55, a whale who sings too high to be understood by the other whales in the ocean. Kelly wraps this beautiful story up in her simple, lyrical prose and gives it whale-sized heart. This luminous story about communication and connection will resonate with anyone who has ever felt misunderstood or unheard.
2 people found this helpful