Supreme Justice: A Novel of Suspense
Supreme Justice: A Novel of Suspense book cover

Supreme Justice: A Novel of Suspense

Hardcover – May 18, 2010

Price
$10.00
Format
Hardcover
Pages
320
Publisher
Harper
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0061926518
Dimensions
6.25 x 1 x 9.25 inches
Weight
1.1 pounds

Description

From Publishers Weekly In this entertaining if predictable sequel to Executive Privilege (2008) from Margolin, policewoman Sarah Woodruff, who's on death row in Oregon, has been tried twice for murdering her lover, John Finley. Sarah's life depends on an appeal to the Supreme Court, but her appeal, if heard, could expose a criminal plot within the CIA. An unexpected vacancy in the court provides one opportunity to quash Woodruff's attempted appeal. For the man at the center of the plot, however, this isn't enough, and a Supreme Court justice becomes a target for assassination. Once again PI Dana Cutler and law clerk Brad Miller find themselves investigating dastardly doings in Washington, D.C., involving a host of conventional characters, from scheming Beltway sachems to a ghetto-raised African-American justice. Thriller fans who like to see the villains receive their just rewards and the good guys come to no harm will find this a comforting read. (June) Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. From Booklist Margolin is usually a sure thing, but this sequel to Executive Privilege (2008) is surprisingly weak. Brad Miller, the lawyer who played a key role in bringing down the U.S. president, is now a clerk for a Supreme Court justice. When seemingly unprovoked attacks on two justices appear to be connected to a pending death-row appeal, Brad and several other characters from the preceding novel race against time to get to the truth. For a debut novelist, this would be an adequate first effort. For a genre veteran like Margolin, it reads like a rough draft: thin characters, dialogue that is frequently stilted, and major structural problems (including a flashback sequence, located in the middle of the book, that amounts to a full third of the novel’s length). Devoted fans will look past the novel’s many flaws to enjoy the intricate story, but this is a far cry from Margolin’s excellent early novels, including Gone, but Not Forgotten (1993) and After Dark (1995). --David Pitt “Entertaining. . . . Thriller fans who like to see the villains receive their just rewards and the good guys come to no harm will find this a comforting read.” — Publishers Weekly “[An] intriguing glimpse into the inner workings of the court. As always with Margolin, roller-coaster plot propels the action along, with plenty of twists and turns to keep things interesting.” — The Portland Oregonian “Margolin’s latest is a fast-paced yarn connecting a Supreme Court vacancy, a death row inmate, an ex-CIA chief and an attack on another Justice.” — New York Post, Required Reading “Get ready for a page-turning thriller. . . . [It] will keep you guessing until the last page.” — National Examiner “A good old fashioned political thriller. . . . Supreme Justice is a simple pleasure. . . . An exciting and enjoyable mystery.” — Huffington Post “Margolin creates a tangled plot. . . . The ending was deliciously devious.” — Bellingham Herald “A wry twist ending . . . puts a legal cherry on top of this satisfying gulp of Supreme Justice .” — Clarion Ledger “Margolin has come up with a winning recipe for success: by combining his legal expertise and experience with attention-grabbing characters and surprising storylines, he’s assured himself a secure spot in a genre known for keeping people guessing.” — Cascadia Weekly “Action speeds along through 65 fast-paced chapters with more bodies along the way. . . . But don’t think you can solve this one on your own. Just when you think it’s wrapping up, there is another surprise.” — The Oklahoman New York Times bestselling author Phillip Margolin returns to the corridors of power in Washington, D.C., with an exciting thriller about a ghost ship and the President's nominee to the U.S. Supreme Court. Sarah Woodruff, on death row in Oregon for murdering her lover, John Finley, has appealed her case to the Supreme Court just when a prominent justice resigns, leaving a vacancy. Then, for no apparent reason, another justice is mysteriously attacked. Dana Cutler—one of the heroes from Margolin's bestselling Executive Privilege —is quietly called in to investigate. She looks for links between the Woodruff appeal and the ominous incidents in the justices' chambers, which eventually lead her to a shoot-out that took place years ago on a small freighter docked upriver in Shelby, Oregon, containing a dead crew and illegal drugs. The only survivor on board? John Finley . With the help of Brad Miller and Keith Evans, Dana uncovers a plot by a rogue element in the American intelligence community involving the president's nominee to the Supreme Court, and soon the trio is thrown back into the grips of a deadly, executive danger. With nonstop action, Supreme Justice picks up where Executive Privilege left off, putting readers right back where they were—on the edge of their seats. Phillip Margolin has written nineteen novels, many of them New York Times bestsellers, including his latest novels Woman with a Gun, Worthy Brown’s Daughter, Sleight of Hand , and the Washington trilogy. Each displays a unique, compelling insider’s view of criminal behavior, which comes from his long background as a criminal defense attorney who has handled thirty murder cases. Winner of the Distinguished Northwest Writer Award, he lives in Portland, Oregon. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • “A master of plot and pacing—and one of those rare authors who can create a genuinely surprising ending.”
  • — Lisa Scottoline
  • “It takes a really crafty storyteller to put people on the edge of their seats and keep them there. Phillip Margolin does just that.”
  • Chicago Tribune
  • The crew from the
  • New York Times
  • bestseller
  • Executive Privilege
  • is back in another pulse-racing thriller from Phillip Margolin. Fans of John Grisham, David Baldacci, James Patterson, and Scott Turow—as well as Margolin’s own immensely popular Amanda and Frank Jaffe books like
  • Fugitive, Wild Justice
  • , and
  • Proof Positive
  • —won’t be able to put down
  • Supreme Justice
  • until the last spellbinding page.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(313)
★★★★
25%
(261)
★★★
15%
(156)
★★
7%
(73)
23%
(240)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

3.5 stars for a solid, engaging legal thriller

I read Margolin's previous [[ASIN:0061236225 Executive Privilege]] and really enjoyed it. This is a good, solid engaging legal thriller, but, for me, didn't live up to the prior one.

Short summary: Brad Miller is back from Executive Privilege where he helped crack the case that brought the former President down. Now, he's working for a Supreme Court Justice - and a case emerges that it appears someone is going to great lengths to prevent the Supreme Court from allowing it to be re-examined. Who is doing that and why?

Here's the ups and downs of it to me:

- Though able to be read as a stand alone, it'll be harder to enjoy that way, since references from the previous book kept getting made about the various characters. I found it distracting, and don't think they're terribly helpful to the new Margolin reader.

- It is well-plotted, so all the pieces get wrapped up nicely, and there's a few twists. But, I didn't find it as page-turning as some thrillers can be.

Bottom-line: It's as good as a lot of the average Turow or Grishams works, and if you like them, you'll probably like this one. But, I would really recommend Executive Privilege before and over this one.
26 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Unreadable trash

I read the 5 star reviews and don't understand if they are shills or insane. This is one of the few books that I've actually quit reading. Every single page I was blown away by the incredibly ridiculous scenarios and two dimensional characters. I eventually couldn't take it anymore. I understand that you have to suspend disbelief when reading but that only goes so far. When every single plot is unbelievable and the dialogue is awful then the entire book becomes unreadable. The plot is so incredibly dumb that we're supposed to believe that in order to cover up a drug deal netting a few million dollars that the CIA is going to kill over 10 people including a Supreme Court Justice? For a few million dollars?? The coverup cost more than they ever profited. Every bit of the storyline is unreal and I'm not sure the last time I've seen such flat characters.

I think my favorite part is when the death row inmate explains to her attorney how the CIA set up this drug deal, killed everyone involved and then framed her for another murder to complete the cover up and immediately her attorney says "That makes sense". It does? On what planet? If there is nothing else to read and you have a long plane trip or bad diarrhea then I guess this book will do. Personally I think that Twilight is more believable than the events in Supreme Justice.
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Not bad, but forgettable

"Supreme Justice" is a readable book, but is not an unforgettable book. It starts out with an exciting first chapter leading one to expect a taut political or espionage thriller. The book then skips around and introduces new characters including lawyers, Supreme Court Justices, DAs, private detectives, law clerks, etc. It skips around in time and space. The first chapter character later reappears. There is a female cop, Sarah, who is indicted for murdering her lover, the man in the first chapter, and is up for the death penalty. Her case is dismissed because the man turned up alive. Then he dies and she is indicted again. In addition a government agency with black suvs and contract killers has made the first chapter incident "disappear" and one of the Supremes and another powerful lawyer want to keep it disappeared. There is an attempt on the life of another of the Supremes. Eventually everything ties together and some disposition is seen of all of the characters except for one real bad guy assassin who is in the wind.

Read it on the airplane or while waiting to see your doctor, dentist, lawyer, etc..
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Too many sub plots

The flow of this book is so choppy with so many sub-plots that it's difficult to retain the interest of the reader. I usually enjoy Margolin's books, but I quit this one in the middle, not worth my time to continue trying to figure out who's who.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Supreme Suspense

Supreme Suspense

Phillip Margolin's "Supreme Justice" [[ASIN:0061926515 Supreme Justice: A Novel of Suspense]]begins with shipboard murders in 2006 and then fast forwards to a case submitted for certiorari in 2012. One of the justices is involved in a cover-up directly involved in the case of a policewoman on death row for the murder of a man suspected of being a CIA operative. The former head of the CIA, his "business," and cronies seem to be involved in preventing the case from being heard by the nation's highest court. The characters are intelligent and one never gets the sense that they are one step behind the reader. The US Supreme Court is being manipulated and infiltrated.

The story is suspenseful, intelligent and eminently readable.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The Continuing Decline of Margolin

Phillip Margolin has always been one of those guys that has played along the edges of being a major writer. In the end, he has generally wound up being the book you pick up in the airport for half price. He has had some major high points such as "Gone, but not Forgotten." Sadly Supreme Justice falls solidly into his low point category.

Fresh off the takedown of a crooked President and his serial killing wife in "Executive Privledge," Brad Miller and his new fiancee Ginny Striker go to DC in order to follow new job opportunities.

Brad works clerks for a Supreme Court Justice as his reward for investigative work in the last book. Ginny starts working at a law firm that conviently holds the major bad guys and the answers to some of the tepid questions the book poses.

By painful coincedence, it is Brad's Justice that causes a riff in the court over a cert case of a woman on death row. She is nearly murdered by an assassin but is saved by, surprise, Brad Miller. So launches the story. Also appearing are Dana Cutler, the PI from the first book and Keith Evans from the FBI. I can buy the setup for Executive Privledge happening in that book, but to get wrapped up in another major conspiracy involving CIA directors and Justices just a few months later? That is stretching it. What is the next book, Miller and Striker take down the Speaker of the House and the Sec. State?

The book chops back and forth between 2012 (the book's present) and 2006 to the murder of a possible drug dealer/intelligence agent by a cop. Sadly, the book telegraphs the major plot points of flashbacks, so they become almost pointless.

It is a book hampered by bad writing. In one scene our FBI man mentions that the FBI can solve any case but can't figure out why there isn't anything good on TV. Really, that 30 year old joke is recycled. Maybe it simply padding as the book is a thin volume already, crashing in around 300 pages with Pattersonesqe chapter sizes and font size. The whole book has the feeling of a novel that was not born out of any good idea, but rather a manuscript deadline.

It is also predictable. As each character is introduced you can pretty much guess what they are going to be. You are the red herring, you are the real killer, you will end up dead. Etc. Etc.

Don't get me wrong, it is not an offensively bad book, but it is well below par. Hopefully Margolin can return to form in future books. But the trio of Miller, Striker and Cutler are certainly not strong enough to carry a third book.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Boring read

Having read most of Margolin's books, I found this one the leased liked. The story line is preposterous, dialogue flat, characters uninteresting. I could barely finish.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Very Enjoyable - Not Great

I would actually give this a 3.5 stars if that were a choice. I think the plot has been well reviewed in other reviews. I enjoyed this book and found the characters and the plot interesting. There is something lacking that makes it not great, but it's certainly a good read. I would not agree with the comment that it's as good as any Turow because Turow's books have a great deal of depth not only in story but in character exploration. I think Margolin was successful in creating characters you care about and a plot that was somewhat unusual. I was even somewhat surprised at the end. I guess the only real flaw was its lack of believability, but that's true in many books. If you like legal thrillers, and I do, you'll enjoy this book.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Pelican Brief On Steroids

I think I have read all of Phillip Margolin's books and I would call myself a fan of his. I look at his books as the literary equivalent of candy and he consistently does a solid job of writing fast-paced, legal thrillers. Supreme Justice is a follow-up to Executive Privilege and contains many of the same characters.

This book follows the Margolin playbook pretty well all the way through. I don't consider his books to be sticklers for realism but this book struck me as particuarly preposterous, with multiple attempts on the life of a Supreme Court Justice, a president being bribed to name a replacement Justice (and where did that scene come from anyways? just what evidence does the bad guy have on the current president that would make her do whatever he wants?) and impostor assassins placed in some of the most important positions of our country's legal system (could the police really be fooled by armed men calling themselves representatives from Homeland Security just because they say so?).

Despite my criticism, I have to admit I still enjoyed the book. To call it fast-paced would be an understatement. The book moves at breakneck speed and I could not wait to get to the end to see how it would all play out. With all that being said, how much is there really to complain about?
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A Good Thriller

I enjoyed Supreme Justice and really kept you on the edge of your seat. The author created good characters and really seemed to know the subject matter he was writing about. There were plenty of mysterious goings on, including assassinations and a surprise ending! I recommend this novel to anybody who likes thrillers.
1 people found this helpful