That Is Not a Good Idea!
That Is Not a Good Idea! book cover

That Is Not a Good Idea!

Hardcover – Picture Book, April 23, 2013

Price
$14.05
Format
Hardcover
Pages
48
Publisher
Balzer + Bray
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0062203090
Dimensions
9.75 x 0.5 x 9.75 inches
Weight
14.4 ounces

Description

How Ideas Become Good Ideas: A Note from Mo The first step to figuring out a story is your characters. And with each book, I go through hundreds of sketches that aren’t used. Here are a few that I did in the early stages of That Is Not a Good Idea! for Hungry Fox, Plump Goose, and the Baby Geese. Purple Fox: After I have a sense of a story and their characters, I start to make test sketches. It's my hope that the technique (the brushes, pencils, markers, or crayons) will give me an insight into who the characters really are. Baby Geese: This process goes on for a while (sometimes weeks, sometimes months). Even the character stylings that don't work help. The covering-the-eye pose from this test was used in the final book, even though the characters look completely different. Goodwolf Sketch: We use butcher-paper as our tablecloth, so that our family can doodle every night after dinner. (You can see some examples on the Mo Willems Doodles blog.) All of the characters seem to have taken over this night's dinner (I saved the drawing for later reference). Test Background: Once the characters started to come into focus, it was time to go through the same process with the backgrounds... From Booklist If anyone is going to pull off a picture book built on the conventions of old-time silent movies—exaggerated facial expressions, telling body language, and, of course, blacked-out dialogue pages cut into the story—it would be Willems. The setup is classic dastardly villain and innocent naïf, as a three-piece-suited, top-hatted, grinning fox catches the eye of a sweet, old babushka-wearing duck. Dinner! He asks if she’d like to go for a stroll in the deep, dark forest to his kitchen, where he’s making a pot of soup that’s missing only one last ingredient. At each step of the way, an increasingly frantic litter of chicks warns That is really, really, really, really not a good idea! By the time the story reaches its peak, you can practically hear the Wurlitzer throbbing, and kids will be squirming with tense glee, primed for a classic Willems gotcha that turns the whole thing on its head for the poor, unsuspecting fox. A quick, crowd-pleasing lark that should be a hit at group storytime. High-Demand Backstory: Willems, Willems Willems! And as much as everyone loves Elephant and Piggie, fans will be pleased to have a new offering in a picture-book format. Preschool-Grade 1. --Ian Chipman “This charmer is lovingly composed as an homage to silent movies and the concept of picture books as the ‘theater of the lap.’ Children and adults will relish being taken for such a thrilling, suspenseful ride again and again.” — School Library Journal (starred review) “Trust Willems to blend silents, animation, and comics for a wickedly droll poultry-in-peril yarn.” — Publishers Weekly (starred review) “There’s a trifecta of reading possibilities here: an energetic storytime, a read-alone, and a raucous readers’ theater.” — Horn Book (starred review) “A new offering of guaranteed laughs from three-time Caldecott-honoree Willems….Pure glee.” — Kirkus Reviews “Kids will clamor for a re-viewing and be pleased to note that the book cleverly sets itself up for the story going either way. This is also a delight to voice, with the goslings particularly enjoyable to act out.” — Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books Praise for GOLDILOCKS AND THE THREE DINOSAURS: “Willems has delivered his very best work so far-this is a tasty treat for kids already fluent with the original, and for any fan of funny, and everybody will want to read it again and again and again.” — Booklist (starred review) Praise for GOLDILOCKS AND THE THREE DINOSAURS: “With a sense of irony (and humor) as sharp as this dinosaur trio’s talons, Willems’s retelling is a sure bet for audiences who have moved beyond more gently witty fare.” — Publishers Weekly (starred review) Praise for GOLDILOCKS AND THE THREE DINOSAURS: “This is pure Mo Willems, from the many visual gags in the cleanly drawn illustrations and the tight, tongue-in-cheek story line to the endpapers .... Readers of all ages will find much to chuckle about in this wacky retelling.” — School Library Journal (starred review) Praise for GOLDILOCKS AND THE THREE DINOSAURS: “On every page, the text winks broadly at readers, first pointing to and then playing with conventions of folklore, narrative voice, literary foreshadowing, and plain old common sense.” — Horn Book (starred review) Praise for HOORAY FOR AMANDA AND HER ALLIGATOR: “Amusing and heartwarming, it will leave Willems’s fans totally satisfied.” — School Library Journal (starred review) Praise for HOORAY FOR AMANDA AND HER ALLIGATOR: “Six and a half short stories make up this expertly paced page-turner about a girl and her toy alligator, laced with the kid-centric humor on which Willems has built his career. ” — Publishers Weekly (starred review) Praise for HOORAY FOR AMANDA AND HER ALLIGATOR: “The pacing, word volume and wide trim size are all inviting and encouraging, bringing readers close to the cozy friendship between Amanda and her impatient stuffed friend. ” — Kirkus Reviews (starred review) Praise for HOORAY FOR AMANDA AND HER ALLIGATOR!: “Willems knows how to keep things interesting and his audience engaged.” — Horn Book (starred review) One day, a very hungry fox meets a very plump goose. A dinner invitation is offered. Will dinner go as planned? Or do the dinner plans involve a secret ingredient . . . ? (Don't forget to listen to the baby geese!) From the brilliant mind of Mo Willems comes a surprising lesson about listening to your inner gosling. Mo Willems knows a Good Idea when he sees one. A three-time Caldecott Honor winner (for Don't Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus! , Knuffle Bunny , and Knuffle Bunny Too ), he also won two Geisel Medals and two Geisel Honors for his Elephant and Piggie books. His books are perennial New York Times bestsellers, including Knuffle Bunny Free , Hooray for Amanda & Her Alligator! , and the Cat the Cat series. Before he turned to making picture books, Mo was a writer and animator on Sesame Street , where he won six Emmys. Mo lives with his family in Massachusetts. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • That Is Not a Good Idea!
  • is a hilarious, interactive picture book from bestselling author and illustrator Mo Willems, the creator of books like
  • Don’t Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus
  • , the Knuffle Bunny series, the Elephant and Piggie series,
  • Goldilocks and the Three Dinosaurs
  • , and many other new classics. Inspired by the evil villains and innocent damsels of silent movies, Willems tells the tale of a hungry fox who invites a plump goose to dinner. As with the beloved Pigeon books, kids will be calling out the signature refrain and begging for repeated readings. The funny details in the full-color illustrations by three-time Caldecott Honoree Mo Willems will bring nonstop laughter to story time.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
60%
(346)
★★★★
25%
(144)
★★★
15%
(87)
★★
7%
(40)
-7%
(-40)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

That Is NOT a Good Idea!

Mo Willems has a great reputation to uphold. "How could another book be as good as Don't Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus!"? But, you'll be glad to know that I (and my students) think that it is just as good or better than DLTPDTB.
The curve-ball this book throws at you catches you by surprise. In fact, after the last page, my group said, "Let's read it again, because now we GET IT!"
The silent movie reference took a little explaining, but it enhanced the suspense because it helped them understand 'why the baby geese couldn't just help out'. On the second read-through, they cackled aloud as every page gave up it's mystery to them.
Mo, you are OK with my class. They thoroughly approve.
36 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

This book upset my 3 1/2 year old

Always love Mo Willems books, but this one is very different than the others. My 3 1/2 year old daughter had an expression of horror on her face when we read this book (the ending, basically). It was not a fun read at all. My daughter received this book as a gift, so I feel bad getting rid of it, but I do not plan to read it to her again. This book is too dark for young kids. I am truly surprised at the number of 5 star reviews.
24 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

4-year-old loved it

I received this book, skimmed through it, and decided I was disappointed in it. However, when my 4 year old granddaughter spent the night, I decided to read it to her before bed. She LOVED it. I think we read it 5 times that night, with her chiming in on the "Not a good idea" pages. I guess it appeals more to little ones than grandmas. Anyway, I am happy I bought it, because she certainly enjoyed it.
17 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

NOT recommended for young and/or sensitive kids

I should have been more cautious based on the cover of this book, but I am a huge Mo Willems fan and generally love his books for my 4 year old (the ones I'm familiar with are filled with likable characters and cute morals, etc), so I didn't pay much attention and just assumed this would be similar to what I have already familiar seen. It's not. It's definitely clever with an unexpected twist at the end (I'll get to that), and may be ok for some kids. However I will be getting rid of this book ASAP, and I would caution parents with young and/ or sensitive kids to read ahead in order to understand what's in the book before purchasing it.

SPOILER ALERT: It's a little scary, as most of the book consists of a fox trying to lure a duck home for "dinner". The duck keeps agreeing to go with him (for a walk... into the woods... to his kitchen....), and every other page there is a young chick (or a few) looking scared saying "that is NOT a good idea!" The twist at the end is that when they are standing over the soup pot and fox says there's a missing ingredient in the soup (ie the duck), she agrees that yes there is and pushes the fox into the soup. The last page of the book is the duck and her children eating the soup. Personally, I like to stay away from scary/creepy and/or violent books when it comes to my son, and I certainly don't want him reading books where the characters eat each other. It's honestly a little disturbing and I'm surprised other reviewers haven't mentioned this, not really my idea of a great children's book. Again it is clever and maybe enjoyable if you're comfortable with the plot twist but I just wanted to put this out there - some parents may be fine with this book which I can totally understand but I wish I'd seen a review like this before purchasing it for myself.

One last note though - my son got to it before I got home to see it myself so he had already read it, unfortunately, but it actually went over his head... He thought the duck pushing the fox into the soup was hilarious, and did not make the connection that the fox ended up being cooked in the soup and the duck and her chicks were essentially eating him. He thought the fox went home. PHEW. But like I said, this book will be leaving my house (or at the very least will be hidden away for a few years) before he has the chance to figure it out :)
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

This is my 4 year olds favorite Mo Willems book

Not the story you think it is!
This is my 4 year olds favorite Mo Willems book.
Some kids may not enjoy it as much as others.
If your child is easily( reeeealy easily) scared this may not be for you.
It's not really scary but it's a tiny bit dark in a funny kind of way.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Odd book

I was going to give this as a gift for a four-year-old but decided to donate it to the public library instead. The drawings are good, but the ending is kind of creepy. The ducks make the wolf into a soup and eat it!
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

This book is not a good idea.

We LOVE Mo Willems books, but this is a dark dark book. We bought it for our daughter's birthday without reading it because we have loved pretty much every Mo Willems book ever. But this book is just twisted and dark. We didn't even give it to our daughter.
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Story Time Fun for All

Written in a style that resembles an old silent film, That is NOT a Good Idea! is the story of a wolf inviting a goose to dinner and the audience that knows what is inevitably going to happen. The kids hearing this story are, of course, a part of the audience along with the chicks. They will be shouting their warning to the main characters. The unexpected ending somehow managed to make this book even better. I can already see the kids' faces when they hear the ending, and hear the parents chuckling in the background at the same time.

I always worry when there is a Mo Willems book that appears on our new book cart at the library where I work. Will it be another gem, or will it feel like another one he just churned out? That is NOT a Good Idea! is definitely a gem; Willems at his finest. I haven't had a chance to read it to a group of preschoolers yet, but I can already tell it will be a hit. It is an easy read-aloud. The illustrations are classic Willems, very appealing to children. The chance for kids to interact with the story is definitely a plus. Adults will appreciate the silent film theme (I love it!) along with the simplicity of the story, and the ending will be a chuckle as well. It's an original story that has a great ending, and it appeals to both children and adults. Win!
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

So fun!!

My family was lucky to get to hear Mo himself present this at a reading 2 days ago and wow - such a great, fun book!!! My kids have loved all of his books and if you ask them which is their favorite you'll get "ALL OF THEM!!" as an answer - can't go wrong with his books! This is definitely another favorite!
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

What a Great Idea!

Taking his inspiration from the silent film era, Mo Willems has crafted another winner. His latest picture book is set up to resemble a silent movie with the wolf cast in the role of villain. Playing the leading lady--make that leading bird--is a seemingly sweet, trusting goose. Spread by spread, the wolf tempts her nearer and nearer to his home in the woods. The journey is interrupted at regular intervals by a chorus of goslings who warn at increasingly higher and higher decibels that their hookup is not a good idea. But whom exactly are they warning?

As always, Willems knows how to pace a suspenseful tale, and his bold illustrations, especially those which highlight his character's expressive faces, add to the unfolding drama. Young readers might be savvy enough to see the twist that lies ahead--but this mature reader certainty didn't!
6 people found this helpful