The Midwife's Tale
The Midwife's Tale book cover

The Midwife's Tale

Hardcover – April 1, 2003

Price
$15.80
Format
Hardcover
Pages
256
Publisher
The Dial Press
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0385335515
Dimensions
5.82 x 0.89 x 8.54 inches
Weight
14.4 ounces

Description

From Booklist It is the 1930s, and Kettle Valley, West Virginia, is still a sleepy place with no modern conveniences. The services of the Whitely woman are always in high demand, and Elizabeth works diligently with her mother learning the skills of a midwife, carefully mixing the tinctures and preparing the tonics that have the potential to preserve life. For generations, the Whitely women have kept the ledgers that define the population of Kettle Valley. The big black ledgers are filled with the names of the babies born into the hands of Elizabeth's mama and her grandma before her. There are also the red ledgers, which hold horrible truths encrypted in a code known only to Elizabeth's mother. Because Elizabeth spends her adolescence as an apprentice to the midwife craft, she is burdened with too much knowledge, and she feels the joy of childhood slipping away to be replaced with a deep, ebbing loneliness that fills her life with sorrow. A tender story of broken dreams. Elsa Gaztambide Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved “Evocative storytelling.” --Kirkus Reviews From the Inside Flap ?I come from a long line of midwives,? narrates Elizabeth Whitely. ?I was expected to follow Mama, follow Granny, follow Great-granny. In the end, I didn?t disappoint them. Or perhaps I did. After all, there were no more midwives after me.?For generations, the women in Elizabeth?s family have brought life to Kettle Valley, West Virginia, heeding a destiny to tend its women with herbals, experience, and wisdom. But Elizabeth, who has comforted so many, has lost her heart to the one man who cannot reciprocate, even when she moves into his home to share his bed and raise his child. Then Lauren Denniker, Elizabeth?s adopted daughter, begins to display a miraculous gift--just as Elizabeth learns that she herself is unable to have a child. How Elizabeth comes to free herself from a loveless relationship, grapple with Lauren?s astonishing abilities, and come to terms with her own emptiness is the compelling heart of this remarkable tale. Incorporating the spirited mountain mythology of prewar Appalachia, Gretchen Laskas has crafted a story as true to our time as its own, and a cast of characters as poignant as they are entirely original. “Evocative storytelling.” --Kirkus Reviews Gretchen Moran Laskas is an eighth-generation West Virginian. She now lives in Virginia with her husband and son. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. One If you were born in Kettle Creek or hereabouts on our part of the Tygart River Valley, your name was written in the ledgers that lined our shelves. They were tall black leather books, shiny and thin like the ones Greeley MacIntosher used over at the store in Philippi. With a good birth we came home and wrote the baby’s full name, the mama’s name, the daddy’s, and the date. All those lists of names should tell you that our family was good at what we do.We never talked about the ledgers to anyone but ourselves. Not that we were ashamed–these were just names after all, but on account of the babies who didn’t come through–and the pain that such knowledge brought. Most babies like that didn’t even have names given them, and when Mama thought me old enough to know, she showed me the lists of Baby Girl Teller, or Baby Boy Switzer, if the woman was far enough along to tell. No matter what, we recorded the names and anything else we could recall about the birthing itself.“Write it down,” Mama told me. “Everything.” She was the first to do this, marking little things about the birth that weren’t so important in and of themselves, but might be later, when you needed to see the history of the family. Granny Whitely and Granny Denniker had kept most everything in their heads–all but the names and dates. “A written record is more reliable,” Mama taught me. And she was right. Kettle Valley is full of Teller, Meroe, and Switzer families, and writing things down kept names and families straight. For a midwife, confusing a family history was one of the worst things you could do, as confusion might make a bad situation worse if you needed to choose the right tonic, or know just when to make a cut.I learned to read looking at those ledgers. Mama taught me herself, using the family Bible once the black books were mastered. Given the number of Hezekiahs and Micahs and Ruths and Mordecais I read about, it was often difficult to remember which ones were biblical wonders and which lived along the Philippi road. Sometimes, even when I read the scriptures now, I can’t be sure I didn’t once hear that King David’s wife Abigail had given birth to a little girl weighing more than twelve pounds. Fortunately, around the turn of the century, fashionable names changed–Henry, Otis, Maurice.Mama didn’t tell me about the little red book, which she kept hidden until I was seventeen and had been attending births for more than three years. I suppose she thought I wasn’t ready for it, and that was truth, for I wasn’t. Don’t know when I might of been ready, natural-like, but I found out about it because Sarah Meroe went into labor right at the same time as Old Lady Whipple. Old Man Whipple was a justice of the peace and was known for making things rough for people who didn’t please him, so when he came, Mama went with him, leaving me to handle Sarah’s birthing all alone.“Ain’t like Old Lady Whipple needs the help,” I muttered to Mama as she gathered her things and helped me prepare my bag. I’d never had a bag packed just for me before. I was scared to be attending Sarah, who was a little bitty thing known for her snorty laugh and big brown eyes–eyes that had nearly swelled shut during her confinement.“Hush, Elizabeth,” Mama told me. Her face looked white, the deep red of her hair shockingly dark against her skin. I wondered what Mama knew about Old Lady Whipple that I didn’t. That high-and-mighty woman had brought out fifteen children, and I couldn’t see that one more would make much difference.“You’ll have to make do,” Mama told me. Then she smiled, reached out, and smoothed my hair. “You’re a fine midwife,” she said. Already her voice had that birthing tone–as strong and sure as a bell ringing in winter. With that voice she called to women through the fiery pain of childbearing when there was nothing more she could do with her hands in their bellies. I coveted my mama’s voice more than anything she owned.“I’ll try,” I said, my own voice weak as well water.So I did, and everything went fine. I came home, my steps almost dancing on the path before me. My body hummed and stirred like one who has witnessed a great joy–and I had, as Sarah’s baby had been a big boy who looked just like his daddy. A good dose of black cherry tea had calmed what trouble Sarah had suffered towards the end, and I was feeling proud and happy. I could hear the sound of Kettle Creek bubbling over rocks as I went into the house.Mama was already home, sitting in her chair, staring into the fireplace where she’d built a roaring fire. She didn’t greet me when I arrived, but I didn’t pay her any mind, so busy was I writing down Ernest Meroe’s name in the black ledger. The first I had ever recorded in my own handwriting.I noticed then that Mama had written nothing from her own birthing. “Didn’t it go well?” I asked.“Well enough, I guess,” Mama said, her voice flat and wearied.“Didn’t they name it yet?” Sometimes families couldn’t agree upon a name, but usually this was only over the first baby, when the father was still interested, or if the mother-in-law was living with them. I’d seen families squabble about a name for weeks. “Did they just run out of names?” I asked with a laugh. “After sixteen babies, surely no one cares.”But Mama didn’t laugh with me, and this bothered me, seeing as she was a great one for laughing, even when no one else could see the joke. “Come sit down, Elizabeth,” she said. She was clutching a red book, her knuckles so white around the edges that I wondered that they didn’t snap. There were traces of blood and afterbirth rimmed around her fingernails.“What is it?” I asked, curious now.She reached out and handed me the little book, but she did not look at me. I turned the strange book over. The red leather cover was dusty and hard. When I opened it I saw a list of names, most familiar to me–names of folks living in Kettle Valley, just like those written in the black ledgers on the desk. There were family names, followed by a letter, a B or a G, sometimes followed by the letter D. I figured B was for boy and G was girl, but I wondered why we didn’t just write the names in the black ledger as we always did. At the very end was the name Whipple, with the letter G. There was no D.“What’s the D for?” I asked, seeing it written after about every third name. The dates went back for more than fifty years, and I saw in the beginning names written in Granny Denniker’s handwriting–names that I had never heard tell of in all of Mama’s stories.“Mama?” I asked, flipping the pages, filled with B’s and G’s and D’s. “What’s the D for?”“Deformed,” Mama said. She covered her face with her hands, leaving bloody smudges across her freckled skin. “Means the baby came out and there was something wrong with it.”I glanced over the pages again. “And if there is no letter D?” I asked.“Then there was nothing wrong,” Mama answered. The hands left her face and settled again into her lap.“Meaning?” I asked, but somewhere inside of me I began to understand.“The baby wasn’t welcomed. Whether it was deformed or not.” Her hands tightened into fists, fanned out, and were still again.I stood up, shaking, the book falling to the floor. “How?”“Pillow, normally.” Mama pushed some hair out of her eyes. I couldn’t seem to stop staring at her hands. “You won’t have to do it for a long time,” she told me. “I promise.”“I ain’t ever gonna do it,” I said. My clothes were damp with sweat–I could smell that childbearing scent dripping through my skin, perfuming the air around me with the iron-hot smell of blood and spices that have been baked inside a woman’s belly.“It’s called midwife’s mercy,” Mama started to say.But I was having none of it. “You can’t make me,” I told her, saying words I never would have dreamed I’d say to my own mama. She was suddenly a stranger to me now, this woman who could hold down a pillow on a baby. I thought of the goose-down filling the cracks around the baby’s nose and mouth, the image of the baby’s face pressed into the pillow, pressed by my mother’s hands.I went out the back door and purged my belly as hard as I could, trying to make myself clean.When I was done, I looked around me, seeing a place I’d always known, but was now foreign. The darkness seemed so dense and heavy that I could hardly make out the rim of Denniker’s Mountain looming behind the house. I could hear the churning water of Kettle Creek, reminding me that the woman inside was my mother, who carried me in her womb. I covered my ears with my hands and slumped against the steps, waiting until the wind changed and a warm summer rain began to fall.The house behind me was quiet, as still and dark as the mountain before me. Only then could I go back inside.When I woke that morning, Mama was gone, leaving only a note saying that she was at Mary Switzer’s. The room felt strange, and I thought at first it was her absence. Then I realized that all of the birthing ledgers were gone.I rummaged through the kitchen cupboards and even picked up the rugs. I checked the fireplace, but there was no ash in the grate. There soon would be, I thought, and headed for Mama’s room.The dark-blue-and-white quilt on the be... Read more

Features & Highlights

  • “I come from a long line of midwives,” narrates Elizabeth Whitely. “I was expected to follow Mama, follow Granny, follow Great-granny. In the end, I didn’t disappoint them. Or perhaps I did. After all, there were no more midwives after me.”For generations, the women in Elizabeth’s family have brought life to Kettle Valley, West Virginia, heeding a destiny to tend its women with herbals, experience, and wisdom. But Elizabeth, who has comforted so many, has lost her heart to the one man who cannot reciprocate, even when she moves into his home to share his bed and raise his child. Then Lauren Denniker, Elizabeth’s adopted daughter, begins to display a miraculous gift--just as Elizabeth learns that she herself is unable to have a child. How Elizabeth comes to free herself from a loveless relationship, grapple with Lauren’s astonishing abilities, and come to terms with her own emptiness is the compelling heart of this remarkable tale. Incorporating the spirited mountain mythology of prewar Appalachia, Gretchen Laskas has crafted a story as true to our time as its own, and a cast of characters as poignant as they are entirely original.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(98)
★★★★
25%
(82)
★★★
15%
(49)
★★
7%
(23)
23%
(76)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Brings Into the World a Bright New Talent

This is a wonderful story of bonds of love shared by mothers and their daughters as well as the love between men and women. Elizabeth, the midwife whose tale we are caught up in, isn't perfect but she is strong, smart and interesting. This is indeed a strong telling of a moving story but I wasn't aware that this kind of well-written novel was out of style.
One thing I loved about this book was that somehow, though it's not written in the sort of folksy dialect usually used to depict mountain people, the author lets the true voice of these people shine through. It's a very skillful job and gives the reader a real sense of place.
I look forward to the next book by this author.
23 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Compelling

This book crept up on me. At first I thought, yes, a pleasant read, nice mountainside, la-la-la. Then the characters pulled me in, and I found the story compelling and couldn't stop reading.

The young girl's apprenticeship to be a midwife, observing and not understanding at first, captured my imagination. And then, as she continues in her profession, trying to help women survive child-bearing and seeing their struggles as wives and mothers, I found myself thinking long and hard about the roles of women then and now, their courage or weakness in loves and losses, their generosity or greed when sick and when healthy, and ... this story captured my heart and mind as well.

I was humbled by the lives of mountain women who had few possessions and almost no physical comforts, and who often died in childbirth. And, of course, I was ruefully aware that the description of the blindness and foolishness of the protagonist could easily have been a description of my own.

(Hmmm. I've now read the previous reviews. I have to say that the people who slammed the book as being inauthentic in its language and dialects may lack experience of that part of the country. I have spent time in the Appalachian hollows (and, yes, the locals do call them "hollers"), and the language sounded unexceptionable to me. Also, according to my information, the author has been steeped in that culture since childhood. I suspect that the criticism says more about personal preference. If one wants a terse Hemingwayesque style, fine. If one doesn't care for the lyrical tone of a mountain storyteller by the fire, fine. But the quiet voice of such storytellers has a role in literature, and I value it.)

I will say that the ending did not entirely work for me, but the overall impact of the book was so important that I give it Five Stars.)
19 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The hard life, the gentle truth

It takes a few days for the full impact of THE MIDWIFE'S TALE By Gretchen Laskas to sink in. Every time we pick up a cell phone when the car breaks down, pop an aspirin for a lingering fever, open a bottle of sports water, answer another telemarketing phone call, readers remember life in Appalachia in the early part of the 20th century. This was truly a world apart. No phones, no instant meals, not even a bookshelf of books to read.
The world of this book is so deeply rooted in the past that when the Spanish Flu breaks out after World War I, the doctor arrives at one house with a mysterious powder--a wonder drug developed by Germans. It's aspirin, and it saves a character's life.
In this remote world, we encounter Elizabeth Whitely, a girl who never knew her father, and who follow her mother along "birthing babies." In an era when doctors were too remote and difficult interest in a birth, midwives were an essential part of life. The herbs, the twisti,g of tiny bodies in wombs, the signs of miscarriage, are all part of Elizabeth's young life, which she assumes will soon be hers.
Then one day she uncovers the dirty little secret of midwives. Not everone wants their baby. And in an ironic look at the anti-abortion hysteria going on today, the wealthiest and most pious-looking clients look aside at such a shocking crime as infanticide. "We don't want her," says one mother and the midwife has no choice but to smother the baby or let it die a more brutal death.
Then there are the abortions or "knocking free" a baby with herbs. This is a simple, but possibly risky, treatment that so-called unschooled people have been doing for thousands of years. And I'm assured than in today's Belize, the jungle people practice it still. No marches, no banners, just a private abortion that no one discusses.
Elizabeth isn't sure she wants any part of such an amoral world and does her best to avoid midwifery, which she never really does. Rebellious and often contrary to the end, she makes poor choices in her love life. But she is blessed in another way. Her stepdaugther--a "Miracle Baby" who should have died--becomes a healer and goes through her life re-affirming Elizabeth's own doubt that life and love are worth the struggle
The end is predictable, probably, but in its own way, this is the only kind of ending this books could have. Life meets the modern world head on, and ready or not, it must join the age we know.
Kudos to Laskas who writes of an area she knows and loves. If the language sounds odd to an urbanite, it's true to the soul of West Virginia. And that genuineness, more than anything, makes
this book one to cherish.
12 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Gorgeous

I was enthralled with THE MIDWIFE'S TALE from the opening paragraph and could not put it down. This book, set in early part of the 20th century, tells the tale of Elizabeth Whitely as she struggles with both the triumphs and the burdens of her profession, midwifery, and her own loneliness when the man she has loved most of her life falls for another. This is a love story, surely, but one not strictly confined to a relationship between a man and a woman. It illuminates the complicated bond between mothers and daughters, the friendships forged by women everywhere, and intricate ties of a close-knit community.
A lovely, moving novel.
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

One to treasure!

"A Midwife's Tale" is a solid, intelligent book, the compelling story of Elizabeth Whitely, last in a long line of midwives who have served the women and children of a remote West Virginia valley for generations. It begins prior to World War I when Elizabeth, training under her mother, discovers the brutal dark side of midwifery. It is the first of the harsh realities of life she will face.
Laskas has drawn a unique character in Elizabeth Whitely, a strong woman who meets disappointments with courage and a great generosity of spirit and happiness with spirited enthusiasm. All the characters in this novel are invested with such original, yet believable, human traits that even the fanciful strains of the story are plausible. It's a complex story, with surprising twists and turns and a truly memorable heroine making her way through it all.
The time and setting of "A Midwife's Tale" are unique, yet never threaten to overpower or even intrude on the story. So seamlessly does the author blend the aspects of a distinctive region that it was only once that I even noticed the dialect. Yet I was always "knew" the geography and history of the place, as well as "heard" the sound of the characters' voices. I've read well-received books by more experienced authors who don't do this nearly as well as Miss Laskas.

"A Midwife's Tale" is a wonderful love story and a polished, literary first novel. I still think about it, even though it's been weeks and many books in between since I read it. I highly recommend it.
10 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Good read, but....!

"The Midwife's Tale" left me a little bit..."hmmm, well...!" I found myself getting kind of tired of Elizabeth Whitely's self-loathing, bad-love-seeking ways, and other characters, especially Lauren, seemed much more interesting. I would have loved to have seen her storyline and perspective developed more. Why did such a fascinating character end up playing such a small role in the storyline, while Elizabeth's almost infuriating devotion to Alvin was the main focal point?

On the other hand, I did enjoy a lot of things about this novel. There are some beautiful descriptions, striking analogies, and raw emotions, almost too human to bear. The author has a lot of potential, and I would be very interested to read more.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I was up till 4 o'clock this morning finishing this book!

Imagine a novel that's not at all hip or sarcastic, a novel that's timeless, one that you'd want to pass along to your mother, to your daughter, to your best friend.
Gretchen Laskas has given us such a novel. In it, she conjures up the speech and perceptions of a backwoods woman in early 20th century West Virginia - a midwife - and she does this gracefully and without a trace of condescension. This is the kind of book you just want to inhabit - it all seems so real.
I'll keep it on my classics shelf alongside TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD and Annie Dillard's AN AMERICAN CHILDHOOD...
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Good Book

I am a midwife, so I love these types of stories. Its got some truth to it, but I really struggled with parts of it. IF you read it, remember its fiction!
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A truly wonderful read

I was given this book to read by a friend who suggested that we consider it for one of our monthly book club readings. I had not heard of the author and have to admit that I waited a couple of weeks before picking the book up to read. Let me say that I am an avid reader. I belong to a book club that has been meeting once a month for 13 years. This book was beautiful and so very well written. So good in fact that I wish I could contact the author! I just finished the book last night, so I'm a bit spellbound. I loved the characters in the book and especially the interesting story. This is a talented writer and I hope to see more from her. Definitely a book we will read and discuss as a group. I highly recommend it.
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

a good read, excellent storyline

the author draws us into the lives of three women who are midwives in the early 1900's and on. Not wanting to give away the plot, but Elizabeth should not have settled for someone who did not love her. Lauren's gift is woven into the story beautifully. Some of the births were hard to read. very sad. I wasn't sure what was going to happen when Elizabeth suddenly meets David. but the author kept me wrapped up and the ending was just what Elizabeth needed.
6 people found this helpful