The Monster of Florence
The Monster of Florence book cover

The Monster of Florence

Hardcover – Bargain Price, June 10, 2008

Price
$19.62
Format
Hardcover
Pages
336
Publisher
Grand Central Publishing
Publication Date
Dimensions
6.35 x 1.13 x 9.25 inches
Weight
1.2 pounds

Description

Amazon Best of the Month, June 2008 : When author Douglas Preston moved his family to Florence he never expected he would soon become obsessed and entwined in a horrific crime story whose true-life details rivaled the plots of his own bestselling thrillers. While researching his next book, Preston met Mario Spezi, an Italian journalist who told him about the Monster of Florence, Italy's answer to Jack the Ripper, a terror who stalked lovers' lanes in the Italian countryside. The killer would strike at the most intimate time, leaving mutilated corpses in his bloody wake over a period from 1968 to 1985. One of these crimes had taken place in an olive grove on the property of Preston's new home. That was enough for him to join "Monsterologist" Spezi on a quest to name the killer, or killers, and bring closure to these unsolved crimes. Local theories and accusations flourished: the killer was a cuckolded husband; a local aristocrat; a physician or butcher, someone well-versed with knives; a satanic cult. Thomas Harris even dipped into "Monster" lore for some of Hannibal Lecter's more Grand Guignol moments in Hannibal . Add to this a paranoid police force more concerned with saving face and naming a suspect (any suspect) than with assessing the often conflicting evidence on hand, and an unbelievable twist that finds both authors charged with obstructing justice, with Spezi jailed on suspicion of being the Monster himself. The Monster of Florence is split into two sections: the first half is Spezi's story, with the latter bringing in Preston's updated involvement on the case. Together these two parts create a dark and fascinating descent into a landscape of horror that deserves to be shelved between In Cold Blood and Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil . --Brad Thomas Parsons From Publishers Weekly Starred Review. United in their obsession with a grisly Italian serial murder case almost three decades old, thriller writer Preston (coauthor, Brimstone ) and Italian crime reporter Spezi seek to uncover the identity of the killer in this chilling true crime saga. From 1974 to 1985, seven pairs of lovers parked in their cars in secluded areas outside of Florence were gruesomely murdered. When Preston and his family moved into a farmhouse near the murder sites, he and Spezi began to snoop around, although witnesses had died and evidence was missing. With all of the chief suspects acquitted or released from prison on appeal, Preston and Spezi's sleuthing continued until ruthless prosecutors turned on the nosy pair, jailing Spezi and grilling Preston for obstructing justice. Only when Dateline NBC became involved in the maze of mutilated bodies and police miscues was the authors' hard work rewarded. This suspenseful procedural reveals much about the dogged writing team as well as the motives of the killers. Better than some overheated noir mysteries, this bit of real-life Florence bloodletting makes you sweat and think, and presses relentlessly on the nerves. (June 11) Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. From Booklist Italian journalist Spezi, source of much of the ooky background info Preston incorporated into his and Lincoln Childs’ serial-murder novel Brimstone (2004), gained much of his insight into the ghastly topic from his long-term reportage on the tangled investigation of the fiend referenced by the title of this book. After moving to Florence in 2000 and excitedly hearing about the local mystery of the murders of several pairs of young lovers in the 1970s and 1980s, Preston struck up with Spezi, joined the pursuit of the malefactor, and with Spezi eventually identified and interviewed a likely suspect. The local constabulary had other ideas. As the two writers closed in, Judge Giuliano Mignini brought them up short by informally charging them with interfering with his investigation. Later, he lodged formal charges against Spezi and had him arrested. Mignini had his own prime suspects, apparently thinking a satanic cult was responsible. Talk about your knotty true-crime situations! Officially, the investigation “grinds on with no end in sight,” having claimed one more victim—Spezi’s peace of mind. --Mike Tribby Douglas Preston worked for the American Museum of Natural History as managing editor of Curator magazine. He's also written articles for The New Yorker, Natural History , Travel & Leisure , Reader's Digest , National Geographic, Harper's, Smithsonian, and Atlantic . Mario Spezi is an Italian journalist who has been investigating the Monster of Florence case since the first murders in 1974. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • In the nonfiction tradition of John Berendt ("Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil") and Erik Larson ("The Devil in the White City"),
  • New York Times
  • bestselling author Douglas Preston presents a gripping account of crime and punishment in the lush hills surrounding Florence, Italy.In 2000, Douglas Preston fulfilled a dream to move his family to Italy. Then he discovered that the olive grove in front of their 14
  • th
  • century farmhouse had been the scene of the most infamous double-murders in Italian history, committed by a serial killer known as the Monster of Florence. Preston, intrigued, meets Italian investigative journalist Mario Spezi to learn more.
  • This is the true story of their search for--and identification of--the man they believe committed the crimes, and their chilling interview with him. And then, in a strange twist of fate, Preston and Spezi themselves become targets of the police investigation. Preston has his phone tapped, is interrogated, and told to leave the country. Spezi fares worse: he is thrown into Italy's grim Capanne prison, accused of being the Monster of Florence himself. Like one of Preston's thrillers,
  • The Monster Of Florence
  • , tells a remarkable and harrowing story involving murder, mutilation, and suicide-and at the center of it, Preston and Spezi, caught in a bizarre prosecutorial vendetta.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(676)
★★★★
25%
(564)
★★★
15%
(338)
★★
7%
(158)
23%
(518)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

true crime against the true crime genre...

I tried to get into this book, but never got pulled in. Preston did a credible job of reviewing the facts of the case, but the book quickly turned away from the killer and focused instead on Preston's involvement in the case, which I could care less about. While Preston did end up a minor figure in the case, his whining about it was the major focus of this book. I'm left wondering how much the (considerable) chip on his shoulder about being questioned by the Italian authorities biased his portrayal of the overall investigation, and have to conclude that I can't trust any of his analysis.
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The Monster of Florence

This book is rambling, never gets to the subject or the point. I knew less about the case after I read the book than before I read it. Not fit to buy! Waste of money! Very disappointing!
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I Told You

Wow, I was dumb. Who reads/listens to a non-"In Cold Blood" true crime book. It's too long they don't find the killer, case not closed. AUDIOBOOKED
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Eh.

Maybe I just wasn't in the right mood or mind set for this book, but I made it through two chapters before I called it quits. It's well written and seems well researched, but I just couldn't get into it.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Preston, Spezi, and the Monster of Florence

I was looking forward to reading "The Monster of Florence" by Douglas Preston and Mario Spezi. I have a fascination with true crime that I hope is not indicative of something within me. Then again, I know many people love reading true crime.

The book started off at "full-speed", highly readable and interesting. Preston, an American writer and journalist, fell in love with Italy in his early teens and decided to go back to Florence with his family. There he intended to write a crime novel set in Florence, and in the course of his research he met an Italian journalist Mario Spezi, who covered crime his entire career.

Preston discovered through Spezi that he and his family lived across the road from an olive grove in which a horrific murder took place - a murder attributed to the Monster of Florence. But who is this Monster? Noone knew. Preston and Spezi forged a strong friendship and an alliance, both determined to discover the identity of the sadistic killer.

Italian police and criminal justice system saw their efforts differently, and soon Preston and Spezi became suspects themselves, entangled in a fantastic and outrageous conspiracy theory. And this is where the story starts to lose my attention.

The book is a narrative, as told by Preston, though the first part of the book is apparently told by Spezi. The first part reads like an investigation of an elusive murderer, a chase after evidence and clues, battling against setbacks and odds that stood in the investigators' way. The second part reads like a rant about the Italian justice system, and almost like a manifesto outlining when and where the prosecution went wrong, repeatedly returning to the subjective storytelling. This happened so much that an occasional poetic description of Tuscany itself seemed out of place.

After reading about the experience of the authors with the Italian criminal justice system, I can certainly understand why they would be disenchanted. However, I wanted to read a book on the Monster of Florence, and not a persistent counter-attack against the public minister of the city of Perugia and the chief inspector in charge of the Monster of Florence case. While that information may be interesting, it does get tiring after several dozen pages. Towards the end the book looked like a vendetta against the public minister of Perugia, when Preston addressed the minister's involvement in Amanda Knox's case, as well as his continued prosecution of Preston and Spezi.

I can't say that the entire book was unsatisfying, but it is definitely not one of the books I would read again. I would actually avoid it and look for other sources of information, if I needed it. The point does remain that Preston and Spezi did marvelous research on the Monster of Florence, which was well presented, along with some theories of possible suspects.

Recommended with caution.

**This review also published on Epinions.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Interesting but naive

There are really two books here. Book 1 works well - a summary of the crimes of the monster, the public reaction and hysteria, the police hunt, likely suspects considered, arrested and discounted, and the authors' own opinion as to who the likely perpetrator is. And their suspicions, although based on circumstantial evidence and the somewhat dubious art of psychological profiling, seem well founded and at least worthy of investigation that is yet to occur. This is definitely not "Queen Victoria was Jack The Ripper" stuff - its better founded than that.

So far so good. Book 2 is less successful, as it deals with the labyrinthine and arcane workings of the Italian legal system. The authors - Spezi in particular - fall foul of the prosecuting magistrate, mainly because he keeps making him look foolish in the press, and find themselves part of the investigation. Spezi is arrested for obstruction of justice - contrary to the books' blurb he is not accused of being the monster - and Preston finds himself under investigation and advised not to return to Italy.

The problem with this book is that Preston just doesn't understand the Italian justice system and therefore his commentary takes on the tone of the naive innocent abroad "Gee whiz guys, this isn't fair, don't you know I'm American?" The Italian system may have many faults and rightly or wrongly may be difficult for an outsider to navigate, but it does not run purely on incompetence, malice and corruption as suggested here. For sure the power of influence is important and its frustrating for Preston that he doesn't have any ("But I'm American!") but it deserves more considered commentary than this. It isnt' Kafka's The Trial, whatever Preston may suggest.

None the less there are important lessons here for foreigners who find themselves in trouble in Italy. Those associated with Amanda Knox in particular would do well to read this.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The true crime would be skipping this book.

I've been reading vigorously for most of my life, but it's rare that a book can grab me so completely as this one did.

It was well wrote, detailed & gave me everything I hoped it would. The one sad thing is that now I'd be afraid to visit Italy, lest I be inducted into some legal woe.

I had never heard of this book before until a friend advised it & now I'm so glad I have it. The dedicated hard work of Spezi & Preston paid off. I salute you both.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A connection to Amanda Knox

Having just visited Florence, I picked up this book quite by accident. What a great story. It's filled with accounts of prosecutorial misconduct, which won't surprise you when you find that the same dolts who screwed up the original case are the ones who prosecuted Amanda Knox. At some point they were even prosecuting Preston. Stay away from Italy. You could be in a minor traffic accident and find yourself sentenced to die. Scary place. We're not going back.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Couldn't put it down!

I've been a long-time fan of true-crime drama, but "The Monster of Florence" by Preston and Spezi took the thrill to a whole 'nother level, as they investigate the decades-old serial murders of lover's lane couples which took place in Florence, Italy from the mid 1970's to 80's.

The most interesting part of the story for me -- though it was all gripping -- were the obstacles the authors encountered in their dealings with the police and judiciary who were responsible for investigating and prosecuting these murders. The story rears up and snatches Preston and Spezi into it -- and the drama and intrigue ramps up. I agree with others who stated that "The Monster" who callously murdered and mutilated his victims almost becomes second fiddle to the monstrous characters who resolutely refused to consider the evidence, and instead turn their prosecutorial malice on the authors and others.

This was a thoroughly read from the first page, and one I couldn't put down.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Incredible.

This was an intense and great read. There is a lot of information and Preston does a great job explaining it all. I am impressed by Prestons and Spezi dedication and frightened that they become a part of their own investigation/book!

Not only a crime story but a true warning to those who want to move to Italy or live there.

I happened to buy this book at a hospital book sale over a year ago but didn't start reading till recently. Without realizing completely what this book was about, I started reading a couple of weeks ago and how fitting with the Amanda Knox appeal coming up. I am so glad I read this book.

I always maintained that Amanda Knox couldn't be the murderer based on how the Italian media portrayed her. As I followed her case I believed more and more, whether she was innocent or not, she was prosecuted unfairly. The Monster of Florence really sheds light to judiciary system in Italy.

This book is bone chilling.
2 people found this helpful