The Testing (The Testing, 1)
The Testing (The Testing, 1) book cover

The Testing (The Testing, 1)

Hardcover – June 4, 2013

Price
$17.95
Format
Hardcover
Pages
352
Publisher
Clarion Books
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0547959108
Dimensions
5.5 x 1.13 x 8.25 inches
Weight
1.05 pounds

Description

From School Library Journal Gr 7 Up-Like almost every 16-year-old in the United Commonwealth, Cia Vale hopes to be called for the Testing, her ticket out of rural Five Lakes Colony and into the University in Tosu City. Cia's father was selected, but only vaguely remembers the experience in nightmares. Her four older brothers were passed over. Just when she has resigned herself to life as a mechanic or farmer, she gets word that she is one of four students selected from Five Lakes and is expected to board the skimmer to Tosu City the next day, most likely never to return. The bulk of the book is taken up with the Testing-devious exercises to identify those with superior leadership skills as society has suffered through Seven Stages of War and desperately needs to repair the damage to living creatures and the environment. The mental and physical trials will weed out 80 percent of the candidates, leaving several maimed or dead. Cia teams up with Tomas for both practical and romantic reasons. She is independent and smart for the most part, and Tomas seems almost too good to be true. There are double-crosses, mutant life-forms, and booby traps to navigate before 20 hearty souls receive word that they have passed. Cia's story is expected to span a trilogy. The influence of The Hunger Games is obvious, and The Testing will satisfy readers who want similar dystopian adventures.-Maggie Knapp, Trinity Valley School, Fort Worth, TXα(c) Copyright 2013. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted. From Booklist Mystery writer Charbonneau throws her hat into the YA dystopian ring with this series opener that bears more than a slight resemblance to The Hunger Games. Sixteen-year-old newly graduated Cia Vale is selected to take part in The Testing, a process that offers the only chance at a college education and training to become part of the next generation of leaders. Cia has spent years preparing for this—it’s her chance to help the United Commonwealth recover from the devastating Seven Stages War. Cia’s father, who took part in The Testing himself, warns her to trust no one. Charbonneau is treading familiar ground as she sets her young heroine against a government machine that is focused, brutal, and duplicitous. Though the story moves quickly, readers might be confused as to the reasons behind the government’s methods. Why the brutality against students? There is no indication that the citizens are oppressed, and they’re unaware of how gruesome The Testing is. The ending will ensure interest in the next installment, but hopefully book two will deliver some answers. Grades 7-12. --Kara Dean "The rising tension, skillfully executed scenarios, and rich characterizations all contribute to an exciting story bound to capture readers' imaginations. Charbonneau works action, romance, intrigue, and a plausible dystopian premise into a near-flawless narrative." — Publishers Weekly (starred review) “Electrifying." — Entertainment Weekly “ The Testing is a chilling and devious dystopian thriller that all fans of The Hunger Games will simply devour. Joelle Charbonneau writes with guts and nerve but also great compassion and heart. Highly recommended.” — Jonathan Maberry, New York Times bestselling author of Rot & Ruin and Flesh & Bone "I galloped through this excellent read; I was in suspense the whole time." — Charlaine Harris, author of the Sookie Stackhouse series "Action-packed and full of twists, The Testing will keep you guessing until the very last page—and desperate for the next book!" — Erica O'Rourke, author of the Torn Trilogy "Charbonneau is a fantastic story teller and this book is a tribute to that background. The intrigue in The Testing passes evaluation of what a good dystopian novel should represent." — Voice of Youth Advocates (VOYA) "The plot twists are well integrated and will keep readers on edge awaiting the next volume." — The Horn Book Joelle Charbonneau has performed in opera and musical-theater productions across Chicagoland. She is the author of the New York Times and USA Today bestselling Testing trilogy and the bestselling Dividing Eden series, as well as two adult mystery series and several other books for young adult readers. Her YA books have appeared on the Indie Next List, YALSA’s Top Ten Quick Picks for Reluctant Young Adult Readers, and state reading lists across the country. Joelle lives in the Chicago area with her husband and son.xa0www.joellecharbonneau.com Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Turning the knob, I push the door open and take a step inside. The smell, urine mixed with corncakes, hits me first. Then I see her. Dangling on a colorful rope. Hanging from the ceiling. Face red and blotchy. Eyes wide with horror. Neck gouged and bleeding where she fought from instinct or because she changed her mind. xa0xa0xa0I scream as the reality of what I see hits me. Hard. xa0xa0xa0Ryme is dead. Chapter 7 Hands help mexa0stand. Lead me into the hall. Someone asks me to wait and other people in jumpsuits come running from every direction. I clutch my bag to my chest like a security blanket as activity swirls around me. Ryme is cut down from the ceiling. A gurney appears. When she is whisked past me, I recognize the rope still around her neck: her dress, the one she looked so lovely in yesterday, tied to a bed sheet. xa0xa0xa0I can't help my stomach from emptying or the tears that flow hot and fast'''for her, for me, for not seeing the desperation and depression under the arrogant façade. Did my taunting her with finishing the final written test push her over the edge? Could a kind word have saved her? xa0xa0xa0'Cia?' xa0xa0xa0I blink and realize Dr. Barnes is holding my shoulders. Looking into my eyes. I blink twice and swallow the bile building in the back of my throat. Mutely, I nod that I hear him. xa0xa0xa0'they are going to assign you a different room.' He leans against the wall next to me. "Would you like to talk about it?' xa0xa0xa0No. But I will. I have to. Softly, I tell him about Ryme's arrogance and her taunts today. My reaction and the apology I eventually gave. Even the corncakes and what I suspected they might contain. He's a good listener. His deep brown eyes meet mine without censorship. His head nods, encouraging me to say more'''never once letting his eyes travel to the officials walking in and out of the room, cleaning the floor next to me, talking in hushed tones about removing her belongings. xa0xa0xa0When I am done, I feel empty, which is better in a way than feeling smothered by guilt. Dr. Barnes assures me Ryme's death is not my fault. As we discussed earlier, stress is difficult. Some students handle stress better than others. Some can't eat. Some never sleep. Ryme took her own life. While this is a tragedy, it is better for the entire Commonwealth population to learn now that she is not capable of dealing with the kinds of pressure she would be forced to deal with in the future. This event is unfortunate, but The Testing served its purpose. He hopes Ryme's choice to end her candidacy will not impact the results of mine. xa0xa0xa0End her candidacy? Inside I am icy cold. An official in purple informs us my room is ready, and Dr. Barnes gives my shoulders a squeeze. I smile and tell him I'll be fine and that talking to him made me feel better. I hope he can't see the lie. Because while his tone was kind, I heard the indifference in his words. To him, this was just another test. One Ryme failed. If I am not careful, I will fail, too. xa0xa0xa0I am shown my new room at the very end of the hall. The walls are painted yellow. They remind me of the dress Ryme was wearing when I first met her. The official asks me if I'm okay not having a roommate. If I don't want to be alone he is certain a female official would be happy to sleep in the spare bed. xa0xa0xa0No, I do not want to be alone. Awake, I am having trouble keeping Ryme's lifeless eyes out of my head. Asleep, I will be defenseless to stop her from haunting me. Knowing I will be alone through the ordeal makes me want to curl up in a ball. xa0xa0xa0But Dr. Barnes's words ring loud in my head. The Testing is about more than what happens in the classrooms. Asking for help through the night will be seen as a weakness. Leaders are not weak. The Testing is looking for leaders. xa0xa0xa0So I thank the official and tell him, 'I'm fine being alone.' He tells me to let the official at the desk know if I change my mind. They can even give me drugs if I need help sleeping. Then he shuts the door behind him. xa0xa0xa0I look around the room. Aside from the color it is an exact replica of the one I previously occupied. I hear muted voices and the sound of footsteps. Other candidates returning to their rooms from dinner. For a moment, I consider opening my door and going in search of my friends. A smile from Zandri, a hand squeeze from Tomas, or even one of Malachi's quiet looks would help ease the sadness. But I don't open the door because that, too, could be considered a weakness. Instead I shower, change into my nightclothes, wash the daytime ones, and hang them to dry. xa0xa0xa0Lying on the bed, I stare up at the ceiling, trying to conjure happy memories. Anything to ward off images of Ryme hanging from the light fixture. I can't help but wonder whether my father witnessed something similar. Whether his brain had made up an even worse memory of The Testing to compensate for the horrific one he used to have. At this very moment, I believe it is more than possible. xa0xa0xa0Everything is quiet. The others have taken to their beds and are sleeping in preparation for whatever is to come tomorrow. I am still awake. I keep the lights blazing bright and fight against the heaviness of my eyes. I am losing the battle when something catches my eye. A small circular glint in the ceiling. One that matches the one I saw in the skimmer. xa0xa0xa0A camera. xa0xa0xa0It is all I can do to keep the discovery off my face. I don't know why it should surprise me that there is a camera watching even when we are doing the most mundane chores like sleeping and getting dressed. But it does. Is this room alone being watched? Because I found Ryme? Immediately, I reject the idea. If they are watching one room, I am certain they are watching them all. The implication of that sucks the air out of my lungs. If there are cameras in every room, someone watched Ryme as she stripped her bed of the sheet. Tied it to her dress. Reasoned out the best place to affix it to the light fixture on the ceiling. They watched as she stepped off the chair. Saw her struggle against the rope, claw her throat in an attempt to free herself, and go limp as her body shut down. xa0xa0xa0They could have saved her. Instead, they let her die. xa0xa0xa0I force myself to appear calm as I walk over to the light switch and cast the room into shadows. Whoever is watching, I don't want them to see the horror I feel. I bury my head under the covers and out of habit clutch my bag to my chest. I wonder if the people behind the screen are reliving Ryme's death while they sleep tonight. It is mean of me, but I hope they are because I am even before sleep pulls me under. xa0xa0xa0Ryme's blotchy red face and her glassy, blood-streaked eyes follow me into my dreams. Her voice taunts me with my inadequacies. She offers me corncakes and this time I take one and eat it. Each time I wake, I force myself to go still. Not to call out or thrash about. I keep my head under the covers just in case the camera can see more than I believe, and do my best to wipe my mind clean of the horrors before dropping into sleep again. xa0xa0xa0When the morning announcement comes, I am grateful to climb out from under the sheets. I go into the bathroom and study myself in the reflector. I look tired, but no more so than I did yesterday morning. Taking this as a good sign, I pull on my clothes and brush out my hair while scanning the bathroom for prying eyes. No cameras. At least none that I can see. The Testing officials must not be interested in our hygiene habits. I leave my hair loose around my shoulders, hoping it will pull focus from the fatigue in my eyes, grab my bag, and head down to breakfast. xa0xa0xa0Tomas and the twins are already seated when I arrive. Tomas's face is filled with relief and he wraps me in a tight hug before I have a chance to sit down. As I sit, Tomas gives my plate a long look. In my effort to appear normal, I have piled it with bacon, eggs, sliced potatoes, fruit, and sweet rolls. I immediately shove a piece of bacon into my mouth to discourage questions about yesterday. It works until Zandri, Malachi, and their roommates arrive. Once everyone is seated, Tomas asks, 'Is everything okay? We kept waiting for you to come back last night.' xa0xa0xa0They wait for me to reply. I replay Dr. Barnes's words in my head. Did he mean for me to keep silent? I don't think so, so I quietly say, 'Ryme is dead. She killed herself last night.' xa0xa0xa0The Five Lakes candidates show various degrees of surprise. The twins sigh and give each other knowing looks. After a moment, Will says, 'We figured it might be something like that. Our teacher warned us about the pressure. He was a Testing official for a couple of years and said there were at least two or three suicides in every Testing class.' xa0xa0xa0Ryme was one. I can't help wondering who might be next. Judging by their silence, I'm guessing my friends are doing the same. xa0xa0xa0We talk about it a bit then concentrate on eating. I give some of my extra food to Malachi, who has definitely added on pounds since coming here three days ago, and shove a sweet roll into my bag. I don't know if we are supposed to take food from the dining hall, but I figure if someone on the other side of the cameras objects, they'll stop me. No one does. xa0xa0xa0Another announcement is made. We tromp to the elevators and are whisked back to the lecture hall. Dr. Barnes is once again up front. He smiles at everyone as they take their seats and congratulates us on finishing the first phase of The Testing. 'the tests are currently being evaluated by the Testing staff. Because we are aware of your unique skills, each group has its own set of requirements to achieve a passing score. After lunch we will meet with the Testing candidates and inform them whether they have been passed on or whether their Testing has come to an end. Until then, you will have time to spend as you like'either in your rooms, the dining hall, or the designated area outside.' xa0xa0xa0Outside. The idea of fresh air lifts my spirits. Dr. Barnes tells us that all candidates going outdoors must stay within the fence surrounding the Testing Center. Breaking the rule is grounds for automatic dismissal from further Testing. xa0xa0xa0Candidates shift in their seats, getting ready to bolt for the door, when Dr. Barnes's expression changes. There is sadness. And though I am prepared for his words, my breath still catches and my eyes mist with tears. "I am sorry to announce that Testing candidate Ryme Reynald took her own life last night.' xa0xa0xa0Some students gasp and cry out, but I notice more than one sly smile that says, One down . I try to remember the faces that go with those smiles just in case. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • The opening volume in the
  • New York Times
  • bestselling Testing trilogy. In Cia's dystopian society, it's an honor to be chosen for The Testing. But it’s not enough to pass the Test. Cia will have to survive it.
  • It’s graduation day for sixteen-year-old Malencia Vale, and the entire Five Lakes Colony (the former Great Lakes) is celebrating. All Cia can think about—hope for—is whether she’ll be chosen for The Testing, a United Commonwealth program that selects the best and brightest new graduates to become possible leaders of the slowly revitalizing post-war civilization.
  • When Cia is chosen, her father finally tells her about his own nightmarish half-memories of The Testing. Armed with his dire warnings (”Cia, trust no one”), she bravely heads off to Tosu City, far away from friends and family, perhaps forever. Danger, romance—and sheer terror—await.
  • The Testing
  • is a chilling and devious dystopian thriller that all fans of
  • The Hunger Games
  • will simply devour. Joelle Charbonneau writes with guts and nerve but also great compassion and heart. Highly recommended.”—Jonathan Maberry,
  • New York Times
  • bestselling author of
  • Rot & Ruin
  • and
  • Flesh & Bone
  • The Testing trilogy is:
  • The Testing
  • The Testing
  • Independent Study
  • Independent Study
  • Graduation Day
  • Graduation Day

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
60%
(3K)
★★★★
25%
(1.2K)
★★★
15%
(748)
★★
7%
(349)
-7%
(-350)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

An adventure that is NOT to be missed!!

I've had my eye on THE TESTING long before it was released. I even received an eARC from the publisher for review. I was just sooo excited to read this, but for some crazy reason, I didn't. I kept thinking how awesome this series sounds, and how much I love dystopians, but I kept putting it off. So finally, when I received my credits from audible audio, I said what the hell, it's finally time to give THE TESTING it's fair shot. And OMG, I found myself instantly drawn into this story. The narrator was amazing, and the mystery was alluring, and I was easily able to get into the vibes. I couldn't help but to pick this audiobook up every free chance I got.

THE PLOT...

Cia has always lived a fairly good life, better then most anyway. With a big family, all brothers, and two loving successful parents that any child would appreciate. She's been preparing for the opportunity to be chosen for The Testing. But when the time comes to graduate and become an official adult, Cia's world becomes a living nightmare.

Cia's dreams have finally come true, she's officially been chosen for The Testing!! And she can't be more thrilled. She's always hoped for the opportunity to show her government just how much she can contribute in making the Commonwealth a better place for their future. And now after all her hard work, it's finally paid off. Until The Testing actually starts and Cia finally sees The Testing for what it really is, a death trap in waiting!

Cia has no choice but to go through with The Testing, or risk treason against the United Commonwealth. And that right there could mean a death sentence in itself. But Cia's not giving up, she's smart, determined, and not easily manipulated. And besides, Cia has one thing that gives her an advantage, and just might keep her alive long enough to get through The Testing. She has her fathers words, his warnings, his own experiences through The Testing. But as The Testing gets deeper, and Cia finds herself getting closer to the finish line, her fathers words ring in her ears "Trust no one." But Cia finds herself drawn to her childhood friend Tomas, and feels for some reason, he can be trusted. But what about the other Testing Candidates? Can they be trusted? Who's real, and who isn't? Who is befriending her to betray her? And who is befriending her to ally with her?

As the plot thickens, and The Testing Candidates get further into The Testing, they will have to determine who is deadly, and who is just trying survive. Because before all is said and done, they will come face to face with death, but whether or not they survive is up to them. But Cia may find that there is more cutthroats then not, and if she has any chance of surviving, she will have to do as her father said "Trust no one!" But surly, she can trust Tomas, can't she?

THE TESTING was a great addition to the Dystopian genre, that is sure to please many readers. I'm looking forward to finishing this series and seeing what happens next in Cia and Tomas's adventure!

Overall, THE TESTING was a fast-paced, action-packed, thrill-ride, that is not to be missed! If you love action, adventure, corrupt governments, rebellions, and overall, a great dystopian novel, then THE TESTING is sure to please!!!

NOTE: I received an eARC from Houghton Mifflin Books for reviewing purposes. All opinions expressed are my own and are not influenced in any way!
52 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Fantastic new dystopian series!

I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

I went into this book eager and excited to learn more about this thing called "The Testing." Having Cia's father's last departing words in the summary piqued my interest, big time. Why can't you trust anyone?! What's so dark about being tested to further your education? When I got an ARC from the publisher (Thanks so much HMHKIDS!) I could not wait to dive into this world. I had to hold off for a couple of weeks due to scheduling but once I finally started reading, I couldn't set it down! School and life demanded my attention so unfortunately, I had to stop reading. But the next minute I was free, I was grabbing this book up again. Needless to say, THE TESTING doesn't disappoint!

I've seen a couple of reviewers claiming that THE TESTING is like the HUNGER GAMES. I don't necessarily agree with that statement. I'll explain why: In a post-apocalyptic world, after the deadly Seven Stages of World, Earth is left ravaged, broken, and hardly sustainable to life. A group of survivors came together, created the United Commonwealth, and started the revitalization of Earth. Fast forward a hundred years or so later, and enter Cia Vale. She lives in the Five Lakes Colony with her family and University graduate father. Without him, new species of plants would not have been developed and everyone would die. (Basically. I'm kind of stretching it a bit). When Cia is chosen for The Testing after graduation, her father is not very pleased. He's gone through it, before.

Cia and the 3 other members of her colony are the first chosen candidates from Five Lakes in years. The competition sees them as no threat. The Testing is a series of tests that not only test the candidates' intellect, but also their character, leadership, ability to work in group, and survive. *cue creepy music* Now, while I can see how some people drew parallels to the HUNGER GAMES, this book has its own flare, spice, and really, its own unique premise. THE TESTING is all about learning who you can and cannot trust, being able to decipher the Testing officials cryptic directions, outsmarting said directions and the other competition, and using the skills and knowledge that has been instilled in you since birth to come out of the Testing alive. This book is a smart book. After reading it and seeing just how brilliant Cia is and her ability to figure out what the Testing officials were actually looking for, I realized I'd probably fail the test. Hard. There are some devious candidates who are willingly to do almost anything to pass the tests. And while the candidates do have to go through a certain test that sees their ability to survive on the ravaged planet, those are the only two ways I would really compare it to The HUNGER GAMES.

I absolutely loved Cia. She's not some "I can take on the world without breaking a sweat" character that you see from a lot of dystopians. She is young. She is scared. She makes people think she is brave, even if she isn't exactly feeling that way at the time. She is cautious. She is willingly to make sacrifices if it means doing the right thing. She trusts a little too easily. She is real. I could not have imagined a better character for this story. I loved watching her grow but also seeing the vulnerable side that a real teenager would exhibit if they were thrown into the real world, so fast, with no idea what the next day might bring. I would be terrified to be sent away from home to take part in The Testing. You have no idea what it's going to be like. If my dad told me the things that Cia's father told her the night before she left, I wouldn't go...if you weren't forced to go, that is.

Tomas. Tomas. Tomas. I have such a hard time with, you! He seems like the perfect, swoon-worthy gentleman who acts like he's had a secret thing for Cia for quite some time. I loved how he wanted to form an alliance with Cia. But after what Cia's dad said, I never could fully trust him. After all the sweet and encouraging things he did to ease Cia's mind, I still had this little bug in my ear saying "don't get too attached!" I'm not going to tell you whether you should trust him or not. You need to read the book to find out! And really, you probably need to read the second book: INDEPENDENT STUDY to make your mind up.

And that brings me to my last point: the ending. I'm a sucker for a good ending. And Ms. Charbonneau, you're killing me with that ending! She ends the novel at such a pivotal point! I have to wait until January '14 to see what happens next?! It's not necessarily a cliff hanger but man, it ended at such a good part. I definitely said, out loud, "NO. You can't just end now!"

To sum everything up: I would definitely recommend this book to all dystopian/post-apocalyptic fans! While there may be some aspects that The HUNGER GAMES fans would enjoy, Joelle Charbonneau has created a unique world with a rigorous and daunting Testing regimen that I don't think I would even be able to pass. She uses syntax to her and the Testing officials advantage, challenging readers to see if they are paying as careful attention as is required for the candidates to move on to the next round. With a realistic and admirable main character, THE TESTING is sure to keep your attention until the very last sentence. But be careful of who you decide to trust!
39 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Boring And Unoriginal!

Seen at my blog, Scott Reads It!
I have absolutely zero self control when it comes to dystopian books. I just have this urge to read any dystopian book I can get my hands on and often I end up extremely disappointed. So many authors are trying to capitalize off the success of The Hunger Games and so their books turn out to be very mediocre. The Testing is essentially a wanna-be, it tries so hard to be the next Hunger Games yet it ultimately fails.

The Testing is about a test that will determine whether or not you can go to University. This sounds like an awesome idea but it turns out this extreme standardized test has already been done before and way better (ex: Legend). Next up we have a protagonist who is very one dimensional and suffers from lack of development. I was pretty apathetic and didn't care for Cia at all. Next up we have a love interest whose whole demeanor screamed "Peeta impostor" in my mind. Cia and Tomas's relationship was awfully similar to Katniss and Peeta's romance, there is even a moment that reminded me of the cave scene from The Hunger Games.

The problem with The Testing is that it's pretty tedious and at times it felt like a chore. It's not a good sign when all of your homework is done and you're avoiding the book you're reading. The first half of The Testing (or so) is literally dialogue and Cia taking written exams. The dialogue isn't even witty or entertaining, sometimes the reader wasn't even informed what actually was said. There were so many times in The Testing when instead of saying verbatim what the character said, Charbonneau just tells the reader what they were talking about. The dialogue that was in The Testing was pretty basic and was nothing special at all.

The relationships between the characters were extremely underdeveloped and I didn't care for any of the characters. I don't even remember any of the characters' names (except Cia) because they were so bland and unremarkable. I even had to look up what Cia's love interest was named which is very sad! I remember the characters from books that I read years and years ago, yet I couldn't remember the names of the characters from this book. Nothing stood out to me about these characters because they never really caught my attention.

The romance in this book is extremely awkward and badly done. Cia and Tomas's relationship is built on absolutely nothing and they have zero chemistry at all. The fact that they are from the same area and that they are both taking The Testing, doesn't mean that they have to fall in love with each other. I didn't even understand why Cia and Tomas even liked each other because there was no spark between them. I'm not sure why the author included a romance, my guess is to conform with the generic dystopian mold.

The Testing has some shoddy world-building and I had zero idea how The United Commonwealth was formed. The United Commonwealth was a total mystery to me and I feel like I knew nothing about it at all. To tell you the truth, if there was any world building I'm not sure I would have even cared because I was so bored with this book. I wanted to Charbonneau to make me care about the world she created but she never did.

The Testing isn't absolutely terrible, there a few good things about it. The ending of this book is actually executed surprisingly well and I loved the final action sequences. The author set up the sequel in an extremely interesting way but I don't really have any interest in reading the sequel. (I probably won't read it, but I'm not ruling out the possibility that I will read it). The only thing I didn't like about the ending was the extremely obvious setting up of a love triangle; does every book really need a love triangle? I'm getting sick and tired of all these love triangles because most of them are done so poorly.

I'm pretty confident that The Testing will become a popular book and will sell extremely well. The Testing already has received a starred from Publisher's Weekly and so many bloggers are obsessed with this book. I'm in the minority who didn't enjoy this book; maybe I have read way too many dystopian books. I feel like the dystopian genre can no longer surprise me because so many authors like Charbonneau are just recycling concepts that been done a thousand times over.

Bottom Line:
If you're looking to read a great dystopian book, The Testing is not for you.
23 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Nope. Not happening.

Even though it was abundantly clear from the cover of 'The Testing' that it was going to be a re-hash of 'The Hunger Games,' I was willing to give it a shot because the idea of a dystopia that seemed to revolve around education was intriguing to me. However, by fifty pages in, I'd thrown up my hands. Education had nothing to do with it. I had no idea why the world of the book was the way it was, and wasn't spurred by intrigue to find out. The main character, Cia, had done absolutely nothing. She'd gone to graduation. Spoken with a friend. Ridden her bike around. The plot was so devoid of energy and drama that I frankly couldn't care if on page 51 aliens had attacked; it was too late. Give this one a pass.
17 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The Testing passes the test

Definitely one of the best books I've read so far this year. The style is engaging and while the plot mimics that of the Hunger Games, I found that The Testing used the techniques from the Hunger Games to make a better book. Of all the dystopian books I've read, this is one of the better books. Cia is an admirable protagonist who rings true to life and the area she comes from. The twists at the end of the book left me hungering for more.

The problems: There are a few passages where I wanted to read the dialogue instead of a description of the dialogue. Also, the author lacks some world building in the beginning which fixes itself by the end. Because this is the first book in a series, I can only imagine that my other questions will be answered in the following volumes.

This is a great book for teens. I can't wait for the sequel!
14 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

There certainly is a lot of testing here.

The title is certainly descriptive. A big chunk of the book is all about test-taking. If this sounds compelling to you, then the first third of the book will be right up your alley. If not, you will likely find that it dragged, as I did. I could easily see some people electing to not finish this book, but I pushed on. Fortunately, the action picked up, but there were numerous other problems with the book that make it difficult to recommend.

We're told that much of the planet was destroyed in a global war, but I had to keep reminding myself that this is supposed to be a post-apocalyptic story, because it just didn't feel that way. Meager details of the war were relayed in the simplest way possible - via a couple of questions on the test that Cia must pass in order to be selected as a future leader. In fact, we are not given much more information on what brought the world to this point beyond the sentence in the synopsis above. A few American cities were bombed, we retaliated, and...the end. We're told the origin of the original bombs was unknown, which seems incredibly unrealistic. This is a huge omission in a book that touts itself as post-apocalyptic. If we don't understand what happened, how can we accept the dystopian society that formed as a result?

This brings us to the Testing itself. Maybe the future books in the series will pull a swticheroo and reveal an ulterior motive for the Testing, but while reading this one, I kept thinking: Is this extreme testing really the best way to suss out leaders? Isn't real world experience a better measure of success? If the people selected for Testing are so phenomenal, and the Commonwealth is so in need of leadership, what is the sense of putting these people through this Testing that may kill them? It all felt very contrived.

I have not yet mentioned the worst part of the story: the romance between Cia and Tomas. It was as believable as it was necessary to the story, which is to say...not very. These two childhood chums start spouting I love you's and making out as bullets and arrows fly past them on the Testing grounds, while Cia's "heart swells with love." Really? It might have been more believable if she and Tomas were in love before the Testing, but it probably would have been better if they were not in love at all.

Note - I received an ARC from the publisher with a request for an honest review.
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The Testing

The Testing takes place in a war torn and rather barren world, more specifically what was formerly known as the United States. The earth is contaminated and the people must strive for the very best to survive in such an unforgiven place. Charbonneau's writing style weaves a detailed picture of the not only the surroundings but also the background, where she takes the time to explain why things are so broken. Which is something that I personally appreciated because so many dystopians will mention the catalyst for change but will never truly give any details.

I feel it is necessary to go ahead and get this particular part out of the way because I'm sure most are wondering. Yes, there are similarities to The Hunger Games. However even with that in mind i feel it is worth being recognized as its own story. It's wonderfully written, the plot is one that held my attention and pulled me in, and the characters are worth investing in. I think if someone can put the similarities on the shelf they will find that it's quite unique and far more detailed in all aspects.

Malencia Vale, our narrator, is a bright and resourceful sixteen year old. She has high hopes for her future but she is tested beyond anything she could have imagined and it forces her to become more. I really enjoyed Cia and while it was heartbreaking at times I enjoyed seeing her grow as a person in response to everything she faces. She's strong and capable of seeing things others can't, but she is also a caring and trusting person. The side characters also get just treatment and are slowly fleshed out as Cia gets to know them better over the course of the Testing. I love the fact that we only get to know what she knows, it really drives the suspense up and had me on the edge of my seat at times. There are still a lot of things I want to know about some of them though and I really hope we get to find out the answers to a few nagging questions in book two.

The few issues I had all revolved around what is and is not realistic, or at least in my personal opinion. However given that the writing is wonderful and that the world building is actually pretty good, I was more than willing to set that aside and enjoy the story for what it is. This turned out to be a solid YA debut for Charbonneau and I can definitely see this being a strong series as well. Even though the release date is a long way away I'm definitely looking forward to Independent Study, book two, to see how things fare with Cia and the others.

I received the book in exchange for an honest review.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

intense and intriguing

This story is basically a cross between Hunger Games and Divergent, so, if you've read those, you'll know exactly what to expect. The pacing is quick, the tension keeps you engaged, and the writing is good. But it's not really any different from what else is already out there.

Cia is an okay character. She's a good person and likable, and I feel I got to know her well. She did change and grow as the story progressed, and she became more and more likeable toward the end. I like her ingenuity and desire to help others, but I didn't really feel her rage toward the end. Nor did I ever get a good sense of Tomas. Cia tells us that he's a good person and that he always looks to help others, but we don't get to see much of it. Granted, Cia and Tomas have a history before they were chosen for Testing, so this was probably done on purpose. But, to me, it still felt contrived.

Even knowing exactly what kind of book this was, and knowing how it was going to end, it still kept my interest. I was curious how it was going to end, and the action kept me reading. But there was one thing I could not get over: I did not buy into the basic premise, and that interfered with my enjoyment of the entire book. Which is a shame, because the writing is good and the action scenes are intense and thoroughly enjoyable. So, I'm not sure if I'm interested in reading the next book.

Some SPOILERS below:

To me, it seemed like the foundation is the story is that civilization is trying to rebuild and create habitable areas. Yet, the government rounds up their most promising minds and then throws them into situations where three quarters of them will be killed. If the governing body is established and civilization is on its feet, like in Hunger Games, *then* it makes more sense. But to kill your most promising when you're still researching and rebuilding and trying to feed your own people is way too short-sighted for any halfway decent leader. Even if the leader is corrupt and only looking for a particular mindset, he would not squander a skilled mind. Instead, he would use it, at the very least, for personal gain. I could not get over this, and it colored everything as slightly contrived for me.

END SPOILER

Age Appropriateness: Considering the sheer amount of violence in this book, I'd say this is appropriate for older teens.
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

suzanne collins renamed the hunger games to "The Testing"

I thought katniss was going to jump out with her bow and arrow at some point.

Total cop off Hunger games... try to be more original
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Completely Enthralling

This is one of those books that I completely enjoyed despite all evidence pointing to the contrary!

I've been on a huge Young Adult/Post Apocalyptic kick for over a year now and have not tired of the genre. I do however expect that each book I read will have something unique to offer, regardless of the fact that they all tend to follow the same formula. It's that unique "something" that allows each book to stand on it's own and be enjoyableand hopefully memorable.

It did not take me long to realize that The Testing was pure Hunger Games. The plot, the romance...there were so many parallels that honestly it felt at times like the same story only unfortunately...of a slightly subpar level.

I really had trouble finding any genuinely unique element or twist that would make this book stand out in the crowd. The characters were likeable but didn't wow me in any way. I found it hard to truly connect to any of them though I certainly empathized with them and rooted for them as the novel progressed.

That said, depite all odds, I was completely enthralled with this book. I could not put it down, I needed to know what would happen next, how it all would end...and I truly can not wait to get my hands on the next book in the series! Perhaps it is due to the authors incredibly engaging writing style? Perhaps due to the mood I was in when I picked this one up? I don't know. All I do know is that somehow a total Hunger Games copy still managed to completely engage me and make me want more.

Guess you'll each just have to judge this one for yourselves!

NOTE: Review Copy received from Publisher in exchange for an honest review
6 people found this helpful