Belknap Press: An Imprint of Harvard University Press
Publication Date
Reprint edition (October 15, 2011
ISBN-13
978-0674062313
Dimensions
5.25 x 2.25 x 8.5 inches
Weight
3 pounds
Description
“In his monumental study of the causes and the consequences of the Thirty Years War, Wilson challenges traditional interpretations of the war as primarily religious. He explores instead the political, social, economic as well as religious forces behind the conflict...Wilson then provides a meticulous account of the war, introducing some of its great personalities: the crafty General Wallenstein; the Swedish king Gustavus Adolphus, who preserved his state through canny political treaties and military operations; and Hapsburg archdukes Rudolf and Matthias, the brothers whose quarrels marked the future of Bohemia, Austria and Hungary. By the war's end, ravaged as all the states were by violence, disease and destruction, Europe was more stable, but with sovereign states rather than empires, and with a secular order. Wilson's scholarship and attention to both the details and the larger picture make his the definitive history of the Thirty Years War.” ― Publishers Weekly (starred review) “Among continental Europeans, the Thirty Years War is etched in memory...A definitive account has been needed, and now Peter Wilson, one of Britain's leading historians of Germany, has provided it. The Thirty Years War: Europe's Tragedy is a history of prodigious erudition that manages to corral the byzantine complexity of the Thirty Years War into a coherent narrative. It also offers a bracingly novel interpretation. Historians typically portray the Thirty Years War as the last and goriest of Europe's religious wars--a final bonfire of the zealots before the cooler age of enlightened statecraft. Mr. Wilson severely qualifies this conventional wisdom. It turns out that the quintessential war of religion was scarcely one at all...Wilson's masterful account of the Thirty Years War is a reminder that war, and peace, are almost never the offspring of conviction alone.” ― Jeffrey Collins , Wall Street Journal “Only in retrospect did the strife acquire coherence as the Thirty Years' War, and Wilson incisively cuts through its several phases to recount the objectives and options of the warring parties...Confidently argued, clearly written, Wilson's history is superb coverage of this pivotal period in European history.” ― Gilbert Taylor , Booklist “Peter Wilson's book is a major work, the first new history of the Thirty Years' War in a generation. It is a fascinating, brilliantly written attempt to explain a compelling series of events, which tore the heart out of Europe.” ― The Times “[It] succeeds brilliantly. It is huge both in its scene-setting and its unfolding narrative detail...It is to Wilson's credit that he can both offer the reader a detailed account of this terrible and complicated war and step back to give due summaries. His scholarship seems to me remarkable, his prose light and lovely, his judgments fair. This is a heavyweight book, no doubt. Sometimes, though, the very best of them have to be.” ― Paul Kennedy , Sunday Times “Wilson's monumental study captures both the complexities of the political and military transformations and the level of brutality that the endemic struggles unleashed...This will be the defining study of the Thirty Years War for the next generation.” ― P. G. Wallace , Choice Peter H. Wilson is the author of Heart of Europe: A History of the Holy Roman Empire , an Economist and Sunday Times Best Book, and The Thirty Years War: Europe’s Tragedy , winner of the Distinguished Book Award from the Society of Military History. He has appeared on BBC Radio and has written for Prospect , the Los Angeles Times , and the Financial Times . President of the Society for the History of War and a fellow of the Royal Historical Society, Wilson is Chichele Professor of the History of War at the University of Oxford. His work has been translated into Chinese, French, German, Italian, Japanese, Polish, and Spanish.
Features & Highlights
A deadly continental struggle, the Thirty Years War devastated seventeenth-century Europe, killing nearly a quarter of all Germans and laying waste to towns and countryside alike. Peter Wilson offers the first new history in a generation of a horrifying conflict that transformed the map of the modern world.When defiant Bohemians tossed the Habsburg emperor’s envoys from the castle windows in Prague in 1618, the Holy Roman Empire struck back with a vengeance. Bohemia was ravaged by mercenary troops in the first battle of a conflagration that would engulf Europe from Spain to Sweden. The sweeping narrative encompasses dramatic events and unforgettable individuals―the sack of Magdeburg; the Dutch revolt; the Swedish militant king Gustavus Adolphus; the imperial generals, opportunistic Wallenstein and pious Tilly; and crafty diplomat Cardinal Richelieu. In a major reassessment, Wilson argues that religion was not the catalyst, but one element in a lethal stew of political, social, and dynastic forces that fed the conflict.By war’s end a recognizably modern Europe had been created, but at what price? The Thirty Years War condemned the Germans to two centuries of internal division and international impotence and became a benchmark of brutality for centuries. As late as the 1960s, Germans placed it ahead of both world wars and the Black Death as their country’s greatest disaster.An understanding of the Thirty Years War is essential to comprehending modern European history. Wilson’s masterful book will stand as the definitive account of this epic conflict.
For a map of Central Europe in 1618, referenced on page XVI, please visit this book’s page on the Harvard University Press website.
Customer Reviews
Rating Breakdown
★★★★★
60%
(146)
★★★★
25%
(61)
★★★
15%
(37)
★★
7%
(17)
★
-7%
(-17)
Most Helpful Reviews
★★★★★
5.0
AHD7A6N664NLUOP2CO2P...
✓ Verified Purchase
Most complete one-volume history of the Thirty Years War in English.
This book is 851 pages long in the paperback edition. That said, it's well-written and not at all a difficult read. If you want a complete history of the Thirty Years War in English that moves with ease and facility between detailed, blow-by-blow accounts of battles (with great battlefield maps!) and larger macro developments across Europe, this is your best option. If you are new to the Thirty Years War and/or want a shorter, even more readable account, consider CV Wedgwood's classic narrative history The Thirty Years War. That book is about half the length of this one (and gives shorter shrift to the second half of the war).
30 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AEQTPVUP33QPMNQGFPPI...
✓ Verified Purchase
Too detailed for the general reader
Rating academic histories is always hard as it seems a little unfair to judge a book like Wilson's by what I think of it as literature. In the case of the Thirty Years War, there is no question that Wilson has done his research and assembled what will be considered THE stand out overview of the war for a long time to come. But as literature for the general reader it sadly fails.
Thoroughly covering the entire war, it feels like it takes 30 years to read. Small meaningless battle after small meaningless battle are described as are the interminable movements of the armies involved as well as their leaders. There is so much detail that the war itself gets lost. In this, it is not helped by the poor maps at least in this edition. There is one good map showing central Europe from France to Hungary and Denmark to Italy but this is not large enough or detailed enough to keep track of where the armies are operating. Other than this one map, all we are given are a couple of dozen very poor maps of the individual battles which in most cases don't provide enough info to even place the battle on the overview map. I simply lost track of who was fighting who, who led whose army, or where those armies were located.
For those REALLY interested in the Thirty Years War, this is probably an essential read. For everyone else, I recommend C.V. Edgewood's book despite it's being getting on a hundred years old.
28 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AFX5CWIE7U2CWZQBJDMT...
✓ Verified Purchase
A Major Accomplishment
This book is incredible. At 850 pages it is quite a slog, but it has 850 pages of (mostly) worthwhile information. It does have army-size counts (i.e. 30,000 men; 25,000 foot, 5,000 cavalry). And I found myself having to write in the margins on an ongoing basis which commander was on which side, just so I could keep track. A few of the additional sorts of information discovered were:
Food/fodder amounts per time period to keep armies in the field.
Trench-building methods for attacking fortresses.
Trees-per-ship numbers for a few different types of ships.
Polish-Cossack motivations.
How the Thirty Years War touched the Americas.
A chapter on “The Human and Material Cost”.
A chapter on “Experiencing War”.
As a contribution to the historical record, this book is an important accomplishment.
26 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AEFIZ7MGU54ZRHO2RLJR...
✓ Verified Purchase
You do not need a Masters in History to enjoy this book!!!
I am about 200 pages into this book and felt compelled to write a review after seeing how many reviews complain about there being too much information in the book and saying things like “don’t read if you aren’t an expert in European history. This is just untrue. Yes there is a lot of information in this book but if you are passionate or interested in history and have an attention span longer than a Tik Tok video you will be fine. And you do not need to be an expert in European history to enjoy this book. Are you going to have to look some things up occasionally? Yes. But if you’re not trying to learn something why are you reading non fiction in the first place? People complaining about this book are most likely people that do not read much and have trouble keeping track of a 1 hour episode of any show on television. If you take the time to read this book and while you’re reading it google a couple of words or events or people then you will love this book. It is an amazing book and a truly monumental work of scholarship. Anyone interested in History should read this book. That is all I have to say thank you for listening.
21 people found this helpful
★★★★★
1.0
AG2YPIMM2YVLOE7MCZY5...
✓ Verified Purchase
And that is not easy when the subject matter is so interesting
Ever since I discovered the C.V. Wedgwood book on the 30-Years War at a Buenos Aires flea market in the 1980s I have been fascinated by the 30-Years War. I was very excited when this book came out and rushed to purchase it. Alas, I found the book completely unreadable and, after 3-4 attempts to plow ahead, I have decided to give it to my local library.
The prose style is stultifying. And that is not easy when the subject matter is so interesting. You might as well read laundry list of the chronological events. No description of what life was like in those times or who the people who figure in the history were as people.
14 people found this helpful
★★★★★
4.0
AHJ3TKGTZH5O6CKNKHFA...
✓ Verified Purchase
Very (very) thorough
An extremely detailed history of the Thirty Years’ War. This book is not for people who are just curious about the war or would like a basic understanding of what it was about and who won. It gets down to a very granular level, describing troop movements and commanders’ decisions in depth. There is some attempt to discuss developments in military technology, economics, social history, and the role of disease in the war, but these topic are not the focus of the book. Although these limitations are real, they aren’t fatal. The Thirty Years’ War was very complicated, involving a lot of different parties with different motives. A detailed chronology is in many ways very helpful, and will be very interesting, to the right kind of reader.
13 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AFGZ2GDNRK4VI3KLFO23...
✓ Verified Purchase
One-third of a review...
…because I’ve only read one-third of the book. At my second attempt to read the book (I collapsed with exhaustion at my first attempt), I’ve progressed to p.300, and the action has just started (the first part of the book describes in vast detail the world that gave rise to the Thirty Years’ War). Professor Wilson is clearly a gentleman of outstanding knowledge and erudition. One marvels that one person can know sooooo much stuff. He also writes well.
However, the problem is that he tells it all. It has been said that the secret of being a bore is to tell everything, in detail. Prof. Wilson certainly isn’t a bore, but the sheer, unremitting deluge of facts, names, places, treaties, etc. is bewildering. Names pop up and one struggles to remember who they were and what they did (or didn’t) and on whose side of the argument they were. I found myself having to scurry back to the index and read about them all over again. Unless you are blessed with a vast memory, you really need to take notes. And then there are the times when something pops up with no previous occurrence. For example, on p.17, there is the Golden Bull. One (this one anyway) immediately thinks, "The, er, what?" No explanation. Not, apparently, Aaron’s golden calf that survived to adulthood, but some sort of agreement.
The problem is that, with so much detail, you find yourself trying to skim the thing without going anywhere near the depths that you feel will suck you under, never again to be seen. Which is a pity because this is indeed a worthy tome. It’s just too detailed for the ordinary everyday reader. I like history a lot, and was looking forward to this, the first comprehensive account in English, I believe, since C.V. Wedgwood’s pre-WW2 account. As. Prof. Wilson says, her views might well have been tainted by the darkening shadow of coming war on the Continent, but it was certainly a much easier read.
“The Thirty Years’ War was an extremely complex event” says Prof. Wilson in his introduction; whether this is a semi-conscious justification for what is to follow I cannot say. Perhaps, given the complexity of the subject and the desire not to end up with something the size of Britannica, the book has to be this way.Nevertheless, general readers, be warned; without considerable previous knowledge of 16-17th century Europe and/or prodigious memories, you will struggle. This book is a wee bit like eating your greens, full of good nourishment, but not necessarily particularly palatable.
13 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AFNCXIFXXIABV77JAANS...
✓ Verified Purchase
Perspective from a professional student of history
I have a Master's Degree in History, and I regularly read non-fiction books about history, politics, and religion. That said, I agree with what many reviewers have said about Peter Wilson's "The Thirty Years War": it is very well-researched and thorough, but somewhat lifeless and hard to get through. He does a good job of covering every aspect of this war, especially the background and build-up, but he doesn't "bring it alive" or provide a human touch. The narrative could be much better. Perhaps he was trying to avoid historically-dubious anecdotes, but I wish he had provided more stories along with a warning that their authenticity is in doubt. The history ends up becoming a list of names, dates, and locations, which (contrary to popular perception) is NOT what history is all about. Having said all of that, I did finish the book and even enjoyed it, though I would have enjoyed another book as much or more. This book is appropriate for intelligent readers with a strong interest in history or warfare, and not for the general reader. It is meant to inform, not entertain, and it does its job well.
11 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AEMOREGK5IAEC2QTYTYR...
✓ Verified Purchase
Very thorough
This book has over 1000 pages. Well, it describes a thirty years long war, so it has to cover a lot of ground. And the author does this in a very thorough and comprehensive matter - it takes 266 pages just to arrive at the start of the war. But after reading this, I understood the extremely complicated political, religious, and sociological landscape in Europe in this era, that ultimately led to this war, for the first time. That alone makes this book worth reading.
But it goes on, with deep analysis of the why, who, what, when involved in the war. It is not a compendium of battles - those are certainly part of the war, but are only described to illustrate the overarching spiderweb of strategy, politics and economics that fueled this war.
At times, the book is a bit dry, and I am missing a more detailed introduction of the main characters. But it is not a "Three Musketeers" style adventure novel, it is a serious popular-scientific work. I would not go as far as to say that after reading this book you will know everything about the Thirty Years War, all of the big and not so big secrets, not even most of the myriad of details involved. But you certainly will have a better understanding why things happened as they did, how politics, religion, business, and dynastic considerations perpetuated this war until Europe was on the brink of ruin and Germany was devastated and ravaged. It is a very comprehensive book, and you need some staying power for the over thousand pages. But you will be rewarded with a very good narrative and a very interesting viewpoint on this European tragedy.
11 people found this helpful
★★★★★
1.0
AHWKS5GSSUPKPJENK6LY...
✓ Verified Purchase
Definitely need some German history knowledge to understand this
I have my MA degree in teaching and I am relatively well-read in history. My family emigrated from the Alsace-Lorraine region of France/Germany in 1732. I wanted to examine the background forces that set the stage for the eventual unification of Germany, and the Thirty Years War seemed like a good jumping off spot to begin. This book is well-written, but the overwhelming amount of information required to understand this book seems to require a Master’s degree in European history. I usually will give up on a book only if it is very poorly written or edited, but I gave up on this after about 300 pages because I could not keep up with all the information presented. It doesn’t help that this book jumps around in time. Had facts been presented in a chronological manner, with perhaps some background information on the people, places and the various treaties (so MANY treaties!), then perhaps I could have hung in there. I will keep looking for a book that gives me some insight on why my distant Pfalzgraf ancestor sailed to Philadelphia in 1732. But this book simply is too detailed and jumps around in time too much for the casual armchair historian.