Water for Elephants: A Novel
Water for Elephants: A Novel book cover

Water for Elephants: A Novel

Paperback – April 9, 2007

Price
$8.39
Format
Paperback
Pages
352
Publisher
Algonquin Books of Chapel Hill
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-1565125605
Dimensions
5.5 x 0.75 x 8.25 inches
Weight
10.4 ounces

Description

"[An] arresting new novel. . . . At its finest, Water for Elephants resembles stealth hits like 'The Giant's House,' by Elizabeth McCracken, or 'The Lovely Bones,' by Alice Sebold, books that combine outrageously whimsical premises with crowd-pleasing romanticism. . . . Black-and-white photographs of real American circus scenes from the first half of the century are interspersed throughout the novel, and they brilliantly evoke the dignified power contained in the quieter moments of this unusual brotherhood. . . . With a showman's expert timing, [Gruen] saves a terrific revelation for the final pages, transforming a glimpse of Americana into an enchanting escapist fairy tale."— New York Times Book Review “Vibrant . . . gritty, sensual, and charged with dark secrets involving love, murder, and a majestic, mute heroine (Rosie the Elephant).”— Parade “Novelist Gruen unearths a lost world with her rich and surprising portrayal of life in a traveling circus in the '30s. An emotional tale that will please history buffs--and others.”— People “[This] sprightly tale has a ringmaster's crowd-pleasing pace.”— Entertainment Weekly “A compulsive page-turner . . . a fascinating setting and a richly anecdotal story that's enjoyable right up to the final, inevitable revelation.”— The Onion “A rich surprise, a delightful gem springing from a fascinating footnote to history that absolutely deserved to be mined.”— Denver Post “One of the many pleasures of this novel is the opportunity to enter a bizarrely coded and private world with its own laws, superstitions and vocabulary. . . . I couldn't bear to be torn away from it for a single minute.”— Chicago Tribune “You'll get lost in the tatty glamour of Gruen's meticulously researched world, from spangled equestrian pageantry and the sleazy side show to an ill-fated night at a Chicago speak-easy.”— Washington Post "Riveting." — The Toronto Globe and Mail “Life is good for Jacob Jankowski. He’s about to graduate from veterinary school and about to bed the girl of his dreams. Then his parents are killed in a car crash, leaving him in the middle of the Great Depression with no home, no family, and no career…This lushly romantic novel travels back in forth in time between Jacob’s present day in a nursing home and his adventures in the surprisingly harsh world of 1930s circuses…just like a circus, the magic of the story and the writing convinces you to suspend your disbelief.”— Booklist “Old-fashioned and endearing, this is an enjoyable, fast-paced story.”— Library Journal "Lovely and mesmerizing...genuine talent."— Kirkus Reviews A "page-turner...Gruen skillfully humanizes the midgets, drunks, rubes and freaks who populate her book."— Publishers Weekly “In this thrilling, romantic story set in a traveling circus in the 1930s, Sara Gruen has a Big Top’s worth of vivid characters and an exhilarating narrative that kept me up all night.xa0 From the perseverance of a terrier named Queenie, to the charm of Rosie the elephant, this masterpiece of storytelling is a book about what animals can teach people about love.” — Susan Cheever, author of My Name Is Bill "The circus, the Great Depression, a complex elephant, equally complex love, the mists and twists of memory articulated in the utterly winning voice of a very old man who's seen it all—these are the irresistible elements of Water for Elephants .xa0 Sara Gruen has written an utterly transporting novel richly full of the stuff of life." — Robert Olen Butler "So much more than a tale about a circus, Water for Elephants is a compelling journey not only under the big top, but into the protagonist's heart. Sara Gruen uses her talent as a writer to bring that world alive for the reader: I could smell it, taste it, feel every word of it. This is a fiction reader's dream come true." — Jeanne Ray, author of Julie and Romeo Get Lucky “Gorgeous, brilliant, and superbly plotted, Water for Elephants swept me into the world of the circus during the Depression and it did not let me go until the very end. I don’t think it has let me go even now. Sara Gruen has a voice to rival John Irving’s, and I am hopelessly, unabashedly in love with this book. Read it.” — Joshilyn Jackson, author of Gods in Alabama “An entirely original, captivating story of finding love in a down-at-the-heels traveling circus in the Great Depression. Sara Gruen writes with great tenderness and breathtaking drama which makes the novel impossible to put down.” — Stephanie Cowell, author of Marrying Mozart "Gritty, sensual and charged with dark secrets involving love,murder and a majestic,mute heroine (Rosie the Elephant)."—Parade Though he may not speak of them, the memories still dwell inside Jacob Jankowski's ninety-something-year-old mind. Memories of himself as a young man, tossed by fate onto a rickety train that was home to the Benzini Brothers Most Spectacular Show on Earth. Memories of a world filled with freaks and clowns, with wonder and pain and anger and passion; a world with its own narrow, irrational rules, its own way of life, and its own way of death. The world of the circus: to Jacob it was both salvation and a living hell. Jacob was there because his luck had run out-- orphaned and penniless, he had no direction until he landed on this locomotive " ship of fools." It was the early part of the Great Depression, and everyone in this third-rate circus was lucky to have any job at all. Marlena, the star of the equestrian act, was there because she fell in love with the wrong man, a handsome circus boss with a wide mean streak. And Rosie the elephant was there because she was the great gray hope, the new act that was going to be the salvation of the circus; the only problem was, Rosie didn't have an act-- in fact, she couldn't even follow instructions. The bond that grew among this unlikely trio was one of love and trust, and ultimately, it was their only hope for survival. Surprising, poignant, and funny, "Water for Elephants" is that rare novel with a story so engrossing, one is reluctant to put it down; with characters so engaging, they continue to live long after the last page has been turned; with a world built of wonder, a world so real, one starts to breathe its air. Sara Gruen is the #1 New York Times and USA Today bestselling author of At the Water’s Edge,Water for Elephants, Ape House, Riding Lessons, and Flying Changes. Her works have been translated into forty-three languages and have sold more than ten million copies worldwide. Water for Elephants was adapted into a major motion picture starring Reese Witherspoon, Rob Pattinson, and Christoph Waltz in 2011. She lives in western North Carolina with her husband and three sons, along with their dogs, cats, horses, birds, and the world’s fussiest goat. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Only three people were left under the red and white awning of the grease joint: Grady, me, and the fry cook. Grady and I sat at a battered wooden table, each facing a burger on a dented tin plate. The cook was behind the counter, scraping his griddle with the edge of a spatula. He had turned off the fryer some time ago, but the odor of grease lingered. The rest of the midway—so recently writhing with people—was empty but for a handful of employees and a small group of men waiting to be led to the cooch tent. They glanced nervously from side to side, with hats pulled low and hands thrust deep in their pockets. They wouldn’t be dis appointed: somewhere in the back Barbara and her ample charms awaited. The other townsfolk—rubes, as Uncle Al called them—had already made their way through the menagerie tent and into the big top, which pulsed with frenetic music. The band was whipping through its repertoire at the usual earsplitting volume. I knew the routine by heart—at this very moment, the tail end of the Grand Spectacle was exiting and Lottie, the aerialist, was ascending her rigging in the center ring. I stared at Grady, trying to process what he was saying. He glanced around and leaned in closer. “Besides,” he said, locking eyes with me, “it seems to me you’ve got a lot to lose right now.” He raised his eyebrows for emphasis. My heart skipped a beat. Thunderous applause exploded from the big top, and the band slid seamlessly into the Gounod waltz. I turned instinctively toward the menagerie because this was the cue for the elephant act. Marlena was either preparing to mount or was already sitting on Rosie’s head. “I’ve got to go,” I said. “Sit,” said Grady. “Eat. If you’re thinking of clearing out, it may be a while before you see food again.” That moment, the music screeched to a halt. There was an ungodly collision of brass, reed, and percussion—trombones and piccolos skidded into cacophony, a tuba farted, and the hollow clang of a cymbal wavered out of the big top, over our heads and into oblivion. Grady froze, crouched over his burger with his pinkies extended and lips spread wide. I looked from side to side. No one moved a muscle—all eyes were directed at the big top. A few wisps of hay swirled lazily across the hard dirt. “What is it? What’s going on?” I said. “Shh,” Grady hissed. The band started up again, playing “Stars and Stripes Forever.” “Oh Christ. Oh shit!” Grady tossed his food onto the table and leapt up, knocking over the bench. “What? What is it?” I yelled, because he was already running away from me. “The Disaster March!” he screamed over his shoulder. I jerked around to the fry cook, who was ripping off his apron. “What the hell’s he talking about?” “The Disaster March,” he said, wrestling the apron over his head. “Means something’s gone bad — real bad.” “Like what?” “ Could be anything—fire in the big top, stampede, whatever. Aw sweet Jesus. The poor rubes probably don’t even know it yet.” He ducked under the hinged door and took off. Chaos—candy butchers vaulting over counters, workmen staggering out from under tent flaps, roustabouts racing headlong across the lot. Anyone and everyone associated with the Benzini Brothers Most Spectacular Show on Earth barreled toward the big top. Diamond Joe passed me at the human equivalent of a full gallop. “ Jacob—it’s the menagerie,” he screamed. “The animals are loose. Go, go, go !” He didn’t need to tell me twice. Marlena was in that tent. A rumble coursed through me as I approached, and it scared the hell out of me because it was on a register lower than noise. The ground was vibrating. I staggered inside and met a wall of yak—a great expanse of curlyhaired chest and churning hooves, of flared red nostrils and spinning eyes. It galloped past so close I leapt backward on tiptoe, flush with the canvas to avoid being impaled on one of its crooked horns. A terrified hyena clung to its shoulders. The concession stand in the center of the tent had been flattened, and in its place was a roiling mass of spots and stripes—of haunches, heels, tails, and claws, all of it roaring, screeching, bellowing, or whinnying. A polar bear towered above it all, slashing blindly with skillet-sized paws. It made contact with a llama and knocked it flat—boom. The llama hit the ground, its neck and legs splayed like the five points of a star. Chimps screamed and chattered, swinging on ropes to stay above the cats. A wild-eyed zebra zigzagged too close to a crouching lion, who swiped, missed, and darted away, his belly close to the ground. My eyes swept the tent, desperate to find Marlena. Instead I saw a cat slide through the connection leading to the big top—it was a panther, and as its lithe black body disappeared into the canvas tunnel I braced myself. If the rubes didn’t know, they were about to find out. It took several seconds to come, but come it did—one prolonged shriek followed by another, and then another, and then the whole place exploded with the thunderous sound of bodies trying to shove past other bodies and off the stands. The band screeched to a halt for a second time, and this time stayed silent. I shut my eyes: Please God let them leave by the back end. Please God don’t let them try to come through here . I opened my eyes again and scanned the menagerie, frantic to find her. How hard can it be to find a girl and an elephant, for Christ’s sake? When I caught sight of her pink sequins, I nearly cried out in relief—maybe I did. I don’t remember. She was on the opposite side, standing against the sidewall, calm as a summer day. Her sequins flashed like liquid diamonds, a shimmering beacon between the multicolored hides. She saw me, too, and held my gaze for what seemed like forever. She was cool, languid. Smiling even. I started pushing my way toward her, but something about her expression stopped me cold. That son of a bitch was standing with his back to her, red-faced and bellowing, flapping his arms and swinging his silver-tipped cane. His high-topped silk hat lay on the straw beside him. She reached for something. A giraffe passed between us—its long neck bobbing gracefully even in panic—and when it was gone I saw that she’d picked up an iron stake. She held it loosely, resting its end on the hard dirt. She looked at me again, bemused. Then her gaze shifted to the back of his bare head. “Oh Jesus,” I said, suddenly understanding. I stumbled forward, screaming even though there was no hope of my voice reaching her. “Don’t do it! Don’t do it !” She lifted the stake high in the air and brought it down, splitting his head like a watermelon. His pate opened, his eyes grew wide, and his mouth froze into an O . He fell to his knees and then toppled forward into the straw. I was too stunned to move, even as a young orangutan flung its elastic arms around my legs. So long ago. So long. But still it haunts me. I don’t talk much about those days. Never did. I don’t know why—I worked on circuses for nearly seven years, and if that isn’t fodder for conversation, I don’t know what is. Actually I do know why: I never trusted myself. I was afraid I’d let it slip. I knew how important it was to keep her secret, and keep it I did — for the rest of her life, and then beyond. In seventy years, I’ve never told a blessed soul. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • Over 10,000,000 copies in print worldwide #1
  • New York Times
  • Bestseller A
  • Los Angeles Times
  • Bestseller A
  • Wall Street Journal
  • Bestseller A
  • Newsday
  • Favorite Book of 2006 A
  • USA Today
  • Bestseller A Major Motion Picture starring Reese Witherspoon, Robert Pattinson, and Christoph Waltz
  • Jacob Janowski’s luck had run out--orphaned and penniless, he had no direction until he landed on a rickety train that was home to the Benzini Brothers Most Spectacular Show on Earth. A veterinary student just shy of a degree, he was put in charge of caring for the circus menagerie. It was the Great Depression and for Jacob the circus was both his salvation and a living hell. There he met Marlena, the beautiful equestrian star married to August, the charismatic but brutal animal trainer. And he met Rosie, an untrainable elephant who was the great hope for this third-rate traveling show. The bond that grew among this group of misfits was one of love and trust, and ultimately, it was their only hope for survival.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
60%
(7K)
★★★★
25%
(2.9K)
★★★
15%
(1.8K)
★★
7%
(822)
-7%
(-822)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Lamer than a foundered horse...

This book was recommended by Amazon as I was buying another, it looked interesting from the cover, so I bought it. I actually was surprised to find that the main character was a vet from Cornell--since I am a vet from Cornell, it really spiked my interest. That was the high point of the read, a brief moment of pleasant expectation. The book is not awful or unreadable, it's just shallow and facile. An interview with the author explains that she became fascinated by old photos of the traveling circuses of the 1930, and wanted to write a book about them. The setting seems authentic and compelling. However, the characters are implausible and their interior lives are culturally anachronistic. No one in this book seems remotely believable for the period--hasn't she read any Steinbeck? The plot is like one of those traveling carny roller-coasters, where you hear each gear clunk loudly and laboriously into place. The movie is likely to be ten times better than the book, because you won't have time to consider how unlikely the story development is.

I think it is rather shoddy that Ms Gruen limited her careful research to only the subject that interested her--the circus. How hard would it have been to consult an equine vet and come up with a plausible scenario for the equine illness that brings the main character on board the train? How hard would it have been to learn the correct location to euthanize a horse with a gun? How hard would it have been to figure out that Ithaca was an end of the line station, and a through circus train would not be "passing by". Couldn't she have gotten her character on the road without having him lose the family home to "his Ivy League tuition"--even the most cursory research would have revealed that Cornell Vet College was and is a state institution, highly subsidized in every respect. Authenticity in all these details would not have detracted from the book.

Most of the criticism of the book I've seen on line has been focused on what is perceived by some as gritty detail and others as gratuitous cruelty to animals. I am a horse vet, and have devoted my life to horses. I have no problem with feeding horse meat to the big cats. But the total implausibility of having the inept assistant slaughter horses by slitting their throats is so ridiculous--the first poke with his dull knife, and even a horse drooping at death's door will be three fields away. The average adult horse has 50 liters of blood--can you imagine how long it takes to pour out 50 soda bottles? This is why people euthanize horses with bullets! Why oh why couldn't she make it believable--there was certainly no shortage of true cruelty to animals to chronicle?

I can only imagine that people love, love, love this book because it is easy to read (clear, straightforward writing, not challenging in the least) and puts 21st century TV movie sensibility into an interesting historical setting with a sappy happy ending.
534 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Well researched but lacking

I found this book interesting because of the research Ms. Gruen obviously did on train circuses and depression-era life. I also thought her passages detailing the life of Jake as an old man were the best written things in the book. Since Ms. Gruen is a woman who appears (from her author's photo) to be barely middle-aged, I have to assume that some research went into finding out about the lives of elderly men as well, because she writes these passages with a clear and utterly believable voice that truly resonates.

Unfortunately nothing else in the book resonates nearly as much, and there's a lot lacking here. The young version of Jake never takes off as a character, nor does his entirely manufactured love story with a circus bareback rider. We know from the moment he sees Marlena that she'll obviously be his love interest, but their relationship never actually develops before they're suddenly declaring love for one another and hitting the sack.

Ms. Gruen also fails in her execution of believable villains. Her two main villains are August, a brutal horse trainer who abuses or neglects all of the animals, and "Uncle Al", the cruel circus boss, but their villainy never really jumps off the page. For some reason, she chose to make her main antagonist (August) Jewish. I still don't understand the reasoning behind that, nor do I understand her choice to call him a paranoid schizophrenic as well. Oh and for good measure, he's also a wife beater. He's simply too many things rolled into one. Perhaps if she'd concentrated on one aspect of his brutality, she could have made him more believable. And unfortunately, since his religion really has nothing else to do with him as a character, it's hard not to simply label Ms. Gruen as anti-semitic. Perhaps if she'd actually used the "show, don't tell" philosophy and let us SEE what Uncle Al was doing instead of just hearing about everything second hand from other characters, he wouldn't have seemed so two-dimensional. As it is, I never bought these guys as the towering pillars of pure evil they were obviously supposed to be.

I also never bought Jake, at least not as a young man. One minute he's making a vow to himself that he'll stay with the animals so they won't be hurt, because that's what his dead father would want him to do. Yet, he stands by not once but TWICE and allows August to savagely beat an elephant with a hook. It's hard to respect a character like that. Jake rarely takes any real action; he mostly just stands by while things happen TO him or happen *around* him.

I also felt the book could have benefited from a diagram. In books that take place on ships, there's usually a sketch in the front of the book with all the parts labeled for readers to refer back to so they can understand the action. I had a lot of trouble visualizing the train where a good 40% of the crucial action takes place in this book, and that was a major barrier to getting into the story. Had there been a sketch of it up front with all the sections labeled, those sections of the story would have been much easier to understand.

Overall, I am giving this book three stars because of the research, the informative author's note at the end, and the sections with Jake as an old man. I also really got a kick out of the ending. But on the whole, I would recommend this as a library book or a used book store book -- definitely NOT one you pay full price for.
233 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Circus Cornball

I guess I'm in the minority, but I really hated this book. The story was impossibly contrived, the dialog cliched and amateurish, the characters shallow and cartoonish. Even the animals were mired in hackneyed anthropomorphism, like something out of a bad Disney 70's era TV show:

"Come on Bobo," says Pete, reaching for the chimp.
The chimp's hairy arms and legs tighten around me.
"Come on now," I say, trying to pluck his arms free. "I'll come back."
Bobo moves not a muscle.
"Come on now," I say.
Nothing.
"All right. One last hug and that's it," I say, pressing my face against his dark fur.
The chimp flashes a toothy smile and kisses me on the cheek. Then he climbs down, slips his hand inside Pete's, and ambles off on bowed legs.

Cute.

Meanwhile, Jacob falls madly in love with the married Marlena, who fights off his advances with protestations like this:

"I just can't. I'm married. I made my bed, and now I have to lie in it."

She makes no mention of cookies being crumbled or the way in which a ball bounces.

Marlena's husband, August, is a psychotic who is mean to animals (Booo!), violent, and equipped with a Snidely Whiplash mustache, so obviously he and Jacob are destined for a big showdown, which amazingly is pulled off by the author without having Marlena tied to a railroad track or menaced by an evil landlord who demands the rent.

"Levity" comes from the bumbling Uncle Al, who explains that August's behavior is due to him being a "paragon schizophrenic," a joke so bad and unconvincing that even a hug from the monkey can't save it.

The book meanders along towards its ridiculous conclusion, with little really happening or lessons learned.

The final result is probably best described as the extremely fictitous and fabricated ramblings of an old geezer who misses the circus.

Me, I would have preferred an ending that was more in line with the rest of the book. I picture Rosie, the smiling elephant, soaking everyone with a big blast of water, causing characters like Blackie, Diamond Jim, Peg-Legged Pete, Yosemite Sam, (etc.) to look down at their wet clothes and then break into sustained, hysterical laughter.
229 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Basically a Question of Taste

On the simplest level, all I can say is that it didn't amuse me and I couldn't force myself to finish it. But I'm a "hard sell" for fiction, and I can see by the other reviews that many people loved it. Lucky them!
On a slightly more analytic level, I'd say that what prevented me from enjoying the book was the "voice" of the narrator, who is supposed to be a man in his nineties remembering his youth in the circus. I'm a man approaching seventy, with some circus experiences as a teenager in Iowa and as the father of a circus acrobat in the Cirque de Soleil era. I found the "voice" of the narrator unconvincing, extremely unconvincing, as a male of the species and as a male American of the 1930s and 1940s. I couldn't get past that central implausibility. I found myself scoffing at the sensibilities of the pseudo-male narrator at every emotional turn of this quite melodramatic novel.
199 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Disappointing

As a devoted historical fiction reader, I thought this book would interest me. It did not. Water for Elephants reads like a children's novel, save for excessive and serious profanity, graphic and frequent sex scenes, and violence so vivid I was moved to nausea. If you are able to ignore those sorts of things, you will not find yourself feeling any kind of sympathy for the one-dimensional characters. The characters do not develop over the course of the story, and seem only concerned with dabbling in vice. As a result, I was unable to identify with them.

A portion of the story is written from the point of view of the main character in his old age. This writing is exceptional, and managed to keep me interested during the course of the book. Still, these marvelous little glimpses of author Sara Gruen's potential do not permit me to recommend this book to anybody. Avoid it.
156 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Please tell me why this is a best-seller?

This was a frustrating, truly awful book. While it started off interesting (a boy's parents dies and leave him nothing, and he gets caught up with a circus), it quickly became transparent and painful. He "falls in love" with a girl he hardly speaks to, who is married. He reacts when he should hold back and holds back when he should act. And there are far too many random, explicit, and unnecessary sex scenes. Perhaps if the author spent less time on graphic sex and more time on character development, this book would have been more tolerable. And the ending, which I was hoping would earn the book some redemption, was terribly disappointing and infuriating.

My faith in the NY Times bestseller list has been ruined.
116 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I Want My 4 Hours Back...

Well, I did finish it...for our next book discussion group, though I'm not sure what we'll be discussing. My biggest beef with this book is the quality of writing, and I always wonder how books like this make the best seller's list. I found the dialogue was not only thin, but so obviously written by a woman that it was impossible to believe in the male narration. It would also have been more believable if the author had vaguely attempted to match the dialogue to the era in which the story took place (did they really say f**k that much back then?) The copy I had was from our local library, and on one page the statement "...Whatever", as in 'big deal', had been circled in pencil with the comment (in an old person's handwriting) "not from the '30's"--that rather summed it up. I got tired of the cheesy descriptions of sex and violence -- believe me, the human imagination is very capable, and less is more in these areas in the hands of a capable writer. Particularly in the case of masturbating dwarves...The characters could have been more richly drawn, the plot less predictable, considering the setting.

I admit that I'm reading this on the heels of the marvelously written 'The Road', by Cormac McCarthy--the comparison is glaring.
106 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

It's a mystery to me.

If I live to be a thousand years old, I will never understand the hoopla surrounding this novel. It was praised for its meticulous research, but while reading it I found myself thinking that it had been written by somebody who had never been to a circus, and I was unsurprised to find out that I was correct. My first college roommate was a real circus girl, and I can tell you that Sara Gruen did not even scratch the surface of circus life.

It's a rare writer who can write well in the voice of the gender they are not, and Sara Gruen is not eligible for that club. If I had not known for sure that a woman had written it, it wouldn't have been a difficult guess.

The story is so melodramatic, it belongs among the most florid of historical romantic fiction, and that is not my cup of tea. I had to force myself to complete this book. I wish I hadn't.
101 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I'm definitely with the minority on this one..........

This book surprised me in the fact that I could not muster up the endurance to finish it -- got to chapter 14 and told myself to not waste any of my precious free time anymore. This was my book club's choice and even though it wouldn't have been my choice, I often read books that I wouldn't have chosen and loved them. Not so with this one -- I kept wondering when the story was going to catch me --it never did. The main character's voice never rang true for me. Overall boring storyline --Young man joins circus, is surrounded by sleaziness of traveling cirus which ultimately shapes the old crotchety man he becomes.....yawn, yawn, yawn...you'll either love this one or hate this one. Seems there is no in-between!
73 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Beautifully written but but BE CAREFUL if you are squeamish about animal/human abuse...

I avoided this novel for a long time because I have never been a fan of the circus (especially because of documented animal abuse and its exploitation of human oddities for amusement and profit.) However, I adore period novels that truly immerse you in another era and I decided to try the book and abandon it if it became too unsettling.

Unfortunately, it did.

Water for Elephants is beautifully written and the author is remarkably gifted at transporting you back in time. She has an inexhaustible imagination and jam packs her story with dozens of quirky and compelling characters who spring off the page with the agility of acrobats. This is not a soporific tale. In addition to all the eccentric characters bounding around the plot of Water For Elephants is as big and blinding as a massive disco ball and about every other chapter bursts like a pinata. Something is always happening: someone is being punched in the nose or high pitched shrieks are coming from the big tent or a mustached villain is hurling insults at some hapless circus employee. This novel is brash and brazen and graphic and I didn't have a problem with most of it. I enjoyed the frenetic pace and the sparkly madness of it all and the tale itself is truly original and engrossing.

My problem with this novel is that it does involve animals that are confined and mistreated and it also discusses the custom of displaying humans with physical deformities as sideshow 'freaks'. I am well aware this could not be avoided considering the subject matter and I'm certain the author wanted to paint a vivid and historically accurate portrait of the circus in the early 20th century. However, she does her job a bit too thouroughly and there were times I had to skip or skim entire paragraphs. I simply couldn't tolerate the highly lurid descriptions of horses throats being sliced open, lit cigarettes being tossed into the beguiling elephant's mouth. or desperate people being gawked at because they were obese or sprouting a parasitic twin from their chest.

That being said, Sara Gruen is an amazingly talented writer and after reading her bio and learning about her small menagerie at home and her penchant for saving orphaned cats I am certain she did not write this book to rejoice in the mistreatment of animals. She also sounds like a kind and compassionate person who definitely wouldn't be eager to view 'freaks' at a circus sideshow. Water For Elephants is a fascinating and dazzling tale but if it makes you uncomfortable to read about animal or human abuse I would probably avoid it.
68 people found this helpful