Winter Rose
Winter Rose book cover

Winter Rose

Hardcover – July 1, 1996

Price
$17.98
Format
Hardcover
Pages
262
Publisher
Ace Hardcover
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0441003341
Dimensions
7 x 1 x 5 inches
Weight
11.2 ounces

Description

From Publishers Weekly Woods-wise and free-spirited, Rois Melior is the opposite of her sensible sister, Laurel. But both Rois, who narrates, and Laurel fall under the spell of the stranger who enters their world. Decades ago, according to village gossip, Tearle Lynn murdered his father and mysteriously disappeared. Now Tearle's son, Corbet, has come home to rebuild crumbling Lynn Hall. Despite her attraction to Corbet, Rois is warned by her otherworldly senses that he is not what he seems. As Laurel falls hard for Corbet, Rois searches for the truth about the Lynns, but the answers she finds lead only to more questions. When Corbet disappears, Laurel begins to sicken and fade. To save her sister as well as Corbet, Rois will have to come to terms with the secret of her own changeling identity. The pace here is deliberate and sure, with no false steps; the writing is richly textured and evocative. McKillip (The Book of Atrix Wolf, and winner in 1975 of a World Fantasy Award for her novel The Forgotten Beasts of Eld) weaves a dense web of desire and longing, human love and inhuman need. Copyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc. From Library Journal Wild and free-spirited Rois Melior finds Corbett Lynn rebuilding his grandfather's house in the woods. Soon her engaged sister, the practical and domestic Laurel, has fallen for Corbett. When Corbett disappears, Rois travels during sleep between the woods and another shadow world to find him. McKillip's (The Book of Atrix Wolfe, Ace, 1995) lyrical imagery infuses this coming-of-age story with intrigue in a world of nature. Highly recommended for fantasy collections.Copyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc. From Booklist The latest from this distinguished writer is a curiously intimate fantasy about two sisters, one a homebody and the other free spirited, and a young man afflicted with an ancestral curse and a haunted estate. He touches the lives of both sisters, and they follow him into a world of love and dreams--or are they nightmares? And if they are nightmares, is there a road back? The story is well crafted and intriguing, McKillip's prose is as good as ever, and her evocation of both the familiar and the mysterious is nothing less than masterly. Winter Rose may well be praised by the more pretentious aficionados of literary fantasy so extravagantly that mere lovers of well-told tales will be turned off. They mustn't make that mistake and miss an excellent book. Roland Green From Kirkus Reviews Characteristically fresh, dainty fantasy from the author of The Book of Atrix Wolfe (1995), etc. Far-seeing, fey, independent Rois Melior spends much of the summer barefoot, roaming the woods about ruined Lynn Hall--until the estate's owner, Corbet, returns to claim his birthright. But supposedly the place is cursed, Corbet's father having murdered his grandfather there. Soon Rois glimpses an otherworld of perpetual summer, where Corbet seems to have spent most of his life--but Corbet's gaze falls upon Laurel, Rois's beautiful elder sister. Vastly curious about Corbet, his family, and the otherworld, Rois lingers at the Hall as winter deepens. Eventually she's drawn into the otherworld, where she meets Corbet, his father, and the world's incomprehensible ruling goddess; later she wakes in the Hall, half-frozen, beside the youthful corpse of Corbet's father, knowing that the goddess has forbidden Corbet to return. Laurel begins to pine away, much as Rois's mother did years before. But Rois realizes that the goddess has given her the means to win Corbet's freedom and save Laurel's life--if she has the courage and the will to hold fast to her need. Tingling and affecting work; a vast shame, then, that--like previous McKillip offerings--the plot's too frail and underdeveloped to do justice to the delightful, delicate filigree of her prose. -- Copyright ©1996, Kirkus Associates, LP. All rights reserved. Patricia A. McKillip is a winner of the World Fantasy Award, and the author of many fantasy novels, including The Riddlemaster of Hed trilogy, Stepping from the Shadows , and The Cygnet and the Firebird . She lives in Oregon. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • Two sisters, one delicate and sensible, one rough-hewn and sensual, fall in love with an aristocrat who returns to claim his family's abandoned estate, only to fall victim to the curse of his legendary grandfather.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(75)
★★★★
25%
(63)
★★★
15%
(38)
★★
7%
(18)
23%
(57)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

confusing and lacking info

I thought that Winter Rose was just a piece of confusing mumbo jumbo. It's hard to recognize whether Rois is dreaming or in reality because sometimes the author doesn't state the fact that Rois is conscious or not. There are other reasons that made the plot hard to follow. The characters didn't give enough information on this "other world" that Corbet came from. How did it form? Is Nial, Corbet, and the "witch" the only inhabitants? Also, the ending leaves too much questions. Does Corbet still love Laurel? What does Rois feel? How did Corbet escape from the other world? Finally, the narrator, Rois, was too mysterious. The point of view should have been in third person, not the wild wood-child. Some of the discriptions by Rois was skimpy and perplexing.
Though I love fantasy (and this book is definitely fantasy), Winter Rose was just too weird and puzzling for me to really like and understand the book.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Beautiful book that sounds like music

It is hard to describe a Patricia McKilip book: her prose has carefully chosen groups of words that are lyrical and evoke such beautiful images. I bought this book when it first appeared in paperback, and since then I have been searching for the half sized hardback copy. Finally found one here at Amazon and I was lucky to receive a very nice copy.
The story will grab you from the first page and will keep you to the end, wanting more. It is well worth the price you can afford.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

McKillip's Take on the Modern Fairy Tale is a Winner

Rois is a child of the wood, she loves to be free to roam the woods to find the herbs, plants and flowers for healing and pleasure. In her travels in the woods, she happens upon a doorway of sorts and out of that doorway walks Corbet Lynn, the cursed grandson, back to rebuild Lynn Hall.
Rois becomes obsessed with the curses remembered by the elder townsfolk, curses supposedly called down upon Corbet's father as he stood over the father he has just murdered.
Rois is a great heroine in a genre that oftentimes writes women as helpless or as accessories to the main male character. McKillip often writes characters who are able to see things that most other people can't see, despite however obvious those things are. This book is achingly sad at times and like a well written fairy tale, the ending is not what you expect it to be. McKillip has a way of taking what would be really sappy and trite if it were done in another book or by another author and owning it in such a way that the emotion resonates with the reader.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A dreamy tale

I just recently finished this book for the second time. The first, I didn't really grasp it. This time around, however, I did. It's a dreamy tale about the wild, wood-loving Rois, the cursed Corbet Lynn, and Rois's sensible sister, Laurel. Ms. McKillip weaves a tale of unspoken love and a disasterous curse the villagers think will come true. When Corbet Lynn returns to his family home to rebuild, he brings with him mystery. Rois is the only one who can see him for who he truly is. I think what bothered me most about the book was that the author did not tie up the loose end about Rois's mother. I really wanted to know who/what she was/is. However, I loved the end when Corbet asks Rois to look at the rose vines intertwined with ivy.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Get lost in this dream

OK, I admit it, I'll read anything based on "Tam Lin". There are at least four novels I know of that are based on that old story, and each has its good points. Pope's _The Perilous Gard_ is the best-plotted; Wynne-Jones's _Fire and Hemlock_ has the most sympathetic characters; Dean's _Tam Lin_ is the funniest. And this one, McKillip's _Winter Rose_, does the most amazing job of making the faery world real.
In this beautifully poetic novel, wild Rois and her quiet sister Laurel both fall in love with a newcomer to town, Corbet Lynn, heir to a ruined castle, his grandfather's curse, and lots of unanswered questions. He longs for the stability he believes Laurel can give him, but at the same time he knows that only Rois will be able to solve the mystery of his past and help him find his future. When Corbet vanishes in the dead of winter, and Laurel pines away for him, Rois journeys deep into the wood, and deep into a gorgeous but frightening dream world, to find out how she can save her sister and her friend. McKillip's prose is magical and poetic, and we are left wondering what is dream and what is real, even as we shut the back cover. Haunting and beautiful.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Solid Fantasy

This was the first novel that I've read by Patricia McKillip. I will certainly be returning to her. Winter Rose is a thrilling and complex fantasy told in an amazingly original and fresh style. The story of Rois fighting her way through a frozen world she doesn't really understand is captivating. The complex relationships between the well developed characters are fascinating. I most enjoyed McKillip's poetic prose style. Winter Rose is a quick, thought provoking, and satisfying read, and I do hope McKillip's other works are as good.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

#byelaurel

I like this author, but this book dragged on forever with very frustrating and unrelateable characters. #byelaurel
✓ Verified Purchase

A Hauntingly Romantic Story

A moving and magic story of a romance with the unseen world during the winter nights. Patricia A. Mckillip at her best.
✓ Verified Purchase

Awesome, thrilling, and filling

I think Patricia's books are wonderful.With their deep charm, and great emontions, they're fit for anyone who decides they like reading great books.You may know me, if you went to check out THE BOOK OF ATRIX WOLFE, another one of Patricia's awesome books, because I wrote a review to that too.But WINTER ROSE is defintely a winner! Patricia Mckillip is a great author, and anyone who finds reading not as a chore, but as an adventure into new lands should read one of her books.I just wish some of her books would stay in print for a while so I have a chance to pick one up.