Bold Spirit: Helga Estby's Forgotten Walk Across Victorian America
Bold Spirit: Helga Estby's Forgotten Walk Across Victorian America book cover

Bold Spirit: Helga Estby's Forgotten Walk Across Victorian America

Paperback – January 11, 2005

Price
$13.81
Format
Paperback
Pages
307
Publisher
Anchor
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-1400079933
Dimensions
5.21 x 0.74 x 7.98 inches
Weight
9.6 ounces

Description

“Surprising, inspiring. . . . Hunt skillfully brings this story alive.” — The Seattle Times "Allows us to follow Helga Estby not only across the physical landscape of 1896 America . . . but across the country's social, political, economic, and cultural landscape as well. . . . Fascinating." --Linda Peavy and Ursula Smith, authors of Pioneer Women: The Lives of Women on the Frontier “A heroic ‘forgotten first’ . . . a new women’s history classic has emerged.” — Foreword Magazine “A thoughtful discussion of the social and psychological factors that often silence family stories. . . . Fortunately [Hunt] has broken the silence of Helga’s story to embolden the spirits of future generations.” -- Bloomsbury Review Linda Lawrence Hunt , an associate professor of English at Whitworth College in Spokane, Washington, now directs the Krista Foundation for Global Citizenship with her husband, Jim. An engaging speaker and freelance writer, she has published articles in regional and national publications, and has traveled throughout America and Norway. Hunt is the author of Bold Spirit, Pilgrimage through Loss, In the Long Run , and many more. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Chapter OneOn Foot to New York Helga Estby, a thirty-six-year-old Norwegian immigrant, woke early on a mid-June morning in 1896 and slipped on her full-length gray Victorian skirt, simple wool jacket, and new leather shoes. She was eager to leave Boise, Idaho, before 6 a.m. to avoid walking during the scorching midday sun in southern Idaho, a hazard she had failed to consider earlier. Her daughter Clara, an artistic, intelligent, and pretty eighteen year old, helped fill their small satchels with emergency necessities: a Smith-and-Wesson revolver and a red-pepper spray gun to thwart dangerous highwaymen or wild animals, a compass and map, a few medical supplies, a lantern for night walking, photographs of themselves to sell, and a curling iron for Clara's soft hair.Even when carrying a little food, their bundles weighed less than eight pounds. Wanting to travel light, neither brought a change of clothes, but Helga packed a notebook and pen to record their experiences, and Clara brought materials for sketching. Perhaps more important, they carried a document from Mayor Belt of their hometown of Spokane, Washington, that introduced Helga as "a lady of good character and reputation" and commending her and her daughter to "the kindly consideration of all persons with whom they may have contact." As vital as a calling card to open doors, this introduction was especially useful with people in politics and the media.They left Boise grateful for the kind considerations shown to them in Idaho's new capital city. The Idaho Daily Statesman had alerted readers of the mother and daughter's arrival and of their brave quest across America. Unlike a small Washington town whose residents refused to let them buy food or find shelter because people suspected the women were "undeserving vagrants," Boise residents showed respect for their "positive spirits and physical energy." They offered the women opportunities to clean and cook and bought their photographs to restore their depleted funds.For thirty days, the unaccompanied women had successfully traversed by foot more than 450 miles during the wettest spring in thirty-three years. Having left Spokane on May 5, they followed the rail route south through Washington and Oregon, then trudged east through the spring snows and thaws over the Blue Mountain range, and on through the swollen river waters threatening the Boise valley. There had been only three days without rain since they started, and they arrived in Boise on June 5 with the city in alarm as the raging Boise River reached flood stage. Their journey astonished people, especially that "the women did not seem discouraged."In truth, it was deep discouragement and near despair that set Helga on this dangerous path to solve her family's desperate financial plight. Since the devastating economic depression of 1893, and her husband's accidents, they simply could not pay the mortgage or taxes on their home and farmland near Spokane. Foreclosure loomed during the spring of 1896, sending Helga into a state of fear compounded by sorrow as she also grieved the loss of her beloved twelve-year-old son, Henry, who had died in January.When she learned of a $10,000 wager offered by "eastern parties" connected to the fashion industry to a woman who would walk across America, Helga decided to try. She could not bear seeing her eight remaining children become homeless and thrown into destitution. She explained to her family and friends, who considered her decision outrageous, that she simply had "to make a stake some way," for she did not want to lose the farm. This was the only way she could see to save it. Most of her neighbors in the Norwegian enclave of farms in Mica Creek considered her choice both impossible and immoral, "not something women do."The sponsors wanted to prove the physical en-durance of women, at a time when many still considered it fashionable to be dependent and weak. Helga accepted certain stipulations within the contract, even agreeing to wear the "reform costume," a bicycle skirt that sponsors wanted her to advertise once she got to Salt Lake City. She and Clara were allowed to leave with only $5 a piece and then had to earn their way across; were to visit the state capitals in the west; and were to get the signatures of important political persons along the way. When she visited Idaho's Governor William J. McConnell at the State House, a friend of Mayor Belt's, his expression of interest in their walk and his personal note on their introductory document increased her awareness of the importance of their attempt.As she left Boise with her resolve fortified, and their supplies replenished, Helga began to worry about meeting another stipulation of the contract: The deadline for their walk required they be in New York City within seven months. The rains slowed their earlier days, and it took several days of working in Boise to earn enough money to continue. They needed to arrive in early December, but the sponsors did allow additional days if they became ill. Because getting lost in America's vast continent in the west was one of the dangers, Helga and Clara had planned to follow the railway routes, including the Union Pacific to Denver.Although enduring drenching rains and wading through hip-deep flood waters in Idaho failed to sap Helga's spirits, it did make her receptive to advice on short cuts. Outside of Shoshone they apparently decided to leave the rails, probably hoping to find a shortcut route that had been used by pioneers seeking a faster way from Pocatello to Boise during the Oregon Trail and gold rush days. For three days Helga and Clara wandered "without a mouthful to eat," eventually becoming lost in the Snake River lava beds of southern Idaho, a treacherous maze of cracked lava, crevices, and sagebrush. Jagged rocks tore up their thin leather shoes and temperatures in the mid-eighties smothered them in their long Victorian dresses. Even more troubling, the fear of rattlesnakes hovered around every step in this barren moonscape land.During these days of gnawing hunger, intense heat, and disorientation, when all the vocal criticism of the folly of their venture looked frighteningly true, Helga may have faced her own fears over the real and present dangers of this odyssey. Her Scandinavian neighbors saw her as a "determined" woman who achieves what "she makes up her mind" to do, and Helga's actions often reflected her inner confidence and quiet faith. She had struggled earlier with anxieties, especially during pivotal challenges, such as the time of a debilitating accident or during prairie fires and tornadoes on the Minnesota prairie. Her belief since childhood in the power of God undoubtedly led her to pray for Divine help as she and Clara grew weaker, seemingly helpless in their own ability to decipher how to get out of this strange land.But the stark danger of their present situation could have caused her to wonder if she naively underestimated the risks she placed Clara and herself in, and too blithely dismissed the fears of those who counseled her to stay home with her husband, Ole, and their children. This life-threatening detour was a mistake so costly that Clara and she risked leaving their bleached bones on the lava beds as the sole surviving remnant of their courageous venture. Helga knew, because they no longer were near the rails, that if they died her husband and children might never know what happened to them, a fear she had not considered with all the other warnings. As the moon rose over the eerie land on their third night lost among the lava rocks, Helga pondered and prayed. Her hope and faith intermingled with alarm at a seemingly impossible situation that her resourcefulness might not be able to solve. Chapter TwoMotherhood on a Minnesota Prairie Helga's walk across America was not her first major journey undertaken to create a better life. At eleven years old, Helga traveled from Norway with her mother, Karen, on the ship Oder and arrived in Manistee, Michigan, on August 12, 1871. Her stepfather had gone ahead to America to start life anew and had settled in this lake town, a thriving economic center for the Scandinavians working nearby in the twenty-four lumber mills. Although a devastating fire destroyed the prosperous town that same year, by 1873 two hundred new buildings reflected the expectation and determination of the optimistic population. Helga attended schools in America for enough time to become proficient in written and oral English, and she loved her new country. A bright child, she found great pleasure in reading. As an only child, she enjoyed how her bilingual ability helped her Norwegian mother and father negotiate in their new land.During the 1870s, with a growing population of nearly 10,000 residents, Manistee was embroiled in raging debates over the "woman question" and a women's suffrage referendum on the 1874 ballot. Given the controversial nature of this topic, as a young girl Helga inevitably overheard conversations on what rights women should have in America. Although the ballot failed at the state level, the vote from the town of Manistee, and the local editorials showed support for the amendment. The failure led to strong determination by local women to "fight out this battle with a zeal that shall know no discouragement, a courage that shall never tire." They invited Susan B. Anthony and Elizabeth Cady Stanton to lecture. In a town this small, their visits introduced Helga to the importance of women's rights.But something far more important affected Helga directly. At only fifteen, she discovered she was pregnant and her life changed dramatically. In Norway, young women from the rural farmlands sometimes became pregnant before marriage without disgrace, but it usually led to a marriage with the father of the child. However, Helga was not a rural farm girl living in Norway; she was the stepdaughter and only child of an immigrant merchant living in America. Circumstances surrounding the fifteen-year-old's pregnancy remain mysterious. She may have been raped while working as a maid in a wealthy home, or an irresponsible father walked away when she became pregnant, or perhaps she entered a relationship with a man her family did not approve of for religious, ethnic, or character reasons and they intervened. No one knows. What is known is this unplanned pregnancy radically altered Helga's future.On October 12, 1876, sixteen-year-old Helga married Ole Estby, a twenty-eight-year-old non-English speaking immigrant from Grue Solor, Norway, who had arrived in America in 1873. He worked in logging camps near Manistee, Michigan, although he initially trained as a carpenter in Germany. Grue Solor is the same region her stepfather came from in Norway, so they likely knew each other earlier. Her marriage to Ole, a Norwegian bachelor, seemed arranged to solve a family problem and avoid shame. Helga gave birth to a daughter she named Clara on November 26, and Ole Estby was probably not the father of her child.Soon after their marriage, Ole and Helga joined the quest of many Norwegian immigrants who had been drawn to this country by the promise of free land. They started their new life together homesteading in Yellow Medicine County near Canby, Minnesota. Within one year of young Helga's life, she became a wife, a mother, and a pioneer homesteader on the barren prairies near the Minnesota-Dakota border. After their move west, Helga and Ole presented Clara as the child of their own marriage. This family secret was a fiction that Helga and Ole maintained until Clara became a young adult.For a child raised in the cosmopolitan city of Christiana and during the boom times of Manistee, Michigan, the new challenges of motherhood and farming in an isolated prairie must have been daunting. As she left her family and home and drove off in a Conestoga wagon with her new husband and infant daughter, Clara, she likely had mixed feelings. She may have been enamored with "Western fever" like so many land-poor Norwegian immigrants, lured with the promise of potential riches for homesteaders, and grateful for the marriage with Ole that gave her and her daughter respectability. Or the sudden turn of events in her life may have left her feeling desolate and scared.Her husband surely saw his future success linked to settling a 160-acre homestead, a general belief confirmed in many letters sent back to Norway by friends and relatives who had immigrated to the United States. The fervency of these American letters enticed Norwegians to leave their families and venture to America, a migration so great that by the early twentieth century, Norway lost as many citizens as had comprised her total population in 1800.The Estbys were among the early settlers to Canby; the first had arrived only five years earlier in 1872 after the end of the Sioux War. Their farmland was about seven miles north of the city of Canby, a city populated in 1877 primarily by Norwegians. It offered a community where Ole could feel at home with his limited knowledge of English.Although Yellow Medicine County promised fertile land, grasshoppers had devoured farmers' crops for the past four years, causing many bankrupt farmers to abandon their homesteads and their dreams. It proved fortuitous, however, that the young Estby family filed in 1877, a year before the infestation ended and a large influx of immigrants arrived. This likely reinforced young Helga's trust in risk taking as a way to solve problems.Helga and Ole arrived in a land bereft of trees. They could see miles and miles of high-grass prairie, with cottonwood and ash trees found only along the river. A vast expanse of sky and land prevailed with nothing to break the wind. Coming from Norway and then Manistee, which nestled near the shores and forests of Lake Michigan, it was a dramatic geographic shift. With no seas, no nearby lakes, no forests, and no mountains, they saw none of the familiar landmarks etched in their memories of earlier days in Norway or Michigan. On the Canby prairie in the 1870s, pioneers battled the wind that at times blew like a cyclone, a sweeping wind that Helga could feel coming from miles and miles.But the prairie soil was rich, with gravel on the kames, which were short ridges formed by accumulated stratified drift from glacier waters. Scattered wetland marshes and ponds drew a multitude of waterfowl such as mallards, commonteals, rails, sand cranes, and Canada geese. Wild raspberries, prairie turnips, prairie peas, and gooseberries provided additional food for settlers.Because of the wind and the coming winter, Ole and Helga's immediate concern was to build a sod home into one of the kames. They cut three-foot strips of sod from the untilled ground and laid these in brick-like courses, grass-side down. The hillside banked their sod home, a one-room structure with a dirt floor. Most sod dwellings provided very little light or air in the poorly ventilated rooms, often having just one door and window. Compared to the frame and brick homes Helga lived in before, a sod home was a crude construction that proved difficult to maintain. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • In 1896, a Norwegian immigrant and mother of eight children named Helga Estby was behind on taxes and the mortgage when she learned that a mysterious sponsor would pay $10,000 to a woman who walked across America. Hoping to win the wager and save her family’s farm, Helga and her teenaged daughter Clara, armed with little more than a compass, red-pepper spray, a revolver, and Clara’s curling iron, set out on foot from Eastern Washington. Their route would pass through 14 states, but they were not allowed to carry more than five dollars each. As they visited Indian reservations, Western boomtowns, remote ranches and local civic leaders, they confronted snowstorms, hunger, thieves and mountain lions with equal aplomb. Their treacherous and inspirational journey to New York challenged contemporary notions of femininity and captured the public imagination. But their trip had such devastating consequences that the Estby women's achievement was blanketed in silence until, nearly a century later, Linda Lawrence Hunt encountered their extraordinary story.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(97)
★★★★
25%
(81)
★★★
15%
(48)
★★
7%
(23)
23%
(73)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Half a story

The author makes a valiant attempt to create an entire narrative out of a few shreds of fact. I was interested in Helga's story (though long passages of the book are tedious going), but in the end, I was hugely frustrated by the complete lack of information on the daughter who accompanied her step for step.

What, oh what, became of Clara? How can the author present as history an account that focuses on only one of the two persons involved? Did Clara marry? Did she have children and grandchildren? Did she ever speak or write of her epic walk? Was she shunned by the family, as her mother was? We simply don't know, after reading this book, and are left to wonder why there is no further information on Clara.

Ultimately, this book is a failed historical account of an intriguing personal adventure. Another reviewer suggested the story would have made a much better novel than nonfiction; considering the lack of primary information, I have to agree.
10 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

It's not interesting and it's not history

Allow me to save you some time: Helga decided to walk across America in order to win money so she could pay off her mortgage. Leaving her unemployed husband to care for her eight other kids, she set off with her daughter and had a fairly uneventful trip. She was never paid, had difficulty getting home and was then shunned by her family because two of her children died while she was gone. She never talked of this again and her children burnt her memoirs.

There, that's one paragraph. With some effort it could be expanded into a short essay. What we have here in Bold Spirit is almost 300 pages of pure speculation. What was Helga thinking? What happened during her trek? History has no clue because history has no source materials to work from. Other than some family memories, some legal documents and some old newspaper stories there is simply no record of what transpired. However, this doesn't stop Hunt from speculating wildly about...well, just about everything.

We hear what Helga's thoughts on politics MIGHT have been. We hear what she MIGHT of seen on her walk. We hear about what she MIGHT have thought about the suffragette movement. We hear what her life MIGHT have been like. Almost none of this has any basis in fact beyond Hunt's imagination! Speculation after speculation is thrown at the reader with absolutely no evidence to back it up. Hunt relies heavily on a half-dozen newspaper accounts of the trip - awfully few for a journey that must have passed through hundreds of towns and cities. These accounts are wildly inconsistent and reek of the sensationalistic tendencies of Victorian journalism. To back up these 'sources' Hunt trots out a variety of quotes from family members who barely remember their grandmother Helga. Not only do we get second-hand quotes redolent with hearsay, we get them over and over again - obviously there just wasn't that much information available. So, Hunt fills in as many of the gaps as she can with speculation and references to other events during Helga's life. Helga's experiences may have been very similar to those of another Norwegian housewife whose memoirs are quoted liberally, but how do we know? We don't, but Hunt assures us that there's a connection. This is history?

This might have worked better as a fact-based fiction novel, but the story itself just isn't very interesting to begin with. Helga may have been a strong pioneer woman, but she just didn't do that much. Yes, she walked across the country but it doesn't seem to have been that hard a task. Then she went home and forgot all about it. Sorry, but that's not exactly 'Gone With The Wind' material here.

Finally, Hunt compounds her errors by filling this book with references to early feminist politics - not a bad thing in and of itself, but there's no evidence to suggest that Helga held similar beliefs. In fact, there's plenty of evidence to suggest otherwise! Sometimes this is tengentially relevant, but usually it's an obvious agenda on the part of the author. Hunt even adds an entire chapter on the tragedies of 'silenced family histories' which, while potentially interesting, would be more at home in a textbook focused on feminist interpretations of history.

The whole thing comes off as a desperate attempt to stretch inadequate material into an 'academically relevant' book. There's just not enough here to justify calling this 'history' and very little of it is interesting. Recommended as light reading for those looking for strong female characters, but anyone looking for actual historical content (or biographical detail!) should look elsewhere.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

If it were possible, I would have given this book 0 stars.

In Linda Lawrence Hunt's historical work, Bold Spirit, the author attempts to describe Helga Estby's walk across America in 1896 without using any primary sources. The only historical records she had available of the walk were newspaper articles. Helga was a Norwegian immigrant mother of eight children who tried to help to pay off her farm's mortgage by making a bet for $10,000 to walk across America in about half a year. The contract also required her to collect signatures of some governors and mayors. She ultimately failed to get the money because the deadline passed. Just like Helga failed to get $10,000 because she ran out of time, the book fails to engage the reader in Helga's story because of the lack of source material.
Hunt had little information to help retell Helga's story because all of Helga's journals were destroyed by her family. The family was so angry because of what they saw as their mother's abandonment. Some of the children died in her absence, which made the rest of the family wonder if they would have died had Helga been home. The family was also shunned because Helga was doing something that made her husband look like he couldn't provide for his own family. They never forgave her for her walk, and eventually destroyed all primary records of the event by burning the journals. The author still tries to show what Helga might do in each situation, but each speculation is tedious to read. The destruction of the journals leads to Hunt's having to say the unfulfilling, "By this time, Helga and Clara MAY HAVE come to some sense of peace," instead of the confident "According to Helga's journal, both she and Clara had gotten over their initial grief." Because of the lack of information available for research, the book becomes a work of speculation and guesses instead of one of fact. Hunt does acknowledge that the book was hard to write because of this lack of information and even includes a section at the end telling why family stories and documents are historically important and shouldn't be destroyed.
The story of Helga and Clara's walk across America probably would have made a very interesting historical novel. Instead of speculating what may have happened on the walk, Hunt simply could have said that the book was based on the real walk of Helga Estby and her daughter across America, used what little information she could find about their trip, and made up the conversations, problems, and feelings the two women had. Hunt already has the basic outline of a historical novel because at each point the women have to make a choice she shows two or more options that they could have chosen. The author should have simply picked one of these situations as the one that occurred and moved on.
Hunt also draws this book out much longer than necessary. There is not enough known about Helga's story to say very much about her walk. She takes what could have been a good chapter of a book on the changing roles of women in the 19th century and stretches out to a laborious 260-page examination of not only the walk across America but also the politics of the 1896 presidential election and the problems between labor groups and bosses.
The book does have a few good points, though, especially in its descriptions of the changing roles of women. Hunt describes the pressure women, especially Norwegian women, felt during the 19th century to be good mothers while also describing the binding clothing and restrictions on rights. Also, her descriptions of Helga's life before and after her walk are extremely detailed, probably because she actually had newspaper articles, court transcripts and interviews from Helga's family members to help describe these times. Any place Hunt knows a lot of information about Helga's life and feelings about what happened around her is interesting.
Helga's story is worth telling simply because she helped destroy stereotypes of women in the 19th century. It is historically important to know about Helga's extraordinary accomplishment. However, the extremely speculative manner in which the information is presented makes the book a tedious ordeal to read.
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Helga's story inspires

Norwegian immigrant Helga Estby's entire life seems to have prepared her for the stunning adventure she undertook in the late 1800s, to prove not only her own strength, but that of all women.

Estby's cross-country walk across the U.S., with her eldest daughter Clara, is documented in Bold Spirit, a historic account patched together by author Linda Lawrence Hunt. Despite the destruction of Estby's careful notes, her letters and sketches, along with the Estby children's lifelong condemnation of their mother's story, Hunt crafts a convincing story.

A "rag rug" patchwork of news stories, a deep and fascinating knowledge of women's history and conversations with Thelma Estby, who was committed to preserving her family's stories, make Bold Spirit an interesting read. Helga was a true American pioneer, emigrating to Manistee, Michigan from Norway at age 11, at a time when Manistee's citizens were fully involved in the question of women's suffrage.

At age 15, Helga's life changed dramatically, although the specifics are not well known. She found herself pregnant and, before the child was born, married Ole Estby, a 28-year-old logger and carpenter. The couple moved cross-country to Yellow Medicine County in Minnesota, and Clara was thereafter presented as Ole's natural child.

A devastating blizzard and a destructive spate of cyclones likely made an employment opportunity in far-off Seattle seem very attractive. As Ole and Helga settled there, Helga filled the traditional role of a Victorian-era wife, enduring 10 pregnancies, the deaths of two children and the dramatic natural and social disasters that shaped the course of her family's life.

Trapped in bad financial situation, with her husband unable to work, Helga found her interest piqued by an ad offering $10,000 to any woman who would walk across the country, in part to promote a new line of women's clothing denounced as brazenly inappropriate because it exposed the ankles.

As she explores the deal itself, Hunt provides a fascinating look at the stifling cultural restrictions faced by Victorian women - and then goes on to show how, with ingenuity, endurance and sheer strength of will, two women stepped into a torrent of criticism and outright hatred, all for the love and preservation of their family home.
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Just What America Needs

Bold Spirit is truly a classic -- Helga and Clara Estby's story should be a "required" read for all school students. In today's world of inflated "superheroes" and overblown fiction, this is a realistic look at what true heroism is. It's too bad that Helga never had the opportunity to be recognized as such in person!
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

"...we expect the already great and famous to do great things, but we easily overlook the achievements of

the more humble among us."

Aptly sums up thirty-six year old Norwegian immigrant Helen Estby's 1886 walk with her eighteen year old daughter, Clara, 3500 miles across America. The trek was attempted for financial reasons, its completion with certain stipulations and within a seven-month time span would result in a $10,000 windfall for the cash strapped family. Unfortunately, due to negative feelings about the journey, during which Mrs. Estby left the care of her eight younger children in the hands of her husband, most of the information about it was not only not saved, but was intentionally destroyed by her descendants. Surmounting obstacles like difficult terrain, inclement weather, bad guys and a lack of money (the contract did not allow them to solicit donations) and the judgmental feelings of the many at the time who felt their behavior was in appropriate, the Estbys showed their detractors that they had the right stuff. The problem with the story, frankly, is a lack of firsthand information, which would have made its telling more personal and compelling: an okay story about a fantastic feat. Good companion reads: Tomboy Bride by Harriet Fish Backus, Grand Ambition by Lisa Michaels, In a Far Country by John Taliaferro and Nothing Like It In the World: The Men Who Built the Transcontinental Railroad 1863-1869 by Stephen E. Ambrose.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Unforgettable story

Linda Hunt has managed to capture a forgotten piece of Victorian America in an amazing book that keeps you turning the page until you are done.

An incredible amount of research went into this work in order to weave a fascinating story that had become a family secret together with historical information from all over the country following the route that Helga took. Bravo!
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Living history

I found this book because it's mentioned at the end of [[ASIN:1400074290 The Daughter's Walk: A Novel]]. A Daughter's Walk is a novel based on a cross-country walk made by Helga & Clara Estby in 1896. Bold Spirit is a factual account of the walk, put together almost exclusively from newspaper accounts of the walk. Helga kept a diary as they walked, but her bag containing her money and her diary was stolen in New York City. Her family destroyed the letters she wrote them on her journey. Later in life, she started writing a memior, but after her death, her children burned it, wanting no reminders of what they saw as their mother's shame and betrayal.

This factual account is actually more heart-breaking than the novel, perhaps because everything is there in black and white with no invented dialogue or assumed motivations to get in the way.

I would recommend reading Bold Spirit before A Daughter's Walk, simply because A Daughter's Walk fills in blanks that you don't realize are even there until you read Bold Spirit. It's kind of like watching the movie before you read the book. Bold Spirit is the book and A Daughter's Walk is the "movie".
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Bittersweet page-turner

Bittersweet: that's the first word that comes to my mind after reading Helga Estby's story.

I disagree with other reviewers who think Linda Lawrence Hunt's writing is lackluster or that this is just half a story. Given the tiny amount of information she had to start with, I think she did a fabulous job weaving historical events into Helga's story. I stayed up late reading this--it was impossible to put down!

Helga Estby was an incredible woman by any measure. The fact that she had the COURAGE to go against her family's and the Norwegian community's concerns in an era of Victorian propriety (1896) in order to try to save her family farm/home from forclosure by walking across the country to try to win a wager, is heroic. And she DID it, with her eldest daughter, Clara. They walked from Spokane, WA to New York City. She did it in the hopes of saving her family financially, and also with the fervent wish that the family would not be separated because of financial concerns.

She had quite an adventure, being on foot with her daughter: they were only allowed $5 each, they didn't bring a change of clothes, they only had a satchel each carrying a pistol, pepper spray gun, and notebook and pen to record their journey. They weren't allowed to beg, but had to work for their room and board. They weren't allowed to take the train, but were allowed to ride "free" on someone's wagon, if offered. They were supposed to visit the capitals of the states they visited, and get signatures from mayors and governors. And in between, they were followed by wild animals, wild men, and wild weather.

They were also supposed to model the new women's fashion garment as stipulation for their journey on foot: a shorter skirt, as opposed to the floor-length Victorian dresses of the day. A woman showing her ankles in those days was running the risk of ridicule and shame from society. In short, they were supposed to show that women were NOT so fragile, physically or mentally, as society would believe!

One of the highlights of their trip was being right in the middle of a presidential election, which had echos of this year's election: one younger candidate exhorting change, and the other older candidate touting his experience. Helga and Clara were fortunate to enjoy the company of the wife of the younger (he was on the campaign trail in the east), and an hour meeting with the elder candidate.

The bitter part is that things did not turn out as she had hoped. What was more heartbreaking is that she lost two children to diptheria while she was away, and her family could not forgive her for her absence in such dire times, most notably her elder children. Because of their deep and bitter resentment, her story was silenced for many decades. That was their way of keeping family "peace." Helga originally gave birth 10 times; she had left seven children behind with her husband, who was unable to work for a time because of an injury. One child had died shortly before she headed east.

The sweet part of the story was that Helga kept her dignity throughout her trip and afterwards. She still managed to enjoy the things she liked, including becoming more active in civic affairs, after she returned from her walk across America. During her journey, she had become aware of women's issues: their rights, the ability to vote or not, and their ability to voice their concerns more freely in other parts of the nation. She also had ample opportunity to observe how far people's kindness--or cruelty, could extend.

Hunt gives a fascinating look into the factors that contribute to silencing a family story at the conclusion of the book. In that chapter she wrote: "Every country needs individuals who refuse to be silenced when breaking out of unhealthy cultural norms, despite the criticism." What a fitting tribute to the memory of Helga Estby!

Anyone who appreciates, history, culture, politics, feminism, and adventure would enjoy Helga Estby's story. Her early pioneer days raising small children in a sod house with her husband on the Minnesota prairie demanded a kind of adventuresome spirit on her part to survive. This book is engaging, clearly written, short, and has lots of pictures to stir your imagination.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Great read

I borrowed this book from the library and have since bought two copies of it for gifting. It's a great book for any feminista, budding or evolved. I especially like that I could see any of my friends liking it -- men and women. History buffs, pyschotherapists, bakers -- they're all friends of mine, and two will be getting this book. Hunt does a very nice job of filling in where documentation falls short, and I wish that was a bit more clear. (True to her academic roots, however, Hunt does use footnotes.) The thing I like best about this book is that it is easily understood as an historical account, but considers the socio-economic factors as well as social values that shaped decisions made by Helga Estby. Really fascinating.
3 people found this helpful