It's a Book
It's a Book book cover

It's a Book

Hardcover – August 10, 2010

Price
$17.99
Format
Hardcover
Pages
32
Publisher
Roaring Brook Press
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-1596436060
Dimensions
8.22 x 0.34 x 10.4 inches
Weight
11.5 ounces

Description

Product Description Playful and lighthearted with a subversive twist that is signature Lane Smith, It’s a Book is a delightful manifesto on behalf of print in the digital age. This satisfying, perfectly executed picture book has something to say to readers of all stripes and all ages. A Look Inside It's a Book (Click on Images to Enlarge) How do you scroll down? Does it need a password? Shh… I’m reading I’ll charge it up when I’m done From School Library Journal Gr 3-5–Smith jump-starts the action on the title page where readers meet the characters–a mouse, a jackass, and a monkey. The monkey's oval head creates an “o” in the word “book.” Slapstick humor ensues in an armchair face-off when one character, reared on a diet of Web 2.0 and gaming, cannot fathom what to do with a book and slings a barrage of annoying questions, “Can you blog with it? How do you scroll down? Can you make the characters fight?” Readers know who is speaking by each animal's unique font type and color, achieving economy and elegance on each page. Exasperated, Monkey hands over the volume. Life, death, and madness, all in a single illustrated page of Treasure Island, draw Jackass in. He responds with a knee-jerk reaction (“too many letters”) and hilariously reduces it to text speak, but his interest is piqued. He covets the book and readers watch him pore over it for hours. Repeated images of him transfixed, shifting left to right, up and down, ears upright, then splayed, and eyes wide open, fill a wordless spread and offer a priceless visual testimony to the focused interaction between readers' imaginations and a narrative. Mouse delivers the final punch line, which will lead to a fit of naughty but well-deserved laughter, and shouts of “Encore.” A clever choice for readers, young and old, who love a good joke and admire the picture book's ability to embody in 32 stills the action of the cinema. Sara Lissa Paulson, American Sign Language and English Lower School PS 347, New York City © Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted. From Booklist Smith throws down his gauntlet in the ongoing debate over digital versus print in this spare offering. A donkey (jackass) with a laptop and a monkey with a hardcover book discuss the merits of their preferred formats. “How do you scroll down?” the donkey asks. “Do you blog with it?” “Can you make the characters fight?” To each question, the monkey offers an answer that riffs on this small, square picture book’s title. At one point, the monkey shoves a page into his companion’s hands, showing a story about a pirate. “Too many words,” the donkey responds, and he quickly transcribes the story as “LJS: rrr! K? lol! / JIM: :( ! :).” Unimpressed, the monkey continues to build his case until his big-eared mate converts to print so enthusiastically that he vows to keep reading. Although it is adults, not children, who will best appreciate the subject and satire here, the basic drama created by the characters’ arguments may help this find an audience among kids, especially tech-savvy ones. Grades 1-3. --Andrew Medlar “I do love this book.” ― The New Yorker magazine's, Book Bench blog “Those of us for whom books are a faith in themselves -- who find the notion that pixels, however ordered, could be any kind of substitute for the experience of reading in a chair with the strange thing spread open on our lap -- will love this book. Though it will surely draw a laugh from kids, it will give even more pleasure to parents who have been trying to make loudly the point that Smith's book makes softly: that the virtues of a book are independent of any bells, whistles or animation it might be made to contain. . . . For in trying to make the case for books to our kids, exactly the case we want to make is not that they can compete with the virtues of computer or screens, but that they do something else: that they allow for a soulfulness the screens, with their jumpy impersonality, cannot duplicate . . . The moral of Smith's book is the right one: not that screens are bad and books are good, but that what books do depends on the totality of what they are -- their turning pages, their sturdy self-sufficiency, above all the way they invite a child to withdraw from this world into a world alongside ours in an activity at once mentally strenuous and physically still.” ― Adam Gopnick, in The New York Times Book Review “This tongue-in-cheek picture book about reading in the digital age features the best last line ever written in the history of children's literature. Savor it in print rather than trying to read it on your Nook, Kindle or iPad --the punchline will be much better that way.” ― USA Today's "Pop Candy" blog “Stylishly designed.” ― The Wall Street Journal, in its Summer Big Books Preview “In the age of e-readers, Smith offers a wry tribute to the printed word through a conversation about a book. As a gorilla sits reading quietly, a technophilic donkey pesters him about the source of his absorption: "Can it text? Tweet? Wi-Fi?" He may be a complete ass, but the donkey finally comes to understand the value of a good book -- least of all, no batteries required!” ― AARP.com “Donkey's gradual capitulation to the power of a real book is marked by both the hands of the clock (in a droll double-page time-lapse sequence) and the angles of his ears. But it's a mouse's final insouciant line that garners the biggest laugh.” ― The Washington Post “Welcome to a stunning picture-book entry in the print versus e-books debate. . . One of this year's best last lines will not be spoiled here.” ― The Chicago Tribune “This is a picture book that captures a defining moment in--dare I say it? --civilization as we know it.” ― The Miami Herald “Lane Smith brilliantly captures the fears of today's book lovers over e-readers in a children's book -- and does so with great humor.” ― The New York Post “Dry humor permeates the visual exchanges. With a cheeky punch line (kids, do not try it at home), Smith uses irreverence to express reverence for the book.” ― The San Francisco Chronicle “Personally, we laughed our a$$ off--and we know a few kids who will, too.” ― Time Out New York Kids “If you're a picture book connoisseur, chances are you're already familiar with Lane Smith. . . . Smith's latest picture book is called IT'S A BOOK. . . It's a very cute book, short and sweet. The illustrations are charming--particularly the monkey's expressions--and your kids will love the silly questions the donkey asks about the monkey's book.” ― Wired magazine's "Geek Dad" blog “Young readers, who are, after all, digital natives, will get a real kick out of Smith's book, as will their increasingly technology-obsessed parents.” ― Scripps Howard News Service “In our increasingly electronic world, it's easy to forget the sweet simplicity of a book. In Lane Smith's delightful It's a Book , the high-tech generation, especially youngsters, can rediscover the fun there is to be had between two covers. The playful read is something you and your grandchildren can enjoy together, time and again.” ― The Bellingham Herald “Adults who think their kids can handle the language with a wink and a smile will love reading this book aloud to their kids and having a great old belly laugh right along with them.” ― McClatchy-Tribune newswire “Smith addresses e-literacy in his irreverent style. . . . Meanwhile, Smith has the best of both worlds: his stylish drawings, sleek typography, and kid-friendly humor combine old media and new.” ― Publishers Weekly, STARRED “The final punch line . . . will lead to a fit of naughty but well-deserved laughter, and shouts of ‘Encore.' A clever choice for readers, young and old, who love a good joke and admire the picture book's ability to embody in 32 stills the action of the cinema.” ― School Library Journal, STARRED “This is an exceptional picture book by an A-list award-winning, best-selling author/illustrator; a book that is promoting literacy and poking fun at those people who are forever glued to their computer screens. I'm quite curious to see how this one will play out. Especially when IT'S A BOOK starts showing up on a bunch of Best of the Year lists. Including mine.” ― Richie's Picks “Wickedly funny.” ― The Horn Book “Smith throws down his gauntlet in the ongoing debate over digital versus print.” ― Booklist “Universally comical . . . the refrain and pacing hit the sweet spot for preschoolers, while a Treasure Island passage reduced to AIM-speak will have middle schoolers and adults in stitches.” ― Kirkus Reviews “A must-read for every publisher concerned about the impact of electronic publishing issues and every child who wants to enjoy more of their childhood and Lane Smith's arch style. A devilish ending may scare a few... if it's you? Lighten up.” ― Publishers Weekly, named a "Staff Pick" by PW publisher George Slowik, Jr. “I just received my finished copy of IT'S A BOOK, and I am simply mad for it. I want to give it to every i-Pad/Kindle-loving friend, to every skeptic who doubts the endurance of book culture in the 21st century, and certainly to children who must, must, must be shown the enchantments of holding a real book in their tiny hands. I hope IT'S A BOOK is a huge, huge success, and not just as a children's book.” ― Irma Wolfson, Book Buyer, Fontainebleau Hotel “A spirited parable that should be required reading for every youngster likely to find piles of shiny new gadgets under the tree this year.” ― The New Yorker magazine's "Book Bench" blog, in its piece "Holiday Gift Guide for the Precocious Child" Lane Smith has written and illustrated a bunch of stuff, including the Kate Greenaway Medalist There Is A Tribe of Kids , and A Perfect Day .He is also the author of the middle-grade novel Return to Augie Hobble, as well as author and illustrator of Caldecott Honor book Grandpa Green and runaway New York Times bestseller It's a Book which has been translated into over twenty languages. His other works include the national bestsellers Madam President and John, Paul, George & Ben . His titles with Jon Scieszka have included the Caldecott Honor winner The Stinky Cheese Man ; The True Story of the 3 Little Pigs ; Math Curse ; and Science Verse . Lane's other high profile titles include Hooray for Diffendoofer Day! by Dr. Seuss and Jack Prelutsky; The Very Persistent Gappers of Frip by George Saunders; Big Plans by Bob Shea; and James and the Giant Peach by Roald Dahl. In 1996, Lane served as Conceptual Designer on the Disney film version of James and the Giant Peach .In 2012, the Eric Carle Museum named him a Carle Artist for "lifelong innovation in the field of children's picture books," and in 2014, he was awarded the lifetime achievement award from the Society of Illustrators. He lives in rural Connecticut with the designer Molly Leach. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • Playful and lighthearted with a subversive twist that is signature Lane Smith,
  • It’s a Book
  • is a delightful manifesto on behalf of print in the digital age. This satisfying, perfectly executed picture book has something to say to readers of all stripes and all ages.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
60%
(270)
★★★★
25%
(113)
★★★
15%
(68)
★★
7%
(32)
-7%
(-33)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

More a Picture Book for Grown Ups

As a picture book for grown ups, It's a Book is clever and well illustrated, easily a 4/5. However, it is being marketed to children four to eight years old. As the mother of two children in that age range, and a former third grade teacher, I find that strange. The concept is great, but the execution is so-so. First off, children aren't as familiar with that technology (blogs are for grown ups.) As people who grew up with technology AND printed books all around them, they just aren't worried about the death of the publishing industry. So, much of it goes over their heads, and then it ends with the word jackass (which is going to offend a number of parents, keep it off library shelves, etc.) I can't imagine recommending this book to other families with little kids. However, I can think of lots of adults and snarky teenagers who would adore it.
80 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Perfect Start

As a librarian and education student I can tell you that blogs are NOT just for adults. Have you been in schools recently? Even elementary schools have students creating and adding to blogs. They are simple and easy to make and run, hardly the sole realm of adults. Any child in elementary school - who does not have parents specifically keeping them away from technology (if you are doing this, you have no right to comment on here saying "My child doesn't know what any of that is!") knows exactly what is being talked about in this book and would find it funny.

I also find it sad that so many are complaining about the word "jackass". A jackass is a male donkey - it's an animal. Use your dictionaries. It is yet another word that will simply make children giggle, they don't have any negative connotations associated with it. To them it is just going to be the animal on the page.

I think this is a fabulous book completely appropriate for elementary school. So many children spend all their free time on computers, watching TV, listening to iPods and such that I've seen children come into the library and not even know there are different kinds of books. This one is a great introduction to books, and will certainly draw them in.
33 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

hilarious spoof on our 21st century computer age

Lane Smith's wicked sense of humor comes through in this easy reader picture book aimed at elementary school-aged kids. This would be a great read-aloud for teachers at the beginning of school. On the title page, we meet mouse, jackass, and monkey, our characters. Monkey is reading a book, and Jackass bombards him with a series of annoying questions, such as "how do you scroll down," "do you blog with it," "where's the mouse," etc., to which Monkey keeps replying "it's a book." There's a very funny twist at the end, as Monkey lends his book to Jackass, and has to go to the library to find something else to read. A very funny gift for book lovers of all ages! Smith's very droll and simple illustrations are critical to the story, and the increasingly annoyed-looking expressions are Monkey are especially funny. This one's a keeper.
28 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Sad - it could have been a winner

Most of this book was humorous, and the idea behind it was a good one. But all humor disappeared at the end of the book. I'm sure there are many adults who would get a chuckle out of it, but it is not suitable for children.

Young children love to read the same book over and over and over again, and to mimic phrases from the book. After I read this one myself, I didn't even let my child see it. Why would I want to train my child to call people Jackass? I wouldn't.
24 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I'm Confused

Big fan of Lane Smith here - my girls adore his "John, Paul, George & Ben" about the Founding Fathers. When I had the opportunity to review "It's a Book", I jumped right on it. And now I am confused.

You see, I can't figure out the target audience for the book. While the reading level is for kids, the content isn't. My 9 year old has no idea what a text, blog or tweet is. She doesn't get wi-fi or screen names. That's because we're traditionalists in this house using books instead of a Kindle. She doesn't have the freedome yet to surf the internet, let alone an email account. Texting and social media are off limits for her at this age. So, the entire joke of "It's a Book" which is that a book isn't a device you plug into the wall and it doesn't do any fancy tricks makes no sense to my kids.

For adults, while I get the joke and my husband gets the joke, we both are in agreement that the entire concept would be better suited to the length and format of a Sunday morning cartoon strip. The book is too long for such a skimpy idea. I also found the use of the term "jackass" while correct to be unnecessary and distracting.
22 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Funny but not a kids book.

I thought this would be an interesting book for the kids to look at and for me to read to them. Most of the story they would not get the words that relate to a computer or the jokes that are thrown in. Plus I know that one of the words used is the name for an animal(another name for a donkey) but I really dont want my kids running around saying it. I read it and thought it was kind of funny but I didnt even let the kids look at it. I think it is not worth buying and would not recommend it. Illustrations were a positive but still not enough to warrant buying the book. This should definetly not be pushed towards the 4-8 reading age level.
15 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

It's a miss

Where to begin? Begin at the beguine, I suppose. I've had It's a Book sitting on my shelf for months and now the time is ripe. As you may have heard one place or another, it contains an off-color word at the end ("jacka**", belated spoiler alert, and Amazon apparently won't let me write the real word) and it makes fun of folks who prefer online zips and whizbangs to good old-fashioned paper books. So what are we to make of it? Well, I hate to lob this designation on any author or illustrator I like, but this is so clearly a picture book for grown-ups that it squeaks. While kids today slip from electronic readers to paper books and back again like svelte otters, it is the grown-ups around them that are heard cooing and purring every time a shiny new electronic toy hits the market. For those who love the printed page, such enthusiasm can be scary. Kids don't fear for the so-called "death of the book" but some of their caregivers certainly do, and so for them Lane Smith has penned an exchange between a pixel-happy donkey and the monkey (slash ape) who just wants to read his book in peace.

Hedging his bets right from the start, Smith begins by pulling his punch as far back as it can reasonably go. Turn to the title page and you read, "It's a mouse. It's a jackass. It's a monkey." Ignoring the fact that the monkey is actually an ape (though he may be hiding his tail beneath his, uh, muumuu?), the story begins with the donkey asking the primate what he's got there. "It's a book." Not understanding the donkey tries to figure out the use of such an object. "Can it text?" "No." "Tweet?" "No." "Wi-Fi?" "No." Eventually the donkey gets to see what a book really can do and when his companion asks if he can have his book back he gets a pretty straightforward, "No," echoing his own earlier dismissals. The donkey, to his credit, offers to charge the book up when he's done, but the mouse perched on the top of the monkey's (slash ape's) head clarifies everything, "You don't have to . . ." Turn the page. "It's a book, jacka**."

In the past, Smith was king at walking the fine line between adult humor and children's humor. Books like The Happy Hockey Family remain spot on. Kids find them funny just on a basic humor level and adults love the sly jabs at easy reading books of yore. This balance was once a Smith trademark, but lately he's been falling too far on the adult side of the equation. When I mention The Big Elephant in the Room to other children's librarians I often meet with blank stares. Though it came out just a year before It's a Book, this title was a pretty strange concoction. In it a donkey (a jacka**?) asks another about "the elephant in the room". His companion then launches into a series of unspoken topics that might be that elephant until, at the end, we see an actual elephant sitting in the room. After trying to figure out if there was a political point to the story (donkeys and elephants rarely co-mingle for any other reason) it occurred to me that the book made no sense. Of course the first thing a child reader is going to assume when they hear the term "elephant in the room" is that there's an actual elephant there. Only adults would go along with the donkey's string of interpersonal mishaps. If The Big Elephant in the Room missed its mark, It's a Book missed the same mark, but managed to hit a much larger target: an adult readership.

It's telling that reviews on sites like Amazon display less a sense of moral outrage against the use of the "jacka**" and rather a quiet bewilderment about the book's audience. The outraged folks are there, of course, but folks that simply want to know "why" outnumber them. Or maybe a more accurate word would be "who?" Who precisely is this a book for? The answer comes, horrifyingly enough, from Barnes and Noble. The bookstore behemoth has for years been able to command that authors and illustrators change aspects of their books (words, cover images, etc.) or else pay the ultimate price: No display space. Rumor has it (and I'm working purely off of what I've heard) that so incensed was B&N by Smith's use of the term "jacka**" that they insisted he change the word. Smith adamantly stood by his "jacka**" and so when you walk into your local B&N (as of the writing of this review) you will find It's a Book not in the children's section at all, but in the adult humor section. The thing is, B&N inadvertently got it right. Not about the word, mind you, but about what exactly the real audience for this title is.

Now before I go any farther, I have indeed heard teachers of older children (4th & 5th graders, for example) say that kids get a kick out of this book. And while I am pleased the older children are okay with being read picture books, were they the perceived audience from the start of the book's creation? Probably not. No 4th or 5th grader I know is going to confuse a book with a Kindle or nook. Smith's sort of setting up a straw man here, but it's not for the kids. It's for the adults. The ones who worry somewhere in the back of their minds that books will someday be nothing more than pixels on a screen. The ones who see their children playing online, texting their friends, updating their Facebook statuses, and fear for the future of the printed page. For them It's a Book is a rallying cry. It touches on everything they fear and then tells them exactly what they want to hear: That the people who live solely in the world of bits and bytes are truly jackasses at heart.

And what about that word anyway? Like pretty much every other reader I was surprised the first time I got to the end of the book. I'm not going to raise a fuss about the term per say. After all, Tinkerbell calls Peter "you silly a**" in Peter Pan while even the beloved James and the Giant Peach (which Smith once illustrated himself) knew when to brandish the term. But then, these books were chapter books. Would I, then, keep this book off my picture book shelves? Of course not! In a culture where we've movies named things like Kick-A** in the theaters, the term is practically ubiquitous. My objection isn't that he uses the word, but that he uses it poorly. Look, I'm a children's librarian. Let's say I read this book to a room full of second graders. We're all having a good time, I'm doing cool sound effects, and then we get to the end. The mouse says, "It's a book, jacka**" and suddenly the entire tone of the storytime has changed. What was a fun informative book suddenly turns . . . well . . . nasty. Because what exactly is the mouse saying? That if you are ignorant of something, like books, and try to learn more then you're a jacka**? That anyone who comes to books late in life is a jackass? What exactly is the donkey's crime here? What, for that matter, is the point of the final sentence?

The point is to shock and ultimately amuse adult readers, and in this Smith has succeeded beyond measure. It's the final ZING for an audience that's comfortable with the term but didn't expect to see it in a children's book. They gasp, then laugh at the fact that they laughed, then feel great affection for the story because (as I mentioned before) it taps into their own fears and reassures them. The only people left out of the equation are children, but that doesn't matter. Small fry don't earn money with which to buy too many books anyway. This begs the question about whether or not the fact that the intended audience is grown-up is even a problem. I don't suppose so but I don't like it when books masquerade as something they are not. If this is a book for big people then say it loud and clear. And if it is for little people, why did you make it so mature?

The kicker is that Smith's art is superb here. Really quite lovely. Where in The Big Elephant in the Room he seemed to be sleepwalking through the pages, here his lines are crisp and clean and almost geometric. Look how beautifully the donkey's ears curve from his head to their tips and back again. Check out the beauty of the straight-backed red chair he sits in. This is almost a Mondrian painting subdued into a natural palette and then transformed into a book for kids. I daresay Smith hasn't done art this lovely in years. And look at his fonts! The donkey's are that strange computerized font we just naturally associate with computers. The mouse and monkey (slash ape) speak with fonts that are far more . . . literary, shall we say? There was thought, clear thought, behind these choices.

I can't help but be amused by the irony that a book that proclaims loud and long the great delights of the printed word verses the electronic one happens to have its own online book trailer (one that judiciously makes sure not to mention the naughty word at the end, by the way). In essence, the book has done precisely what it meant to. It has amused adults to no end. And while it will probably never be read to a class of first or second graders in a true storytime, it will live on in the bookshelves of college students across the country. While it does, I'll hope for the return of Lane Smith to the world of children's literature written for kids first and foremost. Writing for adults is all well and good, but anyone can do that. It takes a special knack to write a book that a kid really loves and enjoys. Fingers crossed that it happens for Mr. Smith again sometime real soon.
13 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Really?

The book is simultaneously clever and obnoxious. It pains me greatly that unneccessary word play and/or language is not only sneaking into kids' picture books - in books like this one, it's the centerpiece. Imagine a 7 year old immitating the text by repeating, "it's a book, jackass," to a classmate, librarian, or parent. The author knows it will happen. The publisher has to know it, too. Teachers will catch heck from parents if this finds a home in a classroom. Even a Lane Smith author study becomes chancy. The play on words is adorably clever - if you're an adult.
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Cute book....for adults.

I ordered this book for a 7 year old birthday party because it was recommended in the 4-8 age range; however, the content of the book, particularly the word "jackass" is inappropriate for children. I think the concept of the book is hilarious, but once I read the entire book, I decided against giving it to a child. Just a warning to proceed with caution. :)
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

It's a book, Jackass. Is the last line of the book. Beware!

What the heck? I ordered this book, plus a bunch of other highly rated books for a k-3 reading program. I thought it looked really cute. I just read it all of the way through for the first time. The last line is, "It's a book Jackass". How inappropriate for a children's book. Yes, they do introduce the "character" of Jackass at the beginning. But I can see the kids going home saying, "It's a BOOK Jackass!" I'd lose my job.

It's been too long so I can't even return it. So I'm out the purchase price. Cute concept and totally failed attempt to have adult humor in a children's book.
9 people found this helpful