Short and Tall Tales
Short and Tall Tales book cover

Short and Tall Tales

Hardcover – October 14, 2002

Price
$9.62
Format
Hardcover
Pages
144
Publisher
Putnam Adult
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0399149566
Dimensions
5.44 x 0.93 x 8.3 inches
Weight
12.8 ounces

Description

From Publishers Weekly Fans of Lilian Jackson Braun's Cat Who... series won't want to miss Short and Tall Tales: Moose County Legends Collected by James Mackintosh Qwilleran. In the voice of Qwill, her beloved fictional journalist, Braun presents 27 amusing yarns, from "The True(?) History of Squunk Water" to "Those Pushy Moose County Blueberries." Copyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc. From Library Journal Braun here presents stories about the denizens of Moose County, presumably collected by the journalist hero of her numerous mysteries. Copyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc. Lilian Jackson Braun is the author of twenty-four previous Cat Who . . . novels and the upcoming The Cat Who Brought Down the House . Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. The Legend of the Rubbish Heap A Chronicle of Two Pioneer Families In the mid-nineteenth century, when Moose County was beginning to boom, it was a Gold Rush without the gold. There were veins of coal to be mined, forests to be lumbered, granite to be quarried, land to be developed, fortunes to be made. It would become the richest county in the state. In 1859 two penniless youths from Germany arrived by schooner, by way of Canada. On setting foot on the foreign soil, they looked this way and that to get their bearings, and both saw it at the same time! A piece of paper money in a rubbish heap! Without stopping to inquire its value, they tore it in half to signify their partnership. It would be share and share alike from then on. Their names were Otto Wilhelm Limburger and Karl Gustav Klingenschoen. They were fifteen years old. Labor was needed. They hired on as carpenters, worked long hours, obeyed orders, learned everything they could, used their wits, watched for opportunities, took chances, borrowed wisely, cheated a little, and finally launched a venture of their own. By the time they were in their thirties, Otto and Karl dominated the food and shelter industry. They owned all the rooming houses, eating places, and travelers' inns along the shoreline. Only then did they marry: Otto, a God-fearing woman named Gretchen; Karl, a fun-loving woman nicknamed Minnie. At the double wedding the friends pledged to name their children after each other. They hoped for boys, but girls could be named Karla and Wilhelmina. Thus the two families became even more entwined...until rumors about Karl's wife started drifting back from the waterfront. When Karl denied the slander, Otto trusted him. But there was more! One day Karl approached his partner with an idea for expanding their empire. They would add saloons, dance halls, and female entertainment of various kinds. Otto was outraged! The two men argued. They traded insults. They even traded a few blows and, with noses bleeding, tore up the fragments of currency that had been in their pockets since the miracle of the rubbish heap. Karl proceeded on his own and did extremely well, financially. To prove it, he built a fine fieldstone mansion in Pickax City, across from the courthouse. In retaliation Otto imported masons and woodworkers from Europe to build a brick palace in the town of Black Creek. How the community reacted to the two architectural wonders should be mentioned. The elite of the county vied for invitations to sip tea and view Otto's black walnut woodwork; Karl and Minnie sent out invitations to a party and no one came. When it was known that the brick mansion would be the scene of a wedding, the best families could talk of nothing else. The bride was Otto's only daughter; he had arranged for her to marry a suitable young man from the Goodwinter family; the date was set. Who would be invited? Was it true that Otto had taken his daughter before a magistrate and legally changed her name from Karla to Elsa? It was true. Elsa's dower chest was filled with fine household linens and intimate wedding finery. Gifts were being delivered in the best carriages in town. Seamstresses were working overtime on costumes for the wedding guests. Gowns for the bridal party were being shipped from Germany. Suppose there was a storm at sea! Suppose they did not arrive in time! Then, on the very eve of the nuptials, Otto's daughter eloped with the youngest son of Karl Klingenschoen! Shock, embarrassment, sheer horror, and the maddening suspicion that Karl and Minnie had promoted the defection-all these emotions combined to affect Otto's mind. As for the young couple, there were rumors that they had gone to San Francisco. When the news came, a few years later, that the young couple had lost their lives in the earthquake, Elsa's father had no idea who they were. Karl and Minnie lived out their lives in the most splendid house in Pickax, ignored by everyone of social standing. Karl never knew that his immense fortune was wiped out, following the financial crash of 1929. Toward the end of the century, Otto's sole descendant was an eccentric who sat on the porch of the brick palace and threw stones at dogs. Karl's sole descendant was Fanny Klingenschoen, who recovered her grandfather's wealth ten times over. Eventually the saga of the two families took a curious twist. The Klingenschoen Foundation has purchased two properties from the Limburger estate: the mansion in Black Creek and the hotel in Pickax. The former has become the Nutcracker Inn; the latter is now the Mackintosh Inn. The "legend of the rubbish heap" has come full circle. --from Short and Tall Tales by Lillian Jackson Braun, Copyright © October 2002, Putnam Pub Group, a member of Penguin Putnam, Inc., used by permission. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • Fictional columnist James Qwilleran, hero of the best-selling "The Cat Who. . ." mysteries, presents a collection of intriguing stories that spotlight the colorful world of Moose County and its residents in such legends as "The Secret of the Blacksmith's Wife" and "The Trevelyan Curse." 175,000 first printing.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
60%
(178)
★★★★
25%
(74)
★★★
15%
(45)
★★
7%
(21)
-7%
(-21)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Only diehard "Cat Who" fans will appreciate this one

It's a nifty little book, don't get me wrong; and you can polish it off in a single afternoon. And some of our favorite "Cat Who" personalities and families are mentioned, so it's like coming home to familiar faces. These 27 tales just won't be entertaining or meaningful to anyone who hasn't read at least a few of Braun's episodes. The best myth / legend is saved for last, in which the mystery of Midwestern scamadiddles is revealed. That one could be shared aloud with others, even if they don't know that KoKo and Yum Yum are Siamese cats. But a larger question looms here: Does this publication, authored by fictional character James "Qwill" Qwilleran, signify the end and culmination of the series? I hope not. Those of us who live Down Below still have a need to believe in the existence of eccentric Moose County, 400 miles north of everywhere. We enjoy visiting there every once in a while, even if the trip is made page-by-page instead of by car or boat.
41 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I didn't *want* to be disappointed...

I was really looking forward to anything else by Braun that dealt with Moose County inhabitants, et al., but although it does indeed live up to its title, this small book has little of the charm of the longer "Cat Who..." novels. Jim Qwilleran is the collector and faithful scribe of these tales; there is (appropriately although sadly) no sign of either KoKo or Yum Yum to brighten the pages. The tales are for the most part VERY short as is the book itself (see previous review re: white space and value for $$) and didn't last me an hour altogether. I was disappointed as the tales themselves didn't seem to have the color of Braun's other novels and short as they were, seemed to drag. I *love* the actual "Cat Who" series and even though the series has deteriorated somewhat (there have been almost 30 of them, after all), I look forward to the next installment!
12 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A series in its death throes

I picked up "Short & Tall Tales..." mainly out of curiosity and in the vain hope that this off-shoot of Braun's "The Cat Who..." series might prove a much-needed revitalization of what has become a tired, aimless series.
I was first put off by the smaller than average size of the book and the generous use of white space around and between the lines of type. It hardly seems to merit the nearly $$$ cover price. Mercifully, I borrowed the book from the public library. As for the tales themselves, they live up to the collection's title, being no more than three or four pages long. Fans who have followed "The Cat Who..." series from its beginning may have their memories jogged as favorite Moose County characters step forth to share their tall tales. The total effect, however, is choppy rather than endearing or quaint. I suspect that Braun (or whoever now writes this series) has tried to get around the criticisms leveled at the most recent installments in the series by resorting to having Qwilleran act as a mere scribe, very much off center stage -- and with Koko and Yum-Yum nowhere in sight. As these tales are supposedly anecdotal, related to Qwilleran by the fictional inhabitants of Moose County, there doesn't have to be any attempt at characterization, dialogue or the use of any literary device.

In all, the series continues to decline.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Probably just a book for series fans...

"Short and Tall Tales" is the book that readers of Lilian Jackson Braun's "Cat Who" mystery series know that James Mackintosh Qwilleran has been working on for several novels now. Well, he's finally finished and this is the book.
Fans of the series may recognize many of the stories in the book as having been told to JMQ in other novels. However, I didn't remember a lot of them and I love the idea of having all those great Moose County legends collected in one place.
This is a quick read - most stories are about three pages long - and a delightful one. It's good for picking up while in line somewhere or just reading in one sitting. I wouldn't recommend this book for anyone who has not read at least one or two of the "Cat Who" mystery series - I don't know how much sense it would make!
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A minor companion

Not as good as the "Cat who..." books themselves. Still, an easy read and not unenjoyable.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Really, A Waste Of Time

One has to wonder if the author simply cannot come up with any more mysteries for Qwill to solve; these were too short, too abrupt, too "re-runnish"--we have read some of these elsewhere in her work--and simply too flat. No substance, and the terseness makes them one-dimensional. Why does Qwill sound like a pompous ass in the few interjections he makes herein? The author cannot be so strapped for money she is simply trying to cash in on the past, can she? One hopes not indeed, because of the many past hours of reading pleasure she has afforded us.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Short and Tall Tales : Moose County Legends

This book contains the familiar stories and legends collected by "Qwill". The book is an enjoyable, quick and easy read. I wished the stories were more detailed than what has already been published in other "Cat Who" books. I would also have enjoyed reading about "Tipsy" the black and white cat of "Tipsy's diner" fame but this story was not included in the collection.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The Cat's Meow...

Qwill has finally done it. Put together the tales he's amassed so far in Moose County into a delightfully clever book. I can see how you must be a fan of Lilian or at the very least read at least a couple of her cat who books to understand the meaning behind this project. I am constantly waiting for her next book.
This would make a great tv series. What fun to cast the characters in these books. But who to play the role of James Mackintosh Qwilleran? Hmmm...
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A must if you are a Cat Who fan

Short & Tall Tales, by Lilian Jackson Braun is subtitled Moose County Legends Collected by James Mackintosh Qwilleran, is just that. Qwill, as he is known in Moose County 400 miles north of everywhere, is a reporter for the local newspaper.
Those of us who have read Lilian Jackson Braun's two dozen books in The Cat Who...mystery series featuring Qwill and his two crime solving Siamese cats will probably find this short, quick reading, cute collection of 27 tales interesting. Others not having the experience will not find interest in this collection.
Now we wait her 25th novel due out in February '03.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Just doesn't cut the mustard

I tried to read the whole book. I tried with all my might, but after reading half the tales in this book, I felt like hurling it out the window. I found most of the endings annoying or perplexing. I was always hoping the next story would be better -- much better. But each story was just as bad as the previous one. I'm exceedingly disappointed with this book. That's too bad because the picture on the cover is awfully nice!
2 people found this helpful