Supergods: What Masked Vigilantes, Miraculous Mutants, and a Sun God from Smallville Can Teach Us About Being Human
Supergods: What Masked Vigilantes, Miraculous Mutants, and a Sun God from Smallville Can Teach Us About Being Human book cover

Supergods: What Masked Vigilantes, Miraculous Mutants, and a Sun God from Smallville Can Teach Us About Being Human

Hardcover – July 19, 2011

Price
$33.61
Format
Hardcover
Pages
464
Publisher
Spiegel & Grau
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-1400069125
Dimensions
6.5 x 1.25 x 9.5 inches
Weight
1.68 pounds

Description

Amazon Best Books of the Month, July 2011 : According to Supergods , Superman comics say less about Superman than they do about Clark Kent. Superman was conceived as a symbol of strength and individualism for the Depression-era middle class--perhaps a more compelling portrait of the era than much literature of the time. But this is just one of the many superhero mythologies author Grant Morrison unpacks to give colorful historical and cultural context. Morrison, a prolific comics storyteller with a career spanning 20 years writing for both Marvel and DC Comics, may be the world's most qualified superhero scholar. (Morrison's reinvention of the Man of Steel, the All Star Superman series, is arguably the best comic of the past decade.) But Supergods isn't a book that appeals strictly to fanboys. Like his comics, Morrison's prose is swift yet powerful, and it's the broader strokes of the Supergods narrative that resonate most. The book succeeds at being a great history of comic books over the past century, but it's an even more convincing exploration of humankind as a whole. --Kevin Nguyen Praise for SUPERGODS "Grant Morrison is the antimatter to the often mundane world of comics - SUPERGODS is the finely tuned death-ray. Far beyond deconstruction, it exposes, challenges, invigorates and detonates everything we know about this modern mythology. SUPERGODS gives meaning to the fictional worlds we create and live within and helps us make sense of the madness within ourselves through the four-color world of the super hero." --Gerard Way, lead singer of My Chemical Romance and author of The Umbrella Academy."Excellent ... engrossing ... Morrison is a skilled word magician, seeking creativity in a cosmological dimension." --Publishers Weekly"Morrison is ideally suited to the task of chronicling the glorious rise, fall, rise, fall and rise again of comic-book superheroes. As thorough an account of the superhero phenomenon as readers are likely to find, filled with unexpected insights and savvy pop-psych analysis. Those who dare enter will find the prose equivalent of a Morrison superhero tale: part perplexing, part weird, fully engrossing." --Kirkus#1 in Wired's "10 Books That Will Fry Your Mind This Summer" "Grant Morrison has a hell of a tale to tell: The graphic novelist who co-created Batman's twisted game-changer Arkham Asylum: A Serious House on Serious Earth tripped on psilocybin mushrooms, fought movie execs to keep the Joker in high heels and reaped the benefits of going 50 hours without sleep in order to better access his unconscious. Subtitled What Masked Vigilantes, Miraculous Mutants, and a Sun God from Smallville Can Teach Us About Being Human, this trippy autobiography-cum-critical essay gathers up the deep thoughts and otherworldly hallucinations experienced by the comics writer." --Wired.comNPR's "Summer High Fliers" "Grant Morrison is one of the world's leading experts on comic books, and he draws on his entire body of work in Supergods, charting the history of superheroes from the very beginning. Morrison places the figures we all know -- Superman, Spider-Man, the X-Men -- in a broad cultural context, invoking art history, science and mythology to explain why we are so fascinated by the superhuman." --NPR.org Praise for Grant Morrison “Grant Morrison is one of the great comics writers of all time. I wish I didn’t have to compete with someone as good as him.”—Stan Leexa0“Grant’s whole body of work inspired me.”—Gerard Way, My Chemical Romancexa0“I suddenly realized that everything that I’m trying to say in my nonfiction work, and in some of my fiction work, had been so beautifully and so imaginatively expressed in the work of Grant Morrison.”—Deepak Chopra Grant Morrison is one of the most popular and acclaimed contemporary writers of any genre. His long list of credits as a comic-book writer include JLA, New X-Men, Seven Soldiers, Animal Man, Doom Patrol, The Invisibles, We3, The Filth, and Batman: Arkham Asylum, the bestselling original graphic novel of all time. He is also an award-winning playwright and screenwriter. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Chapter 1 The Sun God and the Dark Knight CALLING ALL RED-BLOODED YOUNG AMERICANS! This certifies that: (your name and address here) has been duly elected a MEMBER of this organization upon the pledge to do everything possible to increase his or her STRENGTH and COURAGE, to aid the cause of JUSTICE, to keep absolutely SECRET the SUPERMAN CODE, and to adhere to all the principles of good citizenship. It may not be the Ten Commandments, but as a set of moral guidelines for the secular children of an age of reason, the Supermen of America creed was a start. This is the story of the founding of a new belief and its conquest of the world: With a stroke of lightning, the spark of divine inspiration ignited cheap newsprint and the superhero was born in an explosion of color and action. From the beginning, the ur-god and his dark twin presented the world with a frame through which our own best and worst impulses could be personified in an epic struggle across a larger- than-life, two-dimensional canvas upon which our outer and inner worlds, our present and future, could be laid out and explored. They came to save us from the existential abyss, but first they had to find a way into our collective imagination. xa0 Superman was the first of the new creatures to arrive, summoned into print in 1938—nine years after the Wall Street crash triggered a catastrophic worldwide depression. In America, banks were toppled, people lost jobs and homes, and, in extreme cases, relocated to hastily convened shantytowns. There were rumblings too from Europe, where the ambitious Chancellor Adolf Hitler had declared himself dictator of Germany following a triumphant election to power five years earlier. With the arrival of the first real-life global supervillain, the stage was set for the Free World’s imaginative response. When the retort came, it was from the ranks of the underdogs; two shy, bespectacled, and imaginative young science fiction fans from Cleveland, who were revving up typewriter and bristol board to unleash a power greater than bombs, giving form to an ideal that would effortlessly outlast Hitler and his dreams of a Thousand Year Reich. xa0 xa0Jerry Siegel and Joseph Shuster spent seven years tinkering with their Superman idea before it was ready to take on the world. Their first attempt at a comic strip resulted in a dystopian sci-fi story based around the idea of an evil psychic despot. The second pass featured a big, tough, but very much human good guy righting wrongs on the mean streets. Neither showed the spark of originality that publishers were seeking. Four years later, after many fruitless attempts to sell Superman as a newspaper strip, Siegel and Shuster finally figured out how to adapt the pacing and construction of their stories to take full advantage of the possibilities of the new comic-book format, and suddenly this fledgling form had found its defining content. xa0 The Superman who made his debut on the cover of Action Comics no. 1 was just a demigod, not yet the pop deity he would become. The 1938 model had the power to “LEAP ⅛th OF A MILE; HURDLE A TWENTY STO RY BUILDING . . . RAISE TREMENDOUS WEIGHTS . . . RUN FASTER THAN AN EXPRESS TRAIN . . . NOT HING LESS THAN A BURSTING SHELL COULD PENETRATE HIS SKIN!” Although “A GENIUS IN INTELLECT. A HERCULES IN STRENGTH. A NEMESIS TO WRONG-DOERS,” this Superman was unable to fly, resorting instead to tremendous single bounds. He could neither orbit the world at the speed of light nor stop the flow of time. That would come later. In his youth, he was almost believable. Siegel and Shuster were careful to ground his adventures in a contemporary city, much like New York, in a fictional world haunted by the all-too-familiar injustices of the real one. xa0 The cover image that introduced the world to this remarkable character had a particular unrepeatable virtue: It showed something no one had ever seen before. It looked like a cave painting waiting to be discovered on a subway wall ten thousand years from now—a powerful, at once futuristic and primitive image of a hunter killing a rogue car. xa0 The vivid yellow background with a jagged corona of red—Superman’s colors—suggested some explosive detonation of raw power illuminating the sky. Aside from the bold Deco whoosh of the Action Comics logo, the date (June 1938), the issue (no. 1), and the price (10 cents), there is no copy and not a single mention of the name Superman . Additional words would have been superfluous. The message was succinct: Action was what mattered. What a hero did counted far more than the things he said, and from the beginning, Superman was in constant motion. xa0 Back to the cover: Look at the black-haired man dressed in a tight-fitting blue and red outfit with a cape trailing behind him as he moves left to right across the drawing’s equator line. The bright shield design on his chest contained an S (gules on a field or, as they say down at the heraldry society). The man is captured in motion, poised on the toes of his left foot, almost taking flight as he weightlessly hefts an olive green car above his head. Using both hands, he hammers the vehicle to fragments against a conveniently placed rocky outcrop in what appears to be a desert landscape. In the bottom left corner, a man with a blue business suit runs off the frame, clutching his head like Edvard Munch’s Scream er, his face a cartoon of gibbering existential terror, like a man driven to the city limits of sanity by what he has just witnessed. Above his head, another man, wearing a conservative brown two-piece, can be seen racing north to the first man’s west. A third, equally terrified, character crouches on his hands and knees, jacketless, gaping at the feet of the superhuman vandal. His abject posture displays his whimpering submission to the ultimate alpha male. There is no fourth man: His place in the lower right corner is taken by a bouncing whitewall tire torn loose from its axle. Like the bug-eyed bad guys, it too is trying its best to get away from the destructive muscleman. xa0 In any other hands but Superman’s, the green roadster on that inaugural cover would boast proudly of America’s technological superiority and the wonders of mass manufacturing. Imagine the oozing ad copy: “luxurious whitewall tire trim makes it seem like you’re driving on whipped cream,” and black-and-white newsreel cars in mind-boggling procession, rolling off the automated belts at Ford. But this was August 1938. Production lines were making laborers redundant across the entire developed world while Charlie Chaplin’s poignant film masterpiece Modern Times articulated in pantomime the silent cry of the little fellow, the authentic man, not to be forgotten above the relentless din of the factory floor. xa0 Superman made his position plain: He was a hero of the people. The original Superman was a bold humanist response to Depression-era fears of runaway scientific advance and soulless industrialism. We would see this early incarnation wrestling giant trains to a standstill, overturning tanks, or bench-pressing construction cranes. Superman rewrote folk hero John Henry’s brave, futile battle with the steam hammer to have a happy ending. He made explicit the fantasies of power and agency that kept the little fellow trudging along toward another sunset fade-out. He was Charlie’s tramp character, with the same burning hatred of injustice and bullies, but instead of guile and charm, Superman had the strength of fifty men, and nothing could hurt him. If the dystopian nightmare visions of the age foresaw a dehumanized, mechanized world, Superman offered another possibility: an image of a fiercely human tomorrow that delivered the spectacle of triumphant individualism exercising its sovereignty over the implacable forces of industrial oppression. It’s no surprise that he was a big hit with the oppressed. He was as resolutely lowbrow, as pro-poor, as any savior born in a pigsty. Returning to the cover again, notice how the composition is based around a barely hidden X shape, which gives the drawing its solid framework and graphic appeal. This subliminal X suggests the intriguing unknown, and that’s exactly what Superman was when Action Comics no. 1 was published: the caped enigma at the eye of a Pop Art storm. He stands at the center of the compass, master of the four elements and the cardinal directions. In Haitian voodoo, the crossroads is the gateway of the loa (or spirit) Legba, another manifestation of the “god” known variously as Mercury, Thoth, Ganesh, Odin, or Ogma. Like these others, Legba is a gatekeeper and guards the boundary where the human and divine worlds make contact. It makes perfect sense for Superman to inhabit the same nexus. As a compositional crossbar, the X composition allowed Shuster to set a number of elements in a spinning motion that highlighted his central figure. There are moving people with expressions on their faces, car parts, and very bright colors, but layered over the firm brace of the X, they form a second, spiral arrangement that drags our eye up and around on a perceptual Ferris wheel, eliciting frantic questions as it compels our minds to motion: xa0 Why is this running man so scared? What’s this car doing up here? Why is it being smashed against a rock? What is the man on his knees looking at? xa0 Knowing what we do of Superman today, we can assume that the fleeing, frightened men are gangsters of some kind. Readers in 1938 simply had no idea what was going on. Undoubtedly, action would be involved, but the first glimpse of Superman was deliberately ambiguous. The men we’ve taken for granted as fleeing gangsters could as easily be ordinary passersby running from a grimacing power thug in some kind of Russian ballet dancer kit. There’s no stolen loot spilling from swag bags, no blue five o’clock shadows, cheap suits, or even weapons to identify the fleeing men as anything other than innocent onlookers. Based on first appearances alone, this gaudy muscleman could be friend or foe, and the only way to answer a multitude of questions is to read on. xa0 But there’s a further innovation to notice, another clever trick to lure us inside. The cover image is a snapshot from the climax of a story we’ve yet to see. By the time the world catches up to Superman, he’s concluding an adventure we’ve already missed! Only by reading the story inside can we put the image in context. xa0 That first, untitled Superman adventure opened explosively on a freezeframe of frantic action. Siegel dumped conventional story setups and cut literally to the chase in a bravura first panel that rearranged the conventional action-story arc in a startling way. The caption box read, “A TIRELESS FIGURE RACES THRU THE NIGHT. SECONDS COUNTu2008. . .DELAY MEANS FORFEIT FOR AN INNOCENT LIFE,” to accompany a Joe Shuster image of Superman leaping through the air with a tied and gagged blond woman under his arm. The image is as confident, muscular, and redolent of threat as Superman himself. xa0 By the second panel, we’ve reached “the Governor’s estate,” and Superman is already sprinting across the lawn, calling back over his shoulder to the bondaged blonde in the foreground, whom he’s dumped by a tree. “MAKE YOURSELF COMFORTABLE! I HAVEN’T TIME TO ATT END TO IT.” We don’t know who this girl is, although Superman’s gruff demeanor implies that she must be a bad egg—unless, as the cover is willing to imply, the star of the strip is the villain. xa0 xa0Already we are compelled through the narrative at Superman’s speed and required to focus on the most significant, most intense elements of every scene as if with supersenses. The only solution is to be swept up in the high velocity slipstream of his streaming red cape, one breathless step behind him. xa0 When the governor’s dressing-gowned butler refused to open the door to the well-built stranger in the skintight suit, Superman smashed it down, sprinted up the stairs with the butler held screaming above his head, then tore a locked steel door off its hinges to reach the terrified (and clearly security-conscious) official within. The butler, in the meantime, had recovered his wits enough to seize a pistol. “PUT THAT TO Y AWAY,” Superman warned, advancing with a clenched fist. The butler fired, only to discover the muscular hero’s immunity to bullets, which bounced harmlessly off his brawny, monogrammed chest. xa0 This virtuoso kinetic overture alone would be worth ten cents from the pocket of any fantasy-starved reader of the Depression. But Siegel and Shuster were not yet done. They still had a masterstroke to play. Just when we think we have this incredible Superman concept figured out, after witnessing the Man of Steel’s prodigious strength and determination, we are treated to Clark Kent—the man behind the S —a man with a job, a boss, and girl trouble. Clark the nerd, the nebbish, the bespectacled, mildmannered shadow self of the confident Man of Steel. The boys had struck a primal mother lode. xa0 Hercules was always Hercules. Agamemnon and Perseus were heroes from the moment they leapt out of bed in the morning until the end of a long battle-crazed day, but Superman was secretly someone else. Clark was the soul, the transcendent element in the Superman equation. Clark Kent is what made him endure. In Clark, Siegel had created the ultimate reader identification figure: misunderstood, put-upon, denied respect in spite of his obvious talents as a newspaperman at Metropolis’s Daily Planet . As both Siegel and Shuster had learned, to their cost, some girls preferred bounding heroic warriors to skinny men who wrote or drew pretty pictures. But Clark Kent was more than the ultimate nerd fantasy; everyone could identify with him. We’ve all felt clumsy and misunderstood, once or twice, or more often, in our lives. Just as everyone suspects the existence of an inner Superman— an angelic, perfect self who personifies only our best moods and deeds— there is something of Clark in all of us. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • From one of the most acclaimed and profound writers in the world of comics comes a thrilling and provocative exploration of humankind’s great modern myth: the superhero
  • The first superhero comic ever published,
  • Action Comics no. 1
  • in 1938, introduced the world to something both unprecedented and timeless: Superman, a caped god for the modern age. In a matter of years, the skies of the imaginary world were filled with strange mutants, aliens, and vigilantes: Batman, Wonder Woman, the Fantastic Four, Iron Man, and the X-Men—the list of names as familiar as our own. In less than a century, they’ve gone from not existing at all to being everywhere we look: on our movie and television screens, in our videogames and dreams. But what are they trying to tell us?For Grant Morrison, arguably the greatest of contemporary chroniclers of the “superworld,” these heroes are powerful archetypes whose ongoing, decades-spanning story arcs reflect and predict the course of human existence: Through them we tell the story of ourselves, our troubled history, and our starry aspirations. In this exhilarating work of a lifetime, Morrison draws on art, science, mythology, and his own astonishing journeys through this shadow universe to provide the first true history of the superhero—why they matter, why they will always be with us, and what they tell us about who we are . . . and what we may yet become.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(119)
★★★★
25%
(100)
★★★
15%
(60)
★★
7%
(28)
23%
(91)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Terrible Book...Pick up WE3 Instead for good Morrison.

Grant Morrison has written some great books. Most notably, Animal Man, Arkham Asylum and WE3. But, I really have a problem getting through a lot of his writing. I do not care for the current Batman he is writing. And while I was looking forward to this book. I just was left uninterested. I read the first couple chapters, started skimming and eventually dropped it in disgust.

I went back later and read some chapters hoping to just skip thr boring bits, but it read like someone writing to impress someone. As much as it pains me, I cannot recommend this book at all.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

More Criticism, Less Autobiography

I am by no means a huge comic book fan but it is difficult to grow up in America when I did and not have some knowledge of the genre--Superman, Batman, and the rest. In particular, I read The Flash and I became a fan of Gaiman's Sandman and Morrison's The Invisibles. There is something about superheroes that keeps us coming back for more. In Supergods, Mr. Morrison tries to put his finger on their appeal from their beginnings in Depression-era comics through their triumph in modern movies.

In many ways, Mr. Morrison is successful in the task he has set for himself. In particular, his analysis of various high points in the history of comics from Action Comics #1 through Watchmen and beyond, is incredibly insightful. His ability to deconstruct the artwork and analyze the text is wonderful. He also is great at criticizing superhero film. If he had stuck entirely to these things, this book would be 5-star.

Unfortunately, in later chapters, when he reaches his own era, the book becomes more autobiographical and his analysis seems less objective. In addition, his strange, drug-fuelled mysticism holds no appeal. I respect the brilliant work that his experiences have inspired in him. On the other hand, it comes off poorly in the face of his often well-reasoned analysis of the work of other writers.

In the end, however, there is much here to enjoy. Superheroes really have permeated our culture and we need the kind of close-read that Mr. Morrison is generally able to provide. Though I will probably stay away from any future autobiography he might write, I would love to see a book from him that is strictly criticism. That would be really worthwhile.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Untruth in Advertising...

Unfortunately this book is more of a history of comics mixed in with a Morrison biography. The philosophical question posed in the title is rarely addressed.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Not Quite Super

This book starts off interesting enough, especially if you're into early comic book history. The origin information is easy to find in many other books and web sites but it's made more interesting by the fact that it's being relayed and analyzed by one of the comic industry's most popular insiders. Of course this also brings with it the pitfall of bias, which grows more prevalent as the book goes on. This is because Morrison seems to use this book as a sort of biography as the timeline gets closer to the present day. While fascinating at times he can be extremely boring at others. When talking about his own experiences outside the comic industry it just seems to drag on and on. Further exacerbating this problem is that, in my opinion, his descriptions are quite self indulgent; using three sentences full of very pretty words to describe everything from a drug "trip" to a trip to the grocery. You can see when his ego gets the better of him when he describes his own work with the same reverence as he describes the work of Stan Lee, Jack Kirby and Steve Ditko. Unfortunately this book is more about the author than the title suggests.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

More auto-biography than statements about mankind

I purchased this (Supergods) because of the sub-title (What Masked Vigilantes, Miraculous Mutants, and a Sun God from Smallville Can Teach Us About Being Human). This book is more a ramble about the influences and career of the author. That's fine if you're a "graphics novel" fan. I was hoping for something more fundamental and substantial. It is well written and the prose, though a bit flowery, are entertaining.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A comic that gets people to think beyond their comfort zone

Back in August 2010, I had the fortune of interviewing Grant Morrison about his career and writing process. During that phone conversation, we discussed SUPERGODS quite briefly and he described the book as "part history. It's mostly like being stuck with me on a very long transatlantic flight (laughs), so it is kind of anecdotes and meditations." SUPERGODS is a difficult book to define and categorize--is it history? Is it cultural studies? As such, Morrison's words are an appropriate and apt attempt to classify it. Yet, if the book itself is hard to define thematically, the perplexing nature of assigning a specific audience--comics aficionados versus the general, non-comic reading public--is even harder and calls into question who is Morrison's targeted readership with this text?

As a New York Times bestselling author, Morrison has achieved a notoriety beyond incestuous comics circles and their public relations-driven media, as well as the insularly, almost self-isolationist nature of comics culture. Therefore, there is sufficient evidence to believe that Random House and Spiegel & Grau are banking on his crossover appeal to market the book to more than fans of sequential art and literature. The fact that a non-comics industry publisher with greater resources outside simply the Direct Market has undertaken this publishing effort is perhaps the most significant factor. However, despite the assignment of a publisher with ample credits in producing serious, critical nonfiction, SUPERGODS, like most "histories" written by insiders, suffers greatly from either a lack of historical context or a misinterpretation of historical fact. While this is somewhat easier to dismiss in comics-industry-published "histories," readers with even a cursory educated knowledge of American history, cultural theory, and popular culture may be disappointed by Morrison. In fact, the greatest strength of the work comes when Morrison moves beyond rehashing the well-travelled roads of commercial comics "history" and instead engages in a vivid exploration of memory and his life.

Although Morrison is flexing a different set of muscles with SUPERGODS, his writing reveals a sharp and crisp, flowing prose. In fact, the addition of an introduction to the advance review edition is perhaps the greatest testament to his nonfiction skills as it synthesizes, in some cases better than the chapters themselves, his own personal narrative into the larger theme of superheroes and what they represent. One of the greatest enjoyments of the book though is Morrison's wit, humor, and wordplay as he chronicles the creation of the superhero genre. Already a well-told story to those familiar with the medium, in it, Morrison infuses comedic beats and personal revelations into the narrative that divorce the reader from his omniscient, objective persona, but also serve to break the sometimes disjointing laundry list coverage of world mythologies he employs as evidence for superheroes' relevance in contemporary 21st-century culture. When Morrison sticks with this softer approach or moves instead to the autobiographical chapters about his childhood in Scotland, his passion for writing and pursuit of a career, and his eventual entrance into the profession, SUPERGODS forms an important connection with the reader that humanizes its author and makes for an interesting and entertaining experience.

Time and again, Morrison has proven himself as comics' reigning idea or concept man when it comes to revitalizing the static, often stale superhero genre. Although many will quibble and argue about his exact ability at execution and conveying these ideas in comics, and rightly so in some instances, Morrison suffers a similar fate when he tries to articulate these memes beyond the comic book pages. While Morrison recognizes that SUPERGODS is only a partial history, he is nevertheless engaging with it and thus responsible in part for accuracy and authenticity. For example, when discussing the birth of Superman and analyzing the 1938 cover of Action Comics #1, Morrison notes "production lines were making laborers redundant across the entire developed world" and that Superman was "a hero of the people...a bold humanist response to Depression-era fears of runaway scientific advance and soulless industrialism" (6). It was not production lines that were making laborers scarce, but rather the Great Depression. It was a fear of finding employment and a question of who would control the technology and industry that were the promise of labor's future, not the deterrent of it. Not to descend into an American History 101 lecture, but students of history with a textbook knowledge of the New Deal state should recognize the fallacy in Morrison's assessment. Superman is definitely a hero of the people, but he is also the personification of the New Deal state and attempts at curbing exploitation of the working class. Although Morrison reasserts the sound case for the originality and enduring power of the Clark Kent persona, as well as the increasing popularity of the superhero motif in the late 1930s and early 1940s, his reliance on Superman as a modern incarnation of Apollo or Zeus or Moses, Karnataka, or even Christ as a justification for the character's relevance to Depression and World War II era audiences ignores the deepest connection to the culture and society that bore him. It is not Morrison's ideas that are problematic, but the dearth of factual evidence to support them.

When Morrison moves beyond the pop-history interpretation and instead delves into a comparison contrast with DC Comics' Batman, his analysis and argument hold greater value. Also, Morrison's own passion for comics and their characters begins to emerge in Chapter 2 as he discusses his personal affinity for Fawcett's Captain Marvel. Yet, the tenuous nature of his asserted connection between Captain Marvel and Elvis as a "cross-pollination between comics and popular music" or the unsubstantiated statement on Ken Kesey and Captain Marvel may frustrate some readers. Subsequently, his overview of Wonder Woman and Captain America's arrival on the scene retells the all too familiar in Chapter 3.

There is a certain power and potency in Morrison's description, however, of postwar comics and the decline of superheroes that makes the well-trodden and widely known discourse fresh and seemingly anew. And, when he transitions into the Silver Age, Chapter 5: "Superman on the Couch" is superb as is his assessment of the Flash as the first truly modern superhero in Chapter 6. As the "anecdotes and meditations" continue, Morrison raises important points on Marvel's supplanting of DC and the American mainstream's rejection of comics during the 1960s that deserve further attention and serious exploration by comics scholars.

Rather abruptly though, Morrison downshifts into autobiography amid Chapter 8 and the remainder of SUPERGODS attempts to weave his personal life narrative into the larger comics structure he has been crafting. The most successful harmonization of the two strands occurs in his reading of Jack Kirby, Roy Thomas, Jim Starlin, and Steve Engleheart, and their infusion of psychedelia into comics. Although Morrison asserts this move was subversive, he provides no barometer against which to measure it in popular culture when in fact most of what comics did in the late 1960s and 1970s seems an imitation of films, music, and art than an equal cultural innovator. The hybridization does not work as well, however, when Morrison tackles the appearance of social relevance in comics as he neglects any critique of the substance behind those issues. Instead, a summary coverage of Green Lantern/Green Arrow follows as he discusses the inclusion of "Orientals" (155) and other ethic racial groups into the series, yet does not move beyond a brief look at only African Americans. He states that with the creation of John Stewart, "the potential for tokenism was there" but does not exist (156). Morrison points to the character's longevity and popularity but fails to acknowledge that longevity does not equal inclusion nor erode marginalization. There is also little substantive discussion of women's liberation.

The remainder of SUPERGODS follows this pattern. Highlights include Morrison's tight analysis of and reverence for Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, his panel critique and breakdown of Watchmen and its author Alan Moore, and the arrival and importance of Image Comics. Morrison also relates a fascinating biography of Frank Quitely's artistic influences and his discussion of Flex Mentallo is the first time Morrison ties his own comics work into the larger context and theme of the book. A similar connection is made later with his JLA series. Yet, awkward transitions between ideas either regarding comic titles and their authors, or comics and films, along with a disjointed assessment of his own Final Crisis, and a somewhat rambling, encyclopedic overview of later comics made into films round out SUPERGODS.

Although Morrison's ideas about what comics teach about humanity are never fully developed beyond the addition of a succinct and tailored conclusion (perhaps a chapter on villains and the notions of good versus evil?), SUPERGODS still holds value for general audiences, comics fans, and comics scholars alike. First, Morrison's ideas are worthy of attention and further exploration. While their execution here is somewhat troublesome, Morrison has introduced concepts and areas that deserve debate and educated, informed discourse. Second, the relationship of superheroes to figures of global, mythic traditions needs development within an analysis of the role of such figures in contemporary societies and cultures--when did these mythic traditions lose their influence and how do superheroes uphold those values? Or do superheroes do more than simply modernize these classic characters for a new generation? Potentially, Morrison's greatest value may be in the unintended audience of the classroom, where such conversations and dialogues could proceed. Like his comics, SUPERGODS is certain to reinforce the already polarized opinions of the comics reading public toward Grant Morrison; however, if his comics, both the successes and the failures, have proven anything, it is that getting people to think beyond their comfort zones is a noble pursuit, and one that SUPERGODS admirably achieves.

-- Nathan Wilson
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A chaos-fueled Morrison autobiography

First off, I can see why a lot of people may not care for Morrison's book. It is, perhaps, not entirely promoted correctly. At the very end of the book, Morison gives details on how this had actually started out as two distinct projects that merged into one. While I can understand that many people may find the results dissatisfying, I adored this book from cover to cover. Of course, I happen to love author autobiographies, comic books and all things related to the philosophy of chaos. I know I'm the odd one.

Perhaps the only thing keeping this from a 5 star rating was the way he set up the chapters, or shall we say, his somewhat lax organization on them. I'm perfectly fine with reading a book that's part comics history, part autobiography, and part magickal grimoire... but it needed to be balanced better. Even someone such as myself with similar interests found it hard to follow on occasion.

Ultimately, this is book about Grant Morrison. Comic books are so intrinsically tied to his existence and philosophies, it became a major factor in composing the manuscript. Random fans of comic books AREN'T going to appreciate it, nor was it really written for them. If anything, it's for fans of Grant Morrison himself, fans of the "type" of fiction he has a tendency to write. It's for other authors, alt-philosophers, and the radical left.

And I find I'm okay with that.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Not for everyone, but 5 stars anyway...

Maybe I'm not following proper tradition by giving 5 stars to something not everyone will love equally, but I just can't help myself. I really loved this book. It's is impossibly ambitious, a prediction of a future fifth dimensional world mind, an explanation of a platonic superhero ideal that insists on boot strapping itself into our universe, and a often deeply personal memoir of a very unusual man. Oh yeah, and woven in between all that is the entire history of comic book super heroes since the very early Golden Age. Just like Super Man will make you believe a man can fly, "Super Gods" will make you believe a man can face death itself and emerge with a better costume and 5-D vision. A masterwork for our psychedelic future.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Typical Morrison, WAY to wordy

I love my comics and also love comic book history. That said, this was typical Grant Morrison, very wordy, preachy and nonsensical. As many have said before, when he's good he's great(All Star Superman, excellent!) but when he's bad he makes NO sense whatsoever (Final Crisis, HUH?). This is a mixture of both. If you like your comics highbrow, something you get the sense he loves, this is your book. His hyperbole description of comic history is just, ok. It reads like some masters students grand thesis, not very entertaining.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Good read

Good read.