The Battle of Bretton Woods: John Maynard Keynes, Harry Dexter White, and the Making of a New World Order (Council on Foreign Relations Books (Princeton University Press))
The Battle of Bretton Woods: John Maynard Keynes, Harry Dexter White, and the Making of a New World Order (Council on Foreign Relations Books (Princeton University Press)) book cover

The Battle of Bretton Woods: John Maynard Keynes, Harry Dexter White, and the Making of a New World Order (Council on Foreign Relations Books (Princeton University Press))

Hardcover – Deckle Edge, February 24, 2013

Price
$23.42
Format
Hardcover
Pages
480
Publisher
Princeton University Press
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0691149097
Dimensions
6.59 x 1.38 x 9.27 inches
Weight
1.81 pounds

Description

"Winner of the 2013 Spear's Book Award in Financial History""Co-Winner of the 2014 Bronze Medal in Economics, Axiom Business Book Awards""One of The Motley Fool’s (John Reeves) 10 Great Books on American Economic History 2014""One of Financial Times (FT.com) Best History Books of 2013""One of Bloomberg News’ Top Business Books of 2013""One of Kirkus Reviews’ Best Nonfiction Books of the Year for 2013 in Business and Economics""One of Bloomberg/Businessweek Best Books of 2013, as selected individually by Fredrik Erixon, Scott Minerd, Olli Rehn and Alan Greenspan""Featured in The Sunday Times 2013 Holiday Roundup""Shortlisted for the 2013 800-CEO-READ Business Book Awards in Finance & Economics""Honorable Mention for the 2014 Arthur Ross Book Award, Council on Foreign Relations""Shortlisted for the 2014 Lionel Gelber Prize, Lionel Gelber Foundation"" The Battle of Bretton Woods should become the gold standard on its topic. The details are addictive." ---Fred Andrews, New York Times "A superb history. Mr. Steil . . . is a talented storyteller." ---James Grant, Wall Street Journal "Steil's book, engaging and entertaining, perceptive and instructive, is a triumph of economic and diplomatic history. Everything is here: political chicanery, bureaucratic skulduggery, espionage, hard economic detail and the acid humour of men making history under pressure." ---Tony Barber, Financial Times "Steil, a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, understands the economic issues at stake and has done meticulous research on the history. Every good story that has ever been told about the major actors involved and the happening itself is in his book, and a few more besides. For those who come fresh to the subject, and even for those who know most of it, it is an excellent and revealing account." ---Robert Skidelsky, New York Review of Books "[A] masterful (and readable) account of American realpolitik and British delusion." ---Andrew Hilton, Financial World "This is a fantastic book. Gold and money, two of my favorite topics. It's also brilliantly insightful history, and a gripping spy thriller to boot." ---Larry Kudlow, CNBC "[T]he author masterfully translates the arcana of competing theories of monetary policy, and a final chapter explains how, while some of the institutions created by Bretton Woods endure--the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund--many of the conference's assumptions were swiftly overtaken by the Marshall Plan. Throughout Steil's sharp discussion runs the intriguing subplot of White's career-long, secret relationship with Soviet intelligence. A vivid, highly informed portrayal of the personalities, politics and policies dominating 'the most important international gathering since the Paris Peace Conference of 1919.'" ― Kirkus Reviews "In his masterful account, The Battle of Bretton Woods , Steil situates the conference firmly in the tense, heightened atmosphere of the final months of World War II. . . . Steil's book comes alive in his description of [Keynes' and White's] contrasting experiences at the conference." ---Sam Knight, Bloomberg News "[H]ypnotically readable." ---Peter Passell, Milken Institute Review "[T]hought provoking and well written." ---Kathleen Burk, Literary Review "This is an excellent book. . . . [It] also contains some explosive revelations about White's work as a Soviet spy, very well documented I might add." ---Tyler Cowen, Marginal Revolution "If you think economics and finance are dry subjects at best, Steil's book offers a refreshing surprise. It's a political thriller in which the protagonists, one whom you think you know and one whom you probably don't, are much more intriguing (in both senses of the word) than they first appear." ---Daniel Altman, Big Think "[I]n a new book explaining what really happened at Bretton Woods, Benn Steil shows that what happened in the mountains of New Hampshire that summer is not quite the story we have been told." ---Neil Irwin, WashingtonPost.com "[Benn Steil's] new book The Battle of Bretton Woods is perhaps the most accessible study yet of a key moment in world economic history that nonetheless is poorly understood." ---Kevin Carmichael, Globe & Mail "The clash between Keynes and White forms a central theme in Benn Steil's absorbing book, which should be required reading for anyone who wants to understand the not-so-special relationship between the US and Britain." ---Geoffrey Owen, Standpoint Magazine "[F]ascinating. . . . Steil . . . spins the tale of how U.S. Treasury Secretary Henry Morgenthau, a close friend of President Franklin D. Roosevelt, allowed White, a little-known economist who wasn't even on the U.S. Treasury's regular payroll, to dominate the department's monetary and trade policies beginning in the 1930s." ---John M. Barry, USA Today "[A] well-written, fascinating history of the Bretton Woods conference on the international monetary system in July 1941. The book is deep, well researched, and hard to put down. Benn Steil . . . has produced a book that will help us to understand history, but also one we can use to contrast with the current international economic situation. . . . This is a very good book." ---John M. Mason, Seeking Alpha "I do hope the title of this riveting read does not put off readers who mistake Benn Steil's latest work for an arcane discussion of exchange rates, the gold standard and the stuff of debates in commons rooms. This book is more than that, much more. It is a tale of a battle of titans and of a war between nations, each intent on establishing the economic architecture that would ensure its postwar economic domination of world finance." ---Irwin Stelzer, Sunday Times "[V]ivid personality portraits and a lively writing style." ---Mike Foster, Financial News "[F]ascinating. . . . [R]iveting. . . . The Battle of Bretton Woods is chock-full of provocative and timely observations." ---Glenn C. Altschuler, Tulsa World "President Obama would be wise to take it to Martha's Vineyard this summer." ---John Tamny, Forbes.com "Benn Steil has just completed a fascinating book that looks at what really happened in the small New Hampshire town of Bretton Woods in 1944. Perhaps most surprising is that the real story that emerges isn't a tale of how 44 countries came together to rebuild the world. And the real story has different lessons for the 21st century than ambitious idealists might expect." ---Andrew Sawers, Economia "[A] splendid book. . . . If you want to understand the gold standard, the always-doomed dollar standard, why the IMF is in Washington, how the US deliberately humiliated Britain over debt before, during and after WWII as part of a very real currency war (but also out of genuine anti-colonial sentiment that the British never understood), this is the book for you. . . . Every year publishers come out with a couple of purportedly serious books on FX, some by VIPs, and I read them all. This is the only one since Paul Volcker's Changing Fortunes in 1979 that is worth the price. It is non-partisan, well-written, thorough, and chock-full of the historical perspective that can so easily and so often get lost in the hurly-burly of the daily market." ---Barbara Rockefeller, Harriman Intelligence blog "[A] provocative, lively and perceptive book that pulls together economics, politics, diplomacy and history and relates it to our current crisis." ---Keith Simpson MP, Total Politics "This thorough, fascinating account of the international conference that culminated in the 1944 agreement to maintain stable exchange rates skillfully places it in its economic and geopolitical context. . . . Steil not only recounts the intricacies of the deal making but also details the economic dimensions of Bretton Woods. . . . With the help of 10 research assistants, Steil has tirelessly tracked down minute details of the Bretton Woods story and its epilogue. . . . [Steil] offers excellent insight into the tribulations of the key players. He also tells the interesting tale of how, if not for the well-founded suspicions regarding Harry Dexter White's cooperation with Communist spies, the tradition of an American heading the World Bank and a European heading the IMF would have been reversed." ― Financial Analysts Journal "Steil understands the economics at the heart of the tortuous negotiations, but he is also very good at explaining the politics, the power and the passions--the professional and personal rivalries--of the people at the negotiating table. He turns what could have been a dry account of economic accords into a thrilling story of ambition, drama, and intrigue." ---Keith Richmond, Tribune Magazine "[A] very well-written history, with lively personalities, [which] also serves as a great overview of the analytical issues in international monetary arrangements." ---Diane Coyle, Enlightened Economist "Absorbing . . . as an account of history-making at the highest level, this entertaining, informative, gossipy and, for the lay reader, often challenging book provides an excellent read." ---Richard Steyn, Financial Mail "[A]n amazing true story . . . highly entertaining." ---Ian McMaster, Business Spotlight "An object lesson in how to make economic history at once entertaining and instructive." ― Financial Times "A valuable addition to the economic history literature." ― Choice "It's always nice when you can combine outside reading for fun with something that is educational. . . . [A] good read that is also good for you." ---Daniel Shaviro, Jotwell "The book provides a terrifically written, gossipy account of the origins of Bretton Woods. . . . Since the world spent several decades under the clumsy (and, to the U.S., costly) Bretton Woods regime, and since you sometimes hear people harkening back to that time as a golden age (which it surely was not), . . . it is an important read for our day." ---Dan Littman, Senior Payments Research Consultant and Economist, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland "Benn Steil [of the] Council on Foreign Relations has written a fascinating book on the two main architects behind the Bretton Woods system. . . . Steil's book is an outstanding piece of political science research . . . extremely well written and well documented. . . . It is strongly recommended." ---Morten Balling, SUERF Newsletter "Benn Steil's remarkable book . . . is an account of how the IMF first came to be, back in the sleepy New Hampshire summer of 1944. . . . The Battle of Bretton Woods is an essential volume in any understanding of John Maynard Keynes, who though now seven decades gone is as influential a mind as we may yet see in the twenty-first century." ---Brian Domitrovic, Library of Law and Liberty blog "Steil's book . . . shows how normally abstruse economic and diplomatic history can be made palatable and even alluring to the general reader." ---Christopher Silvester, Spear's "[A] fascinating account of the developments leading up to the Bretton Woods conference and its immediate aftermath, from the point of view of the two main characters involved: John Maynard Keynes and Harry Dexter White. The book is based on extensive archive work, so often the participants speak for themselves, which makes for interesting reading." ---Isaac Alfon, Central Banking Journal " The Battle of Bretton Woods sets forth in smooth prose and concise detail an authoritative narrative of the who-what-when-why of the great monetary conference of some 70 years ago. It is jam-packed with heady discussions. . . . If we're fortunate, Benn Steil will deliver a follow-up." ---Kevin R. Kosar, Weekly Standard "Individual persons are at the center of the story, which also comes loaded with tales of international intrigue, spycraft, and famous personalities. It's not just for history buffs and economics geeks." ---Douglas French, Freeman "Seduced by Keynes's rhetorical repudiation both of the 'austerity' implied by [promptly paying off Britain's war debts] and the 'temptation' of accepting a loan, the British shipped Keynes to Washington . . . to seek 'justice', to wit, the third option. In his recent history of the period, Benn Steil deftly paints what ensued." ---Patrick Honohan, Irish Times "[T]his thought-provoking book is about much more than the 1944 conference that established the architecture of the postwar international monetary system, leading to the establishment of the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank." ― Foreign Affairs "Benn Steil has crafted a fine history. . . . Characterized by fine and entertaining writing, The Battle of Bretton Woods is economic and political history in engrossing detail." ---Satyajit Das, Naked Capitalism "Benn Steil provides a well-researched and interesting account of the historic monetary conference. . . . His efforts make for an enjoyable read. . . . Steil is perhaps at his best when articulating how the Bretton Woods system differed from the classical gold standard--a difference that would ultimately lead to the failure of Bretton Woods. . . . Steil's excellent book should serve as a gentle reminder of which monetary systems have worked well in the past--and which should not be repeated." ---William J. Luther, SSRN's Economic History eJournal "An informed citizenry includes an understanding of our economy and how it is integrated into the global financial system. For this, it is important to start from the . . . discussions that occurred among 44 nations in the idyllic and calm resort at Bretton Woods, N.H., in 1944. [Benn Steil's] new book details not only the meeting but the deep arguments between the British economist John Maynard Keynes and [American Treasury official] Harry Dexter White. . . . This is a serious book of political economic history." ---Cmdr. Youssef Aboul-Enein, DCMilitary "Benn Steil's book provides a fascinating account of the developments leading up to the Bretton Woods conference and its immediate aftermath, from the point of view of the two main characters involved: John Maynard Keynes and Harry Dexter White. The book is based on extensive archive work, so often the participants speak for themselves, which makes for interesting reading." ---Isaac Alfon, Central Banking Journal "This masterful account dismantles the idyllic picture of the 1944 Bretton Woods international economic conference, situating it firmly in the tense atmosphere of the final months of World War II." ---Laurie Muchnick, Bloomberg "Steil's book is an object lesson in how to make economic history entertaining and instructive." ---Tony Barber, Financial Times "Benn Steil not only produces the finest account of the conference that established the Pax Americana economic system after World War II, he does it with the skill of a novelist." ---Jon Talton, SeattleTimes.com "[A] well-documented, engaging account of the Bretton Woods Conference. . . . The material on Harry Dexter White is fascinating . . . an essential reference [with] much to teach economic historians." ---Joshua Hausman, Journal of Economic History " The Battle of Bretton Woods is a thorough and fascinating account of a historic event, skillfully placed in its economic and geopolitical context. [H]e offers excellent insight into the tribulations of the key players. He also tells the interesting tale of how, if not for the well-founded suspicions regarding Harry Dexter White's cooperation with Communist spies, the tradition of an American heading the World Bank and a European heading the IMF would have been reversed." ---Martin S. Fridson, Financial Analysts Journal "Steil's book is essential reading for students of multilateralism, diplomacy, and international economic relations. . . . It is also an excellent overview of the behind-the-scenes machinations that caused Britain to agree to the final document that placed America, and the dollar, at the top of the global financial pyramid. . . . [O]f primary interest to most readers . . . it is a fascinating and nuanced glimpse into the psychology of Second World War era economic espionage." ---Marc D. Froese, International Journal "This story is well told. It is also well known. . . . Steil is targeting a broader audience than scholars, however, and in that sense, this book is a success at recasting a surprisingly exciting story." ---Thomas W. Zeiler, Register of the Kentucky Historical Society "Steil breathes new life and controversy into a familiar story by emphasizing the intellectual and political clash between John Maynard Keynes and Harry Dexter White." ---James McAllister, H-Diplo/ISSF Roundtable "Steil rarely puts a foot wrong. His analysis of policies and personalities, however he has acquired his knowledge, reflects a sophisticated understanding of the inner workings of financial diplomacy." ---Stephen Schuker, H-Diplo/ISSF Roundtable "[A]n ably crafted narrative." ---Darel Paul, H-Diplo/ISSF Roundtable "[The book] is a welcome departure from less political, or more American-centric, accounts of Bretton Woods." ---William Glenn Gray, H-Diplo/ISSF Roundtable "[T]his is a beautiful narrative of the making of Bretton Woods, based on serious archival research and with some nice old photos as illustrations." ---Ivo Maes, History of Economic Ideas " The Battle of Bretton Woods is a remarkable work that embraces many disciplines: economic history, political economy and international relations. Benn Steil is able to merge the different perspectives from all these disciplines, taking the reader into both the political battle and the economic thinking." ---Anna Missiaia, Financial History Review "A gripping account. . . . John Le Carre meets international monetary history: this is clearly a different kind of page-turner." ---Jayati Ghosh, Economic & Political Weekly " The Battle of Bretton Woods is a remarkable work that embraces many disciplines: history, economic history, political economy and international relations. Benn Steil is able to merge the different perspectives from all these disciplines, taking the reader into both the political battle and the economic thinking that took place at Bretton Woods." ---Anna Missiaia, Financial History Review "Epic." ---Ashok Rao, Vox "[E]ngaging and instructive . . . Benn Steil has written a book full of historical insight and human color." ---Robert L. Hetzel, Econ Focus "[A] good piece of historical investigation that will put an end to doubts as to whether White was in fact a Soviet agent." ---Maria Cristina Marcuzzo, Economica "[A] thoughtful and well-researched addition to economic history." ---Mark L. Wilson, Journal of Economic Issues "With extensive, original research, Benn Steil has rewritten the history of the conference. Steil reveals the illusions of its two central figures: John Maynard Keynes, the most famous economist of the twentieth century and a senior member of the British delegation, and Harry Dexter White, the little-known assistant secretary of the US Treasury, who almost singlehandedly ran the conference. . . . A major contribution to economic, intellectual, and political history, which is accessible to a wide audience and presents an endlessly fascinating portrait of two complicated men." ---Carl, Strikwerda, The Historian "Benn Steil's The Battle of Bretton Woods is a superb, carefully researched history that enables readers to view today and tomorrow from the vantage point of the past." ---Robert B. Zoellick, International Economy " The Battle of Bretton Woods offers a tantalizing peek into another time of financial stress compounded by a world war. . . . The chess match between White and Keynes is well worth the price of admission--the price of the book and the time it takes to read it." ---Don R. Leet, American Economist " The Battle of Bretton Woods is a well-researched and excellently written book that is recommended for everyone interested in economic and diplomatic history." ---Tobias Leeg, Political Studies Review "Benn Steil has written a wonderfully rich and vivid account of the making of the postwar economic order. The Battle of Bretton Woods tells the fascinating story of the contest between the United States and Britain, led by the outsized personalities of Harry Dexter White and John Maynard Keynes, to reconcile their competing visions and interests." ―Liaquat Ahamed, author of Lords of Finance "A riveting, exceptionally well-written account of the birth of the postwar economic order, and the roles of two determined men who were competing to define it. The Battle of Bretton Woods is a must-read work of economic and diplomatic history with great relevance to today." ―Alan Greenspan, former chairman of the Federal Reserve "This is a fascinating study of monetary affairs and the politics of international finance, all tied up in the history of the Bretton Woods system and its ultimate demise. The book is full of lessons that are relevant today in a world that still resists international monetary reform." ―Paul Volcker, former chairman of the Federal Reserve "Benn Steil has written a fascinating book with far-reaching consequences. In seeing the creation of the postwar economic system through the prism of the harsh interaction between Keynes and White, he makes complicated financial issues easy to fathom. Above all, Steil conclusively establishes the truth of an astonishing paradox―that White, the architect of the global capitalist financial architecture, was also a secret agent of the Soviet Union!" ―Andrew Roberts, author of The Storm of War "Beautifully and engagingly written, deeply researched, and of great contemporary interest, this book addresses how Bretton Woods really worked. One virtue of the book is that it places the United States and its chief negotiator, the enigmatic Harry Dexter White, at the center of the narrative. It also documents more fully and convincingly than any previous account the extent of White's espionage on behalf of the Soviet Union, a story that enhances an already gripping narrative." ―Harold James, author of Making the European Monetary Union From the Inside Flap "Benn Steil has written a wonderfully rich and vivid account of the making of the postwar economic order. The Battle of Bretton Woods tells the fascinating story of the contest between the United States and Britain, led by the outsized personalities of Harry Dexter White and John Maynard Keynes, to reconcile their competing visions and interests." --Liaquat Ahamed, author of Lords of Finance "A riveting, exceptionally well-written account of the birth of the postwar economic order, and the roles of two determined men who were competing to define it. The Battle of Bretton Woods is a must-read work of economic and diplomatic history with great relevance to today." --Alan Greenspan, former chairman of the Federal Reserve "This is a fascinating study of monetary affairs and the politics of international finance, all tied up in the history of the Bretton Woods system and its ultimate demise. The book is full of lessons that are relevant today in a world that still resists international monetary reform." --Paul Volcker, former chairman of the Federal Reserve "Benn Steil has written a fascinating book with far-reaching consequences. In seeing the creation of the postwar economic system through the prism of the harsh interaction between Keynes and White, he makes complicated financial issues easy to fathom. Above all, Steil conclusively establishes the truth of an astonishing paradox--that White, the architect of the global capitalist financial architecture, was also a secret agent of the Soviet Union!" --Andrew Roberts, author of The Storm of War "Beautifully and engagingly written, deeply researched, and of great contemporary interest, this book addresses how Bretton Woods really worked. One virtue of the book is that it places the United States and its chief negotiator, the enigmatic Harry Dexter White, at the center of the narrative. It also documents more fully and convincingly than any previous account the extent of White's espionage on behalf of the Soviet Union, a story that enhances an already gripping narrative." --Harold James, author of Making the European Monetary Union "Benn Steil has written a wonderfully rich and vivid account of the making of the postwar economic order. The Battle of Bretton Woods tells the fascinating story of the contest between the United States and Britain, led by the outsized personalities of Harry Dexter White and John Maynard Keynes, to reconcile their competing visions and interests." --Liaquat Ahamed, author of Lords of Finance "A riveting, exceptionally well-written account of the birth of the postwar economic order, and the roles of two determined men who were competing to define it. The Battle of Bretton Woods is a must-read work of economic and diplomatic history with great relevance to today." --Alan Greenspan, former chairman of the Federal Reserve "This is a fascinating study of monetary affairs and the politics of international finance, all tied up in the history of the Bretton Woods system and its ultimate demise. The book is full of lessons that are relevant today in a world that still resists international monetary reform." --Paul Volcker, former chairman of the Federal Reserve "Benn Steil has written a fascinating book with far-reaching consequences. In seeing the creation of the postwar economic system through the prism of the harsh interaction between Keynes and White, he makes complicated financial issues easy to fathom. Above all, Steil conclusively establishes the truth of an astonishing paradox--that White, the architect of the global capitalist financial architecture, was also a secret agent of the Soviet Union!" --Andrew Roberts, author of The Storm of War "Beautifully and engagingly written, deeply researched, and of great contemporary interest, this book addresses how Bretton Woods really worked. One virtue of the book is that it places the United States and its chief negotiator, the enigmatic Harry Dexter White, at the center of the narrative. It also documents more fully and convincingly than any previous account the extent of White's espionage on behalf of the Soviet Union, a story that enhances an already gripping narrative." --Harold James, author of Making the European Monetary Union Benn Steil is senior fellow and director of international economics at the Council on Foreign Relations. His previous book, Money, Markets, and Sovereignty , was awarded the 2010 Hayek Book Prize. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • A sweeping history of the drama, intrigue, and rivalry behind the creation of the postwar economic order
  • When turmoil strikes world monetary and financial markets, leaders invariably call for 'a new Bretton Woods' to prevent catastrophic economic disorder and defuse political conflict. The name of the remote New Hampshire town where representatives of forty-four nations gathered in July 1944, in the midst of the century's second great war, has become shorthand for enlightened globalization. The actual story surrounding the historic Bretton Woods accords, however, is full of startling drama, intrigue, and rivalry, which are vividly brought to life in Benn Steil's epic account.Upending the conventional wisdom that Bretton Woods was the product of an amiable Anglo-American collaboration, Steil shows that it was in reality part of a much more ambitious geopolitical agenda hatched within President Franklin D. Roosevelt's Treasury and aimed at eliminating Britain as an economic and political rival. At the heart of the drama were the antipodal characters of John Maynard Keynes, the renowned and revolutionary British economist, and Harry Dexter White, the dogged, self-made American technocrat. Bringing to bear new and striking archival evidence, Steil offers the most compelling portrait yet of the complex and controversial figure of White―the architect of the dollar's privileged place in the Bretton Woods monetary system, who also, very privately, admired Soviet economic planning and engaged in clandestine communications with Soviet intelligence officials and agents over many years.A remarkably deft work of storytelling that reveals how the blueprint for the postwar economic order was actually drawn,
  • The Battle of Bretton Woods
  • is destined to become a classic of economic and political history.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(125)
★★★★
25%
(105)
★★★
15%
(63)
★★
7%
(29)
23%
(96)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Epic Battle of Epic Historical Importance

"Battle of Bretton Woods" by Benn Steil

Benn Steil is an exceptional scholar hailing from the Council on Foreign Relations. I approached this book with high expectations and was not disappointed. If I had a buck for every blog, article, or interview referring to the Bretton Woods conference, dollar hegemony, the gold standard, and related monetary matters I could stop reading stuff like this because I would be rich. I surmise, however, that not one in 100 understand what really happened. I do not know if this is THE definitive work on the Bretton Woods conference but it certainly is a definitive treatise. Those who love quotes will burn through a few highlighters. (I did.) The intense discussions--snarky attacks and counterattacks by the combatants--are relayed in detail and in living color. Steil successfully takes you back to the events as though you were there. Minor warning: You do not need to be a wonk to love this book, but you must have some appreciation for wonky. It is not dumbed down to the lowest common denominator. Currency jocks will love the detailed descriptions of the battles over fixed exchange rates, adjustable exchange rates, free trade, dollar hegemony, and the role of gold in this new era.

Steil's discussion can be crudely described in three parts: (1) the decades leading up to the 1944 Bretton Woods conference; (2) the actual conference in which the next 50 years of currency exhanges and global trading rules would be mapped out; and (3) the consequences to the post-war world. The conference stemmed from a few astute players who realized that the world could fall into chaos if plans were not made in advance to establish a global currency regime and rules of global trade--a New World Order. This is that story and the subplots that bring life to the historically profound period.

At stake was a power struggle between the British and the US to establish post war dominance. My preconceived (and decidedly incorrect) notion of WWII was naively simple: the Brits got in a pan-European brawl; the isolationist-prone US sent massive military weaponry and aid via the Lend-Lease program to their strong ally; with Pearl Harbor as a proximate trigger, we entered the war. In reality, the Americans and the British were in a battle royale. The British were trying to establish an aid arrangement that would leave them strong enough to recover some of their imperial splendor after the war. The Americans placed extremely stringent demands on the so-called Lend-Lease program with the explicit intention of leaving the British economically prostrate to ensure American hegemony. There was nothing warm and fuzzy about the alliance. The Battle of Bretton Woods was indeed a battle spanning a number of years, and it got very ugly.

A large portion of the fight was by proxy through two critical figures. Economist John Maynard Keynes, one of the most prominent intellects of the 20th century (whether you like his economic theories or not, which I don't) squared off against Harry Dexter White, a determined yet highly enigmatic American. These two guys were attempting to determine the fate of the global economy through a war of wits and fierce negotions over three years preceeding the conference and at the conference with representatives from dozens of nations. At the conclusion of the conference, each was forced to turn their ample skill to beat back fierce resistance with their respective political elites back home to sell the agreements. It was arguably a fight to the death: both White and Keynes died of heart attacks soon thereafter. One could legitimately argue the Battle killed them.

My image of and respect for Keynes evolved enormously, not as an economist but rather as an unlikely diplomat. He was cantankerous to a fault, but he somehow found a way to compromise when necessary to optimize an otherwise very weak position for Britain and, most importantly, help seal an historically profound agreement. Harry Dexter White's character is confounding and enigmatic. He displayed an unorthodox desire for a strong post-war Russian-Soviet alliance. His pro-Soviet stance is a fascinating sub-plot that only begins to clarify in the post war (cold war) period.

The detailed analysis up to the mid 1950s gives way to a relatively brief synopsis in which Steil races us through the next half century briskly. This final portion, most of which is contained in the Epilogue, is filled with subject matter popular in the blogosphere that I had read many, many times. Steil takes us through deGaulle demanding gold, Nixon taking us off the last residue of the gold standard, the dollar's impact as the reserve currency, and central bankers aggressively fiddling with monetary policy. There was, however, a difference between this post-war synopsis and the reading the blogs: I understood it in a much deeper, contextually accurate way. I've finally got it; I understand our roots. Does it leave me more sanguine about current monetary policies and about the future? Not in the slightest.
120 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

American Bullies at Bretton Woods

There, I said it, and I am an American.

I had heard of the conference but never read about it, and certainly had never heard of Harry Dexter White, but this book goes to great length to explain what happened in this important meeting as World War II was drawing to a close and a plan needed to be developed for a new world order regarding the flows of money to facilitate trade and avoid economic disruptions that the world had seen far too much of.

Steil presents more information on John Maynard Keynes than his American antithesis, Harry Dexter White, and for good reason. Keynes was simply one of the most, if not the most, brilliant intellectuals of the 20th century. His theories of economics were evolving through his life, but he is most remembered for his idea that government stimulus could help alleviate a faltering economy when the private sector failed to do the job, and he was opposed as he said to the "gold cage" that for years had been the standard of international finance. He had a biting wit, coupled with a superior intelligence that far outshone his meager appearance (he was ugly, and knew it) but he was cast in the role of a diplomat to present the case for England as the world entered the post war period.

The problem was that England was broke. She had endured two world wars in the space of 30 years and the empire was begging for funds from Washington, and most of her debt to the US from the Great War was still unpaid. She also had an enemy in FDR, who was determined that the imperial preference of England after the war was to be no more. Her crown jewel, India, was pressing for independence and the empire was in the process of unwinding, as was the strength of the British sterling. Keynes pressed to have the new institutions of the World Bank and the IMF located in London, and the Americans under the leadership of White simply said "hell no."

Enter Harry Dexter White. The name is as deceptive as the individual. He was a son of Jewish immigrants, graduating from Harvard late in life, but brilliant in his intellect and determined that America would rule by the strenght of the dollar and Britain was to be no more as a world power. It was interesting to me to see the Treasury Department so powerful over this whole thing. You may think that the Department of State would have more of an influence because these were important global decisions, but their input was minimal. Regardless, White was a Soviet sympathizer and was just in the process of getting raked over the coals when he died early after the war from a heart attack. Keynes also died at the age of 62, not long after the war. The world remember Keynes and White is more of a footnote. I personally did not like White. He reminded me of a Himmler with his rim glasses and nasty litte mustache. As for his boss, Henry Morganthau, Secretary of Treasury, he was little better. His idiotic plan to strip Germany of all industrial capability after the war and turn it into a nation of small farms was leaked to the press and Goebbels made hay of it, likely resulting in many more American casualities toward the end of the war. Just goes to show that FDR used some strange people in his administration. Thank God his selection of generals was far better.

America was brutal toward the British at Bretton Woods. We often think of the English speaking peoples uniting and working together in true harmony to defeat the fascist nations. That is a myth and this book helps bust it. It shows to me how inhuman America was to our British allies, who bore much of the battle of this war alone, with little hope of survival. It is said that when Winston Churchill learned of the attack on Pearl Harbor, he knew that England would win the war and when he retired, he slept like a baby. Little did he know that the selfishness of the U.S. government would put a boot on the neck of England after the war. Churchill once said that the Germans were either at your throat or under your foot. The later part of that pertains to the American response to England toward the end of the war and after.

A good book. Great information, and highly recommended.
56 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Where's the Money?

A great book on the formation of our international economic system, with proper attention given to the bureaucratic experts, in-fighters, and wizards who gave it life.

For me, the name "Bretton Woods" has been just a short-hand reference to the conference that created the various international financial bodies (mainly the IMF and World Bank) at the end of World War II. Beyond this I knew little. I now have a much better understanding of the actual event held in New Hampshire and the current meaning of this pivotal moment of diplomatic history.

Mr. Steil brings to life the policymakers who argued over perplexing issues, many that still remain with us today: John Maynard Keynes, the English economic superstar, and Harry Dexter White, the America with Soviet sympathies, being two of the more prominent players in this drama.

Lend-lease, how to treat post-war Germany, the implosion of the British Empire, Soviet espionage, the changing status of the U.S. dollar, the lingering role of gold, the eventual rise of China, the Euro, all, and more, are touched upon here in clear, careful explanatory prose.

This book will win prizes.
32 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The massacre of Britain at Bretton Woods

By Martin Hutchinson
The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.

Benn Steil calls his study "The Battle of Bretton Woods" but in reality the 1944 conference which created a new financial system after World War Two was more of a massacre of British interests by the U.S. Treasury's Harry Dexter White.

Steil is a senior fellow at the American think-tank, the Council on Foreign Relations, and a well-known writer on financial topics. He tells the story as personal, political and economic. John Maynard Keynes, the principal British negotiator, was an hereditary member of the Cambridge intellectual elite and the first "celebrity economist". White, from a poor background, was a protégé of Henry Morgenthau, Treasury secretary since 1934. He was also an active agent for the Soviet Union.

Both men were determined to replace the pre-war financial system. Keynes thought he had something better. White (and Morgenthau, who generally followed his lead) blamed it for much of the poor performance of the world economy and U.S. exporters during the 1930s.

Steil brings out nicely the parallels between White's wish for a rigid exchange rate system and today's U.S. policymakers' wish for a floating rate system; the common desire for a weak dollar to help U.S. exporters led to diametrically opposed policy prescriptions. Then, fixed rates kept the currency of a country with a payments surplus from rising. Now floating rates allow the currency of a deficit country to sink.

Thus when Keynes brought out his scheme for a new world currency "bancor" to be created by what became the International Monetary Fund, White preferred to restrict the new institution to receiving gold as capital and making loans from that capital. Eventually, by sleight of hand during the drafting process, White ensured that the dollar would be given a special position of convertibility into gold and use for settlement of international transactions. White was also highly sensitive to Soviet demands, but since their main monetary objective was to retain a major position for gold (of which they were a large producer) there was little potential conflict in that area.

Politically, White and the Soviets were also aligned; they both favored a system of fixed exchange rates and the dismantling of Britain's modest Imperial Preference tariffs. But Keynes also favored government control and distrusted free markets, refusing to explore the possibility of a post-war credit to Britain from Wall Street (which would have greatly strengthened his bargaining position). He made little effort to defend UK tariffs or to obtain the post-war sterling devaluation which British exporters such as Morris Motors desperately needed.

In the event, Morgenthau, White and the Soviets achieved almost all their principal objectives at Bretton Woods, and then went off to play golf. Keynes was left to defend to the House of Lords a deal far different from the one he had contemplated, and to return the following year for a pathetic and only partially successful effort to obtain a post-war credit from the U.S. government.

Steil brings out well the difficult interpersonal dynamics between the two prickly personalities, and makes clear his own view that Britain would have done better to send a diplomat to lead its delegation, who would have been more aware of U.S. procedural shenanigans and more skilled in negotiation, perhaps getting the friendly Dean Acheson at the State Department to help neutralize Treasury's hostile Morgenthau/White tandem. Steil does not offer a name, but the best alternative might have been Oliver Lyttelton, then minister of production, with a 20-year City and industrial career behind him and a genuine commitment to both free markets and the needs of the British and Dominion economies.

The book shows personal sympathy for the combative White and some political and economic sympathy for the common desire to meddle with free markets. Still, Steil is both a fair-minded and engaging writer, and those with different proclivities, even imperialist Brits, can still enjoy his account of one of the defining struggles in a crucial part of the modern world.
[...]
19 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

GREAT READ, EVEN FOR THE FINANCIAL NOVICE.

"The Battle of Bretton Woods" is a great read. I have a long standing interest in fiance and economics having studied the subject in college and graduate school. Steil's description of the disastrous financing of World War One and the following bitterness and mistrust created between the US and England by Europe's default on its loans (not to mention the fateful failure of the US to join the League of Nations) is told with clarity and great insight into the personalities who were called upon to finance the Second World War as well as rebuild the world following the war.

This is a great book. Easy to read and complex issues such as the Gold Standard are fully explained.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Masterful, authoritative, and insightful

In 1944 delegates from 44 countries convened at the Mount Washington Hotel in Bretton Woods, New Hampshire. The topic of discussion was the post-World War II international financial system. In this book Benn Steil tells the story of what transpired at that meeting; he explains how the main characters interacted with each other, and how a rather obscure American civil servant was able to have his plan for the global financial architecture approved. This book masterfully tells the story of the “war of ideas” between Harry Dexter White and John Maynard Keynes, arguably the most famous economist of the 20th century. The style is lucid, the prose is elegant, and the attention to details is superb. This is economic history at its best.In 1944 delegates from 44 countries convened at the Mount Washington Hotel in Bretton Woods, New Hampshire. The topic of discussion was the post-World War II international financial system. In this book Benn Steil tells the story of what transpired at that meeting; he explains how the main characters interacted with each other, and how a rather obscure American civil servant was able to have his plan for the global financial architecture approved. This book masterfully tells the story of the “war of ideas” between Harry Dexter White and John Maynard Keynes, arguably the most famous economist of the 20th century. The style is lucid, the prose is elegant, and the attention to details is superb. This is economic history at its best.
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A great book for anyone interested in US foreign policy, history, or economics

In July of 1944 representatives from forty-four nations gathered at the Mount Washington Hotel in Bretton Woods, NH to establish the rules for the post World War II international monetary system. Although nations from around the globe were at the table, the primary debate was between the United States and Great Britain. The U.S. was determined to advance a policy ensuring the dollar reigned supreme in world trade, thus guaranteeing American dominance. The British were holding out for a monetary system that would not relegate them to a secondary status after the war. Representing the two great nations were two men. For the U.S. it was a little-known economist working as an assistant to the Secretary of Treasury, Harry Dexter White, and representing the British was world-known economist John Maynard Keynes. Benn Steil examines the Bretton Woods conference, and the inter-war years leading up to it, using these two men as a backdrop. Not only is the work well researched, but as a senior fellow and director of international economics at the Council on Foreign Relations, Steil is eminently qualified to make economic judgements. Steil’s thoroughness and expertise combine to make an enjoyable read of what could otherwise be an exceptionally dry topic. The main argument Steil makes is that the dominance of dollar in the post WWII economy was a fait accompli at Bretton Woods.
Mr. Steil introduces the reader to the relatively unknown Harry Dexter White, a minor player at the U.S. Treasury commanding great influence. Steil shows the reader that going into Bretton Woods, White and his boss, Treasury Secretary Henry Morgenthau, were committed to bringing President Roosevelt’s New Deal to the rest of the world. Part of this plan was to shift power not only from London, but from Wall Street as well, to the U.S. Treasury. White was convinced international banking had played a key role in creating the instability responsible for WWII. A new gold standard tied to the U.S. dollar would ensure stability in White’s view. Ultimately White’s ideas led to the creation of “the three so-called Bretton Woods institutions: the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the World Trade Organization (WTO), and the World Bank” (Steil, The Battle of Bretton Woods, 127). Adding intrigue to economics Steil also shows through declassified F.B.I. documents and recently discovered writings by White, that White was an agent of the Soviet Union.
Keynes is often regarded as “the first-ever international celebrity economist” (Steil, The Battle of Bretton Woods, 3). While this may be true, he was no match for the little-known White. White (and Morgenthau) considered the British a threat on the economic stage and made sure their Lend-Lease terms would bankrupt the U.K. by the end of the war and bring them to the bargaining table.
As well as being an interesting historical read, and a useful primer on international monetary policy, Steil captures the importance of economic policy in relation to foreign policy. Morgenthau and White realized the power of the U.S. to inflict its will upon other nations was rooted in the power of the dollar. Today as then, U.S. power flows from the economy. Students of modern U.S. foreign policy would be wise to have a basic understanding of U.S. economic policy and how the U.S. economy interacts in the global system.
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Intrigue and Economics. Who knew?

The political battles of the WWII era is often overshadowed by the drama of those battles fought with real bullets. "The Battle of Bretton Woods" tells, in a quite readable way, the diplomatic battle between the US, who was looking to make permanent the economic supremacy they had achieved during the War and Britain, who was looking to salvage whatever economic leverage they might still have by the end of the War. The "Special Relationship" between the US and Britain that was established during WWII was in reality an uneasy alliance between two rivals that was never fully put aside for the duration of the War.

I liked this book. I gave it four stars (instead of five) as I think this book might be a bit of a slog for readers who don't have a familiarity with the various characters and events that populate this book. However, if you've got a familiarity with the subject, I think you'll enjoy this book.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Outstanding

The author manages to bring an amazingly contemporary and detailed account of the (mostly) forgotten conference, whose consequences and reverberations have determined to a significant degree the subsequent economic and imperial destiny of Great Britain, and that of the US. The main players i the drama are vividly portrayed, their motivations, personalities, lethal charisma and lack of it thereof - a book well written for the interested layman as much as the academic reader. I hope Mr Steil has collected enough unanalyzed material for a follow up on the life and what if scenario had Harry Dexter White lived longer to climb higher up the ladder of power after the sack of Secretary Morgenthau by President Truman.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Can't see the Forest for the Trees

This book provides a lot of details on the Bretton Woods conference. In particular it focuses on the two main players: Harry Dexter White of the US and John Maynard Keynes of England. Much time is spent on whether White was a communist. There are memo-by-memo recountings of the formulations of US and British positions. I am sure the work is extremely well researched, but just too much detail on the events for me.

I was more interested in the impact of the conference and how the two creations from the conference (IMF, Word Bank) function. How do currency exchanges work was a more interesting question than whether White was a communist.
5 people found this helpful