The Birth of Venus
The Birth of Venus book cover

The Birth of Venus

Hardcover – February 17, 2004

Price
$13.27
Format
Hardcover
Pages
397
Publisher
Random House
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-1400060733
Dimensions
5.81 x 1.4 x 9.53 inches
Weight
1.37 pounds

Description

Sarah Dunant's gorgeous and mesmerizing novel, Birth of Venus , draws readers into a turbulent 15th-century Florence, a time when the lavish city, steeped in years of Medici family luxury, is suddenly besieged by plague, threat of invasion, and the righteous wrath of a fundamentalist monk. Dunant masterfully blends fact and fiction, seamlessly interweaving Florentine history with the coming-of-age story of a spirited 14-year-old girl. As Florence struggles in Savonarola's grip, a serial killer stalks the streets, the French invaders creep closer, and young Alessandra Cecchi must surrender her "childish" dreams and navigate her way into womanhood. Readers are quickly seduced by the simplicity of her unconventional passions that are more artistic than domestic: Dancing is one of the many things I should be good at that I am not. Unlike my sister. Plautilla can move across the floor like water and sing a stave of music like a song bird, while I, who can translate both Latin and Greek faster than she or my brothers can read it, have club feet on the dance floor and a voice like a crow. Though I swear if I were to paint the scale I could do it in a flash: shining gold leaf for the top notes falling through ochres and reds into hot purple and deepest blue. Alessandra's story, though central, is only one part of this multi-faceted and complex historical novel. Dunant paints a fascinating array of women onto her dark canvas, each representing the various fates of early Renaissance women: Alessandra's lovely (if simple) sister Plautilla is interested only in marrying rich and presiding over a household; the brave Erila, Alessandra's North African servant (and willing accomplice) has such a frank understanding of the limitations of her sex that she often escapes them; and Signora Cecchi, Alessandra's beautiful but weary mother tries to encourage yet temper the passions of her wayward daughter. A luminous and lush novel, The Birth of Venus , at its heart, is a mysterious and sensual story with razor-sharp teeth. Like Alessandra, Dunant has a painter's eye--her writing is rich and evocative, luxuriating in colors and textures of the city, the people, and the art of 15th-century Florence. Reminiscent of Tracy Chevalier's Girl with a Pearl Earring , but with sensual splashes of color and the occasional thrill of fear, Dunant's novel is both exciting and enchanting. --Daphne Durham From Publishers Weekly In this arresting tale of art, love and betrayal in 15th-century Florence, the daughter of a wealthy cloth merchant seeks the freedom of marriage in order to paint, but finds that she may have bought her liberty at the cost of love and true fulfillment. Alessandra, 16, is tall, sharp-tongued and dauntingly clever. At first reluctant to agree to an arranged marriage, she changes her mind when she meets elegant 48-year-old Cristoforo, who is well-versed in art and literature. He promises to give her all the freedom she wants-and she finds out why on her wedding night. Her disappointment and frustration are soon overshadowed by the growing cloud of madness and violence hanging over Florence, nourished by the sermons of the fanatically pious Savonarola. As the wealthy purge their palazzos of "low" art and luxuries, Alessandra gives in to the dangerous attraction that draws her to a tormented young artist commissioned to paint her family's chapel. With details as rich as the brocade textiles that built Alessandra's family fortune, Dunant (Mapping the Edge; Transgressions; etc.) masterfully recreates Florence in the age of the original bonfire of the vanities. The novel moves to its climax as Savonarola's reign draws to a bloody close, with the final few chapters describing Alessandra's fate and hinting at the identity of her artist lover. While the story is rushed at the end, the author has a genius for peppering her narrative with little-known facts, and the deadpan dialogue lends a staccato verve to the swift-moving plot. Forget Baedecker and Vasari's Lives of the Artists. Dunant's vivid, gripping novel gives fresh life to a captivating age of glorious art and political turmoil. Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. From Bookmarks Magazine With Birth of Venus , Dunant joins a genre inhabited by Tracey Chevalier's Girl With a Pearl Earring and Susan Vreeland's Girl in Hyacinth Blue . Like these novels, Birth of Venus lovingly celebrates art and artistic endeavor, offering pages of convincing period detail. But here, politics occupies center stage as well, with Alessandra caught in the middle of a battle for control of Florence by the Medicis and Roman Catholic friars. Although a poignant coming-of-age story, Alessandra's plight appears melodramatic, her relationship with the artist lacks inspiration, and improbable plots clutter the narrative. Still, the novel's imagination and playfulness, not to mention its broad swath of Renaissance history, will appeal to a wide audience. Copyright © 2004 Phillips & Nelson Media, Inc. From Booklist Dunant's lush and intellectually gripping novel is set in fourteenth-century Florence at the height of the Renaissance. Fifteen-year-old Alessandra Cecchi does not fit the mold of the compliant Florentine woman. She avidly consumes books written in Greek and Latin as she keeps abreast of the art movement, hoping to some day create her own masterwork. The city is teeming with artisans working for the Catholic Church and the ruling Medici family, and sightings of Botticelli in the piazza or the infamous Michelangelo are commonplace incidents in a city that thrives on beauty. The years of Florentine decadence come to a close when the French Army invades Italy and Dominican friar Girolamo Savonarola begins a puritanical crusade. To protect her from the city's tumultuous atmosphere, the Cecchis arrange a marriage for Alessandra, but the man they have chosen has closely guarded secrets and Alessandra's heart also belongs to someone else. This is a beautifully written and captivating work. Elsa Gaztambide Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved “Simply amazing, so brilliantly written...almost intolerably exciting at times, and at others, equally poignant.”–Antonia Fraser“A beautiful serpent of a novel, seductive and dangerous...full of wise guile, the most brilliant novel yet from a writer of powerful historical imagination and wicked literary gifts. Dunant’s snaky tale of art, sex and Florentine hysteria consumes utterly–but the experience is all pleasure.”–Simon Schama“Sarah Dunant has given us a story of sacrifice and betrayal, set during Florence’s captivity under the fanatic Savonarola. She writes like a painter, and thinks like a philosopher: juxtapositioning the humane against the animal, hope against fanaticism, creativity against destruction. The Birth of Venus is a tour de force.”–Amanda Foreman, author of Georgiana: Duchess of Devonshire“Dunant has created a vivid and compellingly believable picture of Renaissance Florence: the squalor and brutality; the confidence and vitality; the political machinations. Her research has obviously been meticulous....A magnificent novel.”–The Telegraph (London)“It’s to Dunant’s credit that the vast quantities of historical information in this book are deployed so naturally and lightly....On the simplest level, this is an erotic and gripping thriller, but its intellectual excitement also comes from the way Dunant makes the art and philosophy of the period look new and dangerous again....Theology has rarely looked so sexy.”–The Independent (London)“No one should visit Tuscany this summer without this book. It is richly textured and driven by a thrillerish fever.”–The Times (London)“[Dunant’s] control, pace, and instinct are well-nigh impeccable.”–The Financial Times From the Inside Flap Alessandra Cecchi is not quite fifteen when her father, a prosperous cloth merchant, brings a young painter back from northern Europe to decorate the chapel walls in the familyx92s Florentine palazzo. A child of the Renaissance, with a precocious mind and a talent for drawing, Alessandra is intoxicated by the painterx92s abilities.But their burgeoning relationship is interrupted when Alessandrax92s parents arrange her marriage to a wealthy, much older man. Meanwhile, Florence is changing, increasingly subject to the growing suppression imposed by the fundamentalist monk Savonarola, who is seizing religious and political control. Alessandra and her native city are caught between the Medici state, with its love of luxury, learning, and dazzling art, and the hellfire preaching and increasing violence of Savonarolax92s reactionary followers. Played out against this turbulent backdrop, Alessandrax92s married life is a misery, except for the surprising freedom it allows her to pursue her powerful attraction to the young painter and his art. The Birth of Venus is a tour de force, the first historical novel from one of Britainx92s most innovative writers of literary suspense. It brings alive the history of Florence at its most dramatic period, telling a compulsively absorbing story of love, art, religion, and power through the passionate voice of Alessandra, a heroine with the same vibrancy of spirit as her beloved city. “Simply amazing, so brilliantly written...almost intolerably exciting at times, and at others, equally poignant.”–Antonia Fraser“A beautiful serpent of a novel, seductive and dangerous...full of wise guile, the most brilliant novel yet from a writer of powerful historical imagination and wicked literary gifts. Dunant’s snaky tale of art, sex and Florentine hysteria consumes utterly–but the experience is all pleasure.”–Simon Schama“Sarah Dunant has given us a story of sacrifice and betrayal, set during Florence’s captivity under the fanatic Savonarola. She writes like a painter, and thinks like a philosopher: juxtapositioning the humane against the animal, hope against fanaticism, creativity against destruction. The Birth of Venus is a tour de force.”–Amanda Foreman, author of Georgiana: Duchess of Devonshire“Dunant has created a vivid and compellingly believable picture of Renaissance Florence: the squalor and brutality; the confidence and vitality; the political machinations. Her research has obviously been meticulous....A magnificent novel.”–The Telegraph (London)“It’s to Dunant’s credit that the vast quantities of historical information in this book are deployed so naturally and lightly....On the simplest level, this is an erotic and gripping thriller, but its intellectual excitement also comes from the way Dunant makes the art and philosophy of the period look new and dangerous again....Theology has rarely looked so sexy.”–The Independent (London)“No one should visit Tuscany this summer without this book. It is richly textured and driven by a thrillerish fever.”–The Times (London)“[Dunant’s] control, pace, and instinct are well-nigh impeccable.”–The Financial Times Sarah Dunant has written eight novels and edited two books of essays. She has worked widely in print, television, and radio, and until recently hosted the leading BBC Radio arts program, Night Waves. Now a full-time writer, she is adapting her novels Transgressions and Mapping the Edge for the screen. Dunant has two children and lives in London and Florence. To schedule a speaking engagement, please contact American Program Bureau at www.apbspeakers.com Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Chapter 1One Looking back now, i see it more as an act of pride than kindness that my father brought the young painter back with him from the North that spring. The chapel in our palazzo had recently been completed, and for some months he had been searching for the right pair of hands to execute the altar frescoes. It wasn't as if Florence didn't have artists enough of her own. The city was filled with the smell of paint and the scratch of ink on the contracts. There were times when you couldn't walk the streets for fear of falling into some pit or mire left by constant building. Anyone and everyone who had the money was eager to celebrate God and the Republic by creating opportunities for art. What I hear described even now as a golden age was then simply the fashion of the day. But I was young then and, like so many others, dazzled by the feast.The churches were the best. God was in the very plaster smeared across the walls in readiness for the frescoes: stories of the Gospels made flesh for anyone with eyes to see. And those who looked saw something else as well. Our Lord may have lived and died in Galilee, but his life was re-created in the city of Florence. The Angel Gabriel brought God's message to Mary under the arches of a Brunelleschian loggia, the Three Kings led processions through the Tuscan countryside, and Christ's miracles unfolded within our city walls, the sinners and the sick in Florentine dress and the crowds of witnesses dotted with public faces: a host of thick-chinned, big-nosed dignitaries staring down from the frescoes onto their real-life counterparts in the front pews.I was almost ten years old when Domenico Ghirlandaio completed his frescoes for the Tornabuoni family in the central chapel of Santa Maria Novella. I remember it well, because my mother told me to. "You should remember this moment, Alessandra," she said. "These paintings will bring great glory to our city." And all those who saw them thought that they would.My father's fortune was rising out of the steam of the dyeing vats in the back streets of Santa Croce then. The smell of cochineal still brings back memories of him coming home from the warehouse, the dust of crushed insects from foreign places embedded deep in his clothes. By the time the painter came to live with us in 1492-I remember the date because Lorenzo de' Medici died that spring-the Florentine appetite for flamboyant cloth had made us rich. Our newly completed palazzo was in the east of the city, between the great Cathedral of Santa Maria del Fiore and the church of Sant' Ambrogio. It rose four stories high around two inner courtyards, with its own small walled garden and space for my father's business on the ground floor. Our coat of arms adorned the outside walls, and while my mother's good taste curbed much of the exuberance that attends new money, we all knew it was only a matter of time before we too would be sitting for our own Gospel portraits, albeit private ones.The night the painter arrived is sharp as an etching in my memory. It is winter, and the stone balustrades have a coating of frost as my sister and I collide on the stairs in our night shifts, hanging over the edge to watch the horses arrive in the main courtyard. It's late and the house has been asleep, but my father's homecoming is reason for celebration, not simply for his safe return but because, amid the panniers of samples, there is always special cloth for the family.Plautilla is already beside herself with anticipation, but then she is betrothed and thinking only of her dowry. My brothers, on the other hand, are noticeable by their absence. For all our family's good name and fine cloth, Tomaso and Luca live more like feral cats than citizens, sleeping by day and hunting by night. Our house slave Erila, the font of all gossip, says they are the reason that good women should never be seen in the streets after dark. Nevertheless, when my father finds they are gone there will be trouble.But not yet. For now we are all caught in the wonder of the moment. Firebrands light the air as the grooms calm the horses, their snorting breath steaming into the freezing air. Father is already dismounted, his face streaked with grime, a smile as round as a cupola as he waves upward to us and then turns to my mother as she comes down the stairs to greet him, her red velvet robe tied fast across her chest and her hair free and flowing down her back like a golden river. There is noise and light and the sweet sense of safety everywhere, but not shared by everyone. Astride the last horse sits a lanky young man, his cape wrapped like a bolt of cloth around him, the cold and travel fatigue tipping him dangerously forward in the saddle.I remember as the groom approached him to take the reins he awoke with a start, his hands clutching them back as if fearful of attack, and my father had to go to him to calm him. I was too full of my own self then to realize how strange it must have been for him. I had not heard yet how different the North was, how the damp and the watery sun changed everything, from the light in the air to the light in one's soul. Of course I did not know he was a painter then. For me he was just another servant. But my father treated him with care right from the beginning: speaking to him in quiet tones, seeing him off his horse, and picking out a separate room off the back courtyard as his living quarters.Later, as my father unpacks the Flemish tapestry for my mother and snaps open the bolts of milk-white embroidered lawn for us ("The women of Rennes go blind early in the service of my daughters' beauty"), he tells us how he found him, an orphan brought up in a monastery on the edge of the northern sea where the water threatens the land. How his talent with a pen overwhelmed any sense of religious vocation, so the monks had apprenticed him to a master, and when he returned, in gratitude, he painted not simply his own cell but the cells of all the other monks. These paintings so impressed my father that he decided then and there to offer him the job of glorifying our chapel. Though I should add that while he knew his cloth my father was no great connoisseur of art, and I suspect his decision was as much dictated by money, for he always had a good eye for a bargain. As for the painter? Well, as my father put it, there were no more cells for him to paint, and the fame of Florence as the new Rome or Athens of our age would no doubt have spurred him on to see it for himself.And so it was that the painter came to live at our house.Next morning we went to Santissima Annunziata to give thanks for my father's safe homecoming. The church is next to the Ospedale degli Innocenti, the foundling hospital where young women place their bastard babies on the wheel for the nuns to care for. As we pass I imagine the cries of the infants as the wheel in the wall turns inward forever, but my father says we are a city of great charity and there are places in the wild North where you find babies amid the rubbish or floating like flotsam down the river.We sit together in the central pews. Above our heads hang great model ships donated by those who have survived shipwrecks. My father was in one once, though he was not rich enough at the time to command a memorial in church, and on this last voyage he suffered only common seasickness. He and my mother sit ramrod straight and you can feel their minds on God's munificence. We children are less holy.lautilla is still flighty with the thought of her gifts, while Tomaso and Luca look like they would prefer to be in bed, though my father's disapproval keeps them alert.When we return, the house smells of feast-day food-the sweetness of roast meat and spiced gravies curling down the stairs from the upper kitchen to the courtyard below. We eat as afternoon fades into evening. First we thank God; then we stuff ourselves: boiled capon, roast pheasant, trout, and fresh pastas followed by saffron pudding and egg custards with burned sugar coating. Everyone is on their best behavior. Even Luca holds his fork properly, though you can see his fingers itch to pick up the bread and trawl it through the sauce.Already I am beside myself with excitement at the thought of our new houseguest. Flemish painters are much admired in Florence for their precision and their sweet spirituality. "So he will paint us all, Father? We will have to sit for him, yes?""Indeed. That is partly why he is come. I am trusting he will make us a glorious memento of your sister's wedding.""In which case he'll paint me first!"lautilla is so pleased that she spits milk pudding on the tablecloth. "Then Tomaso as eldest, then Luca, and then Alessandra. Goodness, Alessandra, you will be grown even taller by then."Luca looks up from his plate and grins with his mouth full as if this is the wittiest joke he has ever heard. But I am fresh from church and filled with God's charity to all my family. "Still. He had better not take too long. I heard that one of the daughters-in-law of the Tornabuoni family was dead from childbirth by the time Ghirlandaio unveiled her in the fresco.""No fear of that with you. You'd have to get a husband first." Next to me Tomaso's insult is so mumbled only I can hear it."What is that you say, Tomaso?" My mother's voice is quiet but sharp.He puts on his most cherubic expression. "I said, 'I have a dreadful thirst.'ass the wine flagon, dear sister.""Of course, brother." I pick it up, but as it moves toward him it slips out of my hands and the falling liquid splatters his new tunic."Ah, Mama!" he explodes. "She did that on purpose!""I did not!""She-""Children, children. Our father is tired and you are both too loud."The word children does its work on Tomaso and he falls sullenly silent. In the spac... Read more

Features & Highlights

  • Alessandra Cecchi is not quite fifteen when her father, a prosperous cloth merchant, brings a young painter back from northern Europe to decorate the chapel walls in the family’s Florentine palazzo. A child of the Renaissance, with a precocious mind and a talent for drawing, Alessandra is intoxicated by the painter’s abilities.But their burgeoning relationship is interrupted when Alessandra’s parents arrange her marriage to a wealthy, much older man. Meanwhile, Florence is changing, increasingly subject to the growing suppression imposed by the fundamentalist monk Savonarola, who is seizing religious and political control. Alessandra and her native city are caught between the Medici state, with its love of luxury, learning, and dazzling art, and the hellfire preaching and increasing violence of Savonarola’s reactionary followers. Played out against this turbulent backdrop, Alessandra’s married life is a misery, except for the surprising freedom it allows her to pursue her powerful attraction to the young painter and his art.
  • The
  • Birth of Venus
  • is a tour de force, the first historical novel from one of Britain’s most innovative writers of literary suspense. It brings alive the history of Florence at its most dramatic period, telling a compulsively absorbing story of love, art, religion, and power through the passionate voice of Alessandra, a heroine with the same vibrancy of spirit as her beloved city.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(555)
★★★★
25%
(463)
★★★
15%
(278)
★★
7%
(130)
23%
(424)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

How real is the "liberating" message of "The Birth of Venus?

Sarah Dunant's "The Birth of Venus" feels similar to Tracy Chevalier's "Girl With a Pearl Earring" and Susan Vreeland's "Girl in the Hyacinth Blue." All three are works of historical fiction that have the ability to convince, albeit fleetingly, that they must be true.

However, "The Birth of Venus" isn't based on the Botticelli masterpiece that still resides in the Uffizi Gallery in Florence. It's based on the metaphorical "birth" -- and transformation -- of a girl-turned-woman whose single-mindedness is constantly thwarted by actions which force her to conform to 15th century Florentine society.

I'm not big on novels associated with the feminist school of thought that suggests forbidden romance, in all of its forms, brings liberation. Yet I was blindsided by Dunant's "The Birth of Venus" - especially its socko-ending - coming from an author better known for her crime novels and TV appearances in the United Kingdom.

Dunant's accomplishment: She establishes familiar plot threads about her protagonist, Alessandra. Hers is a page-turning, rebellious story. You start to feel smug because you think you've figured out how everything's going to end. But just when you think you're heading toward a familiar train wreck, Dunant puts you through many unpredictable (but mostly plausible) 90-degree plot turns that are wonderfully intriguing.

"The Birth of Venus" may not be high literature, but it's Dunant's best work to date. Her love for her adopted city of Florence is obvious. She goes out of her way to spin a fictional tale that's rooted in well-researched, historical reality. The "superstars" of the Renaissance make their appearances, but never in a jarring, manipulative or name-dropping way. They're part of the landscape. And if you know the geography of Old Florence, you also know that even today, it's small enough that you can't help running into these guys.

So what keeps this book from perfection? In my view, just two things:

First, modern slang occasionally surfaces that feels incongruent to 21st century readers who've been drawn into a setting that's more than 500 years old. Yeah, I know we're reading a "fictional translation" of Italian narration to English, but it's still a little jarring to read present-day colloquialisms sprinkled throughout a novel that's mostly placid in tone. Contrast this with erotic passages which for the most part, are devoid of crudeness (though at times described a little too self-consciously).

Second, about those erotic passages. There aren't many. They're executed, for the most part, with great sensitivity. I hate sex described in clinical terms. But a couple of times Dunant comes too close to projecting thoughts into Alessandra's narration that feel pretentious, a little too lyrical or metaphorical, even from the voice of an adult who's "looking backward." Do women really string metaphors about sex together, as you read here, even in their most reflective and introspective moments? As a result, what's supposed to "feel" like sexual "liberation" rings a little false. And I still don't get the stuff involving the tattoos (you'll know what I mean when you get to it).

Suspending disbelief is obviously required when great figures creep into a novel. "The Birth of Venus" weaves its "tale" cleverly, but I wish Dunant's Alessandra had gone no further when she describes the return, years later, of the man who remains an important figure in her life.

She beautifully says, "We had always been bound to each other through the power of longing, even when we understood nothing of desire."

I wished Dunant had stopped there. Instead, she plows ahead with the inevitable "scene" that would've been better suggested than described in a way that feels a little forced, posed and "artsy." I became aware of Dunant's writing. And this isn't supposed to happen. A great story is supposed to make you less conscious of great prose.

I'm still baffled about the mysterious man who's never identified by name. We're given a few clues, but he remains a cryptic figure, a brooding and tortured artist who returns years later so worldly and wise. He reads like every woman's fantasy, a Renaissance romantic too good to be true.

In the end, these may be small quibbles.

It may not be necessary to know the "Who's Who" of the Renaissance, e.g., Savonarola, Medici, the whole lot of 'em, and it may not be necessary to walk the streets of present-day Florence to "get" what's in "The Birth of Venus." But they do enhance the enjoyment of a story that's set in one of the world's most romantic cities. I hope readers less familiar with Florentine art and history get the same wallop I did after finishing it.

A helpful tip: remember this book is being told in the first person AND in the past tense. This way, when you reach the final 30 pages of Alessandra's story, you'll realize you're being set up for a twist.

To my relief, it's unpredictable and immensely satisfying. Without giving it away, "The Birth of Venus" closes unconventionally yet beautifully; optimistically yet realistically; quietly yet without being thrown into the throes of depression.

I still prefer non-fiction over fiction. But as I once wrote about another historical novel I equally enjoyed, if more books were written like Dunant's "The Birth of Venus," I'd stop going to the movies.
467 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Intricate Portrayal of Florence in Savonarola's Time

Alessandra tells her story of Florence during the tight reign of the monk Savonarola, in the form of a memoir, found after her death by fellow sisters in a provincial convent. Living in an age where classic thought and sensibilities are revisited and possessing an acute mind and an acrid tongue, she must resign herself to a more conventional role as a woman of the Renaissance, bound by duty to marry and bear children rather than be the philosopher painter she wishes to be. From the moment she encounters the painter from the North that her father has commissioned to paint the family chapel, she is relentless in seeking him out. While her first desire is to learn the secrets of color and brushwork, she finds herself attracted to the painter in ways she had not expected, and finds herself frustrated in more ways than she bargained when she must follow her appointed path as a Florentine woman.

The plot itself follows a rather straightforward course steered by somewhat predictable but well-crafted characters. Blended expertly with historical details of the age: the reign of the Medici family, the invasion of Florence by France, the paranoia of the city while under the helm of the monk, and the dropping of famous names like Botticelli, Michelangelo, Fra Angelico and Da Vinci, the author presents us with a fictitious view of what life could have been like back in the early 1500s. Alessandra's mindset is indeed, that of a 20th woman, a bit cynical and slightly world-weary for one of such tender years, but this adds to her appeal to the author's intended audience. Overall, the storyline compels one to read on and contains enough hints and little mysteries to keep even the most well-read reader turning the pages.

However, what fails miserably is the author's lack of solving any of the mysteries that she so tantalizingly provides for us. Alessandra fixates on the form of the snake tattooed on the man in the square, so much so that she has one tattooed on her own body---but the reason for her action is muddled and I for one do not understand the actual significance---an act of defiance? Empathy with Eve and her sin? Ironically, the significance of one of the most compelling symbols in the book remains coiled but never unfurled. Similarly, the author hints at the great artist that Alessandra loves and gives us enough clues to make some sort of guess to his identity, but then never actually tells us who he is or if he even existed. We know he is Flemish from the descriptions of the North Sea and the low country. We know he studied anatomy when it was forbidden with the likes of Michelangelo at Santo Spirito. We know that after the fall of Savonarola, he goes off to Rome to escape further persecution. He returns much later, worldly his sexual and artistic techniques honed like a razor, but again, we do not know his identity. Personally, as I read, I assumed he was a creation, but enough of my fellow reviewers have voiced that he was a real historical figure for me to investigate. Lastly, the title, calling to mind Botticelli's masterpiece, has little or nothing to do with the plot. As this book was published in the same time period when books like Vreeland's Girl in Hyacinth Blue and Chevalier's Girl With a Pearl Earring have great popularity, one cannot help but think that the title suggests another imaginative story behind a great work of art. The Birth of Venus, however, is the story of a woman and her duty rather than her act as muse for a great painting or sculpture.

Bottom line: if you are looking for a Girl With a Pearl Earring type confection, you will not find it here. However, if a story told from a woman's perspective, albeit imagined, piques your interest especially told in the colorful velvet world of art and enlightenment of the Renaissance (even in the shadow of Savonarola) you will enjoy undertaking this short journey of duty, love and art.
65 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Fails to deliver

Although I found The Birth of Venus to be a fascinating account of an historical era, I also found it to be a disappointing personal story. Many relationships in the story are explored but few if any deepen or resolve themselves or result in growth of the characters involved. The pivotal relationship between the main character, Alessandra, and the painter fall far short of the mark - can two people who have only been in each other's company for several hours really kindle a love relationship that lasts through the years? Although it is considered an adult book and perhaps should be, considering the coarse language and sexual imagery, Alessandra has the maturity of a teenager; not surprising since she is only fourteen when the story begins. I found it a bit disconcerting that the first two chapters of the book were written in the present tense (giving it a childlike quality) which was then replaced inexplicably with the past tense. The understanding and resolution of Alessandra's relationship with her brothers and mother were weak; her relationship with her husband had potential but still failed to satisfy. Her relationship with her slave was solid and unchanging. I found the opening prologue, set in the future, extremely intriguing, but the explanation at the conclusion seemed implausible, if not downright ridiculous. The historical account of Savonarola's reign in Florence in the 15th century was, however, well done. I had heard of the Bonfire of the Vanities and the way that the author leads you to this historical event was entirely believable. The political issues of the times, though glossed over, were presented and various cultural elements of the era such as etiquette, medicine, clothing, food, social structure, and religious and social customs were woven into the fabric of the book. One exception to the plethora of details, however, was the art of fresco painting - a skill that requires much practice and is not something that a beginner could do successfully on the first try. Despite the shortcomings I've outlined, however, The Birth of Venus still manages to please many. When I checked out the book at the library, the librarian said, "Ooh, I just loved that book!" To each his own.
24 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Was there no editor available?

A fascinating period plus a fascinating story should equal a good read. Unfortunately, this book fails. It is so poorly written that I wonder if an editor reviewed it. The author's most serious error was her inability to keep her tenses straight -- even within the same paragraph. The author needs a refresher course in the mechanics of writing and the guidance of a good editor. This repeated error (along with other technical errors) undermines the book's credibility.
A further credibility problem is that the characters, with their modern day values and behaviour, ring false. I was especially frustrated with the development of Tomaso, whose cruelty to Alessandra is explained only by his homosexuality (sorry, being gay doesn't make you mean to your sister).
As others have mentioned, I too was disappointed that the story had nothing to do with Botticelli or his painting "the Birth of Venus." Add another item to this book's list of flaws.
In summary, while the story and its setting are interesting, the book lacks integrity. A good book for any creative writing teacher to use as a "what not to do" example.
23 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The Birth of Venus : A Novel

I wish I could have given this one a 4.5. It was better than a 4 but not quite worthy of a 5. 5s are saved for the classics.
Anyway, this is one of the best books I've ever read. It had more twists and turns than a maze!! Just when you thought her (Alessandra Cecchi) life couldn't get any weirder, it does.
It's set in Florence in 1492. Alessandra is nearly 15 when her father brings home a painter. Since she herself is an artist, she wants to meet him. But unfortunately, their relationship is severed when the French invade Florence. You see, she told her mother that if the French did invade, she'd marry to avoid being put in a convent. She decides to marry 50 something Cristoforo Langella and soon discovers that neither Cristoforo nor the painter are who they appear to be...
It has sex, murder, suspense, adultery, sodomy. What more could a person ask for??
It's highly recommended if you're a fan of fiction novels.
23 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Uneven historical romance with too many modern intrusions...

A romance novel set in the late 15th century of Florence, Italy, "The Birth of Venus" is an uneven and only particially successfully story that compares to "Girl With a Pearl Earring", "The Ruby Ring" and several books and films about the real female Renaissance artist, Artemisia Gentileschi. (As usual, truth is far more fascinating that made-up fiction.) Sarah Dunant is a very capable writer and she's done a wealth of research here, but the drive to write a feminist novel set in the past drags the book down. As much as it frustrates our present cultural belief systems, the past was not awash with feminist types or politically correct situations. People simply believed different things -- really believed them, not just lip service -- such as the role of women in society and the dominance of the Catholic faith over every aspect of society.

The character of the "feisty female character" is a bit overdone in all of literature, anyways. It makes you wonder a bit about all the millions of women who lead ordinary lives and why we fail entirely to identify with THEM. Alessandra Cecchi is a wealthy 15 year old Florentine girl with artistic aspirations, who has an arranged marriage with an older, homosexual man...who has previously been sexually involved with her brother. She falls in love with an artist, and has an affair with him.

Some readers apparently feel that the title "The Birth of Venus" refers to the actual classical myth, as depicted in the very famous Botticelli painting of this period. However, it's very obvious to me that the title is an allusion to the heroine's sexual awakening at the hands of the artist, and a graphic reference to the female genitalia.

Other readers have wondered about the symbolism of the snake tatoo that Alessandra (trapped in convent at the end) painstaking creates on her body. I think it's pretty obvious that this is a graphic reference to the oral sexual pleasure that her lover has given her, and it's importance in her life -- i.e., he has fulfilled her in ways that obviously her gay husband wasn't able to.

Lastly, it seems like no one even wants to hazard a guess as to the identity of the painter that Ms. Dunant chooses to shroud in mystery. (It's CERTAINLY not Michelangelo.) As a former art student, I'd like to suggest that she is thinking of the German artist, Hans Holbein (the Younger). He was definitely from the North, and from a city that had a rich trading history with Italy. Art historians believe he studied in Italy to develop his astonishing techniques, although there is no actual historical proof of this. He painted many famous religious triptychs. Also, like the character in the novel, Holbein eventually moved to England and became the court painter of Henry VIII (every famous portrait you have ever seen of Henry VIII or his wives is by Holbein). Although Holbein technically was born a little late for the story (in 1497), he had a famous father, Hans Holbein the Elder, and the author here might have been using a little creative license by merging the two...it would also explain why she refuses to identify him, even in an afterword. I would be extremely interested in any readers who either agree or disagree with my theory and in any other artists they might have come up with!!!

In conclusion, this would have been a better book without all the PC feminist and gay posturing, and without the overly modern spin on sexuality. Ms. Dunant is a good writer, and certainly had the potential here to write a historically accurate novel -- it's a shame she did not fulfill that potential.
22 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Waste of Time

One shred of historical knowledge will cause you to trash this book by a few chapters. It was one of the most STUPID pieces of TRASH that I have picked up this year. I wouldn't wish this brain dead idiocy on my worst enemy.
15 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

the birth of venus

i'm glad i borrowed this book from the library instead of buying it. the characters are so not believeable. for a fourteen year old she seems too knowledgeable about history and politics, and what is with her very hostile relationship with her brothers? Sure there is a lot of sibling rivalry, but don't these characters ever grow up and develop some kind of maturity and insight? The prologue was remarkably interesting, and I was hooked, but it was a downward plunge till the end. the painter seems to have made a 180-degree character change when he reappears in the end after a long absence. the plot, characters and coherence of incidents are very loosely interwoven, and very inconsistently developed. a very unbalanced, tedious book.
15 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Slow Start, Great Finish

I almost put this one down. The Birth of Venus, for me at least, got off to a kind of slow start. The story of Alessandra, a young woman in turbulent Florence dragged at first, but then, somewhere about 100 pages in, I couldn't put it down--the story got juicy, a little twisted, interesting. What kept me going, really, were the opening paragraphs, which tell the story of a recently deceased nun, who, upon her death, reveals something no one knew of her in life--that her torso was covered with a huge, serpent shaped tatoo. The suspense of what exactly what that was, and how it came about kept me reading Alessandra's story and I am glad I persevered. The Birth of Venus is an enjoyable story--a quick read that once you get into, you won't be able to put down.
12 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Poorly written. Gratuitous violence added for shock value.

I did not enjoy reading this book, and I returned it. It was difficult to read because it was so poorly written. In addition, the story contained too much unnecessary violence added for shock value. I don't think it was necessary to be so graphic; a good writer can describe these things more eloquently. I have read much better books on this topic.
11 people found this helpful