The Girl in the Red Coat
The Girl in the Red Coat book cover

The Girl in the Red Coat

Price
$21.39
Format
Hardcover
Pages
336
Publisher
Melville House
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-1612195001
Dimensions
6.3 x 1.1 x 9.3 inches
Weight
1.17 pounds

Description

An Amazon Best Book of February 2016: It’s every parent’s nightmare: Beth, a single mother, takes her 8-year-old daughter, Carmel, to a local festival for some fun and frivolity and she vanishes. What follows is an unusual and terrifying journey for them both. Kate Hamer’s sophisticated debut, The Girl in the Red Coat , is no ordinary whodunit, nor does it resort to over-the-top prurience to get under your skin. In many ways, this makes it even more chilling, as Hamer masterfully manipulates the reader into anticipating the worst with each (frantically) turned page. But ultimately it’s two parallel tales of survival: How does Beth press on in the face of paralyzing shame and worry? How does Carmel keep her wits about her in a frightening and complex situation beyond her comprehension? What gives this novel unexpected power and heart are the ways in which they find to hold onto themselves. --Erin Kodicek From Publishers Weekly British single mother Beth knows her eight-year-old daughter, Carmel, has a tendency to wanderâx80x94at a local corn maze, on school tripsâx80x94but one foggy day, the girl vanishes at a local festival and cannot be found. A man who claims to be Carmel's grandfather convinces her that Beth has been in a terrible accident, so Carmel leaves the fairgrounds with him and winds up at a secluded home with the man and his female companion, Dorothy. As Beth frantically searches and slowly isolates herself from the outside world, Carmel is told after careful manipulation that her mother has died, and soon finds herself in America with her new "grandparents," who work as spiritualist healers. Carmel fights to remember her past, but as time passes and she crisscrosses the country, her old life begins to fade. It takes everything in her to remember her name, her address, and her parents. Hamer's spectacular debut skillfully chronicles the nightmare of child abduction. Telling the story in two remarkable voices, with Beth's chapters unfurling in past tense and Carmel's in present tense, the author weaves a page-turning narrative. The trajectories of the novel's two leadsâx80x94through despair, hope, and redemptionâx80x94are believable and nuanced, resulting in a morally complex, haunting read. (Feb.)\n An ELLE Lettres Readers' Prize Winner “Kate Hamer’s gripping debut novel immediately recalls the explosion of similarly titled books and movies, from Stieg Larsson’s The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo and its sequels, to The Girl on the Train to Gone Girl … What kicks The Girl in the Red Coat out of the loop of familiarity is Ms. Hamer’s keen understanding of her two central characters: Carmel and her devastated mother, Beth, who narrate alternating chapters … Both emerge as individuals depicted with sympathy but also with unsparing emotional precision.” —Michiko Kakutani, The New York Times “This stunning debut...has the propulsion of a thriller.” —People “Every sentence in Kate Hamer's debut is so perceptive that you're torn between wanting to linger on the thought and itching to learn what happens next...The taut plot alternates between Carmel's emotional struggle to survive and Beth's refusal to believe that her daughter is gone forever. Meanwhile, their complex yet unbreakable bond is rendered with honesty and love.” — Oprah.com “Keeps the reader turning pages at a frantic clip . . . What’s most powerful here is not whodunit, or even why, but how this mother and daughter bear their separation, and the stories they tell themselves to help endure it.” —Celeste Ng, author of Everything I Never Told You “Hamer’s book is a moving, voice-driven narrative. As much an examination of loss and anxiety as it is a gripping page-turner, it’ll appeal to anyone captivated by child narrators or analyses of the pains and joys of motherhood.” —Huffington Post “Riveting. Worth the hype.” —Book Riot “Compulsively readable . . . Beautifully written and unpredictable . . . I had to stop myself racing to the end to find out what happened . . . Kate Hamer catches at the threads of what parents fear most—the abduction of a child—and weaves a disturbing and original story. There is menace in this book, lurking in the shadows on every page, but also innocence, love, and hope.” —Rosamund Lupton, author of Sisters “Gripping and sensitive—beautifully written, The Girl in the Red Coat is a compulsive, aching story full of loss and redemption.” —Lisa Ballantyne, author of The Guilty One “[A] spectacular debut … Telling the story in two remarkable voices, with Beth’s chapters unfurling in past tense and Carmel’s in present tense, the author weaves a page-turning narrative. The trajectories of the novel’s two leads—through despair, hope, and redemption—are believable and nuanced, resulting in a morally complex, haunting read.” — Publishers Weekly , starred review “Reading this novel is a test of how fast you can turn pages.” — Library Journal , starred review “Hamer’s lush use of language easily conjures fairy-tale imagery, especially of dark forests and Little Red Riding Hood. Although a kidnapped child is the central plot point, this is not a mystery but a novel of deep inquiry and intense emotions. Hamer’s dark tale of the lost and found is nearly impossible to put down and will spark much discussion.”xa0— Booklist , starred review“Poignantly details the loss and loneliness of a mother and daughter separated...Fast-paced ... Hamer beautifully renders pain, exactly capturing the evisceration of loss...Exquisite prose surrounding a mother and daughter torn apart.”xa0— Kirkus Reviews KATE HAMER is a winner of the Rhys Davies Short Story Prize.xa0Her first novel, Girl in the Red Coat was shortlisted for the Costa Book Award for First Novel and was a finalist for The Dagger Award.xa0Her second novel, The Doll Funeral was described by the Guardian as evokingxa0both Jeanette Winterson and Ian McEwan.xa0She lives in Cardiff, Wales with her husband and two children. She can be found online at katehamer.co.uk Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. I DREAM ABOUT CARMEL OFTEN. In my dreams she's always walking backwards. xa0 The day she was born there was snow on the ground. A silvery light arced through the window as I held her in my arms. xa0 As she grew up I nicknamed her ‘my little hedge child.' I couldn't imagine her living anywhere but the countryside. Her thick curly hair stood out like a spray of breaking glass, or a dandelion head. xa0 'You look like you've been dragged through a hedge backwards,' I'd say to her. xa0 And she would smile. Her eyes would close and flutter. The pale purple-veined lids like butterflies sealing each eye. xa0 ‘I can imagine that,' she'd say finally, licking her lips. xa0 I'm looking out of the window and I can almost see her - in those tights that made cherry licorice of her legs - walking up the lane to school. The missing her feels like my throat has been removed. xa0 Tonight I’ll dream of her again, I can feel it. I can feel her in the twilight, sitting up on the skeined branches of the beech tree and calling out. But at night in my sleep she'll be walking backwards toward the house - or is it away? – so she never gets closer. xa0 Her clothes were often an untidy riot. The crotch of her winter tights bowed down between her knees so she'd walk like a penguin. Her school collar would stick up on one side and be buried in her jumper on the other. But her mind was a different matter - she knew what people were feeling. When Sally's husband left her, Sally sat in my kitchen drinking tequila as I tried to console her. Salt and lime and liquor for a husband. Carmel came past and made her fingers into little sticks that she stuck into Sally's thick brown hair and massaged her scalp. Sally moaned and dropped her head backwards. xa0 ‘Oh my God, Carmel, where did you learn to do that?' xa0 'Hush, nowhere,' she whispered, kneading away. xa0 That was just before she disappeared into the fog. xa0 Christmas 1999. The children's cheeks blotched pink with cold and excitement as they hurried through the school gates. To me, they all looked like little trolls compared to Carmel. I wondered then if every parent had such thoughts. We had to walk home through the country lanes and already it was nearly dark. xa0 It was cold as we started off and snow edged the road. It glowed in the twilight and marked our way. I realised I was balling my hands in tight fists inside my pockets with worries about Christmas and no money. As I drew my hands out into the cold air and uncurled them Carmel fell back and I could hear her grumbling behind me. xa0 ‘Do hurry up,' I said, anxious to get home out of the freezing night. xa0 ‘You realise. Mum, that I won't always be with you,' she said, her voice small and breathy in the fading light. xa0 Maybe my heart should have frozen then. Maybe I should have turned and gathered her up and taken her home. Kept her shut away in a fortress or a tower. Locked with a golden key that I would swallow, so my stomach would have to be cut open before she could be found. But of course I thought it meant nothing, nothing at all. xa0 'Well, you're with me for now.' xa0 I turned. She seemed far behind me. The shape of her head was the same as the tussocky tops of the hedges that closed in on either side. 'Carmel?' xa0 A long plume of delicate ice breath brushed past my coat sleeve. xa0 'I'm here.' xa0 Sometimes I wonder if when I'm dead I'm destined to be looking still. Turned into an owl and flying over the fields at night, swooping over crouching hedges and dark lanes. The smoke from chimneys billowing and swaying from the movement of my wings as I pass through. Or will I sit with her, high up in the beech tree, playing games? Spying on the people who live in our house and watching their comings and goings. Maybe we'll call out to them and make them jump. xa0 We were single mothers, almost to a man – as one of the group once joked. We clustered together in solidarity of our status. I think now maybe it was not good for Carmel, this band of women with bitter fire glinting from their eyes and rings. Many evenings we'd be around the kitchen table and it would be then he, then he, then he . We were all hurt in some way, bruised inside. Except for Alice who had red bruises. After Carmel had gone - oh, a few months or so - Alice came to the house. xa0 'I had to speak to you,' she said. 'I need to tell you something.' Still I imagined anything could be a clue to the puzzle. xa0 'What is it? What is it?' I asked, frantically clutching at the neck of my dressing gown. What she told me disappointed me so much I turned my face away and looked at the empty shell of the egg I'd eaten yesterday on the kitchen drainer. But when she started to tell me my daughter had a channel to God and could be now at His right hand - how I hated her then. Her false clues and her finding of Jesus, those wrists in identical braided bracelets turning as she spoke. I could stay silent no longer. xa0 'Stop it!' I yelled. 'Get out of here. I thought you had something real to tell me. Get out of this house and leave me alone, you stupid cow. You crazy stupid cow. Take your God with you and don't ever come back.' xa0 Sometimes, just before I fall asleep, I imagine crawling inside the shell of Carmel's skull and finding her memories there. Peering through her eye sockets and watching the film of her life unfold through her eyes. Look, look: there's me and her father, when we were together. Carmel's still small so to her we seem like giants, growing up into the sky. I lean down to pick her up and empty nursery rhymes into her ear. xa0 And there's that day out to the circus. We have a picnic by the big top before we go in. I spread out the blanket on the grass, so I don't notice Carmel turn her head and see the clown peering from between the tent flaps. His face has thick white make-up with a big red mouth shape drawn on. She puzzles why his head is so high up because his stilts are hidden by the striped tent flap. He looks briefly up at the sky to check the weather, then his red-and-white face disappears back inside. xa0 What else? Starting school, me breaking up with Paul and throwing his clothes out of the bedroom window. She must have seen them from where she was in the kitchen - his shirts and trousers sailing down. Other things, how many memories even in a short life: seeing the sea, a day paddling in the river, Christmas, a full moon, snow. xa0 Always I stop at her eighth birthday and can go no farther. Her eighth birthday, when we went to the maze. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • •  An Amazon Best Book of the Year for 2016
  • Costa Book Award for First Novel finalist
  • •  Dagger Award finalist
  • Newly single mom Beth has one constant, gnawing worry: that her dreamy eight-year-old daughter, Carmel, who has a tendency to wander off, will one day go missing.And then one day, it happens: On a Saturday morning thick with fog, Beth takes Carmel to a local outdoor festival, they get separated in the crowd, and Carmel is gone.Shattered, Beth sets herself on the grim and lonely mission to find her daughter, keeping on relentlessly even as the authorities tell her that Carmel may be gone for good.Carmel, meanwhile, is on a strange and harrowing journey of her own—to a totally unexpected place that requires her to live by her wits, while trying desperately to keep in her head, at all times, a vision of her mother …Alternating between Beth’s story and Carmel’s, and written in gripping prose that won’t let go, The Girl in the Red Coat—like Emma Donoghue’s Room and M. L. Stedman’s The Light Between Oceans—is an utterly immersive story that’s impossible to put down . . . and impossible to forget.
  • "Kate Hamer’s gripping debut novel immediately recalls the explosion of similarly titled books and movies, from Stieg Larsson’s
  • The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo
  • and its sequels, to
  • The Girl on the Train
  • to
  • Gone Girl
  • … "—Michiko Kakutani,
  • The New York Times
  • “Keeps the reader turning pages at a frantic clip... What’s most powerful here is not whodunnit, or even why, but how this mother and daughter bear their separation, and the stories they tell themselves to help endure it.” —Celeste Ng (
  • Everything I Never Told You
  • )
  • “Compulsively readable...Beautifully written and unpredictable, I had to stop myself racing to the end to find out what happened.” —Rosamund Lupton (
  • Sister
  • )  “Both gripping and sensitive — beautifully written, it is a compulsive, aching story full of loss and redemption.” —Lisa Ballantyne (
  • The Guilty One)
  • "Hamer’s dark tale of the lost and found is nearly impossible to put down.” —Booklist

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(1.9K)
★★★★
20%
(1.2K)
★★★
15%
(932)
★★
7%
(435)
28%
(1.7K)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

A compelling first debut and worthy of a read

Beth has a daughter named Carmel who tends to disappear but potentially has a propensity for unusual "Powers." Beth is divorced from her husband, Paul who is Carmel's dad at the time she goes to a Festival with Carmel and she disappears. Where she goes and the story that unfolds surrounding Carmel is the crux of the story and is told entirely from Carmel's point of view. I would guess that 2/3 of the book relates to her predicament and her feelings toward what has happened to her while the other third is relating to what Beth does to find Carmel and what is going through her mind.

Do not mistake this for a traditional thriller as there is very little with regard to the investigative portion of the search. The story really revolves around Carmel's thought process during her plight, how she deals with it and what mainly, the evolution of her emotions as time goes by. Although what happened to Carmel is revealed very early in the book it would be a spoiler to mention it, but that situation is very unique and emotionally interesting.

I am not sure Beth's thoughts were fully explored during this book of which the copy I read was just 324 pages but I am not sure that was the point of the book. The pages do turn although the authors writing style can be a bit hard to follow with her wistful ways at times. Perhaps trying to do too much with visually painting a picture rather than telling the story directly to the reader.

I have not read some of the books that this novel has been compared to other than say, Gone Girl or Girl on the Train but both of those are better books than this one in my opinion. Certainly the emotional side explored with Carmel is compelling and worthy of a read, however.

Note to the potential reader: Do not page forward in this book to see how many pages it is as if you look at the title of the last chapter it gives away part of the suspense in this book.
18 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

"Maybe it's not just me, perhaps many women keep shrines for their daughters."

Since the runaway success of Gillian Flynn's Gone Girl, it seems like publishers have been eager to compare their thrillers to that novel. How many times have you seen a book's cover call it "The next Gone Girl"? Publishers have even gone a far as putting the word "girl" in the title in hopes of drawing a comparison (I'm looking at you The Girl on the Train). And so I when I received a review copy of Kate Hamer's debut novel The Girl in the Red Coat, I was prepared for another disappointing Gone Girl imitation. What I got instead was a brutally honest novel about love and loss that shook me to my core.

The novel follows a single mother Beth and her eight-year-old daughter Carmel. Carmel is a precocious child who seems to march to the beat of her own drum. Guided by her own curiosities, the young girl has even been known to stray from her mother's protective view. One day the unthinkable happens. While exploring a storytelling festival, Beth loses sight of Carmel's bright red coat. At first, it seems exactly like the times that the girl has wandered away before. Beth fully expects to worry her head off for a few minutes only to have Carmel pop back into view, oblivious of her mother's paranoia. But this time, things are different. This time, Carmel really is gone.

Chapters in the novel are alternatively told from the perspectives of mother and child. Like the young Jack in Emma Donoghue's Room, Carmel views the situation with a youthful wonder. Hamer skillfully captures the mind of the young child as she grapples with the fear of being alone in the world and longs to find her mother. These portion illustrate the child's ability to adapt to the harrowing situation. Carmel's youthful ignorance guides her frustratingly further from her home as we read on, unable to intervene in the girl's journey.

The ultimate success of this novel hinges on Beth's heartbreaking story. Her chapter's bring insight into the mind of a woman whose life has been upturned. She is emotionally broken and desperately clings to any hope of finding her daughter. It is in these chapters that Kate Hamer truly shines. She writes of the madness that can come with grief and desperation, truly capturing the isolation and hopelessness of loss.

"I don't think we can feel guilty, Beth. Not for anything we feel or anything we think. No one else knows. No one. And if they say they do they're liars."

The Girl in the Red Coat is a stunning novel that is written with an honesty that strips the character's feelings to the bare bones. The quick pace of the prose deceptively leads the reader towards sudden walls of inescapable emotion that can't be bypassed. I found myself pondering my own losses throughout my life, especially the ones that came out of nowhere. While this novel can be intense and the situations difficult to reconcile, it is the unrelenting love of a mother for her child that ultimately shines through. Despite all of the sorrow and heartache in the world, love will always remain.
17 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Biggest waste of time of the year

This book is so disappointing that I don't even know what I mind the most: the implausibility of the entire plot, the totally anti-clamacic non-ending, or the narrative that leads to nothing. I kept reading in the idle hope that the ending would be worth it somehow, and then starting to skip more and more sentences and paragraphs as I realized nothing was happening. I sometimes put up with slow books because of a deeper message or an intricate plot that needs time to unravel. Nothing unravels here. Nothing is explained. Nothing makes sense. And especially there's no joy at the end. How can a story this bad get any kind of publicity is the true mystery of this book.
10 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Extremely readable book due to superb writing

When I ordered this book, knowing it was about a small girl who gets abducted, I thought, "why would an author write a book that instantly eliminates a huge portion of the population, i.e. women who have had children, since most women I know cannot even tolerate the thought of a child being abducted." The author, however, has crafted a book that is impressive, extremely readable, and, dare I say, enjoyable.

You need not be afraid of reading this book. It is not what your worst fears tell you it is about. It is about how a mother and a daughter, in alternating chapters, describe their experiences after she is whisked off into another life. There is no sexual violence, and no physical violence. It is not a police procedural.

This is a very talented writer. Several times I had to read a paragraph out loud to my wife because the writing was so evocative. At the end, the author acknowledges Stephen King's book "On Writing," and some of King's style shows in her writing. Characters are thoroughly portrayed, and you have a real sense of their personalities and their relationships. The story is very engaging, and you want to know how each of the narrators are handling this crisis over time. Highly recommended.
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A brilliant debut -- Studded with thorns and as twisty as taffy...

Another child abducted. Another frantic, anguished parent awaiting news. Why read it?

A. Kate Hamer's writing -- if you care about bewitching metaphors, poetic prose and a deeply evocative atmosphere you will find it in this novel.

B. The plot is pure genius. This diabolical tale has no predictable route or exit. Its surface topography is a vast and unfamiliar landscape -- rutted and treacherous, studded with thorns and as twisty as taffy.

C. The absolutely mesmerizing voices of the two main characters, Carmel and her mother Beth. The chapters alternate -- each are told in the first person by the mother and the daughter. Hamer embodies these characters so completely you might wonder if she's schizophrenic. She IS eight year old Carmel lost in the fog. Tugging on her crimson toggle coat. Looking up at adult faces the way an 8 year old would. Seeing eyes and mouths and leaves and limbs and loss the way an 8 year old would. Kate Hamer constructs this captivating little girl so deftly and beautifully it's impossible to imagine the child doesn't actually exist in the world. It's impossible to imagine there is a grown woman behind her -- Her choreographer, her Frankenstein, her God: holding her upright, wielding her small arms and spouting her meticulous 8 year old voice with its perfectly whittled down vocabulary and brutally candid prepubescent observations. And then the child is gone and Beth the mother reappears. Her long limbs whipping about restlessly, her exhausted adult eyes combing every inch of land -- sucking up anything and everything that could possibly lead her back to her child. Hamer gives herself completely to each character. She is an incredibly visceral writer. She writes like a fox shadowing its prey. She knows when to move. When to leap. When to bite. And when she does, watch out because she bites to the bone.

D. The fantastic freak in the fog. The Girl In The Red Coat is a cunning and menacing tale. It lures you in like a fairy tale at first. An allegorical nightmare --all swirling leaves and smoky woods. The night sky sparking as the girl in red darts through a lush green maze. Her mother tearing after her. After that flash of red. But something else is after little Carmel too. Something deranged and sinister and it's not the predictable pedophile hoping to defile her. Hamer is clearly too smart and innovative for that hackneyed route. Something will emerge from the fog and the fog will take great chunks out of them until they're nowhere....until they're gone.

E. The mother and daughter's extraordinary endurance through it all. This novel is an illustrious thriller but it's also a taught and perceptive psychological drama. When she isn't splashing on buckets of terror and suspense Hamer is boring into the psyches of this mother and daughter torn apart like a little child boring into a Baroque cupcake the size of a ostrich egg. By the end Carmel and Beth are strewn everywhere. Their mangled dreams and silver tears. Their rotting memories and long rivulets of desperation. You can almost reach out and scoop up their love. Love as hard and calloused as gravel in your hands.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Here we go again... a retread of some familiar literary tropes and themes

This novel tried very, very hard, but somehow couldn't break out of the "been here before" category for me. A child is abducted; a woman, the mother, is left behind to grieve and try to find her way through life as a mother without a child. Meanwhile her daughter, Carmel, has to make her way through a wildly different kind of world, the one her abductors create for her.

Kate Hamer tries to link Carmel's pre-abduction life as a dreamy 8-year-old with an uncanny ability to read the emotions of others to the abduction, but it's a bit heavy-handed, and while I suppose the abduction tale itself isn't impossible, I found the gradually mounting series of events to be improbable. Did Carmel never question her abuctors' narrative, but just take it all for granted? Beth, the mother, was a more believable character, but at the same time, less interesting.

Ultimately, reading along as the chapters moved between telling the tale from Carmel's perspective and those from Beth's, I began to suspect that somehow it would all wrap up with mother and daughter reunited in some way and just wanted to get to that stage. But without disclosing what does happen, I will say that there's a big jump over an inconveniently long time span in the final 20% or so of the book (why?) after which the reader gets a kind of data dump of what has happened to the main characters in the intervening years. And then there's a sudden rush to the end, during which a lot of stuff seems to happen suddenly and inexplicably, without enough linkage to make sense. So, frustrating to read, even for someone accustomed to literary fiction where you have to read between the lines constantly.

I can see why someone might compare this to "Room" although the latter novel by Emma Donoghue is tautly focused and genuinely suspenseful novel that somehow manages to make a small child's narrative voice sound authentic. Unfortunately, Hamer doesn't quite pull off any of those feats in this novel.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Losing And Being Lost. An Unusual Novel

Carmel is an eight year old English girl with a tendency to go missing at times. Beth is her divorced, over-protective mother. One day while they're attending a festival, Carmel goes missing for real, and stays missing for more than five years. Mum can't know, but the reader will soon understand, that she has been abducted and taken to America. During her five year plus exile she must fight for survival and for her identity, while her mother desperately clings to hope and tries to find her missing child.

Author Kate Hamer writes in lucid, flowing prose, alternating viewpoints between Carmel and Beth. Unfortunately the story tends to drag, almost as though it were happening in real time. For this reviewer it was a struggle to get through the book, and the ending, five years later, was anticlimactic. The story was an artful exploration of how a little girl deals with an unbelievable upheaval in her life, but it simply went on too long, and it left too many dangling threads that were never tied up.

I can recommend this one with some reservations. It won't be for everyone. Reviewed by Louis N. Gruber.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Girl missing; Intrigue found

The metaphorical question that needs to be asked by the reader of any unputdownable book is 'and then what?' Often, the question is a mere flicker of curiosity as our daily distractions take over: work, family, walking the dog, feeding the goldfish, cleaning, shaving - although why girls spend so much time shaving parts that don't need to be shaved, I'll never know!

Sometimes a book comes along which is almost as important as, say, feeding the goldfish; cleaning, shaving, even work and family; a book that captures the imagination and has to be completed before the rest of our lives can restart. Kate Hamer's first novel is such a book!

Carmel, a mildly mixed-up eight year old with a propensity to get lost, may have special psychic talent, could, perhaps, be different from everyone else. Her mother, Beth, is struggling to find a version of normality, following separation from her partner, who is now ensconced with a new woman and rarely visits them.

What happens on a misty day when Carmel disappears, mysteriously ending up with Gramps across the Atlantic and why, is at the heart of the book - and this book has heart, lots of it - even showing Gramps three dimensionally and allowing the growing girl to form friendships with her travelling companions, Silver and Melody and fleetingly, Nico. How much we want her to be reassured and 'found'. Even her occasional jousting with Dorothy appears quite normal, although she's living a nomadic life in an abnormal situation.

How special is Carmel, can she really heal, should she use her powers for the good of others? What are we to make of the religious implications of her talent, even if it is being misused and misappropriated?

The author learnt her trade through attendance at a major creative writing course, but the warmth of her characters, non-judgmental approach and ability to construct a unique page-turner which demands a swift sequel, is not something that can be learnt. Like Carmel's apparent talent, it comes from somewhere special: the soul.

There are books and there is literature; this is a work of literary skill that demands attention and rightfully grabs it - right until the last sentence on the last page. A great first book, well done Kate!
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

... reading this novel from the reviews but was really disappointed in it almost didn't finish it

i really looked forward to reading this novel from the reviews but was really disappointed in it almost didn't finish it. in fact started another book before finishing. too slow, too predictable and in my opinion not that well written. this won't go in my library.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

which at times I found annoying or confusing

Title: The Girl in the Red Coat
Author: Kate Hamer
Classification: Fiction
Copyright: 2016
Rating: 2 stars

Carmel is the 8-year old daughter of Beth, a single mom living in England. Carmel has a tendency to wander off, and while attending a local book fair on a foggy Saturday, she does just that. The chapters alternate between Beth and Carmel, with both being told in the first person, which at times I found annoying or confusing. Beth is obviously consumed with finding her daughter, while Carmel has been taken by an older man who is actually a “traveling” Bible-thumper who uses her to earn money by passing her off a healer. The story spans nearly 6 years during which Beth constantly is searching while Carmel constantly is coping with her situation, never forgetting Mum but (obviously due to her age) unable to do anything about it. I picked up this book because it was compared to Emma Donoghue's Room, a book that I thoroughly enjoyed. No comparison in my mind. To me, the story was slow moving, even tedious at times. While not poorly written, it was just not my cup of tea (seems like I say that a lot lately).
4 people found this helpful