The Silent Wife: A Novel
The Silent Wife: A Novel book cover

The Silent Wife: A Novel

Paperback – June 25, 2013

Price
$13.04
Format
Paperback
Pages
326
Publisher
Penguin Books
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0143123231
Dimensions
1 x 4.19 x 6.75 inches
Weight
8 ounces

Description

"It’s this summer’s Gone Girl – I gobbled it down in one sitting, and because of the wonderful writing, I did not feel one speck guilty.” – Anne Lamott, People Magazine "Utterly absorbing." —Laura Miller, Salon "A. S. A. Harrison knocks it out of the park with her first novel, The Silent Wife . With a spare, elegant, and deft hand, she paints two dueling psychological portraits of longtime live-in lovers who become putative killer and hapless victim in a tale that no one is likely to forget anytime soon. I couldn't put this book down." —Elizabeth George, New York Times bestselling author of A Banquet of Consequences "What a deliciously wicked pleasure The Silent Wife was to read. I love books where I can't guess the outcome, although I was rooting for Jodi all the way. A very clever, very funny comedy of manners spliced with a domestic thriller." —Kate Atkinson, New York Times bestselling author of Life After Life "Beautifully written and deeply unsettling, this darkly funny examination of what happens when you've got nothing left to lose is also brilliantly addictive. It left me almost breathless as I raced toward the devastating finale." S. J. Watson, New York Times bestselling author of Before I Go to Sleep "SUPERB...As a novel about the dark side of marriage and relationships, it's better than Gillian Flynn's Gone Girl . A must read for anyone who is occasionally ruthless, reckless, or psychologically weird—and anyone who loves clever books with depth and heart." —Sophie Hannah, author of The Other Woman's House “This summer's sleeper hit” – The New York Times “ The Silent Wife is a boning knife of a novel, sharp and quick.” – Newsday “Watch out, Gone Girl .” – USA Today “A.S.A Harrison's The Silent Wife is a clean, understated thriller” – NPR.ORG “You can't blame the publishers of The Silent Wife for hyping it as ‘the new Gone Girl .’ It's not. It just might be better.” – The Huffington Post “For those who loved Gone Girl … The Silent Wife is a quick-witted marital pas de deaux featuring a psychotherapist and her philandering husband.” – Vogue , “Summer’s Best Mystery Reads” xa0xa0xa0 “May be as popular as Gone Girl was last summer.” – CBS This Morning, “Best Reads for Your Summer Vacation” “The surprises keep coming, pager after quiet page… Harrison writes well with a light touch, but her touch is devastating nonetheless.” – The Guardian , US Summer Reads pick xa0xa0 “That final revelation from Harrison, who, regrettably, died before she could see her debut novel published, inflicts the stealth damage of an icepick to the carotid artery.” – Sarah Weinman, New Republic A. S. A. Harrison is the author of four books of nonfiction. The Silent Wife is her debut novel and she was at work on a new psychological thriller when she died in 2013. She lived with her husband, visual artist John Massey, in Toronto, Canada. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Chapter 1 HER It’s early September. Jodi Brett is in her kitchen, making dinner. Thanks to the open plan of the condo, she has an unobstructed view through the living room to its east-facing windows and beyond to a vista of lake and sky, cast by the evening light in a uniform blue. A thinly drawn line of a darker hue, the horizon, appears very near at hand, almost touchable. She likes this delineating arc, the feeling it gives her of being encircled. The sense of containment is what she loves most about living here, in her aerie on the twenty-seventh ?oor. At forty-?ve, Jodi still sees herself as a young woman. She does not have her eye on the future but lives very much in the moment, keeping her focus on the everyday. She assumes, without having thought about it, that things will go on inde?nitely in their imperfect yet entirely acceptable way. In other words, she is deeply unaware that her life is now peaking, that her youthful resilience—which her twenty-year marriage to Todd Gilbert has been slowly eroding—is approaching a ?nal stage of disintegration, that her notions about who she is and how she ought to conduct herself are far less stable than she supposes, given that a few short months are all it will take to make a killer out of her. If you told her this she would not believe you. Murder is barely a word in her vocabulary, a concept without meaning, the subject of stories in the news having to do with people she doesn’t know and will never meet. Domestic violence she ?nds especially implausible, that everyday friction in a family setting could escalate to such a degree. There are reasons for this incomprehension, even aside from her own habit of self-control: She is no idealist, believes in taking the bad with the good, does not pick ?ghts, and is not easily baited. The dog, a golden retriever with a silky blond coat, sits at her feet as she works at the cutting board. Every now and then she throws him a slice of raw carrot, which he catches in his mouth and joyfully grinds up with his molars. This vegetable toss is a long-standing predinner ritual, one that she and the dog have enjoyed from the time she brought him home as a roly-poly pup to take Todd’s mind o? his yearning for progeny, which sprang up, seemingly overnight, around the time he turned forty. She named the dog Freud in anticipation of the fun she could poke at his namesake, the misogynist whom she was forced to take seriously at university. Freud passing gas, Freud eating garbage, Freud chasing his tail. The dog is endlessly good-natured and doesn’t mind in the least being an object of fun. Trimming vegetables and chopping herbs, she throws herself bodily into the work. She likes the intensity of cooking—the readiness of the gas ?ame, the timer marking o? the minutes, the immediacy of the result. She’s aware of the silence beyond the kitchen, everything rushing to the point in time when she’ll hear his key in the lock, an event that she anticipates with pleasure. She can still feel that making dinner for Todd is an occasion, can still marvel at the stroke of fate that brought him into her life, a matter of rank chance that did not seem to favor a further acquaintance, much less a future of appetizing meals, lovingly prepared. It came to pass on a rainy morning in spring. Busy with her graduate studies in psychology, waiting tables at night, overworked, exhausted, she was moving house, driving north on State Street in a rental van loaded with her household goods. As she prepared to change lanes from right to left she might have looked over her shoulder or maybe not. She found the van awkward, didn’t have a feel for it, and on top of this her windows were fogged and she’d missed her turn at the last set of lights. Given these conditions she might have been distracted—a question that later came to be much discussed between them. When he clipped her driver’s-side door and spun her into oncoming tra?c, there was a general honking of horns and squealing of brakes, and before she could pull herself together—before she fully realized that her van had come to a standstill and she was perfectly alright—he was screaming at her through her closed window. “You crazy bitch. What in God’s name do you think you’re doing? Are you some kind of maniac? Where did you learn to drive? People like you should stay o? the road. Are you going to get out of your car or are you just going to sit there like an imbecile?” His tirade that day in the rain did not give a favorable impression, but a man who’s been in a car crash is going to be irate even if it’s his own fault, which in this instance it was not, so when he called a few days later to ask her to dinner, she graciously accepted. He took her to Greektown, where they ate lamb souvlaki washed down with cold retsina. The restaurant was crowded, the tables close together, the lights bright. They found themselves shouting over the din and laughing at their failure to be heard. What conversation they could manage was pared down to succinct phrases like, “The food is good . . . I like it here . . . my windows were fogged . . . if it hadn’t happened I would never have met you.” She didn’t go out on many bona ?de dates. The men she knew from university took her for pizza and beer and counted out their money. They’d meet her at the restaurant scru?y and unshaven, still in the clothes they’d worn to class. Whereas Todd had put on a clean shirt, and he’d picked her up, and they’d driven to the restaurant together—and now he was looking after her, re?lling her glass and checking on her comfort level. Sitting across from him, she was pleased with what she saw—the way he casually took up space and his air of being in charge. She liked the homey habit he had of wiping his knife on his bread and that he put down his credit card without looking at the bill. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • The New York Times bestselling novel soon to be a major motion picture starring Nicole Kidman, for fans of
  • The Woman in the Window
  • and
  • The Silent Patient.
  • "
  • I gobbled it down in one sitting." – Anne Lamott,
  • People
  • Jodi and Todd are at a bad place in their marriage. Much is at stake, including the affluent life they lead in their beautiful waterfront condo in Chicago, as she, the killer, and he, the victim, rush haplessly toward the main event. He is a committed cheater. She lives and breathes denial. He exists in dual worlds. She likes to settle scores. He decides to play for keeps. She has nothing left to lose. Told in alternating voices,
  • The Silent Wife
  • is about a marriage in the throes of dissolution, a couple headed for catastrophe, concessions that can’t be made, and promises that won’t be kept. Expertly plotted and reminiscent of
  • Gone Girl
  • and
  • These Things Hidden
  • ,
  • The Silent Wife
  • ensnares the reader from page one and does not let go.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(6.5K)
★★★★
20%
(4.4K)
★★★
15%
(3.3K)
★★
7%
(1.5K)
28%
(6.1K)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Scenes Can't Be Unread; Unrealistic; Made Me Mildly Sick ***Spoilers***

This odd story can't be characterized as a modern (2013) novel. The premise that a well-educated moderately affluent woman in Chicago with affluent well-educated married/divorced friends has no money and doesn't know that living w/a man without marriage for 20 years gives her absolutely no legal status as his wife is absurd. This is especially true given that it was written when gay marriage cases were racing to the Supreme Court and all consequences and lack of benefits of being together without marriage was at the forefront of news. Even Joy Behar, the aging flower child host of The View, dashed to the altar in 2011 after 25 years of living together when learning through estate planning that there is a difference between being married and not. Jodi - "Her" - is content to work part time from home and live well, shopping, cooking, and overlooking "His" other women as though she was a 1950s housewife or a modern woman who has come to a financial arrangement with Him. The fact that in 20 years neither raised the issue of money nor marriage after their youthful moving in together is completely unrealistic.

What made me slightly sick is that the roots of Her silence is incestuous child sexual abuse at the hands of her older brother. She learns to loll into acceptance at the age of six and carries that into her adult sex life. "He" remarks how she immediately becomes "slack" with glazed eyes before/during sex at the of 45ish. Queasy-making. That is an image I can't unread. Must every story be about childhood sex abuse? Piling on, the brother moves on to the younger brother.

The story is not Her/Him, but of their parents' marriages. Each - despite deliberate actions to avoid doing so - becomes their parents. Her - silent and seething; Him - an abusive alcoholic hiding from everyone. The unraveling which reads as though it's taking years, the author reminds us is only a matter of weeks - shown through the stages of a first trimester pregnancy. Ironically, it's not Her to whom He is physically abusive; it's the young student who is deliberately pregnant w/His child that he rages and hits as He is dragged toward the altar.

Unfortunately, only one of this vile cast is murdered.
101 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Not worth your time!

I have no idea what book the other reviewers read, but I sure didn't read the same one because I thought this book was horrible. The Silent Wife: A Novel was amateurish, seemingly written by a high school student, and devoid of the depth necessary to make the characters interesting.

The story itself was appealing because I thought it was going to be a mystery of sorts. Sure, you know the main storyline from the book description, but I figured there would be some energy or plots twists to make it exciting. Instead, I quickly got bored of Todd and Jodi and didn't care what happened in their relationship. Especially since the title is misleading - Todd and Jodi are not married so Jodi is not a silent "wife."

One of the main reasons for my dislike of this book was the needless introduction of flashback of Jodi's therapy sessions with Gerard. That side story goes absolutely nowhere and doesn't really fit into the overall plot. It just wastes pages and detracts from the plot. Yes, there is somewhat of a revelation at the end of the book that has to do with Jodi's therapy sessions, but that has nothing to do with the way she behaves in the story and doesn't shed light on anything at all. Also, some of the conversations in the book are ludicrous! For example, Todd (one of the main characters) gets into an argument with his best friend, Dean, and Dean calls Todd a "blockhead" and a "stinking turd." Now remember, these characters are in their late 40s. Who the heck calls someone a blockhead or a stinking turd unless they are still in elementary school?? At another point in the book, the author says, "Jodi's brother Ryan was 6 yrs younger and a boy." Uh - duh!! You just wrote "Jodi's brother," that by definition means Ryan is a boy. And another time, the author writes about Jodi's "disuse of chambers of her heart." What the heck??? Such language is just plain silly.

And then, unless you are a high school student, you would know that there is no way in the world characters in their 40s who have been together for 20 yrs would act so stupidly. The only person in the book whose actions seemed to make sense were Natasha's and that's because she was in her early 20s and still in college. The other characters were just too stupid to be believable - especially since Jodi has a doctorate degree and is a psychotherapist. I felt like I was reading a movie script for a tween television show that would be aired on ABC right after some so-called "drama" like Pretty Little Liars! That's not a good thing.

It's true that the switching back and forth between the point of view of Jodi and the perspective of Todd does add a neat feature to the book, but it's definitely not enough to justify paying more than $0.99 for this book.

I just cannot recommend "The Silent Wife" by A.S.A. Harrison. The characters are superficial, the story is contrived, and the writing is sloppy.
62 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

No.

This book was honestly not very good. I'm pretty disappointed that I purchased it, and I'd suggest steering clear if you're looking for an engrossing summer read.

Where do I even start?

- The author's writing style wasn't necessarily bad, but it was not at all suited to a novel that was marketed as a psychological thriller. I would expect a book fitting that description to have a sense of urgency about it. The stream-of-consciousness style in which Harrison writes just doesn't work here. Pages are devoted to the minutiae of Jodi's and Todd's daily routines, while potentially more interesting plot points are glossed over (but I'll get to that in a minute). There is very little dialogue, and the conversations that are relayed are, as other reviewers have noted, almost like something out of a particularly bad black-and-white film. Characters' interactions feel canned and inauthentic.

- There is very little character development. I feel confused as to the couple of reviews that have mentioned great depth of character in Todd and Jodi. I found both of them completely unlikeable, and not in a way that made me want to keep reading. Todd is the stereotypical philandering husband; Jodi is the stereotypical therapist with an inordinate number of personal issues, and I had a hard time feeling sympathetic for her. Early in the book it mentions how she balks at misogyny in psychotherapy, yet she seems to love playing the kept woman and keeping house for her partner. Her thoughts seemed to hold a lot of internalized misogyny and stereotypical ideas about gender roles. Most notably, she feels she can't expect her partner not to cheat because (by her logic) he's a man and that's what men do. She adores him anyway and dismisses other people who expect him to change, even though his behavior obviously hurts her. She is moody at best and self-destructive at worst without his attention. No mental health professional is perfect, but I'm not even sure that Jodi should be seeing the few clients she has.

Supporting characters aren't any better. From the other woman to the other woman's angry father to Jodi's shady friend Alison, they're all just as one-dimensional as Jodi and Todd.

- The circumstances surrounding Jodi's plan to kill her husband are ludicrous for at least a couple of reasons:
- As I've mentioned, Jodi slowly begins to stop functioning without Todd, and she holds out hope that he will come back to her. We are left with no explanation as to how she seems to set this yearning for him completely aside when she decides to kill him. There is no mention of her feeling conflicted about the decision, which I would expect her to based on what we know about her. On the contrary, she seems to approach a moment of clarity when she decides to do it.
- If Jodi needs more money, wouldn't expanding her practice be the obvious (and legal, and less destructive) choice? I mean, obviously it will take time to do that, but it seems like a no-brainer, since she only works part-time. She even thinks about doing that briefly but abandons the idea in favor of killing Todd.

- Honestly, this book was such a drudge that the twist at the end wasn't even very interesting. Who really knows what happened? Better question: Who cares? Not me.

- The fleeting commentary on Jodi's family history had nothing to do with anything. Not only was it irrelevant to the plot, it didn't really give us insight into her as a character. Okay, it gave us some insight into her relationship with her brothers, but that's a side plot that isn't related to anything else in the book. Why was this included?

This book isn't bad because it's nothing like Gone Girl. It's bad because it's just not very interesting.
29 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Eh...

First of all, it irritates me that this book is being marketed as "the next 'Gone Girl'"; after completing "The Silent Wife", I can tell you that it is nothing like "Gone Girl", so why compare the two in the first place? This book centers around a dissolving marriage (which is probably the only similarity it shares with "Gone Girl") and is told in alternating voices, from the husband and wife.
The Good: The book really fleshed out each of the two main characters. I feel like I can understand and empathize with their actions and ultimately feel sorry for each of them at the novel's end. Their alternating views of their marriage provide a realistic and three dimensional perspective on the troubling effects infidelity can cause. In all, the novel was thought provoking.
The Bad: This book had lots of incidents of plot lines introduced that were either never tied up or were not needed entirely. For example, the wife spends chapters and chapters talking about her estranged brother, but no resolution for their detachment is ever revealed. In the husband's storyline, he becomes worried that he could have contracted HIV, yet this health scare is never explained, nor does it do anything to propel the story.
The Ugly: Most frustrating is the fact that this book is being marketed as "the next 'Gone Girl'". I believe this is insulting to A. S. A. Harrison, because it forces readers to begin "The Silent Wife" with preset expectations that are just not going to be met. I feel like I would have enjoyed the book a lot better if I had not heard or read any of the reviews for it, which definitely clouded my thoughts while reading.
All in all, "The Silent Wife" does a fantastic job of painting two very different people and the rise and fall of the life they built together. However, the story's abundance of loose ends and lack of drive keep it from entering the realm of "great books".
22 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Starts out disappointing and only gets worse.

"The Silent Wife" sounds intriguing from the synopsis. Reviews herald it as the new "Gone Girl." What it really is is a big pike of yikes. From the very first page, this novel is full of unnecessarily flowery language, pretentious-sounding run-on descriptions, and flat, dull characters. Half of what happens isn't even believable. A 46-year-old man has never heard of an at-home pregnancy test? Come on.

Also, I hope you like unnecessarily long descriptions of psychology and six-page transcripts between the main character and her psychologist about a subplot that has essentially nothing to do with anything, because this book is bursting with them.

I'm all for the flawed character, the nitty-gritty personality traits, but without any redeeming qualities, it just becomes exhausting. And there is not a single thing to like about any of the characters in this book. (Except maybe the dog. The dog's alright.)

"The Good Wife" shouldn't be lumped in with the like of "Gone Girl," or even called a thriller. There's nothing thrilling about it. It's as lifeless as Jodi and Todd's marriage. It's impossible to root for any of the characters, and there's no suspense because you really don't care one way or another what happens to them.

Save your money, your time, and your sanity. Stay away from this train wreck of a novel.
21 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Definitely not Gone Girl....at all

I am actually irritated that so many of the reviews and blurbs compare this book to Gone Girl when I found it to be nothing like Gone Girl except for the fact that there is a marriage gone wrong. Statements like "I gobbled it down in one sitting" are also misleading. I had to struggle to finish this book. The main characters are depressing, confusing and not appealing at all. The writing is dreary and I found myself skipping entire passages by the end. The plot makes sense in a nightmarish way, and I don't mean that it was thrilling. The "inner workings" of the characters is incessantly described. I went out of my way to write this review because I was so disappointed, irritated and generally displeased with this book.
17 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Completely disappointing

A disappointing story which was extra disappointing because of all the hype surrounding it. It was a slow drag with one dimensional characters who can't even seem to stay in their dimension. Jodi, a strong unemotional rationalist who completely loses her mind the minute her common law husband steps out and Todd, the serial philanderer who upends his life and shacks up with the first woman who suggests it. Uhm what? The denouement is foreshadowed on the cover of the book so that thrill was gone and even Jodi's last minute reaction/decision is out of left field and completely inexplicable.

Not a well written story. The authors who blurbed this have really disappointed me. I mean have some decency towards readers, don't bald faced b.s. a review, they lose all credibility. Sophie Hannah... for shame :/
15 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

It kept me reading, but I knew what was ...

It kept me reading, but I knew what was going to happen. There was no one to root for in this story. They were all miserable individuals. Also, small point, but irritating non the less, if you are going to write a book set in America for God's sake have it edited by an American. 25 percent of the way through and I knew this author couldn't be American. Americans don't use "foam" cream to shave. We use shaving cream. We don't go to university. We go to college. There were others, but I won't bore you. Never rings true when the lingo doesn't match the setting.
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I can't imagine this would be a very good movie at all

I'm not sure who compared this book to "this summer's Gone Girl", but that, by far, is not at accurate description of this book. Was more than half way through and was still waiting for something to happen. Then it finally happens and I was let down. It was a very disappointing book. I can't imagine this would be a very good movie at all. The flash back to the days with her therapists are pointless and have no impact on the story itself.
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Don't waste your time

If I could give this book 0 stars I would. I have no idea how it's compared to Gone Girl or why it's called a suspenseful book. The story is about the mundane life of a woman and her cheating partner. The author somehow managed to write a whole chapter on the man's itchy balls - which I guess some may call impressive. This book dragged on and didn't have any suspenseful aspects to it. I definitely wouldn't recommend reading it.
10 people found this helpful