Why We Came to the City: A Novel
Why We Came to the City: A Novel book cover

Why We Came to the City: A Novel

Hardcover – February 16, 2016

Price
$10.07
Format
Hardcover
Pages
432
Publisher
Viking
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0525426608
Dimensions
6.25 x 1.35 x 9.31 inches
Weight
1.4 pounds

Description

From Publishers Weekly Jansma's compelling paean to New York City features a group of post-college friends who manage the vagaries of love and friendship against the backdrop of living in the big city: opportunity, stress, beauty, as well as the allure of the über rich juxtaposed against the impoverished. The cast includes Irene Richmond, an artist supporting her craft by working at a hip art gallery; George Murphy, an astronomer whose life research may be imploding; his college girlfriend and soon to be wife, Sara Sherman, an editor for a paper; William Cho, working in investments, living with his mother, and harboring a crush on Irene; and Jacob Blaumann, the quintessential graduate not living up to his potentialâx80x94having made his mark as a poet, but working as an orderly at a mental health facility in the suburbs and having an affair with his boss. Underneath the interactions between the characters lurks an examination of relationships and the ways friendship is tested when one in their midst is beset by a rare form of cancer. Steering clear of the maudlin, the author gives searing portrayals of both challenging cancer treatment and how true friends rise to the occasion when necessary. Jansma (The Unchangeable Spots of Leopards) pens a tightly-written, smartly conceived story that puts an insightful spin on life in the Big Apple. (Feb.)\n Praise for Why We Came to the City “A tremendous accomplishment: anxa0elegantxa0and deeply moving meditation on friendship and mortality, bothxa0fearless and finely wrought.xa0I believe this book will stay with me for a very long time.” —Emily St. John Mandel, author of Station Eleven “Stunning . . . A beautiful, sprawling, and generous book. Jansma is a brilliantly talented writer, but he also has a unique insight into what friends mean to one another, and what it means to be part of a city in which you never quite belong, but can’t quite bring yourself to leave. It’s a heartfelt novel, tender and painful and cathartic all at once, and even if the characters belong to New York, the story belongs to us all.” —Michael Schaub, NPR “A brilliant stylist, Kristopher Jansma draws readers into an intricate web of lives in the big city in his astonishing new work. He writes with power and passion . . . and inhabits his characters, thinking what they think and feeling what they feel so compellingly that he pulls the reader into the story and won’t let go. . . . A wonderful, unforgettable novel.” — Miami Herald “Jansma’s novel is a love letter to Manhattan, the letter so many of us who moved here in our 20s have written. . . . Like the rest of us, his characters learn that things don’t always work out the way we plan, but if we stick with our city, our city delivers.” —Helen Ellis, The New York Times Book Review “Enticing . . . Much like a modern Great Gatsby , this book is awash in the feeling of the city.” —Melissa Ragsdale, Bustle “Fans of Bret Easton Ellis’s stream-of-consciousness narrativesxa0will enjoy Jasma’s paean to New York City.” — In Style “Joyful and tragic, Jansma’s book will appeal to readers who loved Hanya Yanagihara’s A Little Life .” — Men’s Journal “As the characters navigate the complexities of an untimely and unexpected tragedy . . . Jansma artfully counters the heaviness of these themes with a delightful, and at times laugh-out-loud hilarious, narrative. Dialogues are smart, absurd, and addictive; and the author’s insights border on the philosophically expansive and profound.” —Santa Cruz Sentinel "Like A Little Life and The Love Affairs of Nathaniel P. , Jansma's Why We Came to the City shows us, with beauty and insight, what it's like to be young and smart in this time, and in this place. It's xa0a major achievement." —Darin Strauss, author of Half a Life “Why did we come to the city, anyway?xa0And why on earth would we ever leave?xa0In Jansma's able hands, these are and are not metaphors. We came because we are more ourselves as part of a collective.xa0We came to learn our limits.xa0We came so that we might know when to leave.xa0This is a lively, addictive party of a book, and you're invited." —Elisa Albert, author of After Birth “Fantastic. This beautiful, boisterous novel is a paean to New York, to the hubris of youthful optimism, and, especially, to the powerful magnet of friendship. It’s full of as much heartache and humor as the city itself. And like the city, this story will break you apart in a dozen ways, only to teach you, tenderly, how to put yourself back together. I wanted it never to end, but when I read the last page, I loved it even more. Jansma is a star.” —Alena Graedon, author of The Word Exchange “Kristopher Jansma’s dazzling Why We Came to the City is at once a tribute and a breakup letter to New York, timeless as the elegant architectural details that jut ornately from older buildings, yet timely as a phone freighted with an urgent missive. The constellation of relationships he charts feels so vivid and visceral that we not only see it but find ourselves caught, swaying in its gravitational tugs and tilts. In page after page abounding with wit, candor, and compassion, Jansma reveals the indelible nature of our connections and commitments to one another, along with their gossamer fragility.” —Tim Horvath, author of Understories “Lively and elegant . . .xa0poised to make Jansma a name you know.” —Meredith Turits “A deeply emotional ode to friendship . . . Jansma’s narrative shines.” — Kirkus Reviews “Jansma’s compelling paean to New York City features a group of post-college friends who manage the vagaries of love and friendship against the backdrop of living in the big city. . . . A tightly written, smartly conceived story that puts an insightful spin on life in the Big Apple.” — Publishers Weekly “This hefty novel, with its multiple characters and shifting relationships, is the kind that book clubs will love. . . . Gets at the heart of what it’s like to be young and alive in the big city.” —Library Journal Kristopher Jansma is the author of The Unchangeable Spots of Leopards , winner of the Sherwood Anderson Foundation Fiction Award. A graduate of Columbia University’s MFA program, he is now an assistant professor of English and creative writing at SUNY New Paltz and a graduate lecturer in fiction at Sarah Lawrence College. He has written for the New York Times, Salon, The Believer, The Millions, Slice, BOMB, and Electric Literature . He lives with his wife and son in Brooklyn, New York. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. 1 Living Vicariously Irene Richmond ran down the narrow foyer, helping guests get out of their coats, which were dusted with flakes of snow that had been coming down heavily all day and still drifted lightly onto the hotel balcony. Coats that cost more than she earned in a month and that were works of art themselves. Hoods lined with fox fur imported from Finland. A quilted sateen coat filled with goose down and patterned in the latest Japanese style of concentric circles. A long vest made of rabbit. Mongolian lamb’s wool. Irene got a thrill from just holding them, but it was always short- lived. By the time the guests had finished warning her not to crease the collars or wrinkle the hems, there was someone else making an even more fashionable entrance. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 During rare pauses, she checked her phone for messages from George and Sara. Nothing. And nothing from Jacob either. Twisting in front of the hallway mirror, she reseated the bobby pins that kept her blond hair up off her shoulders. She liked the way her neck looked in the golden light by the door. An elegant extension of her one bared shoulder. She hoped it wasn’t too much. Abeba had said only to look nice, but Irene had sensed an implication that she not look nicer than the guests. Juliette then added that it was important to look hip, which Irene took to mean young, vital, and strange. Therefore: cerulean leggings, crochet sweater dress, peacock feather necklace, and a braided skinny-belt. Irene hoped these projected the artistic, professional image specified. Every job had its uniform. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 She checked her eye shadow, which made her irises look a shade darker, almost black instead of blue. She rubbed at a spot beneath her left eye that had been there for a month now but had only recently begun to feel sore. Buzz went the door, and she was off to collect a giraffe-print bolero from the next artist or heiress to stagger in on midnight- black stilettos. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 The K Gallery’s annual holiday party at the Waldorf Astoria was always an impressive affair. All year Irene and her friends looked forward to this night, the second Friday in December. Not that they didn’t go out other nights, not that living in the city wasn’t sometimes glamorous, but never anything compared to this. There were seventy-eight people on the exclusive guest list, and renowned chef Marc Herradura was catering. Honest-to-God movie stars attended. Last year they’d seen that guy from The Office , and the year before that, Cyndi Lauper! This was that other New York: always around them but never visible. For this one night it elonged to them too. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Even with the first big storm of winter going on outside and flights canceled at JFK and LaGuardia (only Newark soldiered on), they had nearly full attendance. All day the gallery’s owners, Juliette and Abeba, had been commanding Irene from one end of Manhattan to the other. They’d thrust her into snow-capped cars in Chelsea with a wrought-iron baboon skeleton (a steal at just $300,000) whose shrieking head had extended dangerously out the window into traffic. Wearing a pair of Abeba’s oversize duck boots, Irene had sloshed across the posh lobby of the Lexington Avenue hotel, aching under the weight of a moldy yam encased in bile-green polypropylene (starting at just half a million). xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Five years ago, when she’d first begun working at the gallery, Irene had gotten a thrill simply from being near such valuable art, but by this point she was considering telling the driver to take her and the oversize photograph of Trisha Birch’s genitals (one million flat) to the George Washington Bridge so she could hurl it out into the Hudson. Or maybe she would just keep going. On and on, out of the city. With the money this one photo was worth, Irene could paint all day and all night for another twenty years. Or start her own gallery. Or institute a progressive artists’ colony where young dreamers could take up their own work. She could help them avoid the eighteen- hour days, the perpetual temper tantrums, the name-dropping, the ego trips, the talentless and tormented. Except that, of course, outside New York City, the Trisha Birch photographs were more likely to get her arrested for indecency than for theft. Maybe in L.A., she thought. Maybe in London. Maybe on Mars, or Neptune. Juliette and Abeba were not terrible bosses, but they had all the fussiness of artists without the brilliance. They had an eye for slick marketing and could start a trend like nobody’s business. But the higher the K Gallery climbed in the Chelsea scene, the more Juliette and Abeba drank sickening amounts of Campari and spoke of selling everything and setting sail for the Marquesas like Gauguin. Rule one of living in the city, Irene had learned—as soon as you got there, you had to begin threatening to leave. She was theoretically putting money aside for a trip to France from which she privately imagined she’d never return, though it seemed like the same $350 or so kept entering and exiting her savings account; meanwhile the trip got more expensive and the exchange rate got worse and the gallery took up more time. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Still, it was, as they said, a living, and far from a bad one. Even when she’d had to examine Teacup Yorkie feces to see which should be threaded alongside diamonds on a necklace for the Bryant Park show. Even cataloging seventeen years of Percy Bryson’s toenail clippings. But she had legit benefits and enough money to pay for a cramped studio apartment on East Fourth Street, where she could paint at night without disturbing a roommate. Plus she wasn’t starving. If not trips to France, her paychecks covered a vintage dress or two and movie tickets and bar tabs and green tea smoothies. Buzz! At last it was them: George Murphy and Sara Sherman. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 George wore a wide smile and a black pinstripe suit. Was it new? It was. Sara had gotten it for him last week at the Macy’s pre-Christmas sale, to wear to his postdoc interviews. Irene kissed his cheek and inspected his penny-coppery hair; it needed cutting. Irene could never resist the urge to ruffle his head lightly, for luck. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 “We made it!” George announced. His cornflower-blue eyes met the room over Irene’s shoulder and then fixed on her. When he spoke to her, or to anyone, they never drifted an inch. His three favorite words were, “Did you know—” and after saying them, he had a way of lowering his voice as he told you something terrific about some distant galaxy he was researching out at the North Shore Observatory, as if Andromeda B were a restaurant you might want to check out sometime. He seemed to want nothing more than for others to find him handy to have around. Swiftly, he could explain to you: the mechanics of an elevator, the science behind a hailstorm, or the electric spark between your fingers and the fringe of your dress. A good Catholic boy from Columbus, someone had raised him right; George Murphy was attentive in a city of the attention- deficient, and for this he was always looked after. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 “No one’s ever on time to this thing,” Irene said. “Here, give me your coat.” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 But George was already hanging it up by himself. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Sara slid in for a kiss from Irene. “Some big accident on the LIE,” she explained. Irene told her she looked stunning, and Sara said she must be mental; she’d come straight from the gym and was sure that she must reek , but of course she did not. Her long purple dress was discreetly sequined. Raven-haired and slender-jawed, Sara forever made Irene itch to break out her charcoals and sketch dark, elegant lines. No matter that she was technically not of the artsy crowd at this party—inside an hour, half the people there would believe Sara was the one throwing it. She’d glide from one conversation to the next, sometimes drawing one or two along with her until no one was a stranger to her, or to anyone, anymore. “Did you know” were also Sara’s three favorite words, followed not by a fact but by a person. She always knew someone you knew: a girl in your prom limo, your YMCA summer camp counselor, the barista at the coffee shop you frequent, a man you met at that bar in Chiang Mai, the boy whose hand you held on a third- grade field trip to the Museum of Natural History. Some people never forgot a face; Sara never forgot a connection. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 George played with his skinny knit tie in the hall mirror. “ Six-car pileup. I’ve done this commute every day for five years, and I’ve never seen a crash that bad.” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Irene watched as the mirror’s golden, thorny frame transformed George into a portrait: Man in Crooked Necktie . She wished she could tear the Claude Lozarette off the farther wall, melt the pigments off the canvas, and use them to paint George right there on the mirror’s surface—why not?—but the moment passed. The knot was fixed; he’d stepped away. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 “Sorry. I had to change in a Starbucks bathroom that smelled like dead aardvarks and—” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Sara interrupted. “Oh, speaking of— this is for you.” She dug an oil- stained brown bag from her bottomless purse. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Irene peeled back the paper to reveal a single, smushed vanilla cupcake. Little rainbow sprinkles formed a lopsided swirl, winking up like stars. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 “They made us buy something. Can you believe it?” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 In fact, Irene could not believe it. First, Sara was a rotten liar, and second, everyone knew Starbucks was one place you could use the bathroom without paying for something; it might as well be rule two of city living. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 George winked at Irene as she helped slip off Sara’s coat. “Someone was afraid you didn’t eat today,” he murmured. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Sara pretended to object, but Irene kissed her cheek again. “Well, did you?” Sara inquired, and before an answer was given, she reached up to poke the faint spot beneath Irene’s eye. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Irene snapped her head to one side. “I had some grapes.” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 She already regretted telling Sara about last week’s CT scan, which meant she’d just keep worrying and eventually she’d ask about yesterday’s follow- up appointment. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 “Jacob here yet?” George asked, absently trying to take Sara’s coat so he could hang it. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Irene yanked it back. “Not yet. But he’s always late.” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 “But we’re late.” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 “He’s always later.” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Then, as Irene moved to close the door, she saw someone approaching—a young Korean man who was shyly inspecting the wall. It took two seconds to see that he didn’t belong there. Distantly, she remembered him from somewhere. He wore a sharp, gray Armani suit and held, in one hand, a bottle of Bollinger Blanc. Who brings champagne to a catered party? Irene wondered as she tried to remember which gallery he worked for. She wasn’t entirely surprised to see Sara give the boy a bear hug. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 “William Cho ? What are you doing here? Irene, did you know William? He was in Art History II with McClellan. You sat in on that one.” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Irene didn’t hesitate to grip his wet, gloved hand in welcome. He was very thin, with cheekbones that she was sure she’d have remembered if he’d had them back in college. People don’t just go around getting cheekbones , she told herself. Or coal-black eyes like that either. She liked the girlish line of his upper lip; he bit it nervously whenever he looked at her. Normally she wasn’t very interested in shyness, but something about him was making her blush. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Sara turned. “George, you remember William.” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 They shook hands politely. “Sure! William Cho, right? We met at that newspaper party with Lisa Schmidt. Sara took over as features editor after Lisa went to Madagascar with that guy with the Rhodes . . . honey, what was his name?” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Sara knew it (Henry Fordham, Jr.), and also that the girl’s name had been Lisa Schlick, but from the look on William’s face, Irene guessed he didn’t know either of them. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 “Hang on!” George said, “Before we get caught up, let me grab us all something from the bar.” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 It was understood that Irene had to wait until the guests had finished arriving, but Sara said anything involving St. Germain would be terrific. It was only then that William thrust forward the bottle of champagne that he’d been cradling like a football. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 George seized it with grateful hands. “ Damn. This is nice stuff, William.” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 “I stole it,” William abruptly announced. xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 “Like, you boosted it?” George asked. “Don’t tell me you boosted this.” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Sara laughed. “Boosted? What are you, a thirties gangster?” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 George winked at her while William clarified. “Yeah. I mean—no. I didn’t rob a liquor store or anything. But it’s been under the coatrack in my boss’s office since last Christmas.” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 Turning the bottle over, George peeled a shiny gift tag off the bottom. “ ‘To Lenny. From the Berg-Geldorf Family!’ Well thank you, Berg-Geldorfs! I’ll see if the guy can put this on ice.” xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0xa0 He clapped William on the back. Then, while Irene and Sara turned their attention to William, he slipped into the main room with every appearance of happiness. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • “Stunning . . . A beautiful, sprawling, and generous book. Jansma is a brilliantly talented writer, but he also has a unique insight into what friends mean to one another, and what it means to be part of a city in which you never quite belong, but can’t quite bring yourself to leave. It’s a heartfelt novel, tender and painful and cathartic all at once, and even if the characters belong to New York, the story belongs to us all.” —NPR
  • December, 2008. A heavy snowstorm is blowing through Manhattan and the economy is on the brink of collapse, but none of that matters to a handful of guests at a posh holiday party. Five years after their college graduation, the fiercely devoted friends at the heart of this richly absorbing novel remain as inseparable as ever: editor and social butterfly Sara Sherman, her troubled astronomer boyfriend George Murphy, loudmouth poet Jacob Blaumann, classics major turned investment banker William Cho, and Irene Richmond, an enchanting artist with an inscrutable past.Amid cheerful revelry and free-flowing champagne, the friends toast themselves and the new year ahead—a year that holds many surprises in store. They must navigate ever-shifting relationships with the city and with one another, determined to push onward in pursuit of their precarious dreams. And when a devastating blow brings their momentum to a halt, the group is forced to reexamine their aspirations and chart new paths through unexpected losses.Kristopher Jansma’s award-winning debut novel,
  • The Unchangeable Spots of Leopards,
  • was praised for its  “wry humor” and “charmingly unreliable narrator” in
  • The New Yorker
  • and hailed as “F. Scott Fitzgerald meets Wes Anderson” by
  • The Village Voice
  • . In
  • Why We Came to the City
  • , Jansma
  • offers an unforgettable exploration of friendships forged in the fires of ambition, passion, hope, and love. This glittering story of a generation coming of age is a sweeping, poignant triumph.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(81)
★★★★
20%
(54)
★★★
15%
(41)
★★
7%
(19)
28%
(75)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

A poignant journey to adulthood. A coming-of-age tale, of five twenty-something friends in NYC-- A give and take!

Kristopher Jansma's follows with his second novel, WHY WE CAME TO THE CITY, a poignant, coming-of-age tale, of five twenty-something friends after 9/11 in New York City. Beginning at the onset of the 2008 financial crisis—recession; from tragedy, life, loss, grief, and friendship.

A journey to adulthood. A dream. Success. Failure. Misfortune. Crisis. Loss. Grief. The ashes. Survival. Mortality. A city can take from us and give. Sometimes we need to say good-bye. Both personal and professionally.

My city is not your city. A different city than the one we knew. What happened to the city fifty years before? A city where we lost and loved. New York has always been about the American dream.

Jansma writes with stunning literary prose, with deep insights, mixed with humor-- a close group of friends. Five years after college: They are flawed. Sara- editor; boyfriend astronomer -George, poet -Jacob, investment banker-William, and Irene, artist. They are at a party toasting the new year. However, as they make their way through the city -- life’s unexpected twists. turns, and tragedies.

Irene is diagnosed with bone cancer and forced to undergo draining chemotherapy sessions. They each confront their own demons, fears, and issues. Rethinking and exploring their dreams, ambitions, hopes, love, careers, and aspirations. If there could be a do over. Time. How to be someone new. Get through the tough times with support of one another.

From the romance with the city, love, passion, and cancer. How the cancer and surrounding elements affect the group--grief, discovery, reconciliation.

As mentioned in several online articles, the storyline reflects similarities of the author’s personal life from moving to New York City as a young man, grad school at Columbia, fell in love and got married, and – along with his fiancé – cared for his sister in his cramped one-bedroom apartment as she battled cancer. His ever-changing relationship with the city while considering moving to the suburbs.

Not only is the book related to New York City, the themes and experiences are relevant to cities everywhere.

“We came to the city because we wished to live haphazardly, to reach for only the least realistic of our desires, and to see if we could not learn what our failures had to teach, and not, when we came to live, discover that we had never died.”

Life can be based on Idealism (based on a conception of things as they should be, or wish them to be with a tendency to be imaginary or visionary), OR Realism (based on a conception of things as they are, regardless of how one wants them to be---practical and pragmatic.

These perspectives also have an impact on how individuals deal with success or failure in their lives. It is very rare to find someone who is a complete and absolute idealist or realist. Events in our life change our perspectives.

Beautifully written, moving, and absorbing will make the reader reflect upon the moment, and appreciate life and those around you --in the present.
I listened to the audiobook, and Edoardo Ballerini delivered an engaging performance.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Like Friends, but more maudlin, more emo, less fun

Read this on the strength of reviews, but came away empty. The author is a fine stylist. His characters, however, are like cardboard. There is the stoic Asian brainiac being pushed by his immigrant parents; the Jewish gay man who cracks wise at parties while hiding inner turmoil; and the Twilight-esque heroine who has no clear personality or likability, but lots of people who care deeply about her. Like the characters in Friends who have that fantastic apartment without any apparent way to pay for it, the tragic heroine in this story battles a serious medical condition free of financial worry. The book is full of situations, but not plot. The author knows how to turn a phrase -- I wish he would throttle down the whining and self-absorption.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Good themes at the heart of it, but the characters are under-developed cliches

This book made me appreciate A Little Life more than I already did. It’s hard not to compare the two: both are stories about a close knit group of friends navigating life amid horrible tragedy.

Kristopher Jansma is a decent writer, and that’s parts of what makes Why We Came to the City so disappointing. It has potential, but for a character-driven novel, his character development is severely lacking.

The characters are introduced so hastily, and we never know enough about them to really empathize with them and care about what they’re going through. In many ways they feel like empty cliches of millennials, and some of the dialogue is so forced and bad that it’s almost eyeroll-worthy.

There are some great themes at the center of this novel (the illusion of control, the inevitability of struggle, cosmic insignificance, free will vs. fate), and it’s when he’s focusing on these themes that Jansma is most successful. Unfortunately though, his characters just aren’t strong enough, for the most part, to carry the story.

It’s definitely readable, but I don’t think it’s deserving of all the hype.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I could not put this book down.

A must read!
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Not good

To preface, this book was voted on by my book club based on the overview which led us to believe that the story followed a group of friends that were affected by 9/11. This is not the case, in fact, 9/11 is hardly ever mentioned! I don't love the authors writing style either, too many run on sentences. I also did not connect with any of the characters and found it very hard to relate to any of them. In addition, there were a few chapters that were unnecessary (Georges job description) and many paragraphs that didn't fit in. I could've easily skimmed through this book in an hour and gotten the gist of the story.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Slow start, but won me over and moved me to tears

I received a free copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

During the first few chapters of Why We Came To The City, I feared this book and I weren’t going to be a good match. The sweeping, grandiose prose was too contrived, the characters too unrelatable. As I read on, however, I discovered there were two levels to this story. The lofty, contemplative level of philosophy and grandiloquence, the level at which the book started, didn’t do anything for me. The intimate level of emotions and personal insights, on the other hand, was spot-on, moving, and changed my perspective about the book.

Jansma’s novel opens with a wide view, introducing the reader to the five main characters as they hobnob at an art show. They’re positioned as five variations on the “Aspiring Young Professionals in NYC” theme, up-and-coming 20-somethings with starry eyes and big dreams. For the first few chapters, I despaired of connecting with any of them. They were so pretentious with their big-city affectations and tweed jackets, arguing the superiority of various translations of The Iliad and debating the meaning of Art, with a capital “A.” They seemed like two-dimensional representations instead of real people; they were the Free-Spirited Artist, the Go-Getter Newspaper Editor, the Gay Poet, etc., when what I really wanted were unique individuals with their own traits and fears and experiences.

A few chapters in, I got the character development I was after. One of the protagonists was diagnosed with cancer. The lens narrowed, the focus became personal, and Why We Came To The City hit its stride. The characters stopped being two-dimensional caricatures and simply became five people who were hurting and trying to figure out how to deal with that hurt in in their own personal way.

Through tiny, precise details, Jansma peeled back the layers of his characters like the layers of an onion. There was wise-cracking Jacob, trying to mask his fear with sarcasm and sass, and take-charge, hyper-organized Sarah, who tried to control the situation with medication charts and precisely timed visitation schedules. There was George, whose fraying nerves could only be soothed by a drink or 10, and William, who questioned whether he was somehow to blame for his girlfriend’s illness.

“In those dark hours with his eyes shut, he had been counting disappointments on a hundred imaginary fingers. Not things that he was disappointed by but disappointments of his own making. Things like having made more money than he deserved, doing mergers for companies with questionable ethics, being a terrible son – anything he felt the universe might be punishing him for by making the woman that he loved so sick.”

As a rule, I generally avoid “cancer books.” In fact, if I’d known that’s what I was getting in Why We Came To The City, I probably wouldn’t have requested a review copy. However, Jansma’s book isn’t really about the disease, it’s about coming to terms with the fact that life doesn’t pull its punches, no matter who you are or what you think you deserve. The five friends in this novel start out on top of the world, expectant and ready for the best life has to offer. When life dishes up tragedy instead, they must figure out how to regroup and keep moving forward.

“For she was special, and had always believed it. She was more punctual, and she was better prepared. […] Always recycling and never littering. Better behaved and never hypocritical. Harder working at the office, tipping more generously, and possessing of a thousand pardons. And yet she couldn’t save Irene just by trying hardest or being best. Because no one was immune to tragedy. No matter how respectfully Sara lived, death could not respect her in return. She, Irene, all of them were susceptible to collapse, regardless of preparations or punctuality or propriety. None of them were special.”

As I’ve already mentioned, Jansma’s attention to detail and ability to paint an intimate picture of the characters’ experiences are what really won me over to Why We Came To The City. At times, Jansma would move away from this personal focus, broadening the book’s gaze to a more abstract, contemplative view. During these sections I would find myself losing interest and feeling the distance growing between the characters and myself.

Eventually, the lens would narrow again and there would be a poignant, penetrating line that socked me in the chest and actually brought tears to my eyes. There would be a moment when one of the friends would try his hardest to give up a vice, to make a deal with God that if he could just be good enough his friend would recover. Or another moment when another friend would look back at their collective lives and wonder how they’d become the people they currently were:

“Now it seemed undeniable to him that, whereas his New York family had indeed been happy in the way that all groups of young dreamers are happy before they’ve given up, they were all quite unhappy now, each in their own special ways. That was what made it all the more miserable: they couldn’t even be unhappy together.”

It’s these small but important insights that Jansma does exceptionally well. They resonated with me and affected me deeply. (view spoiler) They’re also what taught me the lesson of this book: Life may not care about our dreams, but that doesn’t mean we should stop dreaming. As Jacob aptly points out:

“You’ve got to entrust yourself to the waves, lash yourself to the mast, pray the gods are on your side, and rely on cunning to survive the rest. The seas are full of forgotten monsters, yes, but they’re full of forgotten glories too. And the people who stay home and sit out the war never get to see them.”

This review can also be found on my blog, [...]
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

It's ok to be scared.

Why We came to the city, in my opinion, is a must read for every 20-something. It offers readers a non-fantastic view of life from an uncertain generation. While the first chapter rapidly introduces each character making it a little difficult to follow, the remaining chapters bring life to each character and lays out everyone's demons.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Captivating story of a group of millennials and their journeys ...

Captivating story of a group of millennials and their journeys, relationships, especially their relationship with NYC. Very thoughtfully developed, bringing your through various stages and experiences that we all have in life - sometimes heartbreaking, other times uplifting. Definitely worth the read, well written.
✓ Verified Purchase

Three Stars

TAKE BOOK TO BEACH, SNOW LODGE, AIRPORT, THAT KIND OF BOOK
✓ Verified Purchase

Wonderful novel about friendship and NYC

Great read. A novel of friendship and loss, of belonging and otherness, of how the past is a burden and a gift. Jansma is a great storyteller with a profound understanding that place is something material and describable and also very much about where you're at in your life.