Deficit Myth
Deficit Myth book cover

Deficit Myth

Paperback – March 9, 2021

Price
$13.39
Format
Paperback
Pages
352
Publisher
PublicAffairs
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-1541736191
Dimensions
5.5 x 1.25 x 8.25 inches
Weight
10.4 ounces

Description

"Kelton writes clearly and directly, and does well to keep the lay reader in mind throughout. This comprehensive, lucid explanation of a much-buzzed about economic theory will resonate with progressives."― Publishers Weekly "Stephanie Kelton is among the most prominent of the dozen or so economists associated with MMT. Her new book The Deficit Myth is intended to bring MMT to a broader audience. In addition to an impassioned call for a bigger, more active public sector, The Deficit Myth contains a number of distinct economic arguments."― The American Prospect "Clear and vigorously written book."― Foreign Affairs "She has succeeded in instigating a round of heretical questioning, essential for a post-Covid-19 world, where the pantheon of economic gods will have to be reconfigured."― The Guardian "Kelton and her colleagues have brought a great many non-economists into the economic conversation in a way that no other contemporary branch of heterodox economics has been able to....[Sh]e's dead right about a central political fact of our times: A large, active public sector is more needed today than ever, and unfounded fears of public debt are a big reason we haven't gotten it. Which means her eloquent, accessible book is performing an important public service."― The American Prospect “This book is a timely and welcome addition to the economics literature.”― Governance "Kelton certainly offers food for thought at a time when governments are spending eye-watering sums to mitigate damage from the coronavirus pandemic."― Spear's Magazine “Kelton’s wonderful tome is digestible for most, even if one needs to comb through it a few times to get to grips with the terminology and utter shock about the state of economic discussion in the media.”― Redaction Politics "The big thing she gets right is in the way she structures her book around our current beliefs. In addressing our current understanding of how the world works - interpretations she identifies as myths - Kelton leads us step-by-step towards a new understanding of how federal spending works."― Inside Higher Education "Stephanie Kelton convincingly overturns the conventional wisdom that federal budget deficits are somehow bad for the nation. ...Kelton argues that our government's inability to provide for citizens isn't due to a lack for money; instead, our leaders lack political will."― Farhad Manjoo, The New York Times " The Deficit Myth is simply the most important book I've ever read. Stephanie Kelton carefully articulates a message that obliterates economic orthodoxy about public finance, which assumes that taxes precede spending and deficits are bad. Kelton's work is on a par with the genius of DaVinci and Copernicus, heretics who proved that Earth revolves around the sun."― David Cay Johnston, recipient of the Pulitzer Prize, an Investigative Reporters and Editors Inc. Medal, and the George Polk Award "A remarkable book both in content and timing. A 'must-read' that is sure to influence many aspects of policymaking going forward."― Mohamed El-Erian, chief economic advisor, Allianz "In a world of epic, overlapping crises, Stephanie Kelton is an indispensable source of moral clarity. Whether you're all in for MMT, or merely MMT-curious, the truths that she teaches about money, debt, and deficits give us the tools we desperately need to build a safe future for all. Read it--then put it to use."― Naomi Klein, author of On Fire: The Burning Case for a Green New Deal "Kelton's game-changing book on the myths around government deficits is both theoretically rigorous and empirically entertaining. It reminds us that money is not limited, only our imagination of what to do with it. After you read it you will never think of the public purse as a household economy again. Read it!"― Mariana Mazzucato, author of The Value of Everything: Making and Taking in the Global Economy " The Deficit Myth is a triumph. It is absorbing, compelling, and--most important of all--empowering. Embracing a well-researched framework that focuses on how real-world economies actually operate, she lays out a realistic path to true economic prosperity. It is an approach that focuses on Main Street and not Wall Street and will permit us to not only revitalize the struggling middle class, but address critical social problems like chronic unemployment, poverty, health care, and climate change. We of course face many binding constraints on our ability to act, but Kelton argues that the intentional underemployment of our own resources that results from the pervasive influence of deficit myths should not be one. We have needed this book for a very long time. Everyone should read it, and then reread it, before it is too late to change course."― John T. Harvey, professor of economics, Texas Christian University "Kelton's mission in this powerful book is to free us from defunct orthodox thinking about fiscal deficits rooted in the bygone era of the gold standard. Her theoretical canvas is modern monetary theory. At its core MMT offers a simple proposition: In a fiat currency world, the finances of we the people ain't the same as a summing up of our individual budget constraints, because we the people can't go broke, only deficit-spend our collective self into inflationary excesses. In the prevailing era of too-low inflation, the macro policy implication should be obvious: We the people presently have far more fiscal space than the deficit scold, pay-for crowd preaches. Kelton is a gifted writer and teacher and I confidently predict that The Deficit Myth , brilliantly written and argued, will become the defining book on what MMT is--and what it is not."― Paul Allen McCulley, retired managing director and chief economist, PIMCO, and senior fellow, Cornell University Law School "Clear! Compelling! Eye-opening and persuasive, The Deficit Myth is an adventure in the world of budgets, jobs, trade, banking and--above all--of money. With the great force of common sense, Stephanie Kelton and the MMT team have broken through the closed circles of so-called sound finance, a stale orthodoxy that has weakened and impoverished us all. This book shows how they did it, and it blazes a path forward, toward a better world built on better ideas."― James K. Galbraith, The University of Texas at Austin "A robust, well-reasoned, and highly readable walk through many common misunderstandings. A 'must-read' for anyone who wants to understand how government financing really works, and how it interplays with economic policy."― Frank Newman, former deputy secretary of the Treasury Stephanie Kelton , professor of economics and public policy at the State University of New York at Stony Brook and Bloomberg contributing columnist, has been called a "prophetic economist" and a "rock star" of progressive economics. She is the founder and of the top-rated economic blog New Economic Perspectives , and a member of the TopWonks network of the nation's best thinkers. In 2016, Politico recognized her as one of the fifty people across the country most influencing the political debate.xa0Kelton was chief economist on the U.S. Senate Budget Committee (minority staff) and an advisor to Bernie Sanders's 2016 and 2020 presidential campaigns. Kelton is a regular commentator on national radio and television and speaks across the world at large gatherings of people interested in global finance, political economy and public policy. She has superb connections in all areas of print and broadcast national media. Her op-eds have appeared in The New York Times , The Washington Post , The Los Angeles Times and Bloomberg .

Features & Highlights

  • A
  • New York Times
  • Bestseller
  • The leading thinker and most visible public advocate of modern monetary theory -- the freshest and most important idea about economics in decades -- delivers a radically different, bold, new understanding for how to build a just and prosperous society.
  • Stephanie Kelton's brilliant exploration of modern monetary theory (MMT) dramatically changes our understanding of how we can best deal with crucial issues ranging from poverty and inequality to creating jobs, expanding health care coverage, climate change, and building resilient infrastructure. Any ambitious proposal, however, inevitably runs into the buzz saw of how to find the money to pay for it, rooted in myths about deficits that are hobbling us as a country.Kelton busts through the myths that prevent us from taking action: that the federal government should budget like a household, that deficits will harm the next generation, crowd out private investment, and undermine long-term growth, and that entitlements are propelling us toward a grave fiscal crisis.MMT, as Kelton shows, shifts the terrain from narrow budgetary questions to one of broader economic and social benefits. With its important new ways of understanding money, taxes, and the critical role of deficit spending, MMT redefines how to responsibly use our resources so that we can maximize our potential as a society. MMT gives us the power to imagine a new politics and a new economy and move from a narrative of scarcity to one of opportunity.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
60%
(2.2K)
★★★★
25%
(933)
★★★
15%
(560)
★★
7%
(261)
-7%
(-261)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Just new methodology to justify Socialism

Borrow and tax- basic summary of book. And if inflation gets out of control-well that reduces the debt -so not a concern. This book and theory is just a way for the left to justify massive spending without any controls . Of course the result ends up being higher taxes for companies and the middle class. But guess who gets to spend the money?-you guessed it- the State-not you. So in the end, you have wealth redistribution accomplished through a new phony methodology that indents everyone to the State
21 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Destructive socialist thinking. The Great Reset is here.

Book Review
The Deficit Myth (Stephanie Kelton)
Review by (Chad D Wagner)

I tried to avoid purchasing this book or even consuming it but I had to see it for myself to believe the ludicrous suggestions that Stephanie is propagating through the ranks of the United States government and World Economic Forum.

Modern Monetary Theory
This idea proposes that governments who control the money printer should by all means never run out of ink.

As an American I believe it flies in the face of our founding fathers who broke the chains of tyranny to form this country upon liberty and justice. As a tax paying citizen I can only see a monopoly that is engaged in counterfeiting and plundering society to the point of physical and psychological enslavement.

I believe Stephanie may have stolen this idea from a 13-year-old whom she quotes in the book.
She claims that the government will never run out of money.
Proclaiming that increasing the deficit does not impact our children or future generations. (1971 New Home cost $30K
today cost $300K)
She believes that Government budgets should not be compared to household budgets because governments get to print as much money they want.
She dumbs it down enough to compare controlling inflation to driving a car in the snow.

The problems that she aims to correct by printing more money are the same problems that were created by the current system. (Fiat money controlled by banking monopolies and corrupt politicians.)

It’s either ignorance or just plain deceiving to outline the way MMT could have solved such financial predicaments as the great recession of 08 and the housing crisis. Never addressing what the root cause of the crisis was. Nor does she acknowledge that the massive bail out primarily helped the bankers and elite oligarchs that caused the crisis to begin with.

She describes a lovely utopian society where everyone will have a job, healthcare, food to eat and living in harmony with nature. ( Sounds Great! )
⁃ all funded by the big money printer in the sky

As lovely as this utopian society could be, it is based in a world where government has expanded into nearly every facet of our lives, money will be created from nothing to fund not only the projects and services but as per usual a large percentage will flow right into the pockets of the elite. Giving ultimate power to the bureaucrats will get to dictate the rules of the game. (Do as we say or else!)

Reveling there hand 🃏
I’m glad that she made perfectly clear -the strategy of which The Great Reset proponents will use to manipulate and change the course of society as we know it. (TAXES)

As she explains, Taxes are no longer needed to finance our government but when used properly can be a method of control to keep citizens in check.
If we have to pay taxes in fiat dollars then we have to continue to play their game. It’s like playing Monopoly (for ever)…….
By imposing taxes they can manipulate inflation. By raising rates they are forcing us to cut back a little to create room for (their) additional spending. We don’t want to be competing for the same goods, supply and demand would make the price go up. (Inflation) Taxes can be used to discourage certain behaviors. Say for instance a cigarette tax, a carbon tax, a gun tax? I feel like that is called manipulation or social engineering? The most obvious would be redistribution of wealth. ( I think that’s just a catchphrase to keep the idiots believing this is a good thing. ) We all know who the wealth will be distributed to!

Finally, one major weakness of her plan is presuming that we will continue to have this privilege of issuing the world reserve currency. (How long will other governments continue to watch us devalue the dollar before they no longer accept it?)

MMT is no longer a thought experiment. It is being utilized as I write this review 8/25/22 - Chad D Wagner

Stephanie Kelton has served as an advisor to Bernie Sanders and others.

Stephanie Kelton is a guest speaker, panelist at The World Economic Forum 2020
14 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Culpable ignorance

"Modern Monetary Theory", the main topic of this book, is based on the idea that governments can spend money on anything, with any resulting deficit being harmless. This is dangerous nonsense: anyone with a sound grounding in economics is aware of supply and demand curves, the intersection of which determines a price: increase the demand and the price goes up; increase the supply and the price goes down. This applies to any asset, including money. Our present inflation is the result of the government pumping trillions of dollars into the economy, without adequately using the mechanisms of taxation and sale of bonds to limit the money supply. Policies based on this idea will necessarily lead to inflation - and eventually to catastrophes such as Venezuela, where the currency is so worthless that children cut it up for art projects.
10 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Total B.S.

The book: Inflation is good. Debt is good. Seriously wtf. The fiat experiment since 1971 has failed. Wake up!
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Absolutely ridiculous economics and completely out of touch with reality.

The Modern Monetary Theory is perhaps the dumbest economic theory ever conceived. It complete ignores all common sense, international factors, and the collective history of economics.

The premise that the government can borrow indefinitely, irrespective of the level of debt it incurs is absurd. One would have to ignore the basic principles of money and logic. Mrs. Kelton's thoughts are just not coherent and lack common sense.

This theory is not only insanely stupid, it is dangerous as our government reaches 130% debt to GDP ratio.
It’s a one way ticket to a massive debt crisis that will undermine the foundation of the entire wester financial system. Mrs. Kelton should stick to works of fiction, or put down the pipe of whatever she is smoking.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Complete rubbish–Ms. Kelton lives in a fantasy world.

Kelton gets many, many things wrong in this book and is clearly not knowledgeable in matters of inflation, taxes and unemployment.

Read this so you can know how screwed we will be after MMT theorist have their way. Then encourage all your friends to read Thomas Sowell and Hatzlitt.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

This book explains the current status of the global economy and supports how we got here

This book is a complete rethink of monetary policy and has been in effect in the G7 nations for years .... you are now getting to see how ridiculous this philosophy as you watch the global economy crash and burn .... If you are reading this book you will know what we should not be doing to succeed for our children
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

You've got to read this book!

Answer me this. Who in the United States has the legal right and ability to issue the American dollar? If you answered the U.S. Treasury, you're right. Now please tell me how they decide how much money to make. If you answered that they are limited by how much American citizens and immigrants pay in federal taxes, you would be very wrong. In The Deficit Myth: Modern Monetary Theory and the Birth of the People's Economy by economist Stephanie Kelton explains exactly why it's very wrong.

Before Nixon modernized our fiscal policy, it was not wrong to equate our fiscal policy with the way we budget our household expenses. We were using the gold standard and that required us to know where the money was coming from before spending it.

The U.S. Treasury now can use a computer to pay off U.S. Debts. It could pay off the national debt with a keystroke if Congress told it to do so.

Just like it can pay the U.S. Military whatever Congress authorizes.

As Kelton points out, the great recession of 2009-2011 didn't turn into another Great Depression only because automatic stabilizers went into play that didn't need Congress. The Americans didn't suffer as much because automatic payments were issued to them. When Texas had their great economic crisis when they lost electricity, it was automatic stabilizers that rescued them.

Kelton served on Senator Bernie Sander's economic advisor on the Senate Budget Committee in 2015-6 when Republicans ruled the roost, but she was deeply saddened that congress from both sides of the aisle are still stuck in the old ways of thinking.

Even the vast majority of our presidents, including FDR whose structural requirements of Social Security has caused all the confusion. Only Social Security Supplemental Medical Insurance is not bound up in legislative action (inaction). All of Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and other entitlements can be treated like it if Congress chooses to do. The money for entitlements doesn't have to run out or be cut.

Only JFK got it right, she explains, and quotes him at length when he proposed the moon shot in 1961.

Kelton explodes six pernicious myths about the federal deficit that have served only to polarize our country, keep many millions unemployed, crush communities, strengthen inequality, and prevent stable economic prosperity. Her first piece of advice to help the situation is to implement a federal job guarantee, which she notes is not a handout and has some historical precedents.

You will probably be shocked by the book, but she makes a lot of sense. The federal government doesn't use our taxes to pay its budget, but taxes are needed, if I understand correctly, to prevent high inflation.

While high inflation is the one thing limiting U.S. Treasury expenditures, it is our national debt surpluses that bring on recessions. We don't want a balanced budget in the federal government.

Trade peace, not trade wars, are also what we want.

Much of the world need American dollars to trade with becaue we've kept them from expanding what they can export. We don't have to do this and keep them impoverished.

A fascinating, important book. Kelton hopes that change in fiscal policy will be demanded by the American people because that's the only way real change will happen. Vote in courageous legislators who understand, accept, and want Modern Monetary Theory, a step beyond Keynesian theory, to alow our democracy to flourish.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The economics of socialism

I was sent this book by a relative who wanted to prove to me that he is right to support Bernie Sanders and socialism. He’s still wrong.
It took me two chapters to realize that this take on MMT economics is not new and it has failed again and again. It is really an ideology that Professor Kelton was taught in our now left leaning universities and she does not realize that her writing perspective is so biased by this thought process.
I skimmed through the next two chapters thinking how the history of the Soviet Union and it’s failures after the revolution did not deter the author in anyway. It’s as if their experience never happened or they made mistakes that we can correct with her guidance.
I will only say that I am not an expert on this subject but then again I am also not so gullible as to think this take on the National Debt is worth wasting my time on either.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Better than I expected

I came into this book as a deficit hawk. I lean libertarian. Small government, self-sufficiency, stop spending money.

This book was actually pretty good. The author is compelling, and based on some pretty unassailable axioms (e.g. fiat currency is all make-believe anyways), builds a solid argument for why focus on the deficit number misses the point. Rather than "balancing the books" we should focus on limitations of real resources. And to that thesis, I concede that she's probably right.

It falls short in a few ways:
(1) I suspect the author is a little too optimistic in how many real resources we have available. Yes, we misappropriate a lot today and with better management could do much better, but that doesn't mean we have enough to create the seeming Utopia that she describes.
(2) It fails to define exactly how to measure how close you're getting to consuming all of the real resources. If you overshoot and overconsume, inflation is going to be a problem. For all the failings of our current system, it seems to be doing a good job keeping inflation in-check for the last few decades. If we're going to change, you need to propose not just a philosophy but an actual methodology.
(3) It fails to acknowledge human nature. Humans don't judge wealth simply by "how much," but also by "how much more." I don't just want a million dollars, I want more than my neighbor!

Overall, modern monetary theory (MMT) is better than I expected. But to be convinced, I would want concrete resolution to those points.

All that said, I was still impressed and am glad to have spent the time with this book. It forced me to confront biases that I hold... uncomfortable, but healthy.
3 people found this helpful